Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I pulled out of night away - did I still have to pay my share?

112 replies

Nodinnernogift · 28/05/2023 09:51

This is quite light-hearted but I'd love to hear others opinions. The other thread about a shared hotel room reminded me but I'm potentially the bad guy here.

It happened years ago but still feel funny when I run into this now acquaintance.

I began a new hobby and made some friends, let's call them Catherine and Melanie. Catherine was in a serious relationship, Melanie was single as was I. We stayed in touch, meeting up for the occasional dinner or glass of wine. Catherine or I usually instigated these meetups.

Catherine got engaged and invited me to her wedding. I was delighted. She said "are you currently single? Melanie is so perhaps you could share a room in the hotel." I contacted Melanie and it was agreed - she booked, saying the balance was due on arrival.

I then realised I wouldn't be able to attend as I had an unavoidable and not fun family commitment. I immediately messaged the bride to be full of apologies. I was very disappointed but one of those things. It was about six weeks before the wedding. Bride was lovely about it.

Later that same day Melanie messaged asking me if it was true, I was now not going and leaving her with the hotel room. I said yes it's true, I had planned to call her later after work and explain and I would of course pay my half of the hotel charge.

A week before the wedding I got a text message from Melanie saying when did I plan to pay for the room, the wedding is this week. There were a lot of exclamation marks in the message. I said I'll transfer it today and reconfirmed she isn't being charged until arrival.

So I transferred the money, messaged her to say it's in her account (I actually walked into a branch and made a physical deposit just to ensure there were no delays), have a great time and send me photos.

The day after the wedding I contacted her asking how it was and if she had fun. She wrote back that it was brilliant and even better another singleton had contacted her during the week asking if she could share her room so she ended up getting the hotel room 'for free'. Basically I paid half and this other singleton paid half.

I was taken aback but just said I was glad she had a great time and I was gutted I'd missed it.

That was the end of the interaction but some time later I realised she had blocked me on all SM. Catherine stays in touch. When I bump into Melanie she's very friendly but it's all rushed & feels fake.

YABU - of course you had to pay, you left her on her own at a wedding and she heard it from the bride first

YANBU - she should have either let the other woman stay for free or returned the money to you. It wasn't your fault you couldn't attend and you gave lots of notice

OP posts:
Nodinnernogift · 28/05/2023 11:19

Yes I'm always breezy now when I see her as she clearly doesn't like me; a wave and hello and I keep walking.

OP posts:
Nodinnernogift · 28/05/2023 11:18

@MumblesParty and @Theprincessisblanketed good points you have raised and I suspect it could be something like this.

I mean if she was a straightforward CF she wouldn't have been phased at all, just cheerfully pocketed the money and enjoyed her night, not blocking me on SM.

She didn't have to ask me twice though for money - I offered initially and she said no, we will both pay at the desk. Then she asked once a week beforehand and I paid it directly into her account that day. She allegedly had the replacement organised before she paid anything.

But I think you're right and I hurt her feelings.

OP posts:
conniefused · 28/05/2023 11:17

I don't understand why she blocked you when she was clearly the one in the wrong. You did nothing wrong at all. Next time you see her I would be breezy. She's taken the piss and then snubbed you. Why would you want to associate with someone like that?

Theprincessisblanketed · 28/05/2023 11:08

Divorcedalongtime · 28/05/2023 10:19

Maybe she told a fib about finding someone to share the cost of the room with? To get back at you or simply to feel less abandoned…?

This was the first thing I thought. Telling you that she got one over on you then blocking you sounds like she was trying to get at you.

Maybe she was looking forward to you sharing the hotel room and thought you were closer friends than you did, and hearing second hand that you weren't even coming upset her?

MumblesParty · 28/05/2023 11:05

Basically there is fault on both sides.

YWBU to agree to go and to share a room, before checking your diary.

You did the right thing by paying your share, but YWBU to make Melanie have to ask twice for your money. I know the hotel didn’t need to be paid till arrival, but she must have been getting nervous that you wouldn’t pay at all.

Obviously Melanie was unreasonable for not refunding you, when she managed to get someone else to share. However, has this been confirmed, because I wonder if it’s actually true. She may have just said that to wind you up, because she was angry at you for cancelling.

I’m guessing she blocked you because the whole thing left a bad taste in her mouth - your flakiness, the money issue, her then cheating you etc. I imagine she wanted to detach.

MumblesParty · 28/05/2023 10:57

Daffodil92 · 28/05/2023 09:59

Going against the grain a bit- I think regardless of whether she found someone else to share with, you shouldn’t have paid. She would have needed a hotel room anyway. She wasn’t left out of pocket-6 weeks is loads of notice. I wouldn’t have given her a penny.

Are you serious? Wow you are a bad friend.

continentallentil · 28/05/2023 10:49

dudsville · 28/05/2023 09:55

She should have refunded you once she got someone else in place!

This.

She’s at fault not you

DuchessOfMuck · 28/05/2023 10:49

ButtOutBobsMum · 28/05/2023 09:56

I think that earns her a place in the CF Hall of Fame!!

Yep! This ^

I think you had a lucky escape not sharing a room with cf.

