Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want a flashy car to fit in?

315 replies

Lustingovercar · 27/05/2023 20:42

I currently have a small- medium sized EV. Not a premium or anything. Really could do with a longer range EV or go back to ICE. (We no longer fly so holidays are exclusively drive and EV is a bit tricky - current range is 120 miles but on motorway get less than 100) Also have 3 DC and two large dogs so it’s hard to fit in current one.

We live in an area where cars do matter. There’s a lot of premium brands in our area, on school runs etc. I would like to be seen in a big beautiful car (just being honest here because I can on MN!) however I like the fact that my EV is better for the environment. We can afford a big LR Discovery and it would be easier for the kids etc BUT should I really just buy one to fit in?

Lots of mums who lunch/ swishy hair/ large premium SUVs in my area. I work, and drive a small car. I can’t help feeling that I’d fit in a bit more (and, yes, find it easier to make friends) if I had the ‘right’ car.

Please be kind, as I’m just being honest and seeing what people think..

OP posts:
Reality25 · 03/06/2023 08:39

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 03/06/2023 08:20

@Reality25 Without trying to be funny here, how do you know what car someone drives? At work, there's a bunch of cars in the car-park. I suppose I've sometimes seen people getting in/out of them but I don't then remember which car belongs to whom. At home, people drive up, get out of the car, ring the doorbell. I have never looked to see what the car is.

I couldn't even tell you what cars my neighbours have other than "small blue one." Maybe it's just me.

It's not just you don't worry.

As you say, cars don't really interest you and you don't often make associations of cars and people consciously.

But let's say your friend invites you for a day out and volunteers to drive.

You then will make an association. A judgement.

The judgement may also just be that they drive a thoroughly average car that is not noteworthy and so it quickly goes to the back of your mind and you forget all about it. Your brain still made that judgement though. "Friend X's car is normal and as expected."

PimpMyFridge · 03/06/2023 08:33

@Reality25 is right, but so are the others who disagree because both kinds of people exist.

Bizarrely neither @Reality25 or the detractors from their pov seem to realise both things can be true depending who you are talking to. @Reality25 doesn't accept people who don't pay attention to cars exist, but they do, and if those people do notice a car it has little impression, it's a fact, however they are also right that many many people would reach a conclusion based on a car, and some of those will view you quite differently because of it.

The conclusions people reach when/if they judge you on your car might be very different. So flash car might equal 'awesome, fellow petrol head and rich, would love to be friends' and another night think 'oh god another gas guzzler as though the world needs another of those, this person isn't someone I would likely have much in common with'

the question as to whether people judge on cars (judge on the strongest sense here, not in the neutral mild conclusion way, but the 'you stand or fall on the car you drive' way) isn't really the point of the thread though, loads of people do we all know... the question is whether those to whom your car really really matters are the people you pursue relationships with, or bend yourself out of shape for. Those people who are in that camp would play the game of car status, but there are many who aren't, you just need to pick your tribe.

nicedaydoreen · 03/06/2023 08:32

I really want to know where you live for this to actually be a concern???
I live in an expensive area and this is definitely not a thing.
I can't see how what car you drive helps with friendship either? Now if they all go to the gym, beauty parlour then lunch that's probably what you should be doing to make friends with that group?
But is that you, are those your people if you are not the gym and lunch brigade?
Are you more the working mum group instead?
My mum friends are the working mums who I actually have things in common with IE slightly stressed and juggling life, the car fits the kids in but I can't tell you what they drive.
Cars are not something to worry about for social reasons.
Men tend to stand around discussing cars I notice but round here they seem to get excited over strange project cars, camper vans and dream sports cars ( they can't actually get the whole family in).

You do sound like you need a car to take on longer drives though.

coloursquare · 03/06/2023 08:31

The wealthiest (as in multi-millions of family money) and poshest person I know zips around in a beaten-up golf. The cars you are talking about are naff.

