Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you believe in past lives?

396 replies

Sayhellolikethis · 28/05/2023 15:06

Name changed, as I’ve told MIL and DSis about this already…

Putting my little boy (just turned 4) to bed and he told me “I built 60 bridges during the war and I also built a bomb”. I asked him why he built a bomb and he said “I put 2 bombs on each of my bridges to protect them”. He also said “the factories were covered in camouflage”.

He then added “and a fighter jet plane falled to the ground”.

It was such a ramble of words and then he just wanted to snuggle down and go to sleep.

Has anyone else had a similar experience with their little ones? He won’t talk about it any further. Puzzled!!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
anon12093 · 28/05/2023 22:41

I think no one will truly ever know.

JaneyGee · 28/05/2023 22:28

I doubt we have an immortal soul that re-inhabits another body at death. Other things could explain this stuff. Jung believed that we inherit a collective unconscious, which he described as a ‘million year old man’. For him, it was a kind of collective memory. When a child dreams about ‘monsters’, for example, maybe he’s seeing the reptiles and snakes that hunted our mammalian ancestors. Even Freud thought there was some truth to this.

I’ve got a hunch that we inherit the memories of out ancestors - especially the traumatic ones. People who experiment with LSD, for example (I mean those who do it carefully and seriously, under laboratory conditions) claim they have travelled into their DNA and ‘seen’ incidents from their ancestral past. Then there is epigenetics, which may cast some light on it. All this is way beyond me, but I have a hunch that is what we’re really seeing in past life regression. I’m convinced we somehow inherit memories and traumas, not just of our great grandparents, but of our species, and even our genus.

Frabbits · 28/05/2023 22:24

Rollonannualeave · 28/05/2023 21:39

The skeptics on this thread strike me as lazy thinkers that want everyone else to bend over backwards trying to prove things to their very closed and made up minds.

See, it seems to me that believers in woo are the lazy thinkers. Just accepting stuff with no reason or logic requires no effort at all.

IlIlI · 28/05/2023 22:17

I didn't. Then DC spoke repeatedly about where they used to live, their old family etc. I just used to nod along and not know what to say, just listened.
I'm not so sure after that, I don't know what to believe. It all seemed so real and some topics toddlers shouldn't know about.

KrisAkabusi · 28/05/2023 22:07

I imagine that fervent believers would just refuse to believe the new evidence. After all, religion is just a matter of choosing what to believe. I don't think it would have much effect on religion.

No. At the moment ALL religions exist despite no evidence for any of them This time you have proof that one is right and the rest are wrong. That's going to shake things up!

Why would sentences for murder change? Do you mean that courts would opt for life imprisonment instead?
No, I mean that because murder is only a temporary condition, it may not be treated as seriously as it is now.

Inheritance would not change - it would be widely accepted, as it is now, that you 'can't take it with you' so to speak. Death ends all property ownership, and marriage, and all relationships, notwithstanding reincarnation.

Really? You think if Donald Trump dies and cones back he won't want his millions again? He'll happily accept starting from scratch again?

So next time round you could marry someone who used to be a close blood relative, as they are not related in the next life.
I'm not touching that one! 😀

lucya66 · 28/05/2023 21:55

I don’t not believe it but how could a person build 60 bridges and 120 bombs in the space of a war? Maybe he was overseeing it rather than building himself. Seems like a lot of work to do all that.

yvonneb13 · 28/05/2023 21:54

Yes I do.
Watch Barra boys AMAZING!! Total eye opener

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 21:50

KrisAkabusi · 28/05/2023 21:35

Well, for a start all religions except Buddhism would have been proven to be false. You can only imagine the effects that would have on fervent believers. There would be a much different opinion around death if you KNEW it isn't permanent. You could imagine changes in sentencing for murder if it turned out to be only a temporary condition. Attitudes to the death penalty would also change. Inheritance laws would have to change if you could show you were back again and wanted your original wealth. Our entire belief in how everything works would be completely overthrown!

Now this is an interesting discussion.

I imagine that fervent believers would just refuse to believe the new evidence. After all, religion is just a matter of choosing what to believe. I don't think it would have much effect on religion.

Why would sentences for murder change? Do you mean that courts would opt for life imprisonment instead?

Inheritance would not change - it would be widely accepted, as it is now, that you 'can't take it with you' so to speak. Death ends all property ownership, and marriage, and all relationships, notwithstanding reincarnation.
So next time round you could marry someone who used to be a close blood relative, as they are not related in the next life.

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 21:42

Having blind faith in woo is not logical.

Having blind faith in anything is not logical.
I am not in favour of blind faith, although I recognise that many (most?) people need it for emotional and psychological reasons.

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 21:40

There is also no evidence for souls, which is what your theory requires.

Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
There is no evidence that 'souls' don't exist.

Rollonannualeave · 28/05/2023 21:39

The skeptics on this thread strike me as lazy thinkers that want everyone else to bend over backwards trying to prove things to their very closed and made up minds.

Frabbits · 28/05/2023 21:38

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 21:21

It is not my intention to mock anyone - apologies if it has come across that way. Nor am I trying to convince anyone of my point of view.

I am just questioning people to encourage them to reconsider how entrenched and illogical their own view might be.

I accept things as true when they are shown to be. That's pretty logical.

Having blind faith in woo is not logical.

kingtamponthefurred · 28/05/2023 21:37

Rollonannualeave · 28/05/2023 17:01

Wow. Please do not discount this. Gently ask questions and document details. Ask what his name was etc you may want to get in touch with a past life specialist.

