Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why people are so unfriendly towards me?

117 replies

Ilovebountybars · 27/05/2023 19:11

People have always been very unfriendly, cold, and standoffish towards me.
I don't have any friends and I have never really had a group of friends. No one makes an effort to speak to me and in the past when I made an effort with people they weren't interested in becoming friends with me.

I see other people make friends and I watch how people interact with others and often they are very friendly and warm towards them. But with me, they are the total opposite.

For example, I went into a shop yesterday to get my phone fixed and the man working in the shop was laughing and joking with the previous customer, but when I told him about my phone he was very curt and cold towards me. I have no clue why. I recently watched the movie we need to talk about Kevin. People treat me exactly like they treat Eva, but in my case I have no clue why it is.

Has anyone ever seen anything like what I am describing? Has anyone got an idea of why people are like that towards me? Sorry this was so long but I really need some help/advice.

OP posts:
Ilovebountybars · 28/05/2023 12:27

Nevermind31 · 28/05/2023 12:09

Last week I took my children to their swimming lessons. The pool is local, and I’m there every week, so I know loads of people, our kids go to school together, parents of my friend’s kids.
then this man came up to me, held out his hand for me to shake, and started asking me questions, then wanting to shake my 5 year old’s hand. Didn’t know this man, never seen him before,

completely inappropriate and overfamiliar to the point it made me uncomfortable. I said no thank you, I don’t want to shake hands and neither does my child, and turned away from him.
he would have seen me laugh and joke and have a conversation with loads of people, then probably perceived that I was very standoffish with him.
but the point is… he didn’t read the situation correctly, and made me uncomfortable.
so maybe you come across as standoffish, not smiling, uninterested, or maybe you are reading the situation incorrectly (eg too eager, or overfamiliar). It’s a very fine line, but it can be practiced.

That's interesting because I have done or said the wrong thing which other people pointed out as rude. I didn't even realise I was being rude. I am not sure whether it is because of lack of social skills because I have never had any friends or whether it is autism or something like that.

OP posts:
Ilovebountybars · 28/05/2023 12:22

PrinceHaz · 28/05/2023 08:05

In your situation, I would read upon autism, look at YouTube videos about it. Find out about women’s experience of it. Find a fairly current ASD checklist and tick off your traits. Take it to your GP and ask for assessment.
Its ok for you to be different. You don’t need to be a person that makes the person in the shop smile. You should feel free to interact the way that suits you.
You need to find your people, maybe people who share the exact same interests you have, either in person or online. What does interest you, if you don’t mind me asking?

I have had a look of some of the symptoms of autism and Asperger's in girls. I match with some of the symptoms. My interests are shopping I am very much into fashion, reading, and watching films.

OP posts:
inloveandmarried · 28/05/2023 12:22

Check your facial expressions in a mirror. It might feel to you as though you are smiling but maybe it needs to be a bit exaggerated. You'll need to practice so you get used to what feels right for a smile.

People generally make a snap judgment about another person in a few seconds. It's not fair but it's how people are.

So smile, eye contact, if you are interacting for a while with someone, ask their name. Thank them by name when you finish.

Honestly it makes a difference.

A friend of mine has what she describes as 'resting bitch face' lol. She has to overcome this every day otherwise she gets the same reaction you are getting.

Allrightmylover · 28/05/2023 12:20

Being nice has nothing to do with having friends, it doesn’t mean be nasty obviously. What people really like is a good yarn spinner. So the poster upthread who said her DH can say something and people react well when if another person said it the reaction would be different, it’s partly about that.

If you are nervous people do pick up on that and it can unfortunately make them uncomfortable. DH describes me as a social chameleon. I can tell a story to anyone and what I can find is a common connection to discuss. I can only do that because I am good at reading people. DS is the same as was my Mother and my many sisters, though my awful sister has exploited people using what is sort of a gift, I sometimes wonder if it’s a genetic or learned trait

If you are neurodivergent you may find it really hard to read people, consider some assistance in pursuing a diagnosis. Though really what you actually need is what do you do with this diagnosis. Maybe there is something online that can help people to learn social cues. When I was working two staff members were diagnosed with autism, this is academia. People did dodge them quite a bit on the social side, I didn’t and because they knew I didn’t judge them they were more comfortable so their traits were less obvious. In an inaugural lecture of the new head of dept one of them got overwhelmed and to be honest I felt privileged he felt he could confide in me and I said just leave no one will mind. The guy used to have to fiddle with a small object all the time, if it made him feel better what did I care. He was an absolute genius and made the rest of us seem like ants.

