Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Open to honest answers … my partner dislikes my relationship with my mother

743 replies

Rosieposey91 · 27/05/2023 18:21

Bit of background information… my parents separated when I was 3 years old. Super close bond with my mum. Best friends as well as mother and daughter.

my partner is a jealous type. Since the beginning of our relationship, hasn’t understood our closeness and would get aggravated if I text her when we was out together or if she checked I am ok etc if it was getting late.

we often speak several times a day. He is off work at the moment and he gets so angry when she calls or I call her. He calls me a baby and says I’m weird. I am not changing for him, I’ve always been like this with my mum and she has with her mum and I know a lot of families from my area who are the same (eastenders). He isn’t from the same area and he isn’t close with his family.

he said it’s affecting our relationship. That he wants me to cut back the time I speak to her. That we never even finish a film without her calling me. Why can’t she just wait until the end etc. I do get this point as sometimes I will say I am watching something and she still calls me before I’ve let her know it’s finished. Although she will say it’s only a quick question or that it’s late and she is going to bed. Then I feel stuck in the middle because I understand it’s frustrating for my partner when she can’t just wait until I’ve let her know the film is finished.

i do have some health conditions so she worries about me but she has also been able to just call when she wants regardless if I am watching a film etc I’ve never had a problem pausing it to talk to her. Am I in the wrong? He will sit there sulking and then not speak to me the rest of the evening and go upstairs and sulk without eating any dinner etc.

just wondered if people
could give some advise and whether I am right to not change my relationship with my mum? He also says she speaks over him but sometimes he talks for ages and admits he goes on and when she was over she wanted to ask something so she did. He then says it’s rude and no manners. I’m finding it all really stressful and because I’m used to my mum I don’t want to assume it’s him being funny when maybe I do need to put boundaries in place?

i am happy with my relationship with my mum. So it’s only my partner who is annoyed with it despite it not being his relationship and wants me to change even though it’s not affecting me.

thank you xx

OP posts:
Dibbydoos · 28/05/2023 06:23

Hi OP, a close relationship with your mum is fine. I wouldn't change that.
Her calling during a film, that's easy to stop - let her know you're watching a film or say you'll be unavailable until xyz time so pls don't call or better still I'll call you later as we're busy. You can then be in controlled of the time you'll speak. BUT don't not speak to your mum because you're partner doesn't like it.

Nowstrong · 28/05/2023 06:23

I haven't read the whole thread (a bit long), several things has stood out : his jealousy, short temper, sulking. Get rid. You can do better. Perhaps your mother is right not to like him. I wouldn't.

InsomniacVampire · 28/05/2023 06:20

Your partner is self centred and controlling, your mum is way overinvested in your life. Sound slike a nightmare on both ends and you are unable to set up boundaries.

realityhack · 28/05/2023 06:10

greenel · 28/05/2023 04:09

I actually think the OP isn't in a relationship with a decent man because of her relationship with her mum. If she's never witnessed women in her family be with men who meet their emotional needs, and are lovely, supportive partners (so they don't need to rely on their children) - how would she know what a good man/good relationship looks like?

And by this token she too doesn't know how to be a good, compromising romantic partner because she's never witnessed her mum do this with a man. How would she know how to be the sort of partner "a decent man" would want to commit too? If she's emotionally unavailable for a romantic relationship because of her mum, she will only attract the arseholes or equally emotionally unavailable men. No man who could be a great partner wants to be part of a throuple - especially if he is close to his own family, he will understand what OP and her mum have is codependent and unhealthy compared to what he has.

This post is spot on and cuts to the heart of this issue I think.

TallerThanAverage · 28/05/2023 06:07

Best friends as well as mother and daughter

IMO you can be friends with your mother but I don’t think it’s healthy for a parent to be their child’s best friend. They have a completely different relationship with you as.a parent and when you think about all the people you have friendships with through education, work and possibly parenthood to still have an almost incestuous relationship with your parent still is quite sad. I love my mother and my daughter but my mum’s role as was mine is to raise our daughters to be independent women. If my daughter was codependent then I would feel like I had failed.
Your heading states you are open to honest answers but reading your responses I don’t think you are.
Not that I think it’s relevant I’m from east London, Stratford to be precise.

aloris · 28/05/2023 05:57

If you plan to watch a movie with your partner, it's disrespectful to make a habit of stopping the movie at whatever random point your mother decides to call. It prevents him from enjoying the movie, tells him that the activity you're doing with him is not as important as answering your mother's trivial questions, and tells him that you don't care about his time. It's controlling on your part.