A past life specialist 😂😂where do you study to become one of those? The University of Narnia?

Frabbits · 28/05/2023 21:36

Rollonannualeave · 28/05/2023 21:22

@Frabbits do your own research. Keep an open mind. Why expect others to do it for you? What evidence do you have that past lives do not exist?

I don't need to disprove something for which there is no evidence. It's just the default position.

Equally, why should I waste my time looking for evidence of something just because you believe I it? Having blind faith in something is the opposite of being open-minded.

If you are sure that something extraordinary exists, then prove it. Shouldn't be hard if you have actual evidence for it. If you can't then you absolutely cannot expect anyone to accept it just because you think it's true.

HermioneWeasley · 28/05/2023 21:36

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 20:38

If something is being claimed that is in complete opposition to how something is known to work

How do you know how reincarnation or death and rebirth is "known to work"?
And why do you assume that is in complete opposition to everything else you already know?

I explained earlier in the thread how human memory works. Being able to recall a past life doesn’t fit with what we know. There is also no evidence for souls, which is what your theory requires.

as I said upthread, just because there are new discoveries being made doesn’t mean that the things that are known and understood can be thrown in the bin.

a lack of critical and scientific thinking is harmful to society as a whole

KrisAkabusi · 28/05/2023 21:35

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 20:58

Don't you think that if there was any evidence for reincarnation it would change absolutely everything about our lives?

No I don't think it would change anything at all, except that possibly some people would try to be a bit nicer, in case they incurred 'bad karma' and had a worse life next time.
What do you think it would change?

Well, for a start all religions except Buddhism would have been proven to be false. You can only imagine the effects that would have on fervent believers. There would be a much different opinion around death if you KNEW it isn't permanent. You could imagine changes in sentencing for murder if it turned out to be only a temporary condition. Attitudes to the death penalty would also change. Inheritance laws would have to change if you could show you were back again and wanted your original wealth. Our entire belief in how everything works would be completely overthrown!

cardibach · 28/05/2023 21:34

Rollonannualeave · 28/05/2023 21:22

@Frabbits do your own research. Keep an open mind. Why expect others to do it for you? What evidence do you have that past lives do not exist?

‘Do your own research’ is utter nonsense. Nobody on here is equipped to do a proper scientific study with all the safeguards. Nobody has even attempted the first step of a literature review. ‘Research’ is not the same as using google. This is where all the daft anti vax and covid denial stuff came from.

MsCactus · 28/05/2023 21:34

HermioneWeasley · 28/05/2023 19:12

@teabycandlelight i believe they are sincere but mistaken as are people who think they’ve had an accurate psychic reading or religious experience. The point is that what is being claimed doesn’t just require knowledge we don’t have now (people from the Middle Ages seeing an aeroplane) but it is in direct contradiction to all our knowledge of how brains and memory works - it requires a supernatural explanation that works completely differently to everything we know but only sometimes. I do not have to be open minded about that any more than I have to be open minded about the existence of magic, fairies or Thor.

It's not "in direct contradiction to how all our brain and memories work" ...

Scientists have studied and proven inherited memories, and there's examples in the animal kingdom - for example cats are born with the "memory" of how to hunt, they don't need to be taught by their mothers. All instinctive responses are memories pasted down through generations which another animal learnt at one time or another and then their offspring inherits this taught memory.

Just had to point that out as there's lots of people saying memories can't be inherited, but actually it's common among animals - proven in science - and happens all the time. It's not such a stretch to think over memories could be inherited

Rollonannualeave · 28/05/2023 21:22

@Frabbits do your own research. Keep an open mind. Why expect others to do it for you? What evidence do you have that past lives do not exist?

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 21:21

Frabbits · 28/05/2023 21:11

If you want to convince people of a viewpoint, you need to present evidence otherwise you are just relying on blind faith and as such have no right or ability at all to attempt to change people's minds or mock them for their apparent lack fo faith.

It is not my intention to mock anyone - apologies if it has come across that way. Nor am I trying to convince anyone of my point of view.

I am just questioning people to encourage them to reconsider how entrenched and illogical their own view might be.

Frabbits · 28/05/2023 21:11

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 21:07

No thank you. I don't feel the need to do your research for you.

If you want to convince people of a viewpoint, you need to present evidence otherwise you are just relying on blind faith and as such have no right or ability at all to attempt to change people's minds or mock them for their apparent lack fo faith.

Nanalisa60 · 28/05/2023 21:11

My little boy up until he was about 4 , always told me he did not really like the dark sea because he had drowned in it and died, he loved swimming pool put never liked the sea. We also lived by the sea and when we walked to the harbour he would look over the harbour wall and say it was in sea like that I died in the dark cold sea when the boat went down.

Stillcountingbeans · 28/05/2023 21:07

Frabbits · 28/05/2023 20:57

Here's your chance to show us some quality evidence then. Have a go at changing some minds.

No thank you. I don't feel the need to do your research for you.

Frabbits · 28/05/2023 20:59

Pinkbonbon · 28/05/2023 20:50

Isn't energy indestructible anyway? I mean, the food cycle and all that...

Quick Google search mentions 'the law of conservation of energy'. That all things are made up of energy and that energy is only ever transformed into something else, not created or destroyed.

Suppose that would fit in with theories like...chi?
Potentially even reincarnation?

Isn't there some scientific theory about how there are several other dimensions right where we are standing too?

Maybe science will prove some things we never expected it to one day.

A memory isn't energy. Nobody thinks of being able to remember something in the same way as, y'know, kinetic energy or sound. Because that would be daft.