No doubt she expects the world to run round her and stomps like a toddler when things don't go her way. Something else was bound to happen so she would end up pissed.

You don't need people like this in your life op.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/05/2023 10:48

Zanatdy · 28/05/2023 10:42

If it was refundable anyway the room should have been cancelled and she should have found her own accommodation. Fact she didn’t repay you when someone else was sharing was poor

She may not have been able to find other accommodation at a good price last minute so I don't agree with that one.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/05/2023 10:47

"The fuck I'd have paid for a hotel room I wasn't even staying in. Most hotels I've stayed at, you pay the same for a twin or double room regardless of whether one or two people are staying. Single occupancy discount seems to be increasingly rare."

That's a shitty attitude. Single occupancy still exists as do single rooms in some places. No way should someone pay for a twin room because the other person pulled out last minute.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/05/2023 10:45

Daffodil92 · 28/05/2023 09:59

Going against the grain a bit- I think regardless of whether she found someone else to share with, you shouldn’t have paid. She would have needed a hotel room anyway. She wasn’t left out of pocket-6 weeks is loads of notice. I wouldn’t have given her a penny.

No, she was only planning to pay half the hotel room! She wouldn't have needed a twin room if not sharing and might have gone to a cheaper hotel or not at all.

Zanatdy · 28/05/2023 10:42

If it was refundable anyway the room should have been cancelled and she should have found her own accommodation. Fact she didn’t repay you when someone else was sharing was poor

TakeMeDancingNakedInTheRain · 28/05/2023 10:42

She should have returned your half to you when the other person paid and stayed. I've no idea why she told you what she did if she wasn't going to give you your money back? Seems odd to rip you off and then inform you about it!

UnctuousUnicorns · 28/05/2023 10:35

The fuck I'd have paid for a hotel room I wasn't even staying in. Most hotels I've stayed at, you pay the same for a twin or double room regardless of whether one or two people are staying. Single occupancy discount seems to be increasingly rare. I'd say that if I were in Melanie's position; if a second room companion hadn't become available to share, I'd have expected to cough up the full amount for a room that I had to myself.

Nodinnernogift · 28/05/2023 10:29

Riverlee · 28/05/2023 10:23

I agree with @MargotBamborough . It was right that you paid your share, with six weeks to go.

However, if she found someone to fill you place, then that person should have offered you something, even if it was a token amount.

By 'that person' do you mean the new guest. Because they actually paid for half the room. It was my friend Melanie who then got it for free.

Posting this thread got me curious and I went back checking details in old messages. I'd immediately offered to transfer funds to her bank account as soon as she booked it and she wrote back "no it's fine, we pay at the desk". So there was no perceived chasing me for payment in the run up.

Ah well.

OP posts:
AmazonAmazine · 28/05/2023 10:28

Oh wow- I’d have been annoyed! Whilst I would have paid my half, and passed it on for free if needed to another, getting it for free would piss me off! She would be ‘Melanie the freeloader’ in conversation for ever more

IntoDeepBlueSea · 28/05/2023 10:25

I think she was really furious that you backed out (unreasonably so), and so enjoyed finding a reason to take your money. She knew it was the wrong thing to do, hence being blocked on SM

Lidlpopdrinker · 28/05/2023 10:24

She’s a CF.

Riverlee · 28/05/2023 10:23

I agree with @MargotBamborough . It was right that you paid your share, with six weeks to go.

However, if she found someone to fill you place, then that person should have offered you something, even if it was a token amount.

Divorcedalongtime · 28/05/2023 10:19

Maybe she told a fib about finding someone to share the cost of the room with? To get back at you or simply to feel less abandoned…?

UndercoverCop · 28/05/2023 10:16

You should've told her directly, you did the right thing to pay your share. However when she found a replacement she should've refunded you minus any fees incurred (if there were any)

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:15

I think it was right for you to pay your share rather than leave her to pay for all of it herself, but once she had found someone else to share with she should have refunded you what you paid.

Nodinnernogift · 28/05/2023 10:13

The fact that she blocked me left me feeling there was more to it but I can't see what. The bride's sister is her best friend and she knew lots of other guests so she wasn't going to be short on company.

Anyway I'm sure she has a very different version of events.

To the pp who said she feels guilty, I didn't get that impression at all. When I bump into her she's massively friendly but in a massive rush - seems totally fake.

The first time I hadn't even seen her and she made a big show of calling me over and said let's meet up soon, double-checking she had my phone number correct and promising to message the following day to arrange. I thought she must have changed her mind and it would be nice to see her, talk it through if necessary and apologise if needs be. She didn't message then the next time I saw her she behaved the same way and I realised it's all a big act so I'm not interested at all now.

OP posts:
Daffodil92 · 28/05/2023 10:13

@takealettermsjones in that case, she could have cancelled the hotel? 6 weeks is plenty of notice.

elessar · 28/05/2023 10:13

She's absolutely a CF. You did the right thing in offering to pay your share when you pulled out, but when she found somebody else she should have given you your half back, no question.

Only thing you should have done differently was contact her straight away when you told the bride - not great that she heard from someone else other than you.