I am also not impressed by your mother's need to consult you over trivial questions like what shoes to wear to go out, and by her expectation that you will drop whatever you are doing with your partner to talk to her about things that are actually not emergencies. This suggests to me that your mother thinks she should come before your partner. I am wondering how your mother expects you to form a stable partner bond when she keeps intruding on your time with your partner.

Your posts here give the strong impression that your primary partner is your mother. The father of your children is secondary to that and it gives the impression that your relationship with him is conditional upon him accepting he comes second to your mother.

I don't know if he's abusive as you suggest but his wanting to watch a movie without you allowing regular interruptions by your mother, is not a sign of him being abusive. If you do think he is abusive then I am not sure why you are still with him.

Witchcraftandhokum · 28/05/2023 05:25

Sorry but your reply is irrelevant to me. You are clearly from a completely different culture / upbringing. So I do not care for your opinion

only eastenders would understand

I think you need to leave your man and your mum and experience life outside the East End of London.

Achwheesht · 28/05/2023 05:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Achwheesht · 28/05/2023 05:18

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ProfessorXtra · 28/05/2023 05:12

Op you said earlier the contact isn’t really about her or your anxiety. It’s about closeness. But it’s really obvious it’s about both of your anxieties.

She wouldn’t be able to sleep if she wakes in the middle of the night and there’s no text saying you got to bed safe as there’s a risk you could have a cardiac arrest. How many times has that actually happened? And if that happened, how would it have helped you? How you partner knows you are texting your mum when he is asleep, I don’t quite get.

If there is a real risk you could have a cardiac arrest going up the stairs, do you have a personal alarm to alert your partner? There’s other thing that can be put in place. And (god forbid) something did happen, she would likely to be alerted earlier than her waking up in the middle of the night.

You have OCD and anxiety around her dying. So it’s feeding yours as well.

But the most worrying thing is that you will expect this from your daughter as a sign that you are close. My family is Irish on my mums side and Indian on my Dads. I know what close family is. The constant contact isn’t proof that you are super close. Her feeling obliged to be in contact far more than her brother to prove closeness and that you have this expectation already is worrying and it’s really unfair. It’s also likely to cause some huge resentment between your children. That you expectations of them are so different based on their sex, isn’t ok.

Texting good morning and good night isn’t proof that you are closer to your mum than others are to theirs. It’s proof you are both anxious people and need this to be able to go about your day or even sleep. It’s actually proves nothing about closeness.

I don’t know what the solution is. I do suspect Pp is right. The relationship with your mother hasn’t shown you what a good romantic partnership.

theGooHasGone · 28/05/2023 05:12

To follow on: You've already got exactly what you needed from your husband, which is a couple of kids who hate him but love you that you can be unhealthily enmeshed with after your mum is gone. He's surplus to requirements now.

marblemad · 28/05/2023 05:09

I think both him and your mum seem controlling and possessive, dump him and seek therapy for emotional attachment problems with your mum and start distancing yourself. It seems from what you have said it is more her than you, you need to start putting boundaries in place now or it will affect further relationships.

theGooHasGone · 28/05/2023 04:58

Rosieposey91 · 28/05/2023 00:47

I know.

but. We have kids and he has sought help
for his issues. If he can change maybe then I can respect him more to want to compromise?

This statement pretty much sums up your whole issue.

You don't see what you're doing as a problem at all, to the point where you're ignoring and dismissing the majority of the replies in the thread all saying "it's a problem" and calling them rude, thick and ignorant. You asked people what they thought and they told you - you don't like their answers, so you lash out.

Then to top it all off, you say that if your partner tries really really hard to change for you, then maybe you might finally respect him enough to call your mum a little less.

Like other people said, his relationship is over and he doesn't realise it yet. Do the decent thing and let him go.

HoppingPavlova · 28/05/2023 04:36

I understand you wouldn’t do that with your sons, but daughters are different. I wouldn’t expect my son to want to text me good night and good morning but I know my daughter will most likely want to. It is a different relationship although I am equally as close to both my babies, a daughter is naturally more close to their mum in that way.

Dont know where to start with any of that. My kids range young adult to adult and there is no standard that daughters/mums act in different ways to sons/mums do. While I love all my kids equally, I’m closer to some than others simply due to personality, interests etc. While I love my daughter dearly, and she I, we don’t have much in common at all apart from vaginas, I’m definitely closer to some sons and would spend a lot more time with them due to common interests (be that hobbies, sports, music, tv shoes etc). I know many people the same.

