Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Open to honest answers … my partner dislikes my relationship with my mother

743 replies

Rosieposey91 · 27/05/2023 18:21

Bit of background information… my parents separated when I was 3 years old. Super close bond with my mum. Best friends as well as mother and daughter.

my partner is a jealous type. Since the beginning of our relationship, hasn’t understood our closeness and would get aggravated if I text her when we was out together or if she checked I am ok etc if it was getting late.

we often speak several times a day. He is off work at the moment and he gets so angry when she calls or I call her. He calls me a baby and says I’m weird. I am not changing for him, I’ve always been like this with my mum and she has with her mum and I know a lot of families from my area who are the same (eastenders). He isn’t from the same area and he isn’t close with his family.

he said it’s affecting our relationship. That he wants me to cut back the time I speak to her. That we never even finish a film without her calling me. Why can’t she just wait until the end etc. I do get this point as sometimes I will say I am watching something and she still calls me before I’ve let her know it’s finished. Although she will say it’s only a quick question or that it’s late and she is going to bed. Then I feel stuck in the middle because I understand it’s frustrating for my partner when she can’t just wait until I’ve let her know the film is finished.

i do have some health conditions so she worries about me but she has also been able to just call when she wants regardless if I am watching a film etc I’ve never had a problem pausing it to talk to her. Am I in the wrong? He will sit there sulking and then not speak to me the rest of the evening and go upstairs and sulk without eating any dinner etc.

just wondered if people
could give some advise and whether I am right to not change my relationship with my mum? He also says she speaks over him but sometimes he talks for ages and admits he goes on and when she was over she wanted to ask something so she did. He then says it’s rude and no manners. I’m finding it all really stressful and because I’m used to my mum I don’t want to assume it’s him being funny when maybe I do need to put boundaries in place?

i am happy with my relationship with my mum. So it’s only my partner who is annoyed with it despite it not being his relationship and wants me to change even though it’s not affecting me.

thank you xx

OP posts:
realityhack · 28/05/2023 09:29

I don’t think a lot of pp’s understand a close family dynamic

No, we understand. We just don’t agree and that’s what annoys you. Loving someone means respecting their own family time and the importance of that in addition to parent relationships. Would you insist on coming on your kids honeymoon with them for example? Well that’s an example of a healthy boundary. Maybe you don’t understand the importance of raising children to be resilient and not to be so reliant on their parents they are incapable of reaching emotional maturity.

Maia77 · 28/05/2023 09:27

Your relationship with your mum sounds a bit enmeshed. Close relationship with a parent is fine, but this seems a bit unhealthy. These patterns are usually formed in childhood, often when the partner is unavailable so the child becomes the companion and confidant. I think it would be good to set some boundaries. I worked with clients who have had these types of relationships with mothers and after they passed away clients really struggled.

HeckyPeck · 28/05/2023 09:27

DanceMonster · 28/05/2023 09:05

I don’t think some people understand that a close family dynamic doesn’t have to involve speaking to someone multiple times a day, every day.
I am extremely close to my mum. She is on her own, and my brother died. Our closeness isn’t defined by how often we speak on the phone though.

It doesn't have to involve speaking everyday, but it's not a problem if it does.

I think a lot of people on here don't understand abusive relationship dynamics. OPs partner is clearly abusive - sulking and stonewalling, throwing things, short tempered, not letting OP take their daughter to the doctors, telling OP she was making a fuss when she was pregnant and when she was having an anxiety attack. I'm sure that's just the tip of the iceberg too. A classic move of an abusive partner is to try and isolate their partner from their family.

OPs mum has seen her partner for who he is and people like him hate that. His hope will be that if he can take away their closeness he can keep pulling the wool over OPs eyes.

I hope you manage to get away from him OP. In the meantime, don't let him spoil your relationship with your mum.

My husband speaks to his mum every day. It makes them both happy. I wouldn't want to take that away from either of them.

InsomniacVampire · 28/05/2023 09:27

Dibbydoos · 28/05/2023 06:23

Hi OP, a close relationship with your mum is fine. I wouldn't change that.
Her calling during a film, that's easy to stop - let her know you're watching a film or say you'll be unavailable until xyz time so pls don't call or better still I'll call you later as we're busy. You can then be in controlled of the time you'll speak. BUT don't not speak to your mum because you're partner doesn't like it.

OP is telling that to her Mum and the mum still rings before the end of the film, so there is no control over the volume an d timing of the conversations ... But OP also is also happy to have her mother ring at all times and have zero boundaries.

