Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To change my mind about giving free

92 replies

StarDolphins · 27/05/2023 13:19

I know I’m morally going to hell for this.

I’ve made a huge mistake advertising my sofa for free. My new sofa is arriving tomorrow & I panicked because i thought no one would have it as it’s got a broken cushion & cat scratches.

I gave it to this first person that asked even though he had no manners & he’s collecting tomorrow.

I’ve since had 47 messages,one very nice & polite offering £200. I don’t need the money but it’s a great sofa really & I would donate the money to a charity that I know is struggling.

Am I bring unreasonable to give it to the nice woman offering to pay? I know I probably am & I will get flamed!

OP posts:
Irritateandunreasonable · 27/05/2023 17:49

I thought YBU giving it to the woman who could pay - I’d much rather give it to someone who couldn’t afford it (if I could afford to do that).

There’s literally no way in hell I’d be giving a FREE sofa to someone who can’t say please and thank you. Ungrateful little sod.

CadburyDream · 27/05/2023 17:45

Well apparently the op knows her sons so couldn't possibly be dodgy 😏

Thesunnymood · 27/05/2023 17:44

HarrietJet · 27/05/2023 17:41

Nobody offers to pay £200 for an item offered free, op, seriously...

The "courier will give you the money" crowd do...

HarrietJet · 27/05/2023 17:41

StarDolphins · 27/05/2023 13:19

I know I’m morally going to hell for this.

I’ve made a huge mistake advertising my sofa for free. My new sofa is arriving tomorrow & I panicked because i thought no one would have it as it’s got a broken cushion & cat scratches.

I gave it to this first person that asked even though he had no manners & he’s collecting tomorrow.

I’ve since had 47 messages,one very nice & polite offering £200. I don’t need the money but it’s a great sofa really & I would donate the money to a charity that I know is struggling.

Am I bring unreasonable to give it to the nice woman offering to pay? I know I probably am & I will get flamed!

Nobody offers to pay £200 for an item offered free, op, seriously...

Wexone · 27/05/2023 17:23

I recently sold a sofa on fb marketplace it was a huge old thing and sold it cheap to get rid off. the person messaging me was very short and abrut in his messages so was thinking same as you. however when he turned up he was a lovely polite man. English wasn't his 1st language and he didn't have much English either. he was delighted as juts bought he 1st home and couldn't afford much furniture etc. so i wouldn't judge by your 1st interactions. you siad you would give it to him he was 1st let it go

Nameinspirationneeded · 27/05/2023 17:12

You know nothing about the man’s circumstances whether he is more or less worthy or what he will do with the sofa. You obviously didn’t think he was too rude when you made the agreement so let him have it.

Thisisabsolutelyfine · 27/05/2023 17:02

Personally I’d give to the single mum, £200 is probably one of those who’ll disappear when you call her bluff. Tell the guy unfortunately it’s no longer available (unless he has booked transport)

mcmooberry · 27/05/2023 16:59

I would message him tomorrow saying the new sofa is damaged /sent the wrong colour and you have had to refuse it or today saying the company is unable to fulfil your order for some reason. I also have a policy of not selling to rude people who don't even say please. I would then give it to the person who really needs a free sofa.

Blackmetalmama · 27/05/2023 16:59

I don't think you should give it to the rude man at all. You panicked and he has your address, but what will he do? Turn up and deamand a sofa? Just tell him the sofa is going to a family member in need and sorry for the trouble. If he contacted you through facebook can you see his contact list? If so, it's not like doing business through gumtree so i would be less worried about that but totally resent giving it to a rude man over a friend or polite mum.

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 27/05/2023 16:52

The man doesn’t have to have nice manners just as you didn’t have to give it for free. Just let him take it and be glad it’s gone quickly and easily

Curlyfluff · 27/05/2023 16:49

Curlyfluff · 27/05/2023 16:49

I did this with a.tv. I then realised that the rude person I'd agreed to give it to for free, would most likely sell it.
So I said I'd dropped it.
I would just say ooh sorry, my account really wants it, family, you know?

And then either sell it ELSEWHERE or give it away to someone you deem deserving!

My aunt, not account

Curlyfluff · 27/05/2023 16:49

I did this with a.tv. I then realised that the rude person I'd agreed to give it to for free, would most likely sell it.
So I said I'd dropped it.
I would just say ooh sorry, my account really wants it, family, you know?

And then either sell it ELSEWHERE or give it away to someone you deem deserving!

Beautiful3 · 27/05/2023 16:42

Honestly, I'd get rid of it.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 27/05/2023 16:19

Honestly, if someone turns up to collect the old one for free, the day before your new one arrives, you are quids in.

Redebs · 27/05/2023 16:11

Well this is all hypothetical at the moment. You might get a no show. Have you given him a time by which to collect? Message and see if he can come before midday, because you have others interested and will keep it til then.

If he doesn't collect by 1pm, then contact the £200 lady.

The £200 lady could also be a no show, so be prepared. It's very unlikely anyone would pay that for a sofa with damage.

I had some furniture to give away last year and it was an interesting experience. Some people turn up promptly and are really grateful. Some keep making promises to turn up and never do.

At the end, it's just a relief to have things gone to people who will use them and not to have to spend a whole day roasting in a queue at the tip in a hired van.

threelionsonashirt · 27/05/2023 16:04

StarDolphins · 27/05/2023 13:22

Yes I have! I don’t want a brick though my window.

I'd let him have it then.

aSofaNearYou · 27/05/2023 15:57

Tbh I'd be more inclined to sack him off if you actually did need the money, but I'm not sure I see wanting that woman's £200 so you can give it to charity as a particularly positive thing. It's not like you're taking that money from a big corporation and putting it somewhere better, you'd be taking it from an individual that could probably do with keeping it but needs a sofa. If she had a lot of money to spare she probably wouldn't be getting a £200 one from Facebook.

I get the wishing you'd given it to someone that wasn't rude thing, but I'd just leave things as they are as you're in too deep, I'm sure the nice people will find a different sofa.

Peachy2005 · 27/05/2023 15:35

Anyone who replies could be a scammer or a timewaster. If the first guy does turn up, hurray! At least you have backup options if he doesn’t. Just make sure someone is there with you when he’s due round…you do hear unpleasant stories…

Teapleasebobb · 27/05/2023 15:26

Make sure he collects AFTER your new sofa arrives (especially if it's Sofology!) We ordered 3 new sofas a few years ago and on the day they were supposed to arrive, we get a call saying one of the sofas is broken and can they deliver just one, I said no (good job I did as the other would have taken another 17 week to arrive). Luckily we hadn't got rid of the old sofas.
Don't get rid of the old one until you are completely happy with your new one or you may end up without any!

Unicorntastic · 27/05/2023 15:24

.I never give the rude ones anything, just message him and say it’s not available anymore then don’t engage with him, or say the new one is delayed in case the lady who’s offering £200 doesn’t turn up. It must be worth something of people are getting excited about it,

AlwaysGinPlease · 27/05/2023 15:21

Message him and say that the new sofa you're expecting is delayed due to whatever reason so unfortunately he cannot collect it.

inappropriateraspberry · 27/05/2023 15:16

What's wrong? First come, first served. You can't keep everyone on hold hoping a better offer comes along.
You need it gone asap, so he gets it. He might turn out to be really grateful in person, some people don't come across well in messages, and/or can't write very well.
If he lets you down, offer it to the next person. You offered for free, you can't then take money for it.

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 27/05/2023 15:07

You're seriously overthinking this.

You wanted the sofa gone and the man has offered to take it off your hands - surely that's the end of it?

You also don't know if the single mum is anymore in need than the man who just happened to "get in" first.

Wendysfriend · 27/05/2023 15:03

The man might turn out to be nice. He may not use/type please and thank you until he sees you in person.

I wouldn't be giving much head space to anyone with a bit of a story. I often see posts from a woman near by who puts on the poor mouth and comes across online as mother Theresa and I can tell you she's far from any of those things.

I think I'd just be greatful at having it removed and not having to go down the route of disposing it myself .

Enjoy your new sofa

WeDoNotTalktoPennilynLott · 27/05/2023 14:58

I asked if anybody wanted one of those three pot slow cookers, a man said he would have it, after that my friend said she would have liked it. Man said, after handover, "To be honest I'll probably never use it, I just like free stuff" honestly fumed for ages

Swipe left for the next trending thread