Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect grandparents to visit me?

56 replies

snottyqueen · 28/05/2023 10:53

I moved to a city around 2 hours away. Now live with my partner, happily, in a city centre flat. It's great, I can walk to things and be independent. Have a great relationship with my family.

My parents live miles from the nearest shop. I don't drive. Their house is very run down, and the only working toilet is in their en-suite. It isn't a great place to visit unless my partner rents a car. So I avoid going home to visit other than once every 3 months or so for a weekend.

More recently I have been getting lots of comments from my mum and her parents that it would be nice to see me. I have mentioned that I will be back for a weekend next month, and they are always welcome to come and visit me. Whilst we don't have a spare bedroom, I have slept on the sofa before so people can visit as hotels are expensive here.

Fortunately my grandparents are in fairly good health, and travel a lot independently. One has recently been to Crete for three weeks and another has just done a tour of Scotland (self driven). They are in their early 80s. Money isn't an issue for them.

AIBU to think that it would be nice for grandparents to visit me in my adopted home city? A day trip is feasible, and would be about 4 hours round trip on the train. Otherwise, if booked in advance you can get a hotel for £200 or even £100 mid week.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/05/2023 20:41

None of you would want your grandparents to visit once so they see where and how you live etc when they are active, travelling and visiting others happily.
Sure

It literally never occurred to me that my surviving grandparent (by that time in his 80s) would travel to where I moved as an adult. He managed to visit their own children but there was no way he could have visited all his grandchildren. We all visited him.

phoenixrosehere · 28/05/2023 20:34

YANBU.

My own parents did this when I lived away, ignoring the major cost and time it took from me. I was taking buses and trains to see them. Yet, when my sister moved 12 hours away, they visited her more than they visited me. My dad was not happy when I moved overseas even though he had seven years to visit me and only did twice. There was no way I could live where they live because the opportunities weren’t there for me and I know many of the people I grew up with are saving money, trying to move out of the area themselves.

It’s ridiculous that the expectation to visit is expected to be one-sided because one side moved away when people are not only able but can afford to visit. It shows where their expectations and priorities lie.

Jeannie88 · 28/05/2023 20:03

Why don't you make a date for them to come and visit? Say you would love them to come and stay with u or hotel if they prefer, would be so nice to show them around and take out for a meal. Sometimes it really does take those extra few words filled with love and encouragement ❤️

TomatoSandwiches · 28/05/2023 19:36

I don't actually disagree with you op, they seem capable, if they wanted to I'm sure they would except they just naturally assume because you are young it is your job to go to them and don't realise how much you work?
They will just have to wait until you do your scheduled visit.

Grapewrath · 28/05/2023 19:34

Yanbu op
There is a weird rule that only exists on mumsnet where if you move away, you have to make the trips home and should never expect this reciprocated
I understand your gps being elderly is an issue but like you say they are very happy to visit elsewhere

girlfriend44 · 28/05/2023 19:29

snottyqueen · 28/05/2023 12:58

Not that it's really that relevant, but they are not at all short on cash, so it won't be the cost putting them off.

I just think it would be nice for them to see where I live, what my life here is like et cetera. That's all. 😊

I agree. It's not unreasonable for you to want them to see where you live, your life etc.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 28/05/2023 19:22

sadieshavingashindig · 28/05/2023 15:55

Why don't you just tell them how much it would mean to you for them to visit you instead of quietly stewing over it and getting angry.

Stop being so sensible Grin

thecatinthetwat · 28/05/2023 19:18

I think there’s a bit of a generation thing here. The expectation is for younger generations to visit the older ones. Nothing wrong with your stance op, but I think there’s a status quo thing going on. Do a proper invite and then if they don’t except just write it off as a no-go.

DelphiniumBlue · 28/05/2023 15:56

I do think a 4 hour round trip in one day with visiting/ outings etc in between is probably a big ask for someone in their 80s even if they are fit. But as they are fit enough for holidays, I don't see why they can't visit for a weekend. What have they said when you've asked them directly?
It might be worth issuing a specific invitation with clear dates and times, offering for them to stay with you but also linking to nearby hotels .
Is it your mum saying it's too much?

sadieshavingashindig · 28/05/2023 15:55

Why don't you just tell them how much it would mean to you for them to visit you instead of quietly stewing over it and getting angry.

UsingChangeofName · 28/05/2023 15:48

I think if you specifically say "I'd love to see you. Can you come up the Xth - Yth of next month ? I'm not working at the weekend and I've love to be able to show you my new home. You are very welcome to stay with me and I'll sleep in the living room, or, if you prefer a bit more comfort I can find a hotel for you close by and I will meet you at the station and take you home"

It is very different from saying 'It would be nice to see you some time"

olympicsrock · 28/05/2023 15:20

YABU

TheYearOfSmallThings · 28/05/2023 15:17

YABU, especially in relation to your grandparents.

You moved away, you don't drive, and you apparently work 9am to 9pm, which sounds unrewarding for a visitor. In your situation I would learn to drive, and then visit your elderly relatives by car on non-work days. I say that as someone who moved away and uses most of my A/L visiting family - it's not ideal but it isn't their responsibility to visit me when I am the one who left.

bobblyjob · 28/05/2023 15:12

YANBU. It doesn’t sound either practical or tempting for you to visit. People seem to be ignoring the fact you don’t drive (and apparently should have learned solely so you could go and visit your parents) and that your parents house is difficult to stay in
Having said that I can see that they probably just don’t think about visiting because the expectation will be that you will go back. There is no reason they can’t though apart from that is not what normally happens. Sometimes I think the parents/grandparents feel weird coming into our “territory”
i think it’s completely reasonable to ask them. Or how about a half way meet somewhere you can get to? Can you afford an air bnb for the night for all of you in a new spot so it is more of an adventure?

