Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a flashy car to fit in?

315 replies

Lustingovercar · 27/05/2023 20:42

I currently have a small- medium sized EV. Not a premium or anything. Really could do with a longer range EV or go back to ICE. (We no longer fly so holidays are exclusively drive and EV is a bit tricky - current range is 120 miles but on motorway get less than 100) Also have 3 DC and two large dogs so it’s hard to fit in current one.

We live in an area where cars do matter. There’s a lot of premium brands in our area, on school runs etc. I would like to be seen in a big beautiful car (just being honest here because I can on MN!) however I like the fact that my EV is better for the environment. We can afford a big LR Discovery and it would be easier for the kids etc BUT should I really just buy one to fit in?

Lots of mums who lunch/ swishy hair/ large premium SUVs in my area. I work, and drive a small car. I can’t help feeling that I’d fit in a bit more (and, yes, find it easier to make friends) if I had the ‘right’ car.

Please be kind, as I’m just being honest and seeing what people think..

OP posts:
TheMousePipes · 28/05/2023 11:39

Hmm. You sound like a normal decent human and the swishy haired big car brigade are generally (not always but…) a bunch of twats. Like the cool girls at school but grown up. I’d steer clear if I were you.

Cheeserollanyone · 28/05/2023 11:33

Hi OP. You don't need to buy a flashy car to fit in. Why do you feel the need to fit in with people who would want to be friends with you because of the car you drive, house you live in, type of career you have. List is endless.
I totally get you are feeling lonely but you do not need these type of people in your live.
I totally get where you are coming from. I live in a affluent village and most people have these types of cars. The school my DC's go to are the same. We sent them privately due to them needing extra help with their learning. I am lucky to be able to afford this but i also dont feel the need to fit in, or do I want too. It has been lonely but I have found some lovely friends due to a hobby I attend. I don't need these shallow people in my life.
My car is ok, it is safe but it is nothing to look at but it is reliable. I love it.
Don't try to fit in OP. Just be you and work on your confidence. Good luck.

Lustingovercar · 28/05/2023 11:33

onefinemess · 28/05/2023 10:38

Have you ever seen what Lithium mining does to the environment?

Your "green" EV, is a greenwash.

The carbon footprint of building your EV is not much less than an ICE. But the damage done to the local area around the mines is always ignored. Also, currently there is no commercially viable means of disposing of used EV batteries. You have to pay specliast recycling firms, cheapest I could find was £625 for disposal of a 2009 Nissan Leaf.

The biggest issue, which politicians, JSO, and the green lobby just won't talk about, is the scale of mining necessary to replace ICE vehicles (which only includes passenger cars by the way, not industry).
We would have to, as a minimum, increase lithium mining by just shy of 1000% from today's levels. Yeah, 1000%.

And while countries like the US actually have enough lithium in their own mountains, they will never have 20,000 open cast mines scarring the landscape, they would rather China did it instead.

EV's are not the future of anything and ten years from now will be acknowledged for the white elephants they are.

Population reduction is the future. We simply have too many people on the planet. Only a brutally strict curb in the number of children will save the planet.

So should I get rid of my EV and go back to an ICE car? Obviously I don’t want to derail the thread, but it’s a genuine question.

I do appreciate your comments regarding mining and understand that it’s a huge problem.

OP posts:
AngelinaFibres · 28/05/2023 11:32

EmptyBedBlues · 28/05/2023 11:08

I’m entirely sympathetic to the OP’s evident loneliness, but being brainwashed into a ‘cars matter because I live somewhere aspirational’ mindset to the point where she would even contemplate buying a car to ‘fit in’ is ridiculous. It’s the leftover childhood thinking of someone who was told by the class bully ‘You’re not allowed to have lunch with us because you don’t have a Barbie lunchbox!’

OP, this might amuse you. I too once lived in a village which bristled with well-off lower-middle-class consumer aspirationalism which yes, did absolutely express itself through noticing what car people drove. Our car (DH’s company car) ‘passed’ with flying colours, but I ‘failed’ because, rather than driving it, I cycled everywhere. This caused mass bemusement. Was something wrong with me? Why did I cycle around with DS on a child seat ? Why did I use public transport to work? Why did I work FT when surely I didn’t ‘need to’? Why didn’t I blowdry my hair straight? Why did I wear those clothes?

