Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD 3 doesn't want to eat anything other than what she wants

55 replies

applesandbananaa · 26/05/2023 18:54

She has huge tantrums otherwise. I find it really hard to deal with and I don't know what to do.

She won't touch any vegetables. It's touch and go if she'll touch even her favourite foods. Sometimes she just says ' yuck I don't like it'. I try to be cool about it at the time.

I try and ignore it as much as I can 'ok maybe you're not hungry now, we can try again later '..

Then later she'll just have toast or biscuits. It's very hard work and takes a lot of patience to even get her to eat anything.

Can anyone relate ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LightDrizzle · 10/10/2023 09:16

Her meals are put in front of her, you chat, you eat, beyond one gentle prompt you ignore her picking at her food and any moaning. Try really hard to sit down and eat with her and eat the same things. That way it’s a social thing and you are modelling and participating, not demanding and monitoring. After a fair time ask if she’s finished and clear away without any fuss or comment. Try to keep mealtimes chatty and positive and hide any anxiety you feel about her intake. If she says she’s hungry later offer carrots and hummus, full fat yoghurt, a banana, cheese or equivalent. Fruit is okay but I’d try to reduce her carb snacking habit ideally. If she doesn’t want it, no fuss, dinner/ lunch/breakfast will be along soon. Rinse and repeat. Out and about the odd ice cream or cake in a coffee shop as normal.

For a while it would be best not to have biscuits in the house as it’s not “fair” for her to see you having them. I love a biscuit but they have no nutritional value so I’d take them out of the picture to make it easier.

Lialii · 10/10/2023 08:56

My daughter was / is like this as well. Always extremely limited number of foods she would eat, and even those she would often refuse.

We ended up with a selection of easy to prepare and reasonably healthy foods that we always keep around and offer and she basically lived off of them for years. Fishfingers and peas or green beans, beans on toast, porridge with banana, oats yoghurt and maple syrup... Occasionally carrot or cucumber sticks or apple slices, sometimes toast and scrambled egg. Oh and huge amounts of cold milk.

It's been frustrating, especially when we were on holiday and not able to cook, we could never get her to eat anything healthy at all.

I have no advice to offer, other than to say that this summer, age 9.5, she has suddenly started eating a bunch of different things that she always claimed were yucky. Cocktail tomatoes for crying out loud! Still not super varied but SO much more than before.

So in our case the only thing that helped was waiting for her to get older.

shelbabab · 26/05/2023 22:49

Sounds similar to my 3 yr old. It's hard work! When she complains, I just tell her ok eat what u want, leave what u don't 🤷🏻‍♀️

She has asked for macaroni cheese just about everyday this week. On the day we did have that, she hardly touched it 🙈

Sometimes she will eat something other times she won't. She will often come and eat things from my plate despite it being the same as what's in hers. She keeps asking for us to feed her. I refuse, tell her she's a big girl so can do it herself, don't be so silly. She is getting better with eating (it was way worse about a year ago) but very slowly and we seem to go up and down with it.

She always enjoys breakfast. Sometimes has 2 breakfasts! Then very little for lunch more snack like things.

Dinner she might eat none, little or a decent amount. More often than not it's little.

She does complain sometimes that's she's hungry later on. More often at bedtime. I sometimes give her something else, porridge or some yoghurt and fruit. I try not to though.

Today she was trying to negotiate her treat for after dinner despite hardly touching her dinner. She's like just a half (little mini brownie). I said no u haven't ate ur dinner. She whines and this went in for ages. Sometimes she wld go bk and eat a bite then ask for a treat again. Told her if she ate half her dinner I'd give her half a treat 😂 in the end she got nothing.

Jk987 · 26/05/2023 22:05

mdinbc · 26/05/2023 19:07

Children also need to know that certain foods are treats and only given at snack times. We don't get chocolate or ice cream until after dinner is finished, etc.

As Sandylane says, offer a range of good food, but not endless replacements.

I thought it was a bad idea to call some foods 'treats'. Children naturally want things they can't have so it's best to treat all foods the same.

MargaretThursday · 26/05/2023 21:51

DD2 was like that.
I taught her the sign for chocolate at about 16 months and I think she consistently asked for chocolate at every meal for the next two years.
She ate very little. the only thing she ate consistently well was tinned sweetcorn, so that was what she was given if she hadn't eaten anything for a couple of days.
She's 19yo and eats reasonably well now.