Itsokay2020 · 28/05/2023 09:26

Rosieposey91 · 28/05/2023 01:54

Not normal if I didn’t have my diagnosis. Completely normal that I do and any loving mother would do. The fact you don’t see it as normal makes me think you are very strange IMO. So you have yours and I have mine. Chicken Keev lol.

@Rosieposey91 I too live with a serious underlying health condition which could ‘get me’ at any time.

I am also a mum, and am close to both my parents. I am also very independent, and am raising my DC to be independent, confident and self-assured. Quite simply, I don’t know what my life expectancy is - there are no guarantees I will reach retirement age. I don’t want my DC to miss me when I am gone, I want to give them all the skills to live happy and fulfilled lives in which their memories of me make them smile, rather than consume their heart with overwhelming loss and grief.

Focusing purely on the level and type of communication between you and your DM, there is a lot of codependency and an awful amount of health anxiety - if you don’t answer your phone, your DM may fear the worse and then call your DP? This is not rational and is very intrusive.

Whilst on the one hand, your closeness with your DM could be celebrated, my fear is how you’ll both cope when the other is no longer around? It’s clear that some of the topics of conversations (what shoes to wear with an outfit) are a smokescreen for making sure you’re okay. It’s entirely reasonable to see how this would affect your DP. If your health condition is so serious that a heart attack is imminent, I assume you are wearing an alarm? This should give your mum comfort that in the event of a fall (or worse), your mum would be contacted as your NOK.

@Rosieposey91 I don’t think it’s unreasonable to have boundaries in place with regards to your mum. She needs to be respectful of your family life, the needs of your DC and DP. Only you know if your relationship with your DP can be repaired and it’s not fair to heap all the blame on his behaviours. I for one would not tolerate a text to a parent to wish them goodnight from
the ‘marital’ bed - that should be a place of solace, love and unity for you and DP (unless by mutual consent you invite the kids in for a morning cuddle 🥰)

Try to live your life with acceptance of your condition, not fear. Reduce your anxiety and see your OCD lessen. Seek therapy to deal with the adjustment to your life if necessary. I speak from a place of empathy.

GuinnessBird · 28/05/2023 09:25

I've made the mistake of reading the whole thread and all I can say is OP I would have dumped you a long time ago, everything's about you or your mum, you have no consideration for your partner at all.

Go and see a therapist.

TheShellBeach · 28/05/2023 09:25

I am very close to my adult children.
We speak on the phone about once a week.

If the OP is at risk of a cardiac arrest she should ask about getting a mini defibrillator inserted into her heart by a cardiac surgeon.

Or a pacemaker. Or whatever.

In any case, if she's at that much risk, her bedroom should be downstairs, or she should get a stairlift.

DogInATent · 28/05/2023 09:24

I think this type of close relationship with one or both parents is quite normal for some people. I don't think it's a healthy or mature, and I think it would claustrophobic and detrimental in the extreme to a normal, mature, adult, sexual relationship with a partner. I'm unsure who is controlling in this relationship, other than I am confident it's not the partner.

At some point a mother has to allow and encourage an adult daughter an emotionally independent life, and if they're not mature enough to grab it for themselves have the maturity to give them the push.

OP, it's time to start adulting and have a normal adult relationship with your partner that doesn't require it to take second place to your ongoing childhood.

SamW98 · 28/05/2023 09:21

Sagealicious · 28/05/2023 09:08

OP you've mentioned a few times that your partner is very rigid and not willing to make changes but can't you see that you're this way as well?

Absolutely. We’re only hearing one version of events but the OP keeps insisting her partner has to change and compromise but she’s not willing to budge an inch

Theres definitely 3 people in this relationship and it’s very unhealthy.

And btw I’m from Stratford and I don’t understand the dynamic at all

ButterflyOil · 28/05/2023 09:20

Are you going to expect this level of closeness and contact with your own children once they are grown up? Since you said your mum was like this with her mum, is this what you expect will happen with your kids? And how would you feel if they didn’t want that?

The answers to those questions could be interesting for you.

ProfessorXtra · 28/05/2023 09:18

Dedodee · 28/05/2023 08:49

@Rosieposey91 I have a big family OP.
Someone is always ringing during the evening. My dh family rarely ring.
The difference is my dh accepts that I may/will get lots of calls especially as I have elderly parents.

I don’t think a lot of pp’s understand a close family dynamic.
If dh and I are watching a film I just quickly message that I’ll ring the caller later.
Sometimes dh will say that we never get a minute of peace but he would never make an issue of it because he loves my family too.

