Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband won’t share child care

238 replies

Annaliese2015 · 27/05/2023 12:15

Can anyone please tell me if I’m being unreasonable?
my husband and I both work, he works full time and I have just taken on a second job so I also now work full time (2 separate jobs). I worked part time to fit around child care but now my son can go to after school club I am able to work more hours.

my husband earns more than I do which I fully appreciate however he is treating me getting a second job as a treat for me and refuses to take any time off during half terms to look after our son as he sees my jobs as inferior to his.

This is the text message I received from him when I asked him to take a day off to look after our son so I can work:

”I’ve always worked full time you have always worked part time now you want to work extra hours every one else has to change around you I’m not using all my holiday just so you can work that not fair”

I need some neutral perspective on this, am I in the wrong here? if not how do I get him to share time off.
for the 6 weeks holiday I have booked off 2 weeks (max I can take during half terms) but he refuses to use his holiday so I can go to work and book time off.

Does anyone have any advice on this please?

OP posts:
raincamepouringdown · 27/05/2023 16:22

You're in a financially abusive relationship.

You are earning LESS money and paying MORE THAN HALF of everything because childcare is coming out of your salary, as well as half of the bills.

Shocking treatment.

You need to get a shit hot divorce lawyer and tell him to get to fuck with his selfish attitude.

SpringGreensPreens · 27/05/2023 16:21

You’re definitely not being unreasonable but I’ve no idea how you get him to see this as he sounds like a dickhead

Hairpinleg · 27/05/2023 16:16

Is there a reason you pay 100% of the childcare? Was it your idea to have a child and he's pretending that makes it your responsibility to organise and pay for childcare? I can't see why else he would claim a joint child is not a shared job.

Zanatdy · 27/05/2023 16:14

I’d ask him why childcare falls to you? Sorry but that’s what parents do, use their childcare to care for children. What does he think you use yours for? No way could I be with someone like that

WimbyAce · 27/05/2023 16:06

He sounds awful and I'm not sure you will get him to change his mindset. As an example of what a decent father is, my partner just decided to take Tuesday off so he could take eldest to cinema. We have childcare in place for half term so he doesn't need to, he is doing it because he wants to spend time with his children.

Morred · 27/05/2023 16:05

You need to explain to him that you can either split “breadwinning” and “childcare” so one person does one and one person does the other, or you can share them so you each do some of each. Anything other than that is completely unfair. And make sure that “breadwinning” includes paying into pensions for both partners, etc.

You probably won’t persuade him. He clearly doesn’t like you or his son so I’d get rid.

Stillcountingbeans · 27/05/2023 16:03

I need advice on how to make him understand that he is an equal parent and I should be able to equally share time off

You are wanting the impossible.
He will never, ever, ever see that he is an equal parent, because he thinks the child-stuff is 'women's work' and solely your responsibility. As if having a baby was an expensive hobby you chose that only you should pay for.

You will never change him. Put up with him or divorce him.

And btw, you pay 50% of all bills, and 100% of childcare, despite earning less than him, so he is able save money and put it away somewhere, and he wanted you to earn more but is not willing to make any changes to his life - you ARE being financially abused.

HermioneKipper · 27/05/2023 15:58

What an arsehole. Divorce him and see how he likes shared custody.

These men are useless.

He sounds financially abusive as well

CrazyHedgehogLover · 27/05/2023 15:47

I am extremely sorry you find yourself in this position OP! I have read your first update (sorry if I’ve missed anything since) about you losing your mum etc I’m so sorry to hear this! He should be helping you and supporting you by helping look after the child he has created also! I find this absolutely disgusting…

he shouldn’t of been at you to work more! You was already doing enough especially if he has the attitude of “I won’t use my holidays it’s not fair”

I’ve been in your position with my ex I was the one paying for all the childcare for our son, when he was picking up from nursery he wasn’t paying, I’d pick up the next time and be lumbered with a bill for the end of the week! Stupidly I paid it all and it then made my position of going to work pointless because I was the one paying everything, turns out he was saving massive amounts in his bank account paying for nothing, I had been paying for the bills, childcare his excuse was he paid for “food” which was barely anything considering there was only 3 of us! Even then id be topping it up!

your husband sounds like a cock and your deserve better, after not long losing your mum who was clearly a massive support network for you he should be fairer and not so pushy about the second job he should be alot More understanding!!

I would honestly have a chat with him and tell him how serious this is, he either man’s up and accepts this is his child aswell and needs to book holidays off to help cover, if you feel this second job is too much strain please be honest and tell him you don’t feel like you can do it all! Potentially you could make cutbacks instead or he has the option of a divorce and as others have said he will then need to book time off in order to see his child and he’ll also have the duty to pay you maintenance 😊! Don’t beat around the bush with him, three options there and his answer will speak volumes to you.

just to add well done and your doing incredibly well! ❤️

alargeoneforme · 27/05/2023 15:44

Sorry OP, agree with PP. You can't make him be fair about this because he just doesn't want to be. It's not that he doesn't see it, he sees it and he likes it this way. The reason people keep bringing up the money, and how you earn less but pay for more, even though you think it's not part of the discussion, is because it's a very clear sign of how little respect he has for you and how selfish he is. Do you think he hasn't done the sums on it? And in the same way, do you think he hasn't worked out how lucky he is not to have to worry about childcare - he doesn't want his cosy little set-up to be disrupted, thanks very much.

arethereanyleftatall · 27/05/2023 15:37

Op - you keep falling back to 'but should I do more because he earns more?' But...neither you, nor your son, see any of that do you?!? You have told us you pay MORE than half of all the joint bills, so what difference does it make that he EARNS more?!? He's not sharing it!

Istolethecookies · 27/05/2023 15:34

You pay more than 50% of the costs though. because you pay for all the childcare. Even still, I work part-time and my partner full-time, but we both equally use our annual leave to take care of the kids during school holidays. We also don’t split bills 50/50, we split it proportionally based on our different incomes. Your DH is being very unreasonable!

BruceAndNosh · 27/05/2023 15:31

missingthewinchesterboys · 27/05/2023 12:20

Yeah I'd tell him that if he doesn't adjust his attitude, man up and take his turn looking after the kids, he'll have no choice but to use his holiday for childcare when you divorce and give him 50/50 custody

A bloke who doesn't do childcare within a marriage is very unlikely to be keen to do more once he's divorced and single.
She might "give" him 50/50 but doesn't mean he'll take it

Thomasthe · 27/05/2023 15:30

So let me get this straight. You’ve to contribute half financially, but childcare is solely your responsibility? That’s not fair. He wants to have his cake and eat it too. Is he this selfish in all aspects? I’d seriously consider divorce- you’re not a partnership. I dare say you being around all the time to care for your child has enabled him to earn a higher salary. What a walloper.

arethereanyleftatall · 27/05/2023 15:30

'I need advice on how to make him understand that he is an equal parent'

As you've just written this, I think you haven't understood what everyone has been trying to tell you and why everyone is saying divorce.
There is no advice available in this situation.
Your husband has been brought up probably from day 1 as a misogynist. He is inherently selfish and financially abusive. He always will be.
You have been brought up to put everyone's needs before your own.
There is no advice that will change this.
Sorry op.

He obviously knows full well that he's taking advantage of you. And he can't care less

planningnightmare · 27/05/2023 15:29

@Annaliese2015 a pp sums it up perfectly:

You don't pay half of everything. You pay half of everything plus 100% of the childcare bill. Your husband is acting like he doesn't have a child. He doesn't pay for the child or its costs. I bet you pay for uniforms, shoes , clothing etc. He is acting like the child isn't his responsibility. He is taking the piss financially, emotionally and physically. The distribution of labour is all off. I'd LTB at least you'd get child support and he'd have to parent during his contact time if he chooses to have contact.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 27/05/2023 15:26

@Annaliese2015 you are definitely not remotely in anyway being unreasonable and tbh it’s worrying that you think you might be and can’t see how utterly selfish and unreasonable your ‘D’ H is being

Goldbar · 27/05/2023 15:24

Annaliese2015 · 27/05/2023 15:06

I work as a midwife for 23.5 hours and the second job which is 20 hours is totally fine during term time.
he seems to want me to work more but doesn’t want to help me to do this……it’s not even helping me, it’s helping us as a family to have a more comfortable life and be able to afford family days out and holidays.
I didn’t intend the post to be about money, that’s not the issue, I pay half of everything.
I need advice on how to make him understand that he is an equal parent and I should be able to equally share time off with him so it’s not always my responsibility. Or am I being unreasonable to expect this regardless of who earns more? he still gets paid holiday pay if he takes a day off so there is no loss of earnings.
we didn’t ever have a conversation about childcare before we had our son as I never even thought it would be an issue to both be a parent and meet our child’s needs equally.
I’m not asking him to provide child care so I can go out socially, I want to work and be a reliable employee rather than always have to be the one to call my work to say “I have no child care”

What you're asking is for him to be a reasonable human being.

He either is or he isn't, sorry.

Peachy2005 · 27/05/2023 15:23

So sorry about the loss of your mum OP.

I just find this whole thing mystifying. It doesn’t seem like a partnership at all! He earns more so should be contributing more percentage-wise. No matter how many times you repeat that you don’t mind paying for all the childcare and 50% of everything else, we’re going to keep replying that it’s not reasonable. Since you are accepting the complete inequity regarding your finances, why would you think he’s going to suddenly start to be fair and reasonable about the childcare issue?

Perhaps the second job was manageable without extra input from your DH when your mum was available to help out at times but that’s not the case anymore…he should at least be able to recognise that much.

The whole thing is baffling!

ChristmasFluff · 27/05/2023 15:21

OP you are ignoring the fact that you are married to an arse. I agree with everyone else - getting divorced is your best option, and you could probably do with getting some counselling to look into why you are so resistant to this.

And also why you are so needing to justify yourself to him. That reeks of him being controlling and you not seeing it.

skyeisthelimit · 27/05/2023 15:21

When he told you that you needed to work more hours, then he should have discussed childcare and holidays at the same time. Also, you shouldn't be paying 50% of everything.

He must have a lot more disposable income than you, which could pay towards childcare!

You need to sit down with him and look at all finances and childcare costs, then pay into the pot in the ratio of who earns what.

This will only get worse not better.

Some men are selfish though. When XH first left and DD was only 4, I asked him to have DD during the holidays and he refused because he had to work.

The fact that I also had to work, and this was his shared child, and a shared responsibility did not come into the equation. His needs were greater than mine.

BibbleandSqwauk · 27/05/2023 15:20

Have you say down with him, across a table with diagram of yours and his hours, the childcare needed and the income split? If you earn less but pay more of the family expenses (which youn do because you pay for the childcare) then I'd genuinely love to know on what basis it is "unfair" of you to ask him to do (not help, do) at least a portion of the childcare in holidays. Honestly, v simple, factual discussion and leave the silence for him to answer why, if he wants you to work more he thinks that it is fair for you to take all of the holiday hit. Is be suggesting that if he can't or won't cover half the holidays then he covers the holiday club fees for 3 weeks of the 6.

Hellno45 · 27/05/2023 15:15

Annaliese2015 · 27/05/2023 15:06

I work as a midwife for 23.5 hours and the second job which is 20 hours is totally fine during term time.
he seems to want me to work more but doesn’t want to help me to do this……it’s not even helping me, it’s helping us as a family to have a more comfortable life and be able to afford family days out and holidays.
I didn’t intend the post to be about money, that’s not the issue, I pay half of everything.
I need advice on how to make him understand that he is an equal parent and I should be able to equally share time off with him so it’s not always my responsibility. Or am I being unreasonable to expect this regardless of who earns more? he still gets paid holiday pay if he takes a day off so there is no loss of earnings.
we didn’t ever have a conversation about childcare before we had our son as I never even thought it would be an issue to both be a parent and meet our child’s needs equally.
I’m not asking him to provide child care so I can go out socially, I want to work and be a reliable employee rather than always have to be the one to call my work to say “I have no child care”

You don't pay half of everything. You pay half of everything plus 100% of the childcare bill. Your husband is acting like he doesn't have a child. He doesn't pay for the child or its costs. I bet you pay for uniforms, shoes , clothing etc. He is acting like the child isn't his responsibility. He is taking the piss financially, emotionally and physically. The distribution of labour is all off. I'd LTB at least you'd get child support and he'd have to parent during his contact time if he chooses to have contact.

SnoringPains · 27/05/2023 15:11

Annaliese2015 · 27/05/2023 12:54

One minute he’s telling me I need to work full time, so I got a second job and now I’m being selfish expecting him to take days of his holiday to help me.
the second job fits in well (term time) but child care is harder during holidays.
I love my new job and I don’t want to give it up as the team are lovely and it gets me out of the house.
I am paying all of the after school club fees so I don’t see how I can win in this situation?
I don’t want to come across that our son is a burden because obviously he’s not at all but I really don’t know why all of the child care falls on me to arrange? 🤦🏼‍♀️

Your son isn’t a burden, your husband is though. He sounds like a twat and I would have no respect for him as a husband or father, remember your relationship is teaching your son how men treat women. I’d divorce him, take half the assets and child maintenance and have a nicer life.