Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Open to honest answers … my partner dislikes my relationship with my mother

743 replies

Rosieposey91 · 27/05/2023 18:21

Bit of background information… my parents separated when I was 3 years old. Super close bond with my mum. Best friends as well as mother and daughter.

my partner is a jealous type. Since the beginning of our relationship, hasn’t understood our closeness and would get aggravated if I text her when we was out together or if she checked I am ok etc if it was getting late.

we often speak several times a day. He is off work at the moment and he gets so angry when she calls or I call her. He calls me a baby and says I’m weird. I am not changing for him, I’ve always been like this with my mum and she has with her mum and I know a lot of families from my area who are the same (eastenders). He isn’t from the same area and he isn’t close with his family.

he said it’s affecting our relationship. That he wants me to cut back the time I speak to her. That we never even finish a film without her calling me. Why can’t she just wait until the end etc. I do get this point as sometimes I will say I am watching something and she still calls me before I’ve let her know it’s finished. Although she will say it’s only a quick question or that it’s late and she is going to bed. Then I feel stuck in the middle because I understand it’s frustrating for my partner when she can’t just wait until I’ve let her know the film is finished.

i do have some health conditions so she worries about me but she has also been able to just call when she wants regardless if I am watching a film etc I’ve never had a problem pausing it to talk to her. Am I in the wrong? He will sit there sulking and then not speak to me the rest of the evening and go upstairs and sulk without eating any dinner etc.

just wondered if people
could give some advise and whether I am right to not change my relationship with my mum? He also says she speaks over him but sometimes he talks for ages and admits he goes on and when she was over she wanted to ask something so she did. He then says it’s rude and no manners. I’m finding it all really stressful and because I’m used to my mum I don’t want to assume it’s him being funny when maybe I do need to put boundaries in place?

i am happy with my relationship with my mum. So it’s only my partner who is annoyed with it despite it not being his relationship and wants me to change even though it’s not affecting me.

thank you xx

OP posts:
Sallyh87 · 28/05/2023 10:03

I suffer from ALOT of health problems. Had a cardiac arrest, lung failure and was in a coma for a while a few years ago.

Absolutely no way would I spend my time reassuring people I am alive and well. I refuse to be focused on my health apart from obviously taking care of myself as best I can. I do not owe my mother or anyone else reassurances every night.

This @Rosieposey91 isnt a very healthy way to live your life. Through constantly having to reassure your mother it means you can’t really shut off from it.

It does sound like you’re not happy with your DH, so maybe just end that as it’s not working for either of you.

Changeling78 · 28/05/2023 10:02

OP the title says “I’m open to honest answers…” you’re really not though.

Your relationship with your mother may be normal to you, but that does not make it normal. I love my mother so much, we have an awesome relationship but we also have boundaries, you don’t seem to. If my mum phoned during a film, I wouldn’t answer and she wouldn’t think it was because I was dead (I too have a health condition) she would think I was busy. I’m not on call and neither is she.
The relationship may be fine for you but I’d feel smothered. It’s causing an issue between you and your OH, you either want to fix it or you don’t. I’m sure you, your mum and children can move in together and live happily ever after.

ProfessorXtra · 28/05/2023 10:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Bless you. I know logically, it will get better. Just doesn’t feel like it. Just cried my way through blow drying my hair over her.

The bit about hearing her in your head made me laugh. Because I can often hear the same, imagining what she would say. It’s hard times.

mummydoris2006 · 28/05/2023 09:56

@Rosieposey91 I am extremely close to my mum, speak multiple times a day and live opposite each other. I also have many serious health conditions and what sticks out to me in your posts is when you speak of your health.
Literally anyone can have a cardiac arrest at anytime, obviously being diagnosed with AF etc heightens the risk but medication controls and lessens the probability. I am diabetic and have lost hypo awareness, I have suffered two strokes in the past few months and also have other debilitating illnesses. I get up everyday however and live my life. It seems to me like maybe you and your DM have some health anxiety around your illness which isn't healthy for either of you. My DH works longer hours than me so parents literally have found me crumpled at the bottom of the stairs and my DM is my best friend, she still wouldn't panic if I didn't reply to a text for a couple of hours though because I was watching a film!!!
Also I don't think this is intentional but you're basically telling posters that are trying to help that they couldn't possibly be as close to their children as your are to your mum because they're not from the East End or their kids are boys which is actually really rude!

whumpthereitis · 28/05/2023 09:54

Fucking hell. He’s hardly a prince amongst men but I can absolutely see why he’s beyond pissed off that this clusterfuck of weird enmeshment and co dependency.

I would run a fucking mile from anyone like this with their parents.