I wish people would stop saying that people who don’t agree with the op simply don’t understand. It’s so condescending. We just simply disagree.

I come from a Huge Irish family on one side and a huge Indian family on the other. I understand close family.

But also given the way the Op keeps changing her story, I feel she isn’t being honest. It’s not really about close family. It’s about Ops unhealthy relationships.

I imagine her Dp might be an arse. But I also imagine the Op may be leaving huge bits out that may explain some of his behaviourS it would be interesting to see his view. Especially since she wants him to get help and change but has no intention of changing anything herself. That’s a red flag.

Her Dp complains that after she spoke to her mum to say goodnight, she texts her. He complains while she is doing it. But also she has to text her mum once she is in bed because she is at huge risk of having cardiac arrest from walking up the stairs. She must text her mum, because her partner is in bed before her and wouldn’t hear her fall down the stairs or shouting or any of it. So he is fast asleep but also awake complaining that she is texting.I appreaciate he may be awake some nights and not others. But Op says she must do this every night because he is asleep and wouldn’t hear her. That suggests he is asleep 99% of the time. A text to her mother, read hours later, isn’t going to save her. Her mother could work on the basis that if something did happen she would get a call in the middle of the night. If she doesn’t hear anything its all good.

She texts her mum so that if her mum wakes in the middle of the night, she knows she got to bed safe. Because op is at risk of cardiac arrest only from stairs apparently. If her risk of cardiac arrest is so high and it’s not just stairs that are the risk, it could happen at any point after she text her mum. So the middle of the night text isn’t doing anything.

Op says a lot of this is due to both of them losing someone, but then says it’s not anxiety led and that her mother and grandmother did the same. Which when there was only land lines, must have been even worse.

Op says it increased with her health problems, but also that they have always been like this and she fully expects her daughter to enjoy doing the same thing. Why if it’s down to health problems? Why does she expect her daughter to enjoy doing this and her son not?

Op then says she does this entirely out of choice and enjoyment, which doesn’t match all the ‘I need to do this because of my health problems’. Why would she plan what her toddler daughter will enjoy when she is an adult. And why is the expectation not there for a son if it’s based on doing it if you enjoy it?

So many contradictions, it’s reads like someone who knows deep down they are (at least) partially wrong. And keeps changing the goal posts to get peoples agreement.

Greenpeasnwham · 28/05/2023 09:17

It’s not a sign of a healthy close relationship to be this enmeshed. it’s pointing to tricky attachment issues. A health parental attachment creates an internal model of security which can be drawn on by their child instead of actual real world contact with the parent. It’s what allows the person to grow a healthy internal life.
This internal model should sustain through grief, illness, relationships etc. it should certainly last longer than the duration of a film!
Please consider seeing a therapist to give your kids a chance of you having some conscious choices at least about how you’d like to parent them and how you’d like their relationships with others to be. Just now things are not healthy for you all.

PriOn1 · 28/05/2023 09:15

I think the two of you are unsuited and that he is likely verging on abusive with his sulking.

With a different partner, you might find he’d ask you to tone things down a bit with your mum. For example, I think you should switch your phone to silent and ignore it if you’re watching a film and you know your mum will ring. But a good partner would persuade you to do that in a kind and respectful way.

Sagealicious · 28/05/2023 09:08

OP you've mentioned a few times that your partner is very rigid and not willing to make changes but can't you see that you're this way as well?

DanceMonster · 28/05/2023 09:05

Dedodee · 28/05/2023 08:49

@Rosieposey91 I have a big family OP.
Someone is always ringing during the evening. My dh family rarely ring.
The difference is my dh accepts that I may/will get lots of calls especially as I have elderly parents.

I don’t think a lot of pp’s understand a close family dynamic.
If dh and I are watching a film I just quickly message that I’ll ring the caller later.
Sometimes dh will say that we never get a minute of peace but he would never make an issue of it because he loves my family too.

I don’t think some people understand that a close family dynamic doesn’t have to involve speaking to someone multiple times a day, every day.
I am extremely close to my mum. She is on her own, and my brother died. Our closeness isn’t defined by how often we speak on the phone though.

Xrays · 28/05/2023 09:03

Womencanlift · 28/05/2023 08:58

I don’t think a lot of pp’s understand a close family dynamic.

It is a bit disingenuous to suggest a family isn’t close unless they are constantly texting/calling each other

We are an extremely close family but that comes with respect that each of us will have other priorities at some points of the day

Exactly.

This level of “closeness” is not healthy for anyone.

If a woman posted this thread, saying her dh was the op in this situation there would be a unanimous leave him.

