Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wibu if your childminder did this....

56 replies

Neverhaveenoughmoney · 28/05/2023 12:56

Said they couldn't offer a term time contract anymore.
I've NC for obvious reasons. I'm a CM and work with my husband. We are very busy but with all the increasing costs the business is really struggling. The main reason for this is in the school holidays we lose about two thirds of our income due to the fact that so many of our children are term time only.
When we first opened we had some older children in the holidays and some little ones and it was all ok. We earnt less but because the normal months were better financially we could always save for the lesser months.
However now this is not the case. Despite cutting back as much as we can without it effecting the quality of care most months we go overdrawn. I've done some costings for the summer hols and we are not even going to have money to pay half our bills let alone shopping etc.
I've been so worried this week I've barely slept and we have both looked for 2nd jobs.
So the term time parents only pay £15 per day during their contracted days in school holidays to retain the space for term time weeks. So instead of a daily rate of between £43 - 47 it's a big loss for us. All our school children are also tto and no one needs school hol care as they are teachers.
I'm considering saying I am going to have to stop this off and start charging half or full fees all year round.
I imagine this will cause so much upset but I don't know what else to do. We tried having older children in the hols last year and it was a disaster. They were so demanding and it took 1 of us to look after them and the other left with the little ones. Outings were a nightmare too when we could get out as it was hard to fit in the car.
Would really appreciate other parents views on this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Clymene · 28/05/2023 18:02

And I apologise OP, this spat can't be at all helpful.

I'd get an excel spreadsheet and run through some different scenarios.

Start with your break even number and then work out what you need to make to turn a profit that is enough to live comfortably.

What are your overheads? What costs can you cut?

And then you need to work out how many of the different kids you need to have have to make the numbers work:
Under 5s
Term time only (after school and/or before school)
All year round school aged kids
Etc.

A simple sum function would do the calculations for you.

I'm sure you can make it work but you have to think of it as a business, not a kind service. As a pp said, I suspect the fact that you're cheap for teachers has spread by word of mouth and now you've got into a situation where loads of your kids are TTO which isn't financially sustainable.

There will be a way forward so I would plan for launching whatever it is you need to do in September.

Whatabouteverything · 28/05/2023 17:58

lostat · 28/05/2023 13:09

It's not that low paid if you have your maximum numbers. Most I've ever earned!

I cant see how it would pay more than 25k or similar? If that?

Clymene · 28/05/2023 17:54

luckylavender · 28/05/2023 17:45

@Clymene - have you ever been in a perilous financial position? Or sunk everything into your own business? Then someone you don't know says your business isn't viable. You may think your words were just factual, this is someone's life.

I run my own successful business.

I'm a single parent and before it took off, I was living on income support and writing SEO content for pennies to try and survive.

Any more questions?

Creamyoda · 28/05/2023 17:47

Here year round childminders are like hens teeth, you'd be snapped up! Ours was term time but did close for x number of agreed weeks they let us know at the start of each year and of course didn't charge for those but meant they got a holiday etc and we had time to book annual leave. Could you offer a summer club? Also very rare around here and people end up paying £££s- this includes for little ones who are at term time nurseries.

luckylavender · 28/05/2023 17:45

@Clymene - have you ever been in a perilous financial position? Or sunk everything into your own business? Then someone you don't know says your business isn't viable. You may think your words were just factual, this is someone's life.

Clymene · 28/05/2023 17:35

luckylavender · 28/05/2023 17:28

But there's no need to be so rude

Can you explain to me what I said that was rude? Here's my post. It's factual, I said I was sorry that it doesn't seem to be viable, and I suggested a way they could make it work.

If your business is making a loss, it's not a viable business, sorry. I would scale right back and just offer after school /before school care for those children who make up the bulk of your income with only one adult caring for them. So 6 kids I think is the limit?

And the other one of you get a full time job.

luckylavender · 28/05/2023 17:28

But there's no need to be so rude

Whatt · 28/05/2023 17:17

Time to do some childcare agency work in the holidays. You can pick where and when you work.

nobodygoesdowninthejungle · 28/05/2023 17:15

So you're currently charging for 39 weeks of the year but want to start charging for 52 weeks. If you charge for those weeks at the same rate as your usual weeks, your fees will go up by a third.
Can your customers afford that? And will they pay it? How much are the alternative options where you are? If they can't or won't pay the increase, will you be able to fill your places easily at your new rates or might you struggle?
Also, do you want to work the school holidays? Are you going to shut for any period each year and do you want to be paid for that?
Depending on your answers to those, you can then re-visit your business model and decide how to proceed.
I'm sorry to say it but I think you're probably already screwed for this summer. You'll have to give your parents 4 weeks' notice of this (or whatever the notice period is in your contract)?so that they can give notice. If I was one of your TTO parents, I'd give notice 4 weeks before the end of this summer term, not pay anything to anyone for childcare over the summer and start a new childcare arrangement from late August/early Sept.

montessorinanny · 28/05/2023 16:49

I am a childminder. Mine is the only income coming into the house so I have to put a limit on the number of TTO contracts I offer otherwise I cannot afford to pay my bills over the summer. Can you do some bank work with a nursery over the summer to keep you going until September. From September you can perhaps put up your TTO rate and any new parents coming on board need to pay all year round until a TTO space becomes available. You can then decide how many TTO spaces you would like to offer and have a waiting list for those places.

lanthanum · 28/05/2023 16:20

It sounds as if the problem is that you've ended up with almost all teachers, attracted by the term-time only contract (and probably word of mouth). In the longer term, you probably need to charge more for the term-time only contracts, or restrict the number of them you are prepared to offer. I knew a nursery that had lots of teachers' kids - being larger, I think they could accommodate that more easily - the lower numbers probably enabled their own staff to have their holidays in the school holidays.

