Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Open to honest answers … my partner dislikes my relationship with my mother

743 replies

Rosieposey91 · 27/05/2023 18:21

Bit of background information… my parents separated when I was 3 years old. Super close bond with my mum. Best friends as well as mother and daughter.

my partner is a jealous type. Since the beginning of our relationship, hasn’t understood our closeness and would get aggravated if I text her when we was out together or if she checked I am ok etc if it was getting late.

we often speak several times a day. He is off work at the moment and he gets so angry when she calls or I call her. He calls me a baby and says I’m weird. I am not changing for him, I’ve always been like this with my mum and she has with her mum and I know a lot of families from my area who are the same (eastenders). He isn’t from the same area and he isn’t close with his family.

he said it’s affecting our relationship. That he wants me to cut back the time I speak to her. That we never even finish a film without her calling me. Why can’t she just wait until the end etc. I do get this point as sometimes I will say I am watching something and she still calls me before I’ve let her know it’s finished. Although she will say it’s only a quick question or that it’s late and she is going to bed. Then I feel stuck in the middle because I understand it’s frustrating for my partner when she can’t just wait until I’ve let her know the film is finished.

i do have some health conditions so she worries about me but she has also been able to just call when she wants regardless if I am watching a film etc I’ve never had a problem pausing it to talk to her. Am I in the wrong? He will sit there sulking and then not speak to me the rest of the evening and go upstairs and sulk without eating any dinner etc.

just wondered if people
could give some advise and whether I am right to not change my relationship with my mum? He also says she speaks over him but sometimes he talks for ages and admits he goes on and when she was over she wanted to ask something so she did. He then says it’s rude and no manners. I’m finding it all really stressful and because I’m used to my mum I don’t want to assume it’s him being funny when maybe I do need to put boundaries in place?

i am happy with my relationship with my mum. So it’s only my partner who is annoyed with it despite it not being his relationship and wants me to change even though it’s not affecting me.

thank you xx

OP posts:
ChocolateRaisin09 · 28/05/2023 17:29

I agree that this is OCD/anxiety (and I've been there so I'm not judging) because what happens if either of you doesn't answer for a day? I imagine you'd be beside yourselves, it would be traumatic. Because you're completely codependent which isn't typical of mother & adult child relationships these days. It must be exhausting. One way to find out would be to conduct a poll of friends/ people to see how often they speak to/text their mum.

MrsTerryPratchett · 28/05/2023 16:59

i guess just to let her know I’m in bed and ok. Maybe it is too much, but it’s not harming anyone. I have ocd so that could play a role, my mum worries about me because of my health so she likes to know I’m ok and she doesn’t trust in my partner to support me really. It’s hard to convey all in messages on here but I appreciate that maybe the texting and call isn’t needed and has just become a habit and reassurance for my mum that im ok. It’s been hard on us all since my diagnosis.

She's anxious, you have OCD. I think it's far more likely to be this than some Eastend cultural imperative and that you love your mum more than anyone else does.

If you both need to check constantly and feel anxious and unhappy if you don't, do you see how that is OCD/anxiety behaviour? It's textbook. And it ramped up after illness. Also textbook. If it 'works' for you, fine. And your relationship with your partner is dead anyway so why bother. But the denial is the disorder speaking. The anger when people disagree is the disorder speaking. The pretence that it's all completely normal is the disorder speaking.

Bear in mind that these behaviours don't reduce without work and you are training your DD particularly to also anxiously check constantly. You were trained, please let your DD decide herself when kind of relationship she wants.

I8toys · 28/05/2023 16:48

YABU seems a bit OTT for adult children to have to speak to parents several times a day unless there is a crisis, illness or circumstances that require an update.

justasking111 · 28/05/2023 16:43

We're kinda like the Walton's in that we all live nearby, open door policy no appointment needed here. We don't phone each other at night but share on what's app. Some think it strange but it works for us. We are a village of related adults raising children and grandchildren. We're in Wales so it's not as unusual.

I know we're lucky to be living close together. It's not always possible. When younger my children worked around the world from the arctic circle to Africa, the middle east, Caribbean. My youngest is living with a Yorkshire lass her family three generations all live in spirit distance of each other too.

So I'm not knocking the OP. When I was growing up we rarely saw grandparents, aunts uncles cousins because of my father's job taking us all over. I attended eight different schools in all. My children two. I don't have lifelong friends and miss that connection

Coyoacan · 28/05/2023 16:22

On a serious note, OP, you are living with a man you do not love and much prefer the company of your mother. I suggested at the beginning that you should move back in with your mother and everything indicates that you should. But if you want to have another partner in the future, you would need to limit the phonecalls and texts with your mother to something more reasonable.