What I did was:
Ignore all strops about what she wanted.
Put a plate of small portion in front of her.
Have lots of options on the plate. (so a plate might have, 3x ham sandwiches (about 2cm square), one piece of cucumber, one piece of carrot, half a tomato cut up, a piece of cheese.
If she eats all of one bit of food, offer more of that.
Don't make any comments on what hasn't been eaten.
If she refuses, let her get down, but put the plate somewhere where she can reach and let her come back to it.
Don't refuse a treat because she hasn't eaten her meal (but make sure it's not too close so she won't be hungry)

Bridgingthefeckingmassivegap · 26/05/2023 21:36

The insta pages feeding littles and kids eat in colour are really helpful for tips on this! She's 3 so it's totally normal, but there are ways to make it less stressful.

Hollyppp · 26/05/2023 21:35

towriteyoumustlive · 26/05/2023 21:21

Sounds like a normal 3 year old.

Stop giving her toast and biscuits! She has learned that refusing what's on offer gets her what she wants!

One of my twins used to do this. If he said no, I just said "OK, never mind" then ignored him.

If he wanted pudding he needed to try everything on the plate.

They're now 7 and eat most foods.

I'd just not make an issue out of it. Just put the food on a plate, usually with something they do like, and chat to them while you eat and ignore any mention of yuck. If they don't eat it, then say that's ok you can get down and go play... then leave their plate for later.

This happens in our house too.
i make food, if I get ‘I want chocolate’ I am not just going to get chocolate and let DS ignore his supper.

i say ‘you don’t have to eat it, it’s your choice’ and if he asks for something else I say you’re clearly not hungry and then ignore him. He always eats his food after 2-10 mins

Hollyppp · 26/05/2023 21:33

TomatoSandwiches · 26/05/2023 19:04

You can offer chocolate milk or chocolate porridge or chocolate spread on toast, doesn't need to be much but those options are healthier.

Remove chocolate bars or buttons from the house so they aren't available.

This

iLovee · 26/05/2023 21:32

bussteward · 26/05/2023 19:31

Oh, yes – we did a lot of floor picnics during this phase, and a tea called “platter” that we still have: stuff on a board, fruit, vegetables, cheese cubes, the actual thing you’d like her to eat, breadsticks. Sometimes she preferred to eat under the table being a cat; other times inside a large cardboard moving box (“my quiet box”). I just rolled with it and she got through the phase.

You sound like a really lovely mum ❤️

towriteyoumustlive · 26/05/2023 21:21

Sounds like a normal 3 year old.

Stop giving her toast and biscuits! She has learned that refusing what's on offer gets her what she wants!

One of my twins used to do this. If he said no, I just said "OK, never mind" then ignored him.

If he wanted pudding he needed to try everything on the plate.

They're now 7 and eat most foods.

I'd just not make an issue out of it. Just put the food on a plate, usually with something they do like, and chat to them while you eat and ignore any mention of yuck. If they don't eat it, then say that's ok you can get down and go play... then leave their plate for later.

SoftSheen · 26/05/2023 21:07

I wouldn't give her biscuits as a replacement for a proper meal, but e.g. wholegrain toast with peanut butter is fine, or oatcakes and cheese, or just a banana. Small children need a lot of carbohydrate foods for growth (and proportionately, a bit less protein than adults), just try to make them healthy ones.

A good trick is to offer salad vegetables before dinner e.g. cucumber, carrot and pepper sticks, perhaps with something to dip them in. More likely to be eaten when presented alone than when given alongside something else.

gigglie · 26/05/2023 20:56

have you tried watching supernanny episodes on YouTube about fussy eaters. She had some great tips.

takealettermsjones · 26/05/2023 20:18

I'm sure you've already thought of this stuff but just some things that helped with mine:

• Can you get her involved in cooking? My eldest will eat almost anything she's made herself. Control central 😆

• Can you try making the foods/veg etc into fun shapes (get some cutters from Amazon)?

• Can you talk about colours, maybe on a rota e.g. "today were going to have a green/yellow/red thing with dinner, what could we have?" And use that colour cup/plate, wear that colour top, whatever works or you have available!

I also make sure I do all my "teaching" about food not at mealtimes. So when playing with her kitchen/shopping till etc we will talk about the foods and what they do for our bodies etc, but not at the table. It seemed like too much pressure at that time. But sometimes at mealtimes she would repeat back to me things I'd told her when playing etc.