Still didn’t gel.😀

I just had a Bay City Rollers tartan lunchbox flashback. I had a tupperware lunchbox, bought from the tupperware man who used to sell door to door in the early 70s. Lots of the girls in my class had the Bay City Rollers lunchboxes. I wasn't allowed to be part of their group.

AngelinaFibres · 28/05/2023 11:27

Lustingovercar · 27/05/2023 21:39

You are so right.

I’ve always been the type of person who has tried to feel strong about my choices (no cars on finance, save for things carefully) and to treasure and appreciate what I’ve got such as family, health and love. I’m having a wobble because I’m in a slightly low place and feel like I don’t fit in. I understand that this absolutely pales into insignificance compared to what you must be going through.

Tomorrow, I’m going to drive my small fully owned car and hold my head high, feel confident to make new friends, and think of others who are going through much harder things than me. I cannot begin to imagine what you are going through. Sending love.

There is a quote I like to remind myself of often " We work more and more hours to get more and more money to buy more and more things we don't need to impress people we don't even like'.
The people who truly like you won't care what you wear,what you drive, whether you have swishy hair. The shallow, fake types will only like you because of what you wear, what you drive, and whether you have swishy hair. If something awful happens in your life you won't see those people for dust.

crazycatladyof6 · 28/05/2023 11:18

A car will not alter your ability to make friendships. I would say you would benefit on working in your confidence

PrincessofWellies · 28/05/2023 11:11

I was given a 1971 MG Midget 20 years ago and still have it. It costs £100 in insurance and no mot no tax. Can you get yourself a second fun car like this?

EmptyBedBlues · 28/05/2023 11:08

NosyHamster · 28/05/2023 10:00

Can people be a bit kinder to the OP please? She’s been very honest and is feeling a bit low at the moment. There is nothing wrong with wanting to fit in.

I’m entirely sympathetic to the OP’s evident loneliness, but being brainwashed into a ‘cars matter because I live somewhere aspirational’ mindset to the point where she would even contemplate buying a car to ‘fit in’ is ridiculous. It’s the leftover childhood thinking of someone who was told by the class bully ‘You’re not allowed to have lunch with us because you don’t have a Barbie lunchbox!’

OP, this might amuse you. I too once lived in a village which bristled with well-off lower-middle-class consumer aspirationalism which yes, did absolutely express itself through noticing what car people drove. Our car (DH’s company car) ‘passed’ with flying colours, but I ‘failed’ because, rather than driving it, I cycled everywhere. This caused mass bemusement. Was something wrong with me? Why did I cycle around with DS on a child seat ? Why did I use public transport to work? Why did I work FT when surely I didn’t ‘need to’? Why didn’t I blowdry my hair straight? Why did I wear those clothes?

Still didn’t gel.😀

Farmageddon · 28/05/2023 11:05

NosyHamster · 28/05/2023 10:00

Can people be a bit kinder to the OP please? She’s been very honest and is feeling a bit low at the moment. There is nothing wrong with wanting to fit in.

I agree, people are being harsh. Most of us carry some sort of insecurities from childhood with us - you are never too old for this shit - and sometimes it manifests in weird ways.

OP, I think you know deep down this isn't going to solve anything, perhaps like people have suggested you could try joining an activity or sport to give you more of a social outlet. At least then you would have a common thing to talk about.

scorpiogirly · 28/05/2023 11:02

I drive an old 09 plate corsa with a few dents etc.

I was actually thinking about this the other day. What's the point of driving a flashy car? You can't see it when you're in it and it doesn't get you there any faster.

User1529865 · 28/05/2023 11:02

Can't you make your hair swishy, that seems to be one of the criteria and is a lot easier than changing your car, probably you could buy a wig if your hair isn't the right type.

FoxtrotOscarFoxtrotOscar · 28/05/2023 11:01

This reminds me of an OLD date. It was a gorgeous sunny day and we'd agreed to meet outside for a drink. I knew immediately on sight he wasn't for me. Anyway I was happy to stay outside and have lunch but, no, he had tickets for an art fair, really wanted to go, and offered to drive. As soon as I saw his car I knew why. He wanted to show off his massive brand new Porsche and tbh I felt very self-conscious in it. It was all a bit tragic and I never saw him again!

fguuh · 28/05/2023 10:59

On the fence with this. I have one of the cars you're talking about, as do a lot of people near me/at the school. However I don't think many people judge others on their cars (some people judge others for anything). In fact, one of my friends is a horsey type and often turns up in a very old car that's full of mud etc if she's come straight from riding. No one judged her.