BlackWhiteColour · 28/05/2023 08:58

realityhack · 28/05/2023 08:22

Nobody should want to put their child in that position

I think this is key. Most of us encourage our children to be independent, capable adults because we recognise that over reliance on a parent will cause huge problems with their ability to cope with life when the parents inevitably die. Smothering someone is not a "loving" act at all, its completely and utterly self serving because the person needs you to be reliant on them for their own self worth and to fill a gaping hole in their life. You can still adore your parents, be close to them and have a great bond without this kind of unhealthy codependency.

If you really love someone, you want to empower them and equip them with the tools they need to thrive in life, not make them completely reliant on you to the point its ruining their relationship. That is not love, its control.

Absolutely. I worry a lot how dependent my 18y girl is in me for emotional support. I am gently trying to encourage resilience and other coping strategies. That’s my duty as a good mum. She knows I am behind her 100% but she needs to be able to cope without me too.

Womencanlift · 28/05/2023 08:58

I don’t think a lot of pp’s understand a close family dynamic.

It is a bit disingenuous to suggest a family isn’t close unless they are constantly texting/calling each other

We are an extremely close family but that comes with respect that each of us will have other priorities at some points of the day

RightWhereYouLeftMe · 28/05/2023 08:56

I don’t think a lot of pp’s understand a close family dynamic.
If dh and I are watching a film I just quickly message that I’ll ring the caller later.

Well that's a different close family dynamic to the OP then. She has specifically said she won't text her mum to say that they're watching a film and therefore she can't talk - someone suggested it and she said no she can't do that.

Listenforachange · 28/05/2023 08:54

OP does your mum also have this health condition, and does your daughter have it? Because as this thread has gone on you’ve used the danger of your condition to justify the level of contact. You said near the start your mum had this relationship with her own mum, and you’d want the same with your daughter. The condition is a red herring. It’s unhealthy

Confusion101 · 28/05/2023 08:53

He isn't annoyed he sends a text to your mother to say you are in bed. It is one thing on a long list of things that makes him annoyed regarding your relationship with his mam. The text on top of the other text on top of the four phone calls pone that interrupted a convo ye were having or a film ye were watching. It's a lot.

I think you should consider what you actually want to change, what compromises you want to make as others have said. But it seems you don't actually want to make any because you don't see what you are doing is OTT and are not happy with your partner. Leave him. Staying together for children isn't actually doing them good in the long run.

And side note, if your partner had this level of a relationship with his parents ye would never have time for each other.

Vroomfondleswaistcoat · 28/05/2023 08:52

It's not a mother's job to be her daughter's 'best friend'. It's her job to make her adult daughter fit to survive in the world without her. I love my daughters very much, and I am completely here if they need me, but phoning every day would be like me saying that I don't trust them to get on with life.

And one day I won't be here. I want them to have healthy loving relationships so that they have someone when I'm gone. So I think your mother needs to trust you to contact her if you need her, and if you're quiet she should know you're having a good time, not use you to assuage her raging boredom.

MyTruthIsOut · 28/05/2023 08:50

Ionlydrinkondaysendinginy · 28/05/2023 08:45

🤣🤣🤣🤣

(and you forgot to include the part where they keep telling each other they love each other).

Dedodee · 28/05/2023 08:49

@Rosieposey91 I have a big family OP.
Someone is always ringing during the evening. My dh family rarely ring.
The difference is my dh accepts that I may/will get lots of calls especially as I have elderly parents.

I don’t think a lot of pp’s understand a close family dynamic.
If dh and I are watching a film I just quickly message that I’ll ring the caller later.
Sometimes dh will say that we never get a minute of peace but he would never make an issue of it because he loves my family too.

MyTruthIsOut · 28/05/2023 08:49

Fluffyfluffs · 28/05/2023 08:45

I read your post and agreed with you until you said she phones on the middle of films etc and you answer.

I’ve read some updates and he sounds abusive and a little controlling but on the other hand, I think your constant contact with your mum sounds a bit weird. If my DH was taking calls from his mum in the middle of a film, it would drive me up the wall.

My DM passed away, but if she text me or sung me, I certainly wouldn’t answer if it wasn’t convenient. I certainly never spoke to her and text her several times a day. I mean as a grown up, who on Earth sends their child/parent a goodnight text?? I’m all for close relationships but yours sounds really intrusive and I think you need to find a better balance.

Hand shuffle 😂😂😂😂

That made me laugh!!

I bet she’d still answer her phone whilst shuffling if her mother called 😂