Nothing like general gender stereotyping though. Would have been different if you confined it to the relationship you and your mum have but you have made broad sweeping statements that are generalised which is bullshit. In other news not all females wear pink and not all males wear blue🙄.

HerbsandSpices · 28/05/2023 04:36

Me and my married daughter are very close but I would never interfere in her marriage like this. If we're chatting she will tell me she is off to watch a movie with her DH. Their time together as a couple of very important too.

Maybe you need to ring fence the evening as partner time and speak to your mother other times? My daughter also has medical conditions but I know she is with her DH who would let me know if there were any serious issues arise.

steff13 · 28/05/2023 04:19

greenel · 28/05/2023 04:09

I actually think the OP isn't in a relationship with a decent man because of her relationship with her mum. If she's never witnessed women in her family be with men who meet their emotional needs, and are lovely, supportive partners (so they don't need to rely on their children) - how would she know what a good man/good relationship looks like?

And by this token she too doesn't know how to be a good, compromising romantic partner because she's never witnessed her mum do this with a man. How would she know how to be the sort of partner "a decent man" would want to commit too? If she's emotionally unavailable for a romantic relationship because of her mum, she will only attract the arseholes or equally emotionally unavailable men. No man who could be a great partner wants to be part of a throuple - especially if he is close to his own family, he will understand what OP and her mum have is codependent and unhealthy compared to what he has.

This is a really great, insightful post.

greenel · 28/05/2023 04:09

SargentSagittarius · 28/05/2023 03:48

The gambling addiction is clearly just one issue.

OP - I think you’d be far less enmeshed with your Mum if you were with a decent man, and in a healthy relationship.

You wouldn’t entreat into that relationship / rely on her so much, and she wouldn’t worry about you so much, and need that constant reassurance that you’re OK.

Ditch the man. It sounds like everyone, including your kids - and even including him! - would be happier.

I actually think the OP isn't in a relationship with a decent man because of her relationship with her mum. If she's never witnessed women in her family be with men who meet their emotional needs, and are lovely, supportive partners (so they don't need to rely on their children) - how would she know what a good man/good relationship looks like?

And by this token she too doesn't know how to be a good, compromising romantic partner because she's never witnessed her mum do this with a man. How would she know how to be the sort of partner "a decent man" would want to commit too? If she's emotionally unavailable for a romantic relationship because of her mum, she will only attract the arseholes or equally emotionally unavailable men. No man who could be a great partner wants to be part of a throuple - especially if he is close to his own family, he will understand what OP and her mum have is codependent and unhealthy compared to what he has.

Chickenkeev · 28/05/2023 03:59

SargentSagittarius · 28/05/2023 03:48

The gambling addiction is clearly just one issue.

OP - I think you’d be far less enmeshed with your Mum if you were with a decent man, and in a healthy relationship.

You wouldn’t entreat into that relationship / rely on her so much, and she wouldn’t worry about you so much, and need that constant reassurance that you’re OK.

Ditch the man. It sounds like everyone, including your kids - and even including him! - would be happier.

That"s a bit rubbish tbh, OP needs to find herself outwith any random partner she's with. It's only through finding yourself that you can find a proper partner (imo anyway)

FictionalCharacter · 28/05/2023 03:53

“That we never even finish a film without her calling me. Why can’t she just wait until the end etc. I do get this point as sometimes I will say I am watching something and she still calls me before I’ve let her know it’s finished.”

I’d find it completely intolerable if my MIL called my husband several times a day and wouldn’t even wait until we’d finished watching a film.

I get that you’re close to your mum but this sounds suffocating.

greenel · 28/05/2023 03:52

Op, I've read all your posts and my DP too who I've written about here a few times is a 4th generation east ended and I'm Indian. He went into therapy in his 30s because he realised himself his relationship with him mum (exactly like yours) was codependent and it was a generational thing.

You too are falling into the trap of other women in your family of picking and staying with poor partners because you have your mum and children to support you. Because you have no example of a healthy adult relationship, you don't know how to have one. And instead of focusing on this part of your life and improving it, you are using your mum to fill the gap and she is you, and you are also doing to your children what she is doing to you. But at some point one of your children (like my DP did) will realise it is not a child's job to be responsible for a parent. Your mother needs another adult to support her and putting that burden on you since you were a child is unhealthy. I can guarantee you will never have a good relationship with a partner, the sort of relationship where you are a team with a romantic partner - because your mum fills your emotional needs as you do hers. And when your mum passes, you will turn to your children. That's why so many women in the east end live like this - because it's easier to make your child your companion than deal with a grown man or focus on finding the right partner. This is an observation my DP made btw as he too thought the east end way was all about family. No, it's also about avoiding adult responsibilities and putting them on the child. I am Indian and very close to my parents as an only child but his relationship had zero boundaries. And it was sobering for him that HE had to put in boundaries because his mother had none of her own.