Personally I'd worry about making a large purchase and things not improving regarding friendships. For me I'd invest a bit of time first. Perhaps you can arrange a coffee?

Mistletoewench · 28/05/2023 10:56

hopeishere · 28/05/2023 09:33

@Ozgirl75 it was hard for DS as he wanted to be in the "party car" instead of on his own with me.

Buckinghamshire?

TrashyPanda · 28/05/2023 10:56

Are you teaching your DC to value people for who they are, or to be persuaded by luxury goods?

think about the values you hold dear - honesty, decency, compassion etc - and choose pals who value these more than superficial signs of wealth or you will never be happy or have meaningful relationships.

BlueKaftan · 28/05/2023 10:49

3 children, 2 dogs…..by my way of thinking you’ve already got too much!

polkadotdalmation · 28/05/2023 10:46

So you live in the south by any chance? I encountered this a lot there. Moved. Much happier.

Fairislefandango · 28/05/2023 10:44

We live in an area where cars do matter.

In any area only some people think cars matter as a status thing. You get to choose whether to be a person who buys into that bullshit or not. It's fine to want a nice car because you actually genuinely appreciate nice cars. Personally I don't give a monkey's about car brands.

faffadoodledo · 28/05/2023 10:41

And @Lustingovercar I think you're being gloriously honest. Ignore posters like the one who called you a d@ck.
But I am very very curious as to your whereabouts!

faffadoodledo · 28/05/2023 10:40

whirlyswirly · 27/05/2023 20:50

I'm so glad I live where I do. Everyone has a car full of sand round here. And scratches from narrow lanes.

I think you must live where I do!
That said we do now have a new EV and I feel weirdly out of place! Too flashy for my environment!

onefinemess · 28/05/2023 10:38

Lustingovercar · 28/05/2023 09:23

I would be interested to know why you don’t think my EV is better for the environment.

Have you ever seen what Lithium mining does to the environment?

Your "green" EV, is a greenwash.

The carbon footprint of building your EV is not much less than an ICE. But the damage done to the local area around the mines is always ignored. Also, currently there is no commercially viable means of disposing of used EV batteries. You have to pay specliast recycling firms, cheapest I could find was £625 for disposal of a 2009 Nissan Leaf.

The biggest issue, which politicians, JSO, and the green lobby just won't talk about, is the scale of mining necessary to replace ICE vehicles (which only includes passenger cars by the way, not industry).
We would have to, as a minimum, increase lithium mining by just shy of 1000% from today's levels. Yeah, 1000%.

And while countries like the US actually have enough lithium in their own mountains, they will never have 20,000 open cast mines scarring the landscape, they would rather China did it instead.

EV's are not the future of anything and ten years from now will be acknowledged for the white elephants they are.

Population reduction is the future. We simply have too many people on the planet. Only a brutally strict curb in the number of children will save the planet.

WithManyTot · 28/05/2023 10:37

I have just changed form a 15 year old 120K+ miles diesel hatchback that I owned from new, to a nearly new 'flashy premium brand' electric SUV that cost more than my first house when it was new.

I chose the new car because it was interesting and I liked it, but it has made 0.00000000000000% difference to the school carpark, and I 0.0000000000% care.

No new people have spoken to me, no old people stopped talking to me. The school carpark has cars in it from <£1K to >£100K.

If you want a new car for yourself, buy one, don't buy one if you think or want too change other peoples perception of you...

Pahpahpotato · 28/05/2023 10:34

Well, yes you’re being unreasonable, and somewhat judgemental and sniffy about the ‘others’ not working, and not outright owning their cars (not that you could know that!) among other things. You don’t even sound like you like the women you profess to want to be friends with.
Your car sounds shit (that range is appalling!) so who could blame you for getting a new one, but the notion of buying a car to ‘fit in’ is a bit.. well, embarrassing.

Beezknees · 28/05/2023 10:32

Oh and I have a teenager and I did not make one single friend at the school gates during the whole time he was at primary. I had little in common with any of them and I wasn't going to force friendships just because our kids went to the same school. It's better to find friends through shared interests if you can.

Beezknees · 28/05/2023 10:29

Of course YABU. Why on earth would you want friends that only want to be friends with you for superficial reasons?

I'm a single working mum living in a housing association flat, getting Universal credit. I don't even own a car at all. I do not give a shiny shite about this "keeping up appearances" nonsense.

Working on your self esteem should be a priority for you rather than a fancy car.

Swipe left for the next trending thread