Batalax · 28/05/2023 09:52

I speak and text my family lots through the day so I get that, but I’d not keep stopping a film. You need to text that you’ll be busy so we’ll say good night now etc, but pps are right this is actually really about your relationship.

Im glad this thread has clarified things. But do think a bit more about the phone interrupting your relationship in your next relationship. You don’t mind, but this thread shows that many do. You need to create boundaries for when you text/call and you both need to be a bit more flexible about timings when it’s inconvenient.

TheShellBeach · 28/05/2023 09:49

Scienceadvisory · 28/05/2023 01:27

But your mum won't know either because she is also asleep. She won't see your message until the morning.

Grin
TheShellBeach · 28/05/2023 09:47

OP, do you realize that your mother raising the alarm in the morning, over a cardiac arrest you might have had the night before, is several hours too late?

You don't seem to understand your alleged health condition.

Onetoffeetin · 28/05/2023 09:45

I've not managed to read all 18 pages, have got about halfway through, so apologies if I'm repeating what others have said.
You said your dad left when you were young and your mum doesn't have a LTR. Also your grandad died young. I wonder if your mum and nan being on their own meant they need to rely on each other more?
You have a partner. You don't sound happy. His responses sound ridiculous and unhealthily jealous, but he may have a bit of a point as it does seem rather intense. I wonder if, assuming you do decide to split, you need to have a think about boundaries in relationships? It does sound rather excessive to be in touch several times a day, including when you get up and when you go to bad. Between you perhaps you could agree what would work?
Or, if you part you need to find someone whose family values align with your own.
Another thing that struck me is it sounds as though, if you don't respond immediately to your mum, she worries (e.g. her lying awake until you say goodnight). By responding in the way you do, it could serve to reinforce her anxiety. It is almost as if you're telling each other you're still alive at the end of each day. I get what you said about your nan, however, you don't live alone - it is perhaps more important she checks in with you rather than you with her?
I am close with my mum and check in with her regularly. She has ill health (has done for 35 years and had to give up work through injury), when I was young I had to help out a lot at home as my dad had an extrmely stressful and consuming working life. When she is going through a bad period, I will contact her more. Mostly by message now, or send her pics etc as my life is too busy with my own family and full time work. I am lucky tho as she doesn't live alone, she has my dad. My sister also lives a little closer to them.

BlackWhiteColour · 28/05/2023 09:45

I actually feel sorry for the OP. The mother has fostered this dependency and guilt so the OP thinks it’s normal. I can almost see the mum rubbing her hands with glee that her daughter’s relationship is on the rocks and she can have her baby girl all to herself again.

Achwheesht · 28/05/2023 09:43

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ShandaLear · 28/05/2023 09:43

If a man had written what you’ve written everyone here would be calling him a mummy’s boy and advising the woman to leave the relationship. Taking a call in the middle of a movie is batshit, and he must be very frustrated at playing second filled all the time. I would advise him to leave the relationship and advise you to let him go for his sake.

DozyDelia · 28/05/2023 09:42

I honestly think only eastenders will get it.

No, we don't.

It's nothing to do with being a working class family living in the east end.

It's a weird and very unhealthy relationship.

Women who are in a relationship, have two toddlers, and are aged 30, do not speak to their Mum to say Goodnight, every night when they get into bed (with their partner, presumably.)

You need to see this for what it is.

Co-dependency and your mother hasn't had 'that' bad a life.

My mother's dad died when she was 16, her brother (51) and mother died within a year of each other . She nursed her MIL through cancer at our house (giving up her bedroom for her and sleeping in the lounge) shortly before those events.

Stop making excuses. Your mum 9and you) need counselling because if You spilt from your partner, it's likely that another man will not tolerate this set up.

TiredOfCleaning · 28/05/2023 09:38

I don't think there are three people in the relationship.

There's two. But the partner isn't either of them.

MMMarmite · 28/05/2023 09:38

Rosieposey91 · 28/05/2023 00:27

Thanks. Makes sense. But why can we both be close. My mum and me. My partner and me.

ask me that question on a good day and I would say I absolutely think our relationship is worth fighting for. As long as he seeks help for his temper and way of dealing with things (he moans all day long)

im by no means perfect, I am very laid back so things that annoy him just don’t bother me. So he moans even more. I’m laid back with my children, he is more strict. Wants them in bed by 6.30pm so he can have peace. If they are happy playing or want another story I am happy to let them have longer 8pm the latest but he flips out saying he gets no evening. I let my boy sleep in our bed, he hates it and complains. It’s not every night but he just likes to be with us. We parent differently. He has a temper, I don’t. He snaps at the kids, he broke my sons toy the other day because he was being silly with it and not listening. He shouts, I don’t. They never want daddy, always me. It’s hard.