Nevermind31 · 28/05/2023 12:09

Last week I took my children to their swimming lessons. The pool is local, and I’m there every week, so I know loads of people, our kids go to school together, parents of my friend’s kids.
then this man came up to me, held out his hand for me to shake, and started asking me questions, then wanting to shake my 5 year old’s hand. Didn’t know this man, never seen him before,

completely inappropriate and overfamiliar to the point it made me uncomfortable. I said no thank you, I don’t want to shake hands and neither does my child, and turned away from him.
he would have seen me laugh and joke and have a conversation with loads of people, then probably perceived that I was very standoffish with him.
but the point is… he didn’t read the situation correctly, and made me uncomfortable.
so maybe you come across as standoffish, not smiling, uninterested, or maybe you are reading the situation incorrectly (eg too eager, or overfamiliar). It’s a very fine line, but it can be practiced.

JMSA · 28/05/2023 11:50

Have you tried therapy? I think if it was everyone else who had the problem, I'd be looking at myself to see what I could do differently. That sounds like I'm blaming you for something, OP. I promise you I'm not. But I'd find it unnerving if everyone else seemed not to take to me, and I'd want to explore that. I wonder also if this is the reaction you have come to expect from others, and it almost becomes like a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Also, how old are you? I'm late 40s and although people are generally polite and friendly towards me - as am I to them - I definitely feel more invisible than I used to.

PinkRiceKrispies · 28/05/2023 11:47

I disagree that you are not funny, your Vladimir putun comment upthread really made me laugh.
Don't be so hard on yourself and smile!!

Highdaysandholidays1 · 28/05/2023 11:39

A couple of people have said- why change? If you are not a smily person, don't smile.

I think there's a few reasons why it's worth at least being able to smile if you want to- in our culture, this is normal behaviour, it's a social norm to look at least pleasant when asking for something. It's stronger in the US where the culture of 'have a nice day' is even more prevalent. In some cultures, like where my husband is from, this is not the case, or at least it did not use to be. If you walked into a bank in that culture smiling, then the counter-clark would just stare at you. Smiling all the time is seen as inauthentic. I have noticed though that the young people in that culture, serving at restaurants and doing service jobs, have adapted to the US/UK smiling culture over time, probably as they have seen it in films, have learned English and have adopted these social norms.

I don't think that practicing smiling will solve all your problems either, but I do think if you fall out of the habit of having contact with people, it can be very hard to start up again. So, practicing in small, non-important ways might pay off. Very few people want to have friends who don't smile at them or show they enjoy their company in other ways, such as enthusiasm or engagement.

Gwenhwyfar · 28/05/2023 11:24

I've recently been moved to a different place at work so now the contrast between how people are with my colleagues and how they are with me is much clearer. One thing is just how long some people have known each other. I have colleagues who've known each other for 25 years and know each other's children. I can never compete with that.

The other is what people are talking about here. How open you are, how much you smile at other people. I'm a bit shy so I can't do that. It's also not in my interests too become like that because I actually need that little bit of self-protection and there are times, like early in the morning, when I'm just not ready for small talk with people I don't know so well.
I don't think we can all be extraverts and there's no need to force ourselves to be something we're not. I want to get to know people, but maybe it has to be on my own speed.

schnauzerbeard · 28/05/2023 10:55

I think you get what you give. If you don't smile and set the friendly tone you can't expect others to always do it. Sounds like you walked in and was very formal so the shop keeper mirrored your stand offish manner.

ICMB · 28/05/2023 10:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

aintnothinbutagstring · 28/05/2023 10:26

I found working for a few years in retail really boosted my social skills and confidence (wouldn't recommend you necessarily take this step!). Dealing with rude customers, nice customers - same with colleagues, some nice and some difficult - lots of workplace banter, jokes and innane chat - helped alot! Agree with others that building connections is alot about just chatting shit at first with interested look on your face. When I go home - I am not that person at all and will tell my DH or DC when I'm bored with the conversation!

Whiteroomjoy · 28/05/2023 10:10

Ilovebountybars · 27/05/2023 19:57

I went to a counsellor a while ago. Both her and teachers at school said that it was such a shame that I had no friends because they thought I was such a nice person.

I have observed people recently and the contrast between how they are to me and how they are to others is shocking. They are warm and friendly to others but with me, it is like they are talking to Vladimir Putin or something.