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 03/06/2023 08:20

@Reality25 Without trying to be funny here, how do you know what car someone drives? At work, there's a bunch of cars in the car-park. I suppose I've sometimes seen people getting in/out of them but I don't then remember which car belongs to whom. At home, people drive up, get out of the car, ring the doorbell. I have never looked to see what the car is.

I couldn't even tell you what cars my neighbours have other than "small blue one." Maybe it's just me.

Reality25 · 03/06/2023 08:12

OP, even in this thread you have seen the fear from certain individuals when they realise "oh shit, people judge me by my car".

Many many people don't wish for it to be true. They want to be judged by "what's on the inside" and "who they are as a person".

The world is not so fragile I'm afraid. Your decisions and choices combine to give a presentation of who you are to others. Only you know who you are exactly. Everyone else just see what you present to others.

You will be judged by different people by differing levels on your house, your car, your photos on social media, your clothes, your job, your education etc etc.

It's just life, you don't need to live in constant stress about it but certainly be aware of it and don't be one the ostriches with their heads firmly stuck in the sand trying to deny the reality of the world to protect their fragile self-esteem.

Drive a banger - be thought of as poor.

Drive a brand new sports car - be thought of as rich and successful.

Make the change and you'll find out in a flash 😀

Reality25 · 03/06/2023 07:42

AsphaltGirl · 02/06/2023 22:31

@Reality25 on the off chance that you're a real person, I genuinely have no idea at all what car any of my friends drive. Or even if they have a car.

I realise this may be difficult for you to comprehend, but it is true.

I judge people who drive like dicks, because they are endangering other people's lives. I don't notice what particular model of car they're driving if they do that.

If a friend drove a ferrari to my house, I'd have no idea, because I don't look at their cars. I'm sorry to break this to you. People mostly don't give a shit.

I hate to break it to you but you're just lieing to yourself to try to save face.

Certainly have made me chuckle for the week so thanks though!

whenindoubtgotothelibrary · 02/06/2023 22:53

EmptyBedBlues · 27/05/2023 23:50

Meanwhile, the rest of us trudge about in the dust with dung on our faces, pointing at passing Cortinas.

I don't care about cars very much at all, as long as they don't break down all the time, which was not a given until fairly recently (I grew up in the 70s).

But EmptyBedBlues is very funny.

AsphaltGirl · 02/06/2023 22:45

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 02/06/2023 22:34

@AsphaltGirl I think that one of my friends has a .... silver car? And another has a grey one?

You're doing better than me there! I think one of my friends once had a red car. But I wouldn't bet even a fiver on it

PrivateSchoolTeacherParent · 02/06/2023 22:34

@AsphaltGirl I think that one of my friends has a .... silver car? And another has a grey one?

AsphaltGirl · 02/06/2023 22:31

@Reality25 on the off chance that you're a real person, I genuinely have no idea at all what car any of my friends drive. Or even if they have a car.

I realise this may be difficult for you to comprehend, but it is true.

I judge people who drive like dicks, because they are endangering other people's lives. I don't notice what particular model of car they're driving if they do that.

If a friend drove a ferrari to my house, I'd have no idea, because I don't look at their cars. I'm sorry to break this to you. People mostly don't give a shit.

Reality25 · 02/06/2023 21:45

pigsDOfly · 02/06/2023 16:49

What utter rot.

But what a horrible, shallow world we'd be living in if that were how people judged other people.

Does an expensive car really confer 'respect and admiration' from people? A certain type of person maybe.

Personally, people get my respect if they are the sort of decent, thoughtful human being that deserves respect, not because they drive a particular lump of metal.

I drive a decent enough car but I can't imagine anyone I know judging me one way or the other because of it. But perhaps that's because I don't mix with the vulgar, shallow type of people that would only deem someone worthy of their 'friendship', or not, because of the car they drive.

If your friend came to your house in a Ferrari one day, what goes on in your head?