Hbh17 · 28/05/2023 16:12

OP, if I were your partner, I would find this completely suffocating. He may be expressing it badly, but he has a right to expect you to prioritise him over your mother. When we are adults, we need to learn to distance our parents, to a greater or lesser extent.

TheShellBeach · 28/05/2023 15:49

penniesmakeshillingsandshillingsmakepounds · 28/05/2023 14:26

God you must have had no time for anything else when your Nan was well with all the calling and texting to the two of them. Sure you'd have to go to bed a 7pm to get all the multiple goodnights done.

Grin
steff13 · 28/05/2023 15:31

penniesmakeshillingsandshillingsmakepounds · 28/05/2023 13:14

Norman Bates maybe?

Well, a boy's best friend IS his mother.

sandyhappypeople · 28/05/2023 15:26

mikulkin · 28/05/2023 14:55

OP, if you can leave your phone at work or during sex can’t you text in advance to your mum and say I am going on a date night and will text after that? If she calls during and you don’t answer by text or orally, you are not ignoring her as you told her in advance. The problem with your view is that you are very much concentrated on not upsetting your mum in any way but happy to upset your partner.
there are several issues there. I understand you have good relationship with your mum and you have some certain things you do however

  • even if your mum despises your partner she has to respect your wish to work on your relationship. If you are so close you can have honest conversation with her saying I do want to work on this relationship and one of the things I want to compromise on is not to pause film or interrupt date night with him even for a quick text or phone call. She will respect this as she loves you. I would also ask your mum not to show despise to you as you want to make it work. She loves you a lot from what I can see and as your best friend she will want to respect your view even if she disagrees with you, You can explain to her that you don’t want to ignore her and as a result you will text n advance when this happens so that she is aware and you will text or call once you finished film or date night
  • you can’t wait for your partner to improve and then start making compromises, there are two people in this relationship and you both need to do steps at the same time. He works on his temper and you do these compromises. It does feel a bit, that he needs to prove to you that he is worth of compromises and I can understand it doesn’t leave him feeling valued. You need to tell him in advance on what you plan to do and ask him to respect that you are doing steps in his direction but you are not planning to change completely. Similarly he needs to make changes - you both agree which - the most obvious one for me is not to lose his temper and not sulk but he won’t change completely, so perhaps he will still insist on children going to bed at certain time. If you accept that he will need to accept some of your routines.
  • I do fully understand that it doesn’t bother you to have a quick call or text during meal or film but you also need to respect the fact that it would bother a lot of other people including your partner. I know you don’t understand this but we do not have to understand every reason behind every behaviour of other people - you just need to respect them. My husband really gets upset if I text during our meal , I don’t understand it as I don’t do it during conversation but in between but I respect his view and don’t do it. Equally I get upset if he has TV on (without sound) during dinner (he sometimes likes to keep an eye on score in football game) so he compromised on that. It is two way street. We both agreed that if phone rings during dinner, we check and if it is one of our children or parents we either text asking if it is urgent or answer (his mum is old and can’t do texts), if not emergency we say we are having dinner, and will call back. We also agreed that if it is an important game (don’t ask me what it means) the tv stays on without sound during dinner. The point which I am making is we discussed what irritates the other person and made some compromises, not full way change but compromises.

The main difference here is that you obviously care about how your behaviour affects your partner, and have mutual respect in your relationship, which to me is how it should be and how me and DH are, but it doesn't read to me like OP cares about any of that, and she's unwilling to work on it.

She's arguing the toss with everyone with a different viewpoint and now only responding to people who agree with her, so really she's not interested in an objective viewpoint, she just wants everyone to tell her it's right that she's completely disregarding her partner.

I used to speak to my mum most days, see her once or twice a week, and even now she's gone, while I miss her and wish I could have more time with her, I don't wish I could go back and call, text or see her more, she raised us to be independent and it set us up for a life without her. I know someone like OP in real life.. I fear for her when her mum is gone, as she is her whole life. I personally don't think parents should encourage this extreme level of dependency, it's selfish and cruel.

WisherWood · 28/05/2023 15:20

To me, the OP's partner sounds aggressive and unpleasant at best. However, I'm also quite aware that we're only getting her take on him. He sounds like he's thoroughly nasty to the kids. But it may be that she's overindulgent, they're spoiled, and he's made the mistake of trying to correct that by being way too strict. Either way, the conflicting parenting that she's described won't be good for them.

