Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schoo trip first come first served

157 replies

Meetingonthehill · 26/05/2023 21:45

AIBU to think school could and should have managed this better?

Son is Year 9.

Today school informed the children that there is an enrichment trip to a theme park. The letter would be sent to parents at 3.30pm and the payment portal opened at the same time. Kids advised it was first come first served.

This particular enrichment activity was open to Year 9 (this is their only offering for this year group) and also open to Year 8 (who have the choice of two theme parks).

(Year 9 have had no enrichment trips prior to this - Covid meant the Year 7 residential wasn’t offered and nothing was offered last year when they were in Year 8.)

My son tried to call me at 3.20 as he came out of school but I was at work (no phones allowed). I did finish work at 3.55 so called him back when he told me about the letter and trip.

I logged on to the portal straight away but all the places had gone.

AIBU to think that if offering something on a first for first served basis they should give people a bit more notice than 10 minutes? (The time between when the kids can use their phone after school and the time the portal opened.)

Surely only the parents who don’t work/have desk based jobs can realistically book something with that tight a turn around?

Not to mention those who may just be able to afford it but might need a little bit of time to balance the books to make sure.

Of course, it’s half term next week so nothing can be done and probably won’t be.

I realise they are lucky to have staff that can put on trips but it seems really unfair to split this opportunity across two year groups and not give everyone a fair chance at taking them up on the offer (especially as they haven’t had any other trips before). I realise they may not have the staff to cover everyone going. But why not make the booking process fairer?

OP posts:
Guiltridden12345 · 26/05/2023 22:27

Guiltridden12345 · 26/05/2023 22:25

Although I’m pretty sure this isn’t the aim, I agree that it’s probably the unfortunate effect.

I think a theme park COULD be a good enrichment activity - just a bloody fun day out with Adrenalin pumping and everyone in high spirits - but I do think it’s a cost which puts it out of many families’ league.

Sorry this was in relation to @GeekyThings and the haves just having more.

SchoolShenanigans · 26/05/2023 22:25

I would complain to the school, that's really unfair, especially as they've already missed out in previous years. Poor effort.

Guiltridden12345 · 26/05/2023 22:25

Although I’m pretty sure this isn’t the aim, I agree that it’s probably the unfortunate effect.

I think a theme park COULD be a good enrichment activity - just a bloody fun day out with Adrenalin pumping and everyone in high spirits - but I do think it’s a cost which puts it out of many families’ league.

QueSyrahSyrah · 26/05/2023 22:25

LividHouse · 26/05/2023 21:56

@GeekyThings but how? You can’t POSSIBLY offer every trip to several hundred kids, without knocking how many coaches you’d need or how much it’d cost, or how many staff would be needed.

What you’re saying sounds great but IN REALITY means you think they should never offer a trip at all.

Of course you can, if you have the staffing to make it possible (I don't know what the required ratio is for year 9).

You get quotes from coach companies based on a few different scenarios of possible numbers, base the trip cost on the worst case scenario, and then confirm the amount needed after the booking deadline. If the transport cost pp comes down as numbers go up then you either pass on the reduction to parents or the excess goes in the school funds.

My school used to take almost all of us to a theme park at once every 2 years. Nearly 1200 of us on a fleet of coaches.

Yellowrosesmakemehappy · 26/05/2023 22:24

LividHouse · 26/05/2023 21:54

You CANNOT understand the levels of stress and hours of work that go into planning even the smallest of trips nowadays.

And you CANNOT make it fair for everyone, because by definition giving you a place would mean denying someone else a place.

I ran a trip two years ago where an arsey email from a parent about something similar, when I was genuinely on my arse with logistics and paperwork and competing demands sent me over the edge and I haven’t run the trip this year because I just can’t face this sort of stuff.

You really, truly can’t please everybody and they will have had a list of reasons as long as your arm about why it had to happen this way.

That still doesn’t make it fair though? I can whinge about my job and the process and how complex it is but the customers won’t care if it’s not fair, they’ll be annoyed at me?
Pupils and parents are the customers of schools.

GeekyThings · 26/05/2023 22:20

LividHouse · 26/05/2023 21:56

@GeekyThings but how? You can’t POSSIBLY offer every trip to several hundred kids, without knocking how many coaches you’d need or how much it’d cost, or how many staff would be needed.

What you’re saying sounds great but IN REALITY means you think they should never offer a trip at all.

No it doesn't. He's at a primary school, which, on the whole, aren't that big; it's also not every year group, and trips don't have to be, meaning the number is reduced hugely. I doubt it even hits 40 kids, let alone hundreds!

I remember as a kid growing up most school trips were local and for the day. I can't ever remember going to a theme park with a school, what learning is that giving you? We'd go look at a printing press in a museum, or have a ride on a canal boat - school trips now are ridiculous. They're just another way of giving the haves that little bit extra on top, which quite honestly they don't really need, they already have it home.

They should prioritise the kids who don't have access to anything, and you don't do that by making it expensive and difficult to book unless you don't work.

LoveBluey · 26/05/2023 22:18

Completely unfair way to manage it. Anything like this that is first come first served we get notification in advance with details of when the booking system will open and for school trips we always get at least one months notice - normally more and the option to pay in instalments.

Ghastisflabbered · 26/05/2023 22:18

Guiltridden12345 · 26/05/2023 22:08

Lottery is inherently more fair than first come first served and no more difficult to administer. Why wouldn’t schools do that?

People still moan when a lottery is drawn though.

If you have to do a lottery you have to give everyone time to sign up, then deal with the people who “forgot” the deadline and ask to be included after the deadline.

Then you have to randomise your results so you can pick who is going. Then you have to tell the lucky people they’ve got a spot and after that you have to tell everyone who didn’t get a spot that they’ve not been successful - followed by at least a weeks worth of bitching and moaning that their child deserves a space more/would gain more from the opportunity/ poor Fenella has never been away before/I thought we were signing up to go not to express interest so I’ve already bought a full wardrobe of camping gear.

If it’s first come first served then it’s really bloody clear to everyone from the start.

Pottedpalm · 26/05/2023 22:14

I’m wondering how a trip to a theme park can be described as enrichment.

GloryBees · 26/05/2023 22:13

I’m struggling to see how enrichment is a theme park visit (misses point of thread). Regardless it’s a completely unfair system, lottery much fairer if it’s over subscribed. Totally ridiculous.

Guiltridden12345 · 26/05/2023 22:08

Lottery is inherently more fair than first come first served and no more difficult to administer. Why wouldn’t schools do that?

parietal · 26/05/2023 22:08

My kid's school does a lottery for oversubscribed trips. Much fairer.

Also, a cheap local trip with space for everyone is much better than a theme park for 50%

clary · 26/05/2023 22:07

Yes OP I agree - we used to do first come first served - crucially after a certain point - so the letter would go out on Wednesday and we would say "you can book from Saturday morning" and there are xx places. Seemed more fair tbh and gave ppl a chance to make sure they had the money.

Stabee · 26/05/2023 22:07

We had a similar situation once. A load of DC signed up without checking at home if they could make the date. Then dropped out so loads of places went unfilled, with a number of DC were told no places left so turned away. All very bizarre. Empty coaches and disappointed DC.

Guiltridden12345 · 26/05/2023 22:04

I empathise with both sides. But I do see how people who work full time/entire working days miss out on parents eve slots, trip windows etc because they tend to go live during normal office hours. I think to make it more fair, for more people, schools could give at least 24 hrs notice so that working parents can get someone else to help them out with booking on if they wish.

Im not full time. I can have my phone on me at all times. I (and my kids) definitely get the edge over other working parents so I get why people feel aggrieved.

life isn’t fair though. when I was in yr 8, there were two trips - one was a week long camp and the other a few days in France. Each was express your interest then a lucky dip. That seems more fair? However, in my case I got neither when several other kids got to go on both. That really didn’t seem right!

openstop · 26/05/2023 22:03

Muchtoomuchtodo · 26/05/2023 22:02

@Meetingonthehill I can appreciate that there needs to be a limit on numbers for planning purposes. Our school is far from perfect but we get told what day and time trips with limited numbers will be opened for payment via parentpay.

This is usually a random evening about a week after we’re notified, at about 7pm when I assume the majority of kids who want to go will have had chance to inform their parents/guardians and who will have a responsible adult at home who could make the payment.

there will never be a one size fits all solution but this feels reasonable. The approach that your ds’s school took doesn’t.

That sounds much better a week gives people time to think if they can afford it

Bobbybobbins · 26/05/2023 22:03

Random draw would be better but I don't think I would complain over it tbh.

openstop · 26/05/2023 22:02

And yeah the kids who haven't been on a trip should get first dibs on this trip. COVID has decimated their education

Muchtoomuchtodo · 26/05/2023 22:02

@Meetingonthehill I can appreciate that there needs to be a limit on numbers for planning purposes. Our school is far from perfect but we get told what day and time trips with limited numbers will be opened for payment via parentpay.

This is usually a random evening about a week after we’re notified, at about 7pm when I assume the majority of kids who want to go will have had chance to inform their parents/guardians and who will have a responsible adult at home who could make the payment.

there will never be a one size fits all solution but this feels reasonable. The approach that your ds’s school took doesn’t.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/05/2023 22:01

Awful way of doing things. If it’s going to go live at a certain time, and be first come first served, parents need to have notice of when that time will be. And it should be outside of usual working hours.

EmeraldFox · 26/05/2023 22:01

I think 6pm with a day's notice would have been fairer.

openstop · 26/05/2023 22:01

LividHouse · 26/05/2023 21:54

You CANNOT understand the levels of stress and hours of work that go into planning even the smallest of trips nowadays.

And you CANNOT make it fair for everyone, because by definition giving you a place would mean denying someone else a place.

I ran a trip two years ago where an arsey email from a parent about something similar, when I was genuinely on my arse with logistics and paperwork and competing demands sent me over the edge and I haven’t run the trip this year because I just can’t face this sort of stuff.

You really, truly can’t please everybody and they will have had a list of reasons as long as your arm about why it had to happen this way.

You can make it fairer by giving everyone a shot and not releasing the slots during the core 9-5 working day!!!

TomatoSandwiches · 26/05/2023 22:01

Normally I would disagree with you op, you can't please everyone..
However since your sons year group has not had any enrichment trips since he started because of Covid then yr9 should be prioritised over yr8.

Perhaps you can ask for your DS to be first refusal for any cancellations on the day and set some money aside?

It is shit though.

LividHouse · 26/05/2023 22:00

mycoffeecup · 26/05/2023 21:58

Easy. Anyone who wants to go signs up before a certain time, if demand outstrips supply, those who didn't get to go on the last trip get priority then names out of a hat.

I mean, that’s basically what happened in the OP? Demand outstripped supply.

And you’ll still have someone’s mum phoning up to say Jimmy was off school on sign up day so it wasn’t fair that he couldn’t go on the list.

Overthebow · 26/05/2023 21:59

Yes awful way of doing it. So unfair to those with working parents. Names out of a hat is much fairer if they can’t take everyone.