Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find this deeply unusual and sad?

455 replies

ToTheMax0 · 28/05/2023 12:04

Met a 39 Yr old lady the other day at a small gathering at my neighbours.
I asked if she was married with kids and she looked embarrassed and said no to neither. Later on in the evening, she admitted she had never kissed a man or dated, nothing like that. Not assexual, just nothing has ever led her to a relationship and she's scared to date online but also, not entirely interested. She went to mixed schools but was teased for being ugly and then onto an almost all female college and university. Was never into the pub and club scene as a young woman either. Just find it sad for her.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 28/05/2023 14:32

"It's the same as asking someone 'what do you do for work?' if the answer is just a stay at home mom"

Interesting because I was once asked 'Do you work?' I was really shocked as if the person thought I was an heiress or something. I don't much like being asked what my job is, but I accept that it's a normal getting to know you question.

Moveoverdarlin · 28/05/2023 14:31

Her life sounds positively idyllic.

CremeEggThief · 28/05/2023 14:28

Have to agree you sound nosy and intrusive, OP, and you don't seem embarrassed or ashamed of it either, judging by your replies to posters who have pulled you on it either! YABU!

HadleyVaughn · 28/05/2023 14:27

It's fairly standard "getting to know you" stuff in my experience.

@coffeecupsandwaxmelts - how old are you though? Like I said in my post above, I think this is a dated type of small talk that isn't really socially acceptable without invitiation as it's intrusive and people are aware that it may carry implied judgment and justification.

It's the same as asking someone 'what do you do for work?' if the answer is just a stay at home mom, the person asking has indicated an expectation of a job and it is highlighting a personal life choice someone may not want to justify or feel judged about.

Wednesdaysotherchild · 28/05/2023 14:22

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 28/05/2023 12:24

I don't think asking someone whether they're married and have children is the big deal PP's are making it out to be. It's fairly standard "getting to know you" stuff in my experience.

Sure, if you want to hear about my 14 miscarriages, do go ahead and ask! I might cry on you but I’m done pussyfooting around rude people now…

HarrietJet · 28/05/2023 14:21

Wishing4sunshine · 28/05/2023 12:09

Why did you even ask her?

Yes, honestly... You really got into it with a complete stranger, op. Maybe mind your own business going forward?

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 28/05/2023 14:17

I dread being introduced to smug, rude, nosey, intrusive people like you!

porridgeisbae · 28/05/2023 14:16

Conversation might be a bit limited.

@Gwenhwyfar That might be better for all concerned.

Travellingwillow · 28/05/2023 14:16

I'm single, no kids, had long term relationships. Have to say I'm alot more content than alot ofmarrieds I know, either from problematic current or ex relationships and or their children, and I'm not even referring g to baby toddler kids. Get well peed off with women/men assuming I'm sad, deprived or in someway pitiful because of my status.

I do have single friends who are in a similar place to your acquaintance who have not had long term relationships or even short ones, they do feel they've missed something be it children, having sox or companionship. But they are in no way SAD or to be pitied. Theyre intelligent, witty and independent every one of them, men are the ones who have missed out.

willWillSmithsmith · 28/05/2023 14:16

Unless it’s a natural progression in a conversation I’d never randomly ask someone if they’re married or have children for small talk. The strange bit for me would be that she told you some stuff that I’d consider personal (never been kissed etc). That’s as unusual to me as me telling some stranger at a social gathering when I lost my virginity.

Another note - the people wondering if you’re male - I wonder that as do women refer to another woman as a lady (unless they’re telling their young child to say thank you to the lady or similar). I never refer to other women as ladies.

HadleyVaughn · 28/05/2023 14:15

Come on now, most will ask if a woman is married or has kids, it's just social chit chat.

I think in 2023 this is a bit out of touch and very dated for lots of reasons

First there isn't really an expectation any more that a woman is married or has children. This question really only tends to come from older married women who are a bit out of touch.

Second the whole #bekind movement - you don't know who you are talking to, there are plenty of people who wanted children but couldn't have thtem, rounds of £££ failed IVF, plenty of people who suffered bereavement and this kind of question is on a sensitive subject that is very distressing for people.

Third, I think now it is more conventional to wait for people to volunteer that information themselves. Similar sexuality - how on earth you know she is not assexual blows my mind. I hope to god you didn't ask her. If anything I feel sorry for her being put in a situation where she felt obligated to reveal this information to a total stranger

Fouth, there are a lot of people who are child free by choice and have fulfilled happy lives without the kind of problems that come with being married to often selfish men and having to raise children. Statisically single women are much happier than married women; unsurprisingly married men (catered for) are happiest. Asking the question is dated anyway but persisting is basically putting someone in a situation where they are feeling obligated to justify their life choices to you which is rude.