Plus, if he is as bad as she says, I wonder if the root of the problem is her relationship with her mother. If your prime relationship is with a parent and is co-dependent or enmeshed, any relationships that follow are not going to be great either.

LittleSwede · 28/05/2023 15:18

Hi OP, it sounds as if you are really trying to figure out is if your partner is abusive or not?

Why don't you google Why Does He Do That by Lundy Bancroft, you'll find a free online book to read. Read it and you will find that sulking and silent treatment does actually fall into the Emotionally Abusive category and you'll have your answer there. This is the one book that is always recommended on MN, read it, it's a mind opener. Good luck and best wishes.

justme2022 · 28/05/2023 15:15

I have a really close relationship with my mum. We speak on the phone every day. I usually face time once a day so she can see the kids (we live 300 miles apart so we only see her in person every 6 weeks or so) and we text a couple of times a day when I'm at work. She never calls or texts after 6. 30 in the evening because that's when my partner gets home and that's our family time with our kids and time for us to enjoy together. If I text her to say goodnight she would probably laugh at me. Your relationship with your mum does sound suffocating to me but then mine with my mum would be suffocating to other people.
Your partner sounds like an arse. Your mum thinks he's an arse and you think he's an arse. So I would say your relationship with him is probably on the way out regardless of what goes on between you and your mum.

Cantstandbullshitanymore · 28/05/2023 15:12

Rosieposey91 · 28/05/2023 02:29

Thank you. It resonates very much with me.

in fact this whole discussion has made me realise that I really don’t need to put up with him and I don’t and won’t change my relationship with my mum. Some people don’t get it and that’s fine. Those of you who do , we are the lucky ones. Thank you all for your support and going to leave it there as my mind is now made up :)

To me, anyone who stays and types 3 pages of responses on mumsnet has issues they need to resolve especially when you s already concluded you’re right anyway, it’s a desperate cry and need for validation.

If you want to maintain your relationship with your mother go ahead and he can also decide if he wants to continue with the relationship or continue to roll his eyes and you can then decide if you can’t tale anymore eye rolling and leave, it’s all your decision so I don’t see the need for this debate on mumsnet.

AliceOlive · 28/05/2023 15:08

@mikulkin Great advice.

AliceOlive · 28/05/2023 15:07

FelisCatus0 · 28/05/2023 15:00

I don't know I think she's pretty awful to him, tbh. She has no respect for him, and won't put the phone down for him. She doesn't respect his parenthood and undermines him. She feels he is the one who needs to change. I honestly think he'd be better off finding someone who treats him better, leave her to her strange relationship with her mother. I feel for him. I am very pro-female but she just seems abusive to me.

He’s a gambling addict displaying all of the the behaviors that come along with addiction.

Weird that you would think he would be a good match for anyone.

Paperlate · 28/05/2023 15:07

FelisCatus0 · 28/05/2023 14:55

Not at all. The OP was rude to people, so we're entitled to answer back. You have it back to front. If an OP starts a thread asking for advice, and then they start attacking the replies and dismissing the advice, they'll get it back.

Some people have been quite rude to the OP. Including you.

AliceOlive · 28/05/2023 15:01

Coyoacan · 28/05/2023 14:55

All this is the downside of phones. I doubt the OP's great grandmother popped in to put her daughter to bed every night in the good ol' days of the East End.

I live in Mexico where families are also incredibly close. My friend's sister and her husband used to videocall their son in England every day and micromanage his life from here. The poor thing had crossed to world to have some space to breathe and even that hadn't worked.

This is very true! Couldn’t do that when it wasn’t free, either. I think smartphones are a disaster.

70sTomboy · 28/05/2023 15:01

Quite frankly, you and he aren't suited. He needs to stop sulking and acting up, but I get his frustration. You need to grow up.
If you're not ready to adult, then cut the guy loose. He probably didn't envisage being in a relationship with your mother, too. A call once a week, maybe a message when there's something to discuss in between is all it needs.

Instilling Independence is part of good parenting. Your mother needs to back off, or she is letting you down.

FelisCatus0 · 28/05/2023 15:00

AliceOlive · 28/05/2023 14:57

She actually took on board quite a bit of it. Admitted she didn’t need to take texts during a movie. But he’s awful to her so she’s not interested in catering to him. Who can blame her? she can’t depend on him, but knows her mom will always have her back.

And why is a 30 second text “good night” a big deal? Sheesh, tons of people I know do that with friends, siblings, parents. All of it ramped up with covid, of course.