Newsflash - you form an opinion about it. A judgement.

"Judge" - verb - "to form an opinion or estimate".

Probably you'd ask them about it and then your opinion would change based on their response.

Reality25 · 02/06/2023 21:31

chupachucks · 02/06/2023 16:55

@Reality25 Yep I judge people who drive a shiny new German saloon, I always think shallow self absorbed shit driver who's so bothered about trend they buy some of the most unreliable cars on the road 🤣

Well there you go! Exactly my point, you make a judgement.

I even specifically mentioned that it may not be a good judgement. But it will change your perception of the owner. Maybe slightly, maybe a lot, depending on how much value you give to cars, how close you are to the owner etc etc.

Same can be said for the clothes you wear, or the house you have, or the university you went to, or many other things that form a part of who you are.

chupachucks · 02/06/2023 16:55

@Reality25 Yep I judge people who drive a shiny new German saloon, I always think shallow self absorbed shit driver who's so bothered about trend they buy some of the most unreliable cars on the road 🤣

pigsDOfly · 02/06/2023 16:49

Reality25 · 31/05/2023 15:14

YANBU

Love it or loathe it, cars are a symbol and something used to judge you.

Everyone will judge you based on your car. Neighbours, your kid's teachers, your bosses at work, your other colleagues, your friends, everyone.

Some will do it consciously - these are the ones who are viewed as shallow.

Everyone else do it subconsciously. But make no mistake they still do it.

You WILL notice the difference in people's behaviour and demeanour if you suddenly change from a banger to a shiny new German saloon.

Most of it will likely be a positive difference - i.e. admiration and respect. But you may also encounter jealousy and envy. And you may also encounter disrespect from certain groups (think environmentalists when they see your 3-ton gas guzzler).

So your decision should be how much you want the judgement that comes with the nicer car. And what judgement your social circle will give.

From your description, it looks like you'd benefit a lot from it. Mostly respect and admiration. Go for it!

What utter rot.

But what a horrible, shallow world we'd be living in if that were how people judged other people.

Does an expensive car really confer 'respect and admiration' from people? A certain type of person maybe.

Personally, people get my respect if they are the sort of decent, thoughtful human being that deserves respect, not because they drive a particular lump of metal.

I drive a decent enough car but I can't imagine anyone I know judging me one way or the other because of it. But perhaps that's because I don't mix with the vulgar, shallow type of people that would only deem someone worthy of their 'friendship', or not, because of the car they drive.

Reality25 · 01/06/2023 10:53

AsphaltGirl · 01/06/2023 09:38

It's not "clinical", it's complete bollocks.

Typical head-in-the-sander. Ignorance is bliss!

AsphaltGirl · 01/06/2023 09:38

Reality25 · 01/06/2023 09:33

Certainly is a clinical response haha, but no point skirting around the truth sometimes.

Of course there are other reasons for buying a nice car but those who think that other people's perception is an invalid reason are just kidding themselves I'm afraid. Being in denial can be comforting!

It's not "clinical", it's complete bollocks.

Reality25 · 01/06/2023 09:33

EmptyBedBlues · 31/05/2023 18:09

This message sounds as if it’s been written by an alien who gets his ideas about humankind from reading the FT How To Spend It Magazine.

Certainly is a clinical response haha, but no point skirting around the truth sometimes.

Of course there are other reasons for buying a nice car but those who think that other people's perception is an invalid reason are just kidding themselves I'm afraid. Being in denial can be comforting!

Scarfweather · 31/05/2023 20:42

PimpMyFridge · 27/05/2023 20:53

I lived in an area like that so I get what you mean. The school mums would carefully 'not notice you' so they weren't rudely blanking you, until they checked your car... Then they were either super friendly and trying to get their child to be friends with yours, or outright blank you from that point. 🙄
They were a bit stumped by me for a while as I walked to school.

I couldn't wait to get away people who couldn't see the interest of anyone beyond material possessions. I have all sorts of people in my friendship circles from landed gentry, to senior corporates to the school cleaner... The single common factor they all have is they are interesting in the world, curious about the people in it and see value in people at all levels.

Not very helpful to you op if you're caught in that bubble and want to join the crowd, but there are people out there who share your values and won't need you to be 'right'

Are you me? I couldn’t have put my experience of prep school more eloquently if I tried. while I wouldn’t wish it on anyone, I’m so reassured that I wasn’t the only one who had this experience!
OP, if you upgrade the car to fit in, it will never end. Also, there’s something to be said about having the confidence to be true to yourself. Next it will be the clothes, the holidays, getting the right invites to the right lunches, the bigger house etc….
I do know exactly how you feel - fundamentally most of us want to fit in. But fitting in with this shower of people is not going to benefit you in the end because you’ll be forever comparing until your DC move on to college or a different school.

Whywere · 31/05/2023 20:28

I think someone went to ChatGPT for advice

EmptyBedBlues · 31/05/2023 18:09

Reality25 · 31/05/2023 15:14

YANBU

Love it or loathe it, cars are a symbol and something used to judge you.

Everyone will judge you based on your car. Neighbours, your kid's teachers, your bosses at work, your other colleagues, your friends, everyone.

Some will do it consciously - these are the ones who are viewed as shallow.

Everyone else do it subconsciously. But make no mistake they still do it.

You WILL notice the difference in people's behaviour and demeanour if you suddenly change from a banger to a shiny new German saloon.

Most of it will likely be a positive difference - i.e. admiration and respect. But you may also encounter jealousy and envy. And you may also encounter disrespect from certain groups (think environmentalists when they see your 3-ton gas guzzler).

So your decision should be how much you want the judgement that comes with the nicer car. And what judgement your social circle will give.

From your description, it looks like you'd benefit a lot from it. Mostly respect and admiration. Go for it!

This message sounds as if it’s been written by an alien who gets his ideas about humankind from reading the FT How To Spend It Magazine.

AsphaltGirl · 31/05/2023 16:32

Everyone will judge you based on your car. Neighbours, your kid's teachers, your bosses at work, your other colleagues, your friends, everyone.

this is the biggest load of shit I've ever read in my life.

I have no idea what car any of my friends or family drive.

if I thought a child's teacher was judging a parent by their CAR, I'd think they were suffering a mental health crisis

Reality25 · 31/05/2023 15:14

YANBU

Love it or loathe it, cars are a symbol and something used to judge you.

Everyone will judge you based on your car. Neighbours, your kid's teachers, your bosses at work, your other colleagues, your friends, everyone.

Some will do it consciously - these are the ones who are viewed as shallow.

Everyone else do it subconsciously. But make no mistake they still do it.

You WILL notice the difference in people's behaviour and demeanour if you suddenly change from a banger to a shiny new German saloon.

Most of it will likely be a positive difference - i.e. admiration and respect. But you may also encounter jealousy and envy. And you may also encounter disrespect from certain groups (think environmentalists when they see your 3-ton gas guzzler).

So your decision should be how much you want the judgement that comes with the nicer car. And what judgement your social circle will give.

From your description, it looks like you'd benefit a lot from it. Mostly respect and admiration. Go for it!

Thedogscollar · 31/05/2023 12:07

@Whywere
You are entitled to your opinion.

On Sunday I was exhausted, upset and angry. I shouldn't have come on here to unwind. Apologies if my posts have offended or upset anyone on here.

Obviously the OP is imo a non problem and I was wrong to compare it to anything else. I should have read it and scrolled on.

I should have known better it being AIBU.

Whywere · 31/05/2023 11:37

Thedogscollar · 31/05/2023 11:05

How sad that buying a big car to be able to fit in and make new friends is seen as an everyday issue.

And yeah, I’d agree with you. I think the poster is BU. But personally and professionally I think you’re B much more U.