I don't think it will go down well if you say now that you're charging more over this summer, but giving notice now of a change from September will give people time to look at other options if need be. Depending on the market locally, they might find you're still the best option.

Badbudgeter · 28/05/2023 16:13

No idea why that posted twice. Sorry!

Badbudgeter · 28/05/2023 16:12

Neverhaveenoughmoney · 28/05/2023 15:57

Thanks some good points to consider. I don't want older children in the school hols as they are too hard to manage with the younger ones and eat so much I spend even more money!
I am qualified but nursery work is minimum wage. I guess my husband could look for a job but it would be a shame for him to pack it in. The kids love him. I also don't want to give notice to my term time little ones but might not have a choice. I suppose the decision will be there's.

Older children’s parents are completely used to providing a packed lunch, copious snacks and a fiver for an ice cream though. One of you could take the older children, one the younger. Have you got any holiday places/ hotels close by? A childminder friend does wedding childcare at a nice local hotel, mainly Saturdays but she charges £££s. Also does babysitting at the same hotel for £25 an hour whilst Mum has a massage in the spa. She only does wrap around childcare now as makes more money not having dc during the day.

Badbudgeter · 28/05/2023 16:09

Neverhaveenoughmoney · 28/05/2023 15:57

Thanks some good points to consider. I don't want older children in the school hols as they are too hard to manage with the younger ones and eat so much I spend even more money!
I am qualified but nursery work is minimum wage. I guess my husband could look for a job but it would be a shame for him to pack it in. The kids love him. I also don't want to give notice to my term time little ones but might not have a choice. I suppose the decision will be there's.

Older children’s parents are completely used to providing a packed lunch, copious snacks and a fiver for an ice cream though. One of you could take the older children, one the younger. Have you got any holiday places/ hotels close by? A childminder friend does wedding childcare at a nice local hotel, mainly Saturdays but she charges £££s. Also does babysitting at the same hotel for £25 an hour whilst Mum has a massage in the spa. She only does wrap around childcare now as makes more money not having dc during the day.

rosesinmygarden · 28/05/2023 16:07

I'm a teacher and we chose our child minder because she offered term time only contracts. However, we paid a premium for this and were contracted to pay in full for all dates on our days in term time, whether we used them or not. We paid the same every week for 39 weeks even if dd did not attend for any reason. This was fine for me as a salaried teacher, and it meant the childminder knew exactly what she had coming in from us.

She was fab though, and I'd have been happy to pay her a retainer/fee over the holidays if it meant keeping our place.

I think you have to do what you need to, to make your business financially viable.

I'm now a private tutor and have a similar set up as I can't afford for people to just come and go as they please.

Clymene · 28/05/2023 16:06

@luckylavender - it's a business! There being a dearth of CMs is neither here nor there. If the OP's business model means she's running at a deficit, she either need to change the model or do something else.

At the moment she is getting into debt which is not sustainable.

Neverhaveenoughmoney · 28/05/2023 15:57

Thanks some good points to consider. I don't want older children in the school hols as they are too hard to manage with the younger ones and eat so much I spend even more money!
I am qualified but nursery work is minimum wage. I guess my husband could look for a job but it would be a shame for him to pack it in. The kids love him. I also don't want to give notice to my term time little ones but might not have a choice. I suppose the decision will be there's.

OP posts:
SpringGreensPreens · 28/05/2023 14:51

I think you’ll need to advertise for new clients who want year round care and give notice to the term time only ones as you find new clients.

hookiewookie29 · 28/05/2023 14:45

Can you change payments so their fees are worrked out over 12 months? I have 2 teachers children and I work their fees out over 12 months so I have money coming in all year.

Mumuser124 · 28/05/2023 14:45

I pay my child minder all year round. It’s a retainer fee for the place, rather than how much he goes.

I pay full price, even when she’s on holiday. Obviously I’d love to not have to pay for time I don’t use but I understand it is her income and I wouldn’t expect to not be paid for my AL etc in my job so same rules applying

Parkandpicnic · 28/05/2023 14:42

Your terms should be what works for you as a CM, I’ve had CM that have had to change their offer and prices and that’s been fine by me. Sometimes it’s meant hasn’t worked to continue but still grateful for the care they gave my children and having facilitates me to be able to work.

Anothernameonthewall · 28/05/2023 14:41

I used to Cm. One way I got round this without charging outwith term time (except for retainer fees) was a small overall hourly increase (50p/ £1) and change the way you bill. Instead of monthly invoicing, work out how much each family owes over the year and then divide by 12. That is then your monthly set fee. Any additional charges accrued can be billed separately if need be. Much quicker on your monthly paperwork and admin too.

luckylavender · 28/05/2023 14:40

Clymene · 28/05/2023 13:02

If your business is making a loss, it's not a viable business, sorry. I would scale right back and just offer after school /before school care for those children who make up the bulk of your income with only one adult caring for them. So 6 kids I think is the limit?

And the other one of you get a full time job.

Gosh that's harsh. There's a real lack of childminders currently, so hounding them out of business isn't ideal. Good luck OP.

Beautiful3 · 28/05/2023 14:38

Could you run a holiday club? I'd stop with the term time only kids too. Or charge a higher daily rate to cover the holidays?

Tarantella6 · 28/05/2023 14:36

The problem with CM for older ones in holidays is it's a much more expensive option - if I can use a holiday club for £25 why would I pay twice that for a CM? Unless you've got a real shortage of clubs locally, I'm not sure a CM is people's first choice, unless they're already using you in term time.

How does the £15 retainer compare to your normal wraparound fee? Is it a lot less? Surely charging the wraparound fee all year round wouldn't be a huge increase for those parents?

Swipe left for the next trending thread