My 90 year old neighbor lives alone and has her kids texting and calling constantly. Grand kids and great grandkids, too. She has a huge and busy life, but her kids want to know she’s okay on a daily basis.

I don't know I think she's pretty awful to him, tbh. She has no respect for him, and won't put the phone down for him. She doesn't respect his parenthood and undermines him. She feels he is the one who needs to change. I honestly think he'd be better off finding someone who treats him better, leave her to her strange relationship with her mother. I feel for him. I am very pro-female but she just seems abusive to me.

AliceOlive · 28/05/2023 14:58

And do you feel the same about spending time arguing with strangers on mumsnet? Because some people have spent more time on this thread than OP spends texting her mom.

AliceOlive · 28/05/2023 14:57

FelisCatus0 · 28/05/2023 14:48

No, people are having a go at her because she asked a question, didn't like 99% of the answers, and then dared suggest the rest of us were not normal and 'not close' to our own mothers simply because we don't call or text mummy to say nightnights. It's her whole arrogant, smug and dismissive attitude that got up people's noses.

She actually took on board quite a bit of it. Admitted she didn’t need to take texts during a movie. But he’s awful to her so she’s not interested in catering to him. Who can blame her? she can’t depend on him, but knows her mom will always have her back.

And why is a 30 second text “good night” a big deal? Sheesh, tons of people I know do that with friends, siblings, parents. All of it ramped up with covid, of course.

My 90 year old neighbor lives alone and has her kids texting and calling constantly. Grand kids and great grandkids, too. She has a huge and busy life, but her kids want to know she’s okay on a daily basis.

mikulkin · 28/05/2023 14:55

Rosieposey91 · 28/05/2023 02:41

But I can leave my phone. I go out with friends or when with my children and don’t touch my phone. So you have misread this or taken it the wrong way. I speak to her when I want to.

OP, if you can leave your phone at work or during sex can’t you text in advance to your mum and say I am going on a date night and will text after that? If she calls during and you don’t answer by text or orally, you are not ignoring her as you told her in advance. The problem with your view is that you are very much concentrated on not upsetting your mum in any way but happy to upset your partner.
there are several issues there. I understand you have good relationship with your mum and you have some certain things you do however

  • even if your mum despises your partner she has to respect your wish to work on your relationship. If you are so close you can have honest conversation with her saying I do want to work on this relationship and one of the things I want to compromise on is not to pause film or interrupt date night with him even for a quick text or phone call. She will respect this as she loves you. I would also ask your mum not to show despise to you as you want to make it work. She loves you a lot from what I can see and as your best friend she will want to respect your view even if she disagrees with you, You can explain to her that you don’t want to ignore her and as a result you will text n advance when this happens so that she is aware and you will text or call once you finished film or date night
  • you can’t wait for your partner to improve and then start making compromises, there are two people in this relationship and you both need to do steps at the same time. He works on his temper and you do these compromises. It does feel a bit, that he needs to prove to you that he is worth of compromises and I can understand it doesn’t leave him feeling valued. You need to tell him in advance on what you plan to do and ask him to respect that you are doing steps in his direction but you are not planning to change completely. Similarly he needs to make changes - you both agree which - the most obvious one for me is not to lose his temper and not sulk but he won’t change completely, so perhaps he will still insist on children going to bed at certain time. If you accept that he will need to accept some of your routines.
  • I do fully understand that it doesn’t bother you to have a quick call or text during meal or film but you also need to respect the fact that it would bother a lot of other people including your partner. I know you don’t understand this but we do not have to understand every reason behind every behaviour of other people - you just need to respect them. My husband really gets upset if I text during our meal , I don’t understand it as I don’t do it during conversation but in between but I respect his view and don’t do it. Equally I get upset if he has TV on (without sound) during dinner (he sometimes likes to keep an eye on score in football game) so he compromised on that. It is two way street. We both agreed that if phone rings during dinner, we check and if it is one of our children or parents we either text asking if it is urgent or answer (his mum is old and can’t do texts), if not emergency we say we are having dinner, and will call back. We also agreed that if it is an important game (don’t ask me what it means) the tv stays on without sound during dinner. The point which I am making is we discussed what irritates the other person and made some compromises, not full way change but compromises.
FelisCatus0 · 28/05/2023 14:55

Paperlate · 28/05/2023 14:53

People are sticking the boot in because they think that's what you have to do on AIBU. The OP is entitled to answer back.

Not at all. The OP was rude to people, so we're entitled to answer back. You have it back to front. If an OP starts a thread asking for advice, and then they start attacking the replies and dismissing the advice, they'll get it back.