Createausername1970 · 28/05/2023 14:57

snottyqueen · 28/05/2023 10:53

I moved to a city around 2 hours away. Now live with my partner, happily, in a city centre flat. It's great, I can walk to things and be independent. Have a great relationship with my family.

My parents live miles from the nearest shop. I don't drive. Their house is very run down, and the only working toilet is in their en-suite. It isn't a great place to visit unless my partner rents a car. So I avoid going home to visit other than once every 3 months or so for a weekend.

More recently I have been getting lots of comments from my mum and her parents that it would be nice to see me. I have mentioned that I will be back for a weekend next month, and they are always welcome to come and visit me. Whilst we don't have a spare bedroom, I have slept on the sofa before so people can visit as hotels are expensive here.

Fortunately my grandparents are in fairly good health, and travel a lot independently. One has recently been to Crete for three weeks and another has just done a tour of Scotland (self driven). They are in their early 80s. Money isn't an issue for them.

AIBU to think that it would be nice for grandparents to visit me in my adopted home city? A day trip is feasible, and would be about 4 hours round trip on the train. Otherwise, if booked in advance you can get a hotel for £200 or even £100 mid week.

You don't want to visit your own parents very often because they live in a run down area, long way from the shops and only have one loo.

Maybe your grandparents have what they consider to be valid reasons for not visiting you. Maybe they would rather put the £100+ hotel and petrol money towards travelling the world while they still can.

But if you were the one that moved away, the onus is on you to keep the contact going, whether that is you visiting them or issuing invitations.

Nanananananana99 · 28/05/2023 14:30

I was lucky enough to have a couple of grandparents into my mid 30s, never had a grandparent visit me during my adulthood. It’s just not a thing. That doesn’t mean it can’t be if you have a unusual relationship with them but I think you are being a bit unrealistic.

I do think it’s nice that you want them to see how you are making a life for yourself but the bed way to do that, as they are in their 80s, is through sending lots of lovely letters/photos and ringing when you can.

As you have said they are currently in good health, book a couple of holiday days and go visit THEM for a long weekend or a week if you can as health at that age can turn really quickly.

I wish I had spent more time with Grandparents. (Pandemic didn’t help)

ProfessorXtra · 28/05/2023 13:54

Thesunnymood · 28/05/2023 13:34

None of you would want your grandparents to visit once so they see where and how you live etc when they are active, travelling and visiting others happily.
Sure

There are grandparents visiting grandchildren living in different countries. Of course being grandparent doesn't mean you are never expected to travel and everyone must always travel to you.

Don’t think anyone said they wouldn’t want their grandparents to visit.

They said they wouldn’t expect them to.

Thats 2 different things.

BemusedBrenda · 28/05/2023 13:51

OP, I think PP are being harsh and missing the point a tad. I also live quite a distance from my family and I definitely think it works both ways. I spent the first year I moved away travelling two weekends every month to try to see everyone, but I realised it was unsustainable and yes, it should work both ways. Ime you soon learn who really values their relationship with you because they will make reciprocal visits. My grandparents are also in their eighties but they have visited me a couple of times although I usually go to them. Visiting once every 3 months is actually quite a lot when you work full time and have to fit everything into your weekends.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 28/05/2023 13:48

Thesunnymood · 28/05/2023 13:34

None of you would want your grandparents to visit once so they see where and how you live etc when they are active, travelling and visiting others happily.
Sure

There are grandparents visiting grandchildren living in different countries. Of course being grandparent doesn't mean you are never expected to travel and everyone must always travel to you.

I wouldn't ever expect grandparents in their eighties to come and visit me, no. And I say that as someone who grew up only seeing mine every two years or so as my parents moved overseas.

fUNNYfACE36 · 28/05/2023 13:36

You live in a city centre! Much different to driving in the Scottish Highlands or catching a flight to crete

Thesunnymood · 28/05/2023 13:34

None of you would want your grandparents to visit once so they see where and how you live etc when they are active, travelling and visiting others happily.
Sure

There are grandparents visiting grandchildren living in different countries. Of course being grandparent doesn't mean you are never expected to travel and everyone must always travel to you.

LlynTegid · 28/05/2023 13:30

Would it be worth trying to get them to visit say for your birthday, or some other occasion?

HoldingTheDoor · 28/05/2023 13:29

Posters just got stuck on age and missed that the grandparents regularly travel.

I didn't miss it. I'd still expect to travel to them.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 28/05/2023 13:29

Thesunnymood · 28/05/2023 13:24

Posters just got stuck on age and missed that the grandparents regularly travel.

Of course it's bit sad they don't come visit you while they visit others like that. I guess everyone just has to make peace with seeing each other once every x months in your parent's house.

Nope, I didn't miss it.

Regardless of how able they are, I still wouldn't expect the burden of travel to fall on an elderly couple in their eighties - especially if I was the one who chose to move several hours away from them in the first place.

My in-laws are in their eighties and live half a mile away - FIL was fixing tiles on his shed roof a few months ago but I still wouldn't expect him to travel to us as part of a social occasion - we would always go to him.

And yes, we tried to help him with the roof but he insisted he was more than capable 😂

GrumpyPanda · 28/05/2023 13:28

Unreasonable to expect. Not unreasonable to invite. Yes, you say you've done that, but has it been as a concrete proposal? Say for a specific weekend, with specific suggestions of what to do together while they're visiting? Or had it just been a generic, you know you're always welcome?