He shouts, broke your son's toy. He doesn't sound great! Is he addressing his temper and changing? If not, personally I'd be out of there.

But why can we both be close. My mum and me. My partner and me. It sounds like your mum really doesn't like or respect your partner. I think it's hard to be very close to two people who really disapprove of each other.

ProfessorXtra · 28/05/2023 09:36

HeckyPeck · 28/05/2023 09:27

It doesn't have to involve speaking everyday, but it's not a problem if it does.

I think a lot of people on here don't understand abusive relationship dynamics. OPs partner is clearly abusive - sulking and stonewalling, throwing things, short tempered, not letting OP take their daughter to the doctors, telling OP she was making a fuss when she was pregnant and when she was having an anxiety attack. I'm sure that's just the tip of the iceberg too. A classic move of an abusive partner is to try and isolate their partner from their family.

OPs mum has seen her partner for who he is and people like him hate that. His hope will be that if he can take away their closeness he can keep pulling the wool over OPs eyes.

I hope you manage to get away from him OP. In the meantime, don't let him spoil your relationship with your mum.

My husband speaks to his mum every day. It makes them both happy. I wouldn't want to take that away from either of them.

I agree with a lot of this he sounds awful.

But given the clear health anxiety in the family, it may be that he is fatigued with it all. I know someone who has health anxiety and all they talk about is the twice they were right and unwell. Not the hundreds of times they have insisted something is wrong when there isn’t.

He could have just been wrong in the case of the daughter. He may have got to the end of his tether with the anxiety and stress when op is pregnant. There was a thread recently, where the Op had huge anxiety and her husband couldn’t take it anymore.

He absolutely shouldn’t be throwing things. But not talking isn’t always abusive. Often people just shut down when they have repeatedly tried to communicate their feelings and needs and it’s completely ignored. The silent treatment can be abusive. It can also be a reaction to being in a relationship with someone who has you at the bottom of the pile and who ignores your needs.

Usually before that stage there’s talking, arguments, bickering etc.

He certainly doesn’t sound like a prince among men, but op said he is pursuing help while she sits there and says she refuses to change anything. Which doesn’t sound great.

I think it’s entirely possible that Op and her mother and him do not know what a healthy relationship actually is.

and no one said she wouldn’t speak to her mum everyday. There’s a huge difference between speaking everyday and what op is doing.

DozyDelia · 28/05/2023 09:35

I've skim- read all your posts @Rosieposey91 and seem to agree with everyone else.

This isn't a healthy relationship with your Mum.

You both appear co-dependent.

As an example, my mum lives hundreds of miles away. I used to speak to her once a week on average. Now, as she's older and widowed, it might be 2-3 times a week.

The amount of contact you have is not good for either of you.

Your partner is right.

Lapland123 · 28/05/2023 09:34

Kennykenkencat · 28/05/2023 03:28

Family is so important to me

Hate to break it to you but it isn’t really. You husband and your children are your family. Yet you allow your 3 year old to bad mouth your Dh to your mother.
Your mother became your extended family when you married Dh.

Family isn’t important to your mother either. The most important thing in your mothers life is winding your Dh up.

If a Dd has a heart condition and her mother knows that her Dd and Dh will be watching a film and the mother hates the son in law so much that she calls during the film anyway just to anger her son in law which then his reaction stresses her Dd out would you actually think that the mother had that close of relationship with her Dd if her hatred for her son in law potentially out weighs the life of her Dd

This is the ironic part of all this.

Family is so important to the OP
She’s so family- oriented that she won’t even try to change to keep her kids’ nuclear family intact

What a joke

Sorry for the partner , and the kids who will be packing their suitcases to live their lives 50:50

You should have just found a sperm donor and had kids with your mother

PosseGalore · 28/05/2023 09:34

Sorry, I haven't read the whole thread about your health problems. It makes even more sense that you and your mother are so close, but I think it's OK to e the way you are together even if you didn't have a health problem. A lot of people haven't experienced that degree of closeness with their parent so will find it all a bit odd but I really don't.

Aprilx · 28/05/2023 09:33

If I were him, I would be off, there are three people in your relationship. I can’t imagine providing my parent with a running commentary of life to the extent she even knows you are watching a film, never mind her not caring about waiting until it is over.

I think you can continue your relationship with your mother as you see fit, but it probably will be to the detriment of other relationships.

Mummyoflittledragon · 28/05/2023 09:30

Rosieposey91 · 28/05/2023 01:54

Not normal if I didn’t have my diagnosis. Completely normal that I do and any loving mother would do. The fact you don’t see it as normal makes me think you are very strange IMO. So you have yours and I have mine. Chicken Keev lol.

As the parent of a 14 yo teen with a medical condition, which could be very serious if triggered, I do not find this level of contact ‘completely normal’. I absolutely hate that my dd could die in certain circumstances if not properly looked after once the medical condition is triggered. It’s terribly frightening. But as a mother, I have to put my anxiety to the side for her sakes. She has to be allowed to become an independent adult.

If you are happy to have this much contact, it’s fine. But my dd would not be. She definitely is not being brought up to be a people pleaser. I wouldn’t inflict that on her having been very much trained to be one from very young. I also wouldn’t want her to worry about me that much either… myself being someone, who is really not well.

HeckyPeck · 28/05/2023 09:30

Itsokay2020 · 28/05/2023 09:26

@Rosieposey91 I too live with a serious underlying health condition which could ‘get me’ at any time.

I am also a mum, and am close to both my parents. I am also very independent, and am raising my DC to be independent, confident and self-assured. Quite simply, I don’t know what my life expectancy is - there are no guarantees I will reach retirement age. I don’t want my DC to miss me when I am gone, I want to give them all the skills to live happy and fulfilled lives in which their memories of me make them smile, rather than consume their heart with overwhelming loss and grief.

Focusing purely on the level and type of communication between you and your DM, there is a lot of codependency and an awful amount of health anxiety - if you don’t answer your phone, your DM may fear the worse and then call your DP? This is not rational and is very intrusive.

Whilst on the one hand, your closeness with your DM could be celebrated, my fear is how you’ll both cope when the other is no longer around? It’s clear that some of the topics of conversations (what shoes to wear with an outfit) are a smokescreen for making sure you’re okay. It’s entirely reasonable to see how this would affect your DP. If your health condition is so serious that a heart attack is imminent, I assume you are wearing an alarm? This should give your mum comfort that in the event of a fall (or worse), your mum would be contacted as your NOK.

@Rosieposey91 I don’t think it’s unreasonable to have boundaries in place with regards to your mum. She needs to be respectful of your family life, the needs of your DC and DP. Only you know if your relationship with your DP can be repaired and it’s not fair to heap all the blame on his behaviours. I for one would not tolerate a text to a parent to wish them goodnight from
the ‘marital’ bed - that should be a place of solace, love and unity for you and DP (unless by mutual consent you invite the kids in for a morning cuddle 🥰)

Try to live your life with acceptance of your condition, not fear. Reduce your anxiety and see your OCD lessen. Seek therapy to deal with the adjustment to your life if necessary. I speak from a place of empathy.

When you have an abusive partner, it's entirely fair to blame them for the relationship not being good. There is no possible way to behave that would make an abusive relationship good.

In fact, saying that the abusive partner is not entirely to blame makes it more likely that the victim won't leave as it will play right into the abusers hands.

PosseGalore · 28/05/2023 09:30

You're lucky to have such a close relationship with your mum. You can conduct that relationship any way you please. It's a shame that your partner doesn't take part in the lovefest - there is a world in which he would just chime in with a "hello, love" when she calls rather than rolling his eyes, but he's not that person. Given that he isn't you do need to find a compromise. Can't you call your mum to say goodnight before you start the film? It's just a new routine, but you'd soon get used to it. I live alone and never feel lonely apart from that moment just before I go to bed. I think it's got something to do with a subconscious fear of being alone if someone broke in. I would love to have a daughter to say goodnight to every day, it would be tremendously reassuring and make me feel that I wasn't alone. I hope you are able to find a solution that means you are able to enjoy both relationships.

FinallyHere · 28/05/2023 09:30

*my partner is a jealous type

He will sit there sulking*

It doesn't really matter what he is objecting to. Just don't waste your life with anyone who cannot 'use their words' to express their dissatisfaction and thinks sulking will achieve their ends.

You are actually even asking yourself whether you should change in response.

Just don't. Throw him overboard.

Find someone mature enough to discuss any issues that arise between you without resorting to toddler sulking behaviours. Good luck

catsnhats11 · 28/05/2023 09:29

You're mum sounds very dependent and maybe there is codependency going on. Several phone calls a day? A phone call and text every night before bed? Wayyy to much and I say this as someone who was very close to my mum and spoke to her on the phone (once) nearly every day.

If you read back your posts but swapped "mum" for "DH" and vice versa, people would be screaming abuse, control and red flags!

You admit you prefer your mums company to your DH. I think you need to make a choice before your DH makes it for you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread