Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you believe in past lives?

396 replies

Sayhellolikethis · 28/05/2023 15:06

Name changed, as I’ve told MIL and DSis about this already…

Putting my little boy (just turned 4) to bed and he told me “I built 60 bridges during the war and I also built a bomb”. I asked him why he built a bomb and he said “I put 2 bombs on each of my bridges to protect them”. He also said “the factories were covered in camouflage”.

He then added “and a fighter jet plane falled to the ground”.

It was such a ramble of words and then he just wanted to snuggle down and go to sleep.

Has anyone else had a similar experience with their little ones? He won’t talk about it any further. Puzzled!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
CurlewKate · 30/05/2023 19:24

Incidentally- the whole point about having a scientific approach to subjects like is not about having sides. It's about looking at the facts, and using the information we have to come to a best fit explanation. So, a child talking about a past life could be describing just that. Or she could be describing something she had imagined or half heard or saw in a picture. Seeing a glimpse of a computer game being played in another room. Something on the news as it was being turned off. The best fit is obviously the second option. So that's the sensible option. Until such time, maybe tomorrow, that something happens to make the first the more likely option. Always choose the the most obvious explanation but be prepared to change your opinion as new evidence emerges.

CurlewKate · 30/05/2023 19:03

@Outofthepark "It's just sad to see so much embarrassing and arrogant posturing on this thread, when the simple truth is, we have no idea. It could've been a nice chance to just muse over what if's, or a friendly difference of opinion, but it's just lots of bitchiness, cringy posts about dictionary definitions and passive aggressive posts about science, and trying to outsmart each other instead."

I just don't see any of this. Could you point me to some examples, please?

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 18:51

*prove

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 18:51

Outofthepark · 30/05/2023 18:47

Yes it could, I quickly looked it up. But that's beside the fact.

I personally don't have an opinion one way or the other, because I don't have enough facts to know, and nor do any humans on earth, and we likely never will. 🤗 So I'm taking neither side.

It's just sad to see so much embarrassing and arrogant posturing on this thread, when the simple truth is, we have no idea. It could've been a nice chance to just muse over what if's, or a friendly difference of opinion, but it's just lots of bitchiness, cringy posts about dictionary definitions and passive aggressive posts about science, and trying to outsmart each other instead.

You quickly looked up what? It could not have been any war since the humans began to fight wars because fighter jets are a relatively new invention. You can’t argue with this because it is a fact. If this boy fought in a war in his past life where there were factories and planes then it was a relatively recent war.

And I can’t provide that there aren’t invisible centipedes crawling all over my body. Nobody can prove there aren’t. But we’d presume someone had a mental illness if they told us invisible centipedes crawled all over them at all times. Because it’s very unlikely that it’s true.

Outofthepark · 30/05/2023 18:47

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 16:54

Well it couldn’t really have been any war since humans began to fight, could it? Because planes and factories are relatively modern concepts, aren’t they?

And we can prove some things are true. That’s what makes them true. I hardly think it’s arrogant to say ‘there is no proof that any person has had a past life.’

Yes it could, I quickly looked it up. But that's beside the fact.

I personally don't have an opinion one way or the other, because I don't have enough facts to know, and nor do any humans on earth, and we likely never will. 🤗 So I'm taking neither side.

It's just sad to see so much embarrassing and arrogant posturing on this thread, when the simple truth is, we have no idea. It could've been a nice chance to just muse over what if's, or a friendly difference of opinion, but it's just lots of bitchiness, cringy posts about dictionary definitions and passive aggressive posts about science, and trying to outsmart each other instead.

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 18:21

Newspeaker · 30/05/2023 18:17

"Reports in 2014 that explosives had finally been removed from a bridge on the Swiss-German border came as a surprise to some — mostly those who hadn’t realized it had been wired to blow in the first place. The Säckinger Bridge was built over the Rhine in 1272 and has long been considered a national monument, but that didn’t stop the government from rigging it with TNT during the Cold War. Military actions like this were part of a larger Swiss defense strategy, which included withdrawing to the mountains and fighting a guerrilla war if invaded. The idea was to leave rubble rather than functional infrastructure behind. These days, the Swiss military won’t comment on whether other infrastructure is still rigged for reasons of military security. Either way, this bridge set up to be demolished on demand is only one example of a longstanding national approach."

So you think he built this bridge (and many others like it) in 1272? Were there many fighter jets and factories in 1272?

Or do you think he’s lying about building the bridges and in fact simply planted bombs on pre-existing bridges?

Newspeaker · 30/05/2023 18:17

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 12:17

If this boy had a past life he obviously was a bit of a nutter in it. Why would he put bombs in bridges he had build to protect them? Were 60 bridges ever build in one area/by the same construction workers during any war in recent times, which presumably this is if there were jets? If not then it’s unlikely he’s describing a past life and more likely he’s talking nonsense as kids do.

"Reports in 2014 that explosives had finally been removed from a bridge on the Swiss-German border came as a surprise to some — mostly those who hadn’t realized it had been wired to blow in the first place. The Säckinger Bridge was built over the Rhine in 1272 and has long been considered a national monument, but that didn’t stop the government from rigging it with TNT during the Cold War. Military actions like this were part of a larger Swiss defense strategy, which included withdrawing to the mountains and fighting a guerrilla war if invaded. The idea was to leave rubble rather than functional infrastructure behind. These days, the Swiss military won’t comment on whether other infrastructure is still rigged for reasons of military security. Either way, this bridge set up to be demolished on demand is only one example of a longstanding national approach."

Againstmachine · 30/05/2023 17:28

OnlyFannys · 30/05/2023 12:25

Have you read Eben Alexander's book "Proof of heaven"? Its a very compelling book written by a neurosurgeon (so obviously a very educated man with regards to how the brain works) and his experience when he was essentially brain dead. Not "evidence" as such but an interesting read by a credible source

Eben Alexander appears to so unreliable it's unbelievable.

Multiple malpractice, sacked from lots of medical jobs he is practically incompetent as a doctor. From the doctors who treated him the book is a work of fiction.

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 16:54

Outofthepark · 30/05/2023 16:42

Well this isn't true. Could easily have been pontoon bridges or bailey bridges, and if so, that would've made him a potential war hero, not a nutter. The use of bombs to blow bridges to keep enemy out isn't that unusual either. Could've also been any war since humans began to fight in any country so none of us have any idea!

Sure we can't prove it's true or untrue but...we can't prove it's true or untrue. So why pour scorn as if we have knowledge of something we don't? Truth is, none of us have a clue one way or another so let's not be arrogant or posture about what might be true or false 😄

Well it couldn’t really have been any war since humans began to fight, could it? Because planes and factories are relatively modern concepts, aren’t they?

And we can prove some things are true. That’s what makes them true. I hardly think it’s arrogant to say ‘there is no proof that any person has had a past life.’

Outofthepark · 30/05/2023 16:42

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 12:17

If this boy had a past life he obviously was a bit of a nutter in it. Why would he put bombs in bridges he had build to protect them? Were 60 bridges ever build in one area/by the same construction workers during any war in recent times, which presumably this is if there were jets? If not then it’s unlikely he’s describing a past life and more likely he’s talking nonsense as kids do.

Well this isn't true. Could easily have been pontoon bridges or bailey bridges, and if so, that would've made him a potential war hero, not a nutter. The use of bombs to blow bridges to keep enemy out isn't that unusual either. Could've also been any war since humans began to fight in any country so none of us have any idea!

Sure we can't prove it's true or untrue but...we can't prove it's true or untrue. So why pour scorn as if we have knowledge of something we don't? Truth is, none of us have a clue one way or another so let's not be arrogant or posture about what might be true or false 😄

Outofthepark · 30/05/2023 16:34

blobby10 · 28/05/2023 15:30

Yes I do and had similar with my then 2year old son x we never questioned him or put words into his mouth but some of the stuff he came out with was amazing x between the ages of 2 and 5 he talked about two separate previous lives and even described dying when he fell off a boat 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️who am I to say whether he was or wasn’t telling the truth? Just because science can’t prove it doesn’t make it untrue

Yeah, I'm with this. Science can prove testable things. If we can't prove something by testing it, there's no scientists out there with pitchforks. It just means we can't call it a field of science, and it remains in the camp of 'we don't know' as we can't prove or disprove it. Which is kinda exciting really, to know it could be a possibility.

OnlyFannys · 30/05/2023 16:23

CurlewKate · 30/05/2023 16:12

@OnlyFannys I don't think I have read Alexander's book-although I did read a lot of books like it when I was going down a rabbit hole a few years ago and I have read about him. IIRC, his attending physician raised many concerns about his account of the events around his experience.

According to an article released in 2018 there were some false reports around this, the article links to an independent, peer reviewed medical journal though I haven't had time to read it through

http://ebenalexander.com/independent-medical-review-validates-facts/

Independent Medical Review Validates Facts

In the decade since my near-death experience (NDE) during a week-long coma in November 2008, I have been through many ups and downs in sharing my experience with the world. The low point involved a published account of false and misleading statements....

http://ebenalexander.com/independent-medical-review-validates-facts

CurlewKate · 30/05/2023 16:12

@OnlyFannys I don't think I have read Alexander's book-although I did read a lot of books like it when I was going down a rabbit hole a few years ago and I have read about him. IIRC, his attending physician raised many concerns about his account of the events around his experience.

OnlyFannys · 30/05/2023 12:25

CurlewKate · 30/05/2023 12:16

"You cant just dismiss these experiences as hallucinations, there's no way you can know or prove that's what they were. To so confidently state "hallucinations" as a Fact is rather arrogant." I can- until such time as proper evidence is put forward to prove me wrong. Then I will happily change my position. As far as I know, there is no such evidence.

Have you read Eben Alexander's book "Proof of heaven"? Its a very compelling book written by a neurosurgeon (so obviously a very educated man with regards to how the brain works) and his experience when he was essentially brain dead. Not "evidence" as such but an interesting read by a credible source

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 12:19

But no, I don’t believe in them. I think if people had multiple lives, we would have seen widespread confirmation of them rather than kids saying jumbled statements that parents then twist to sound like it could be ‘past life’ experiences.

Kanaloa · 30/05/2023 12:17

If this boy had a past life he obviously was a bit of a nutter in it. Why would he put bombs in bridges he had build to protect them? Were 60 bridges ever build in one area/by the same construction workers during any war in recent times, which presumably this is if there were jets? If not then it’s unlikely he’s describing a past life and more likely he’s talking nonsense as kids do.

YukoandHiro · 30/05/2023 12:17

Againstmachine · 28/05/2023 18:07

We are living on modern world we shouldn't be believing this woowoo, so yes it is anecdotal.

Just because there is things we can't explain doesn't mean we make shit up to explain it.

I mean, you're right - but obviously billions of people around the world are religious. So people do this every day.

CurlewKate · 30/05/2023 12:16

"You cant just dismiss these experiences as hallucinations, there's no way you can know or prove that's what they were. To so confidently state "hallucinations" as a Fact is rather arrogant." I can- until such time as proper evidence is put forward to prove me wrong. Then I will happily change my position. As far as I know, there is no such evidence.

CurlewKate · 30/05/2023 12:14

I do think "nearly" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in the term "nearly dead." And hearing is, I think, the last sense to go. When I mentioned hallucinations, I was talking about the reports of portals of light and seeing relatives who had already died.

blahblahblah1654 · 30/05/2023 12:13

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing yes I certainly don't find the idea of reincarnation comforting.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 30/05/2023 12:12

It’s such a comforting thought to think we might get another go, but equally feel unlikely

That said, perhaps it’s not comforting, as we could get brought back into a part of the world where life is much less rosy

blahblahblah1654 · 30/05/2023 12:10

I suppose you could be classed as clinically dead, but there would still need to be some brain activity

mamabear715 · 30/05/2023 12:10

Yes, I believe. Not giving details as the sceptics would have a birthday.
#Rolls eyes.

blahblahblah1654 · 30/05/2023 12:09

No one has really died and returned. That's why we can't prove anything after death. Once you die it's a one way ticket to wherever that is. When your brain truly dies that's it. The visions/experiences happen when the person is still alive. Not discounting it entirely as how would I know, but it seems far fetched.

Hopelesscynic · 30/05/2023 12:05

CurlewKate · 30/05/2023 10:14

Brains starved of oxygen hallucinate.

Not when things the "nearly dead" people have said after returning to life, exactly describe what's been happening around them while "dead" (e.g confirming what they've heard doctors say word for word or "seeing" things while out of body that they shouldn't be able to see - again confirmed by the doctors working in them, relatives present etc).
You cant just dismiss these experiences as hallucinations, there's no way you can know or prove that's what they were. To so confidently state "hallucinations" as a Fact is rather arrogant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread