Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schoo trip first come first served

157 replies

Meetingonthehill · 26/05/2023 21:45

AIBU to think school could and should have managed this better?

Son is Year 9.

Today school informed the children that there is an enrichment trip to a theme park. The letter would be sent to parents at 3.30pm and the payment portal opened at the same time. Kids advised it was first come first served.

This particular enrichment activity was open to Year 9 (this is their only offering for this year group) and also open to Year 8 (who have the choice of two theme parks).

(Year 9 have had no enrichment trips prior to this - Covid meant the Year 7 residential wasn’t offered and nothing was offered last year when they were in Year 8.)

My son tried to call me at 3.20 as he came out of school but I was at work (no phones allowed). I did finish work at 3.55 so called him back when he told me about the letter and trip.

I logged on to the portal straight away but all the places had gone.

AIBU to think that if offering something on a first for first served basis they should give people a bit more notice than 10 minutes? (The time between when the kids can use their phone after school and the time the portal opened.)

Surely only the parents who don’t work/have desk based jobs can realistically book something with that tight a turn around?

Not to mention those who may just be able to afford it but might need a little bit of time to balance the books to make sure.

Of course, it’s half term next week so nothing can be done and probably won’t be.

I realise they are lucky to have staff that can put on trips but it seems really unfair to split this opportunity across two year groups and not give everyone a fair chance at taking them up on the offer (especially as they haven’t had any other trips before). I realise they may not have the staff to cover everyone going. But why not make the booking process fairer?

OP posts:
Meetingonthehill · 27/05/2023 10:14

Thank you all for your comments.

I’m reassured to hear I’m not being unreasonable in thinking it was a really poor way to allocate places.

Just to address a couple of points; it’s a 4 form entry so relatively small in terms of some senior schools - about 120 in the year group.

There are a couple of other days (on school site) planned - a sports day and an art day I think. Nothing more planned for off site.

There was no previous mention of this trip. I’ve asked a couple of other parents just to be sure and their children didn’t know anything until yesterday. No emails to parents until the one yesterday either.

And to the poster who thinks I can’t possibly envisage how tricky it is plan these things; whilst I’ve never planned a school trip I do plan events and trips for vulnerable adults. I agree these things are challenging especially within the public sector.

However part of the planning is how to allow users/carers to book. If I said to my service users “just in case they don’t see the email, you’ve got to let your carer know I’m opening the booking at 2pm and it’s first come first served”, I wouldn’t be doing my job very well at all.

Thanks all.

OP posts:
Changechangechanging · 27/05/2023 10:12

so those with parents working full time should not be disadvantaged compared to those who get picked up at 3

just to be pedantic, it’s more than possible to be in full time work and be able to pick your child up at 3

Paq · 27/05/2023 10:07

@Sailawaytocromer my teacher friend is just back from a school trip to London where some of the kids went on their first escalator. Climb down off your high horse and understand the (sad, unfair, unnecessary) realities of some children's lives.

QuillBill · 27/05/2023 10:05

I really don't think the school would like that

That wouldn't bother me, and I am a teacher.

The theme park will be open to countless members of the public.

My dc have been on the Alton Tower's attendance trip every year since year seven. The staff aren't going round with them. They take all their phone numbers and put them into the school mobile on the coach and tell them to stay in groups or however many it is.

worktired · 27/05/2023 09:53

First come first served is not fair.

I would like to see all kids be able to go on all trips (although I realise that's not easy.

At ours they ask for expressions of interest, then select children & contact parents for payment. Not sure how they choose, although they've said that they take into consideration the number of negative behaviour points when deciding (ie not wanting to reward poor behaviour).

Sailawaytocromer · 27/05/2023 09:46

@Paq I take your point. But if it’s a deprived school/area, giving children the chance to explore something more challenging than a theme park has many benefits. If my children were not able to experience many days out with me, would I rather the school took them to a theme park or to the Wonderlab at the science museum or for an immersive day at the Tate or for a day doing a hockey/tennis/cricket/athletics workshop…? I’d go for the non theme park option every time. I’m all for schools introducing children to cultural/sports/arts experiences outside their normal lives.

Newmumatlast · 27/05/2023 09:46

SunnySaturdayMorning · 27/05/2023 08:54

That’s good. Challenging behaviour should not be rewarded. Actions have consequences.

You do realise that challenging doesn't necessarily mean naughty/intentional? And if so, wow. Pleasant.

Newmumatlast · 27/05/2023 09:41

LividHouse · 26/05/2023 21:54

You CANNOT understand the levels of stress and hours of work that go into planning even the smallest of trips nowadays.

And you CANNOT make it fair for everyone, because by definition giving you a place would mean denying someone else a place.

I ran a trip two years ago where an arsey email from a parent about something similar, when I was genuinely on my arse with logistics and paperwork and competing demands sent me over the edge and I haven’t run the trip this year because I just can’t face this sort of stuff.

You really, truly can’t please everybody and they will have had a list of reasons as long as your arm about why it had to happen this way.

You can't possibly tell someone that they cannot understand the levels of stress and hours of work, when you've no idea what they do or their personal experiences.

You miss the point when you say that you can't make it fair for everyone giving the example of if OP gets a place then someone else doesn't. Fairness doesn't mean everyone getting a place. Fairness is making sure everyone has as fair possible an opportunity. Obviously there is only so much that can be done in that regard as you're right that you cannot please everyone. But it really wouldn't be hard work for the teacher/s who organised this to realise that a. Opening the portal at the time they did with limited spaces would prevent people with parents and work or who need to sort funds from partaking and b. It wouldn't take much extra work (if any extra work at all) to change the time the portal opens to, for example, the following day.

Saisong · 27/05/2023 09:41

Year groups at DCs school are 240 (8 classes) so no way every trip can be offered to all. The way they try and make it fair is everyone can register an interest (with estimate of costs), then a draw is made at a later date. If you are successful you have a couple of days to make the deposit or place is forfeit and given to next on waiting list. The next time a trip comes up for that year group places are first allocated to those who missed out on the previous trip before the draw/waiting list is done.

This seems to work mostly - though I can't say there aren't parent who complain. In our case one DC was fortunate enough to get a place on residential for one trip, before the details of the next trip were announced. They would far rather go on the second one, but are unlikely to get one (still a possibility in the draw, but unlikely). Giving up the place on the first (still a good trip) would not guarantee a place either. So we're just rolling with it - life is not entirely fair, a good lesson to learn now!

The school does do one whole year residential in Y8, for which they like full attendance and really big it up. It's just camping at an activity centre, and the year has to go in 2 groups over the week, getting 2 nights each half, with a crossover day in the middle. There is lots of support for everyone to attend, and it at least ensures almost everyone gets one residential with the school.

VegetablesFightingToReclaimTheAubergieneEmoji · 27/05/2023 09:40

My children’s school does the same. It also ridiculously expensive.
it is great to reward the good ones, it’s only rewarding if the parents have access to emails and have the funds

IhearyouClemFandango · 27/05/2023 09:34

mycoffeecup · 26/05/2023 21:58

Easy. Anyone who wants to go signs up before a certain time, if demand outstrips supply, those who didn't get to go on the last trip get priority then names out of a hat.

This. Many, many schools manage this. Anything else is just plain lazy tbh.

openstop · 27/05/2023 09:34

XelaM · 27/05/2023 09:26

An you not buy him a ticket to the same theme park gor the same day and just take him? Then he could meet his year group there. Is that an option?

I really don't think the school would like that

Newspeaker · 27/05/2023 09:33

For future - maybe write to the Headteacher suggesting an alternative and fairer approach? Get a look at their Inclusion Policy and see if you can find something useful there. All pupils should have equal opportunities, so those with parents working full time should not be disadvantaged compared to those who get picked up at 3.

LadyEloise1 · 27/05/2023 09:33

Dixiechickonhols · 26/05/2023 21:59

I think that’s poor. Lottery would be better. I’d feed back to school. It’s unfair like you say and not inclusive it’s a few days to pay day for some. Giving say a week then selecting at random from those would be better.

I agree.

BusyMum47 · 27/05/2023 09:30

Luzina · 26/05/2023 21:59

My stepdaughter’s school sent an email out saying there would be an enrichment trip with all the details etc. they had an expression of interest form that parents could fill in the following day from 6pm. They then confirmed she had a place a few days later and we paid. Seems a fairer system

Exactly the same at my son's school. They send the info out, give parents a date to register interest, then follow up with the date/time that the payment portal will open & warn parents if there may be a 'limited spaces' situation. This is usually over the space of a couple of weeks so everyone has plenty of time to sort themselves out. Occasionally children my son knows have been unlucky & not gotten a place on a trip but the school always works with a 'reserve' list right up until the day before.

XelaM · 27/05/2023 09:27

Sorry for the typos. It should say:

"Can you not buy him a ticket to the same theme park for the same day and just take him? Then he could meet his year group there. Is that an option?"

XelaM · 27/05/2023 09:26

An you not buy him a ticket to the same theme park gor the same day and just take him? Then he could meet his year group there. Is that an option?

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 27/05/2023 09:11

Un7breakable · 27/05/2023 08:31

Lotteries don't work as DC don't want to go without their friends.

I agree first come first served isn't good with little notice.

First come first served doesn't work for friendship groups either

HappyKoala56 · 27/05/2023 09:11

I think first come first serve is fine, but a few days notice and a start time that everyone can realistically make 6/7pm would be much better. Nothing will change for this trip, but maybe your feedback will help for next year

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 27/05/2023 09:09

Un7breakable · 27/05/2023 08:31

Lotteries don't work as DC don't want to go without their friends.

I agree first come first served isn't good with little notice.

Not insurmountable.

You could set it up so the kids enter on pairs so they always have one friend. Coach seats are in pairs so you don't want odd numbers.

Runningslow · 27/05/2023 09:09

Dixiechickonhols · 26/05/2023 21:59

I think that’s poor. Lottery would be better. I’d feed back to school. It’s unfair like you say and not inclusive it’s a few days to pay day for some. Giving say a week then selecting at random from those would be better.

The problem with a lottery is that a lot of kids would only want to go if their friends were going, which they wouldn’t know until after it had taken place

LlynTegid · 27/05/2023 09:07

It could be argued to be discrimination, however well intentioned. Those unable to take work calls are more likely to be in certain jobs.

A period of time (say 72 hours) to sign up as interested, names drawn out of a hat, then say a period to pay (say 24 hours) after which your place goes to someone else (from a reserve list).

Motherhubbardscupboard · 27/05/2023 09:05

They should have given more notice. Are you sure that was the first time they had mentioned it? I've had children at three different secondary schools and I've had alarms set to log on to the portal at a certain time to pay multiple times but always been given a few days notice. And I do agree it's unfair for parents who can't log in at that particular time because of work. I do recall one time when my child missed out, because similar situation to the OP, places had gone by the time my child was able to contact me, but it was slightly different in that they were a younger year group suddenly invited to take up spare places on an older year groups trip.

AlyssumandHelianthus · 27/05/2023 09:04

What a shame for your son. I think it's worth giving feedback but not in an arsey way. A lot of teachers are on their knees and I think you need to acknowledge that they are really trying their best. Enrichment trips are one of the most exhausting things to do with kids. It's early start, late finish, massive amount of responsibility - imagine being in charge of 100 teens in Thorpe park!!
A pps suggestion that those who didn't get to go have priority on the next trip seems like a fair & workable suggestion.

Headingforholidays · 27/05/2023 09:03

openstop · 27/05/2023 08:47

Yes and if it comes to it they do the same trip 2 days on a row with both halves the year group

But you generally find that not everyone wants to go (or can afford to go) on every trip. Some trips are suitable and can be organised for the whole year group, but not all are or need to be.

Swipe left for the next trending thread