Op, first I am definitely not “ victim blaming” in what I’ll say. I’m sorry you’re in this situation and it is definitely appalling for you.

imhe, it does sound like this issue is more to do with how you initiate social interactions. And that You need some help with this specifically

it is unusual to not make friends at uni and this is something that should alert you to needing some help to sort this. It sounds like you’re still quite young , so you need to get on top of this to reach your full potential in life.

we are social beings. It is hard wired into our psyche. Trust is the glue that makes that work. We use “ thin” trust daily when meeting random strangers or just in our expectations of dealing with others. Over time, as you have more interactions with that person thin trust develops into the thick trust between friends and close social relationships. But trust is reciprocal- we are very tuned to pick up signals that someone doesn’t trust us, and in turn we don’t trust them, we hold back to ensure we protect ourselves etc. and that leads to a downward spiral of disconnection with the other person

all humans have a need to be socially accepted ( with exceptions of specific mental conditions). We are hard wired to be accepted and trusted ( thin trust) from the moment we meet someone

small signals are important to ensure the other person knows you trust them by default. A smile, eye contact, mirroring their body language, and that’s even before you get into talking.

what you wear, what you look like will have very little to do with such a widespread persistent problem. Ok, they’re a few prejudice people out there that are rude to people that look “ different” ( weight, colour, disability etc) , but you’re not talking about a small number of bad encounters we all have. Forget what you look like - it ain’t that.

so 2 things I think you need some help with

  1. The fact you’ve been able to switch off those signals that are inate to us to make those social connections- like stopping smiling. Smiles are contagious for a reason and that’s a hard thing to stop. That’s a concern really.
  2. you are going into interactions from the get go with distrust and beliefs that you cannot connect . As I said, trust is reciprocal, people will pick up on that and in some ways will be afraid, they’ll be asking themselves same thing “ why is this person so standoffish / cold/ reserved with me” and will mirror back

I would be looking at help from a qualified psychologist ( NOT a counsellor) to look at these behaviours you’ve developed, and why. Then work with you to overcome them

tackling · 28/05/2023 10:09

What an absolutely rude and unpleasant comment @ICMB for someone saying to the world sadly that they've never been able to make friends. You're being a right charmer across mumsnet at the moment.

ICMB · 28/05/2023 09:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Tots678 · 28/05/2023 09:42

Maybe you need a bit of guidance with the rules of conversation. There's a middle ground though. Stay true to yourself and don't be too false. That will just lead to disappointment all round.
Oops should have been bold.
if you find that you have autism/adhd it can be a great relief. You aren’t miserable/unfriendly/ snooty or anything else wrong with you. You are you, not the smiley, inane chatty, friendly creatures described above you are you - and possibly have conversations about what interest you eg ‘so are lots of this type of phone having this problem’, ‘which is the best phone for the money’, etc
Imv that’s the best thing about a diagnosis -there’s nothing wrong with you. You are you and can get on with it without comparing to others.

Thepeopleversuswork · 28/05/2023 09:29

I think you have to remember that being socially confident is (for most people) an acquired art. It doesn’t come naturally to most people, it is learned. If your parents were socially confident you will learn earlier etc but most people don’t automatically know how to do it.

I was very socially awkward when I was younger and felt very much as you did but I forced myself to get better and I am now quite good at it.

The most important thing, as PPs have said, is to be (or imitate) the person you want to interact with. If you don’t smile at someone they are unlikely to smile back. Smiling (even if it’s fake) goes an incredibly long way. It’s basically universal code for “I come in peace.”

Some people find small talk very difficult and unnatural but a little bit of chat does also go along way to signal that you are friendly. Anyone working in retail will know that it’s part of their job description to at least be cordial to customers so retail is probably a good way to start practicing because you are unlikely to be met by hostility.

Another thing to work on is your own sense of self worth. If you meet someone who is rude or surly it’s easy to be derailed by this and internalise it. You need to detach and develop a sense of “I don’t give a shit.” No one is liked by everyone and there will always be people who don’t warm to you. You can’t control that so it’s important not to let that knock you off course.

It’s mainly about developing a sense of doing your own public relations. Presenting yourself in the best possible light to give yourself the best chance in these interactions. You don’t have to make everyone your best friend and you don’t have to have sparkling conversation. And remember listening is often the best way to do this if you feel insecure. You just have to not let yourself down. It will feel uncomfortable and unnatural to start with, possibly quite tiring. But it will quickly become second nature.

AngelinaFibres · 28/05/2023 09:23

My husband and SIL are on the spectrum. She is very businesslike in all interactions. She would see it that her phone has a problem, she wants it fixed and that's that. She can't do small talk and gives off ' here's the job, sort it out please' vibe. Not unpleasant but absolutely not ' I'm chatty, let's have a chat'. My husband was a business manager for a huge German engineering Company. He worked with lots of ( always) men who were just like him; efficient, factual, to the point, no flattery, no flummery. It was a high pressure environment. Since retiring he has had to learn a new way of being and he has found it hard. I am also retired and I am not going to live my life like an executive on an important project. I like people. I like chatting. I don't find standing in a queue behind an old person massively stressful. I may be that person one day and that cashier my be the only person who has noticed me all day. He has really had to train himself to calm down , to learn a different way of interacting because, unlike his sister, he does care about how he is perceived . He has face blindness too . It was easier at work because people always wore the same thing and they were in the expected place at the expected time. He's like the Queen with me as his assistant nowadays at social things. Oh look (husband) it's David,Susan,Steve.
If you smile Op it will get you a long way.

Anyotherdude · 28/05/2023 09:20

At age 19, I had a bad case of resting bitch face, hence the constant encouragement to “cheer up luv, it might not happen,” from (mostly male) passers by. When I got so pissed off one day that I retorted “what if I want it to happen, then?” And got a belly laugh from the guy, I started laughing too, and we parted ways with a smile on both of our faces.
After that, I practiced smiling and thought through how to approach or walk past people, and the rbf-related cat-calling stopped.
Later, I got into fashion and makeup, and realised that how you present yourself is 90% of job done when you meet new people!
It’s worked for me for the last 40-something years, so it can be a habit that is learned, and makes life so much easier.
It might work for you too, OP - try it and see - it gets easier the more you practice.

rainydayy · 28/05/2023 09:15

You sound exactly like my lovely daughter. She has been diagnosed with autism at nearly 31 years old and it's made all these little things make sense 🌸

tackling · 28/05/2023 09:12

Posted too soon there, I think a lot of us suggest it to others when we see signs or things that feel familiar, because it can be a transformative revelation.

Of COURSE social anxiety doesn't equal autism but along with everything else it can be one of many signs.

tackling · 28/05/2023 09:10

@Backtothegym the OP has explicitly said it's a possibility.

In terms of you "hating it" ... well, about six years ago I posted a list of things about myself on Mumsnet in despair asking why I was the way I was. A few kind posters suggested autism which I honestly had never thought about (and didn't think was common in women).

Without those replies I would still be leading a life of self loathing and confusion - I was suicidal and on my way to losing my job.

I agree the suggestion comes up a lot and I also see it inappropriately too ("my husband was rude" "is he autistic?") but then again I think autistic women are probably over represented in mumsnet compared to real life because the nature of a moderated online forum makes it an autism-friendly way to socialise.

IndiganDop · 28/05/2023 08:57

OP, people have different circles of relatedness.
There's your partner, family and maybe one or two best friends in the innermost circle. These are people you love and can be your most relaxed self with - farting out loud, for example!

Then there are other friends who you might go out with or visit with, people you like and who like you.

Then there are people you see regularly where it's important to maintain cordial relations with - for example, students on your course or in your building, work colleagues, your boyfriend's mum, maybe the postman if you get a lot of parcels, the guy in the corner shop you pop into most days for milk. Friends of friends would fall into this group too - say you go to a party or for dinner with your friend and her boyfriend who you haven't met before. People in this group are ripe for sliding into your friends group if they ask things like if you might want to go to an event.

Then there are business relationships, which are "professional" - you are friendly in the meeting, but you are all there for a particular reason and wouldn't be interacting otherwise. This circle has two rings really - regular business colleagues and one off business meetings. In my opinion a bit of small talk is more important in the former than the latter. But it depends on how focused on the piece of business you both are. For your example, your phone problem falls into this band. You and this man are not friends, he is being paid to do a job which is why he is interacting with you. He doesn't like or dislike you; if you go in businesslike he will respond businesslike. If you go in more open he will respond more open. He doesn't much care either way! You've already been given plenty of helpful advice on what to say for small talk.

Finally there are strangers. The world runs more smoothly if you have a pleasant neutral face and nod and smile if you catch someone's eye. These are people where there is no relationship - you are just passing through each others' lives. A person on a train with you or standing in the same lift would be an example. In general we Brits don't talk much to these people and you can appear a bit weird if you try to chat to someone in this category!

towriteyoumustlive · 28/05/2023 08:33

@Ilovebountybars I'd say it's highly likely you are autistic.

My BIL was always paranoid people didn't like him and didn't understand their reactions. He was diagnosed in his 40s with autism.

It's probably worth reading some books on social interactions for those with autism and reading facial expressions.

Don't give up on the clubs. Pick something you really want to do and stick with it.

NeedToChangeName · 28/05/2023 08:21

I doubt very much that strangers are taking an instant dislike to you

Far more likely this is a combination of your social skills (yes, it's a skill and can be learned), confirmation bias (you expect to find people unfriendly) and self esteem (in the past, if I walked past people laughing, I always suspected they were laughing at me. People with higher self esteem don't think that way)

I agree with a PP. Start small and practise those skills. Next time you go into a shop, smile and say hello

Swipe left for the next trending thread