If you think about it in no other situation would it be acceptable for a grown woman (your mother) to be best friends with a child or teenager, someone who's nappies they changed. She should be relying on other adults or friends for companionship, not you. The biggest question here is : would you feel as responsible for your mum if she made the effort to build a network of her own, have a supportive partner of her own, have close friends of her own? And if she doesn't have these things, why not?

SargentSagittarius · 28/05/2023 03:48

The gambling addiction is clearly just one issue.

OP - I think you’d be far less enmeshed with your Mum if you were with a decent man, and in a healthy relationship.

You wouldn’t entreat into that relationship / rely on her so much, and she wouldn’t worry about you so much, and need that constant reassurance that you’re OK.

Ditch the man. It sounds like everyone, including your kids - and even including him! - would be happier.

Chickenkeev · 28/05/2023 03:29

SargentSagittarius · 28/05/2023 03:18

You’d do anything for her, except the one thing that would give her peace of mind and genuine contentment - and be the best thing for yourself, as well - which is split from this awful man.

It’s perfectly obvious what you should do.

Genuinly i might have missed something, but from what i can tell the guy has a gambling addiction and has now owned up to it. He should be applauded for that rather than shunned?

Kennykenkencat · 28/05/2023 03:28

Family is so important to me

Hate to break it to you but it isn’t really. You husband and your children are your family. Yet you allow your 3 year old to bad mouth your Dh to your mother.
Your mother became your extended family when you married Dh.

Family isn’t important to your mother either. The most important thing in your mothers life is winding your Dh up.

If a Dd has a heart condition and her mother knows that her Dd and Dh will be watching a film and the mother hates the son in law so much that she calls during the film anyway just to anger her son in law which then his reaction stresses her Dd out would you actually think that the mother had that close of relationship with her Dd if her hatred for her son in law potentially out weighs the life of her Dd

WhatToDoAboutTheNosys · 28/05/2023 03:27

I have a relationship similar to yours with your mum, but yours is definitely to the extreme. She could text you goodnight instead of calling if you tell ger you're having the evening with your partner.

My mum and dad broke up when I was 2. We'll have days when she calls several times, but no structure to it. I can definitely see why your partner has issues with it all and my mum gradually stepped back.

For example she may call a few times in a day, but we whatsapp a lot and we'll have days when we don't call. She respects that evenings and weekends is time with my DH so she'll only call then if its important, we'll message instead.

At first I'd answer calls in films, if we were driving together or on a walk. DH pointed out that it's rude because his only option is to sand wait in these situations, which is selfish. I'd say it'll only be a minute but not realise we'll be chatting for a while. Also it does ruin the immersion in a film neither of us use our phones if we watch a film.

How long ago were you poorly and medicated? If it was recent then her worry if fair, if its not then it will be good for her to relax back a bit now. If my mum calls and I miss her, she'll text "ring me" or call right again, otherwise she understands that I'm busy and will call back when I can.

I'm busy with my toddler so we mostly chat in the car when I'm driving somewhere.

Texting when you're also in bed is ott in my opinion, but also completely harmless so if you both like that you do this then crack on!

GingerScallop · 28/05/2023 03:26

Chickenkeev · 28/05/2023 02:49

Why are you saying to PP 'nothing to do with you'? You've put this up on a public forum, asking for advice etc. Do you want advice or not?

She's an Eastender, don't you know? The advice she wants is that this is perfectly normal and very eastend and only an Eastender would know and/or understand. Its cultural. Actually, its physiological. Its in the DNA and its immutable. All Eastenders do this and not one has changed.
Honestly i don't necessarily think op is wrong. if she likes her relationship with her mum this way its fine. If she had a good relationship with her DP I would say manage relationship with mum differently. Call her before tv show then let her know you will speak to her again after x hours. But as it is, partner is not great. She doesn't say it but there is built up resentment in the relationship. And when a 3 year old starts getting in marital and/or woes and reporting to external parties then its turned toxic. Am not a divorce advocate but its really bad for the 3 year old talking about his/her dad to gran this way. And it seems neither mum nor gran are managing that well. probably because it validates their feelings towards dp (but really, is it good for dc?). I think its time to call the divorce lawyers. And if you can afford it, therapist to disentangle healthily from DP. And perhaps to see mum from independent, professional eyes

Swipe left for the next trending thread