Whatever you say, given the whole tone of your post, I bet anything that you conveyed to her that it was in your view a terrible thing she wasn't married and didn't have children (which itself is a bit of a sad world view) - whether by your further questions or even by body language by a little tilt of the head, microgestures, and soft "oh".

BCBird · 28/05/2023 14:15

It's only sad if she feels sad about it,not u.

mrsbyers · 28/05/2023 14:14

Lambstails · 28/05/2023 13:55

@mrsbyers

I remember being in a similar situation moving into a 3 bed house on a typical suburban estate - one of the local kids came up and asked if I was married , said no, did I have kids , said no and then she piped up so what do you need a 3 bed house for ? Obviously her parents had been gossiping.

This happened to me too! We went to a neighbour's house for dinner recently, where there was another invited couple who lived in the village (we had never met the other couple before). Halfway through the meal, the woman asked how many children we had, when I said "we don't", she looked at me gone out and said "what the hell have you got a 4 bedroom house for then?". I wanted to tell her to fuck off and keep her snout out of my business, but instead I opted for the truth and told her that when we bought the house over 20 years ago, the plan was to fill every bedroom with tiny feet, but it sadly never happened for us. Even then, she seemed to think we should have downsized. Some people 😂😂

There’s only three houses in our new build street , all four bed houses and all ‘just’ a couple living in them - so it’s deffo not unusual. For us we have a separate bedroom each due to snoring / medical issues , one for a spare and one room for office / gym / music room so it’s perfect for us

MaggieBsBoat · 28/05/2023 14:12

I find @ToTheMax0 your level of interpersonal skills quite low.
I’m 50, network a lot because of my career and it would absolutely not cross my mind to ask a question such as this to a woman on meeting her (or man for that matter) the first time. Up your game!

arethereanyleftatall · 28/05/2023 14:12

I find people like the op absolutely pointless to talk to.

Just zero understanding that anyone who doesn't have a life exactly like theirs is, can't possibly be happy.

It's also deeply patronising.

The ops response to this woman is why she was embarrassed. But she shouldn't be. She should be embarrassed on behalf of the op.

KimberleyClark · 28/05/2023 14:11

It would have served you right if she had answered “No, I’m asexual and I can’t have kids anyway - had to have a hysterectomy ten years ago”.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/05/2023 14:08

"This is why people have dogs."

Conversation might be a bit limited.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/05/2023 14:07

"The one question I'd have been interested to ask the victim is which single-sex university she went to, as I wasn't aware of any."

Try studying languages!
And my uni had an all female hall as well (mainly popular with some foreign students).

PlinkPlonkFizz · 28/05/2023 14:05

ToTheMax0 · 28/05/2023 12:04

Met a 39 Yr old lady the other day at a small gathering at my neighbours.
I asked if she was married with kids and she looked embarrassed and said no to neither. Later on in the evening, she admitted she had never kissed a man or dated, nothing like that. Not assexual, just nothing has ever led her to a relationship and she's scared to date online but also, not entirely interested. She went to mixed schools but was teased for being ugly and then onto an almost all female college and university. Was never into the pub and club scene as a young woman either. Just find it sad for her.

  1. Bet you're male
  2. Bet you're a troll
  3. If you are not 1 or 2, you sound like a patronising busybody with limited imagination.
CuntingSheep · 28/05/2023 14:05

I know relationships are really tough at times but the connection and love is worth it

This is why people have dogs.

The one question I'd have been interested to ask the victim is which single-sex university she went to, as I wasn't aware of any.

porridgeisbae · 28/05/2023 14:03

@ToTheMax0 I had two miscarriages so I would feel uncomfortable if someone asked me if I had children. Maybe about marriage etc too.

Rhondaa · 28/05/2023 14:03

'Come on now, most will ask if a woman is married or has kids, it's just social chit chat.'

I'd never ask such personal questions. Someone could be recently separated, be having fertility problems anything. You're putting yourself and them in a potentially awkward situation.

I'd stick to weather and what you've seen on the telly tbh.

Crossandupset · 28/05/2023 14:02

Are you always so toe-curling condescending?

TheKobayashiMaru · 28/05/2023 14:02

You remind me of people I met in the 90's OP. They asked me what I did when we met on holiday, the light left their eyes when they heard. It is all about finding out if you were 'their type of person', not genuine interest.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 28/05/2023 14:01

ErinTingey · 28/05/2023 13:56

I know relationships are really tough at times but the connection and love is worth it.

What if she is asexual? The 'no sex' part of it makes compatible partners incredibly hard to find.

Plus there are other things that really aren’t worth it. Last time I trusted a man enough to be alone with him I was forcibly raped. I have PTSD and won’t ever put myself in a situation where that could happen again even if it means being alone forever. And no, I wouldn’t be disclosing information like that to a random neighbour, my go to line is just to say love has never really happened for me but in reality it’s far more complex than that.