The only cajoling/reminding etc I do at mealtimes is "we won't be eating again today (or not until teatime etc) so you need to make sure your tummy is full. Are you sure you have eaten enough?"

Caveat that when ill, everything goes out the window and I will let her eat pretty much anything she likes so long as it's got calories in it!

vejazzlement · 26/05/2023 20:16

Mine were the same about eating more/better with extra people there. Funnily, my child who was the least fussy as a toddler is now the worst by miles, and she's 19. Confused

All you can do is hang in there, keep on eating with them - even if it's just the three of you - and chatting with them, don't focus on the food, but don't offer toast and biscuits later on. If you do want to offer something (because, let's face it, nobody wants a child to go to bed feeling hungry and miserable), then offer a drink of milk and relatively bland cereal before tooth-brushing.

I know it feels hard now, but it will pass.

applesandbananaa · 26/05/2023 20:08

vejazzlement · 26/05/2023 20:02

She just wants to do what she wants

That's because she's 3, OP.

Easier said than done, but just don't stress about it. It's easier if you all eat together, as it shows her that eating isn't just about food but about chatting (in an ideal world - our oh-so-perfect family meals frequently ended up with someone crying or flouncing, but you get the idea).

If someone doesn't eat something, it is no big deal. Just remove their plate along with everyone else's. Have fruit for pudding. If a child is hungry later, offer Weetabix or something.

One of mine in particular was a horrendous eater as a small child. He is now 22 and is the one who will eat absolutely anything, and in fact chooses the most unlikely things from a menu (so that I have to resist the temptation to say "are you sure? You know you don't like anything other than Marmite and Milky Ways").

She loves to eat when we are all together. She likes it when it's a big event. Rather than just DD, DD and I. Unfortunately, she only gets to eat with DH once a week. She loves it when all 4 of us eat together or when we have guests and it's even more people.

She'll actually eat then and even try new stuff.

But when it's just a usual day and it's just the three of us, she doesn't really want to eat. Sad

OP posts:
vejazzlement · 26/05/2023 20:02

She just wants to do what she wants

That's because she's 3, OP.

Easier said than done, but just don't stress about it. It's easier if you all eat together, as it shows her that eating isn't just about food but about chatting (in an ideal world - our oh-so-perfect family meals frequently ended up with someone crying or flouncing, but you get the idea).

If someone doesn't eat something, it is no big deal. Just remove their plate along with everyone else's. Have fruit for pudding. If a child is hungry later, offer Weetabix or something.

One of mine in particular was a horrendous eater as a small child. He is now 22 and is the one who will eat absolutely anything, and in fact chooses the most unlikely things from a menu (so that I have to resist the temptation to say "are you sure? You know you don't like anything other than Marmite and Milky Ways").

HappiDaze · 26/05/2023 19:41

My DS was really really fussy and it did my head in but my way worked

HappiDaze · 26/05/2023 19:40

I never praised DS either as it's just food

I never begged him or bribed him

I never told him off

Or told him other children were starving etc

Just silently put the food out then silently take it away and chat about anything but food

caringcarer · 26/05/2023 19:37

If toast and biscuits were not an option she'd eat her food eventually as she would be hungry. Don't make a rod for your own back OP. Offer the food the family is eating at each meal, your DC either eats it or leaves it but is not offered various other options like biscuits. Offer a healthy snack like fruit or carrot sticks and houmous or cheese and a cracker mid morning and mid afternoon. If sugary good is an option she will hold out for it.

HappiDaze · 26/05/2023 19:37

Oh yes never ever make a big deal out of it

If DS didn't eat it then I'd just remove the plate and say nothing at all about it

I'd ignore any protests and sometimes just put the plate in front of him and walk into another room for a while so he'd get used to dealing with food in a plate in his own way

georgarina · 26/05/2023 19:37

LividHouse · 26/05/2023 19:00

“Don’t want that. I want seee-reeee-yullll” is all I hear at dinner time 😳

Omg this is my life. Violent rocking in the high chair and wails of 'see-weee-ohhh'

Mirabai · 26/05/2023 19:36

QueefQueen80s · 26/05/2023 18:59

I never understand these battles with food. Just give them what they want to eat

Hence child obesity…

Outwiththenorm · 26/05/2023 19:35

Praise praise praise works with our one, even for the tiniest bite or lick. Well done for trying and ignore what they don’t touch! (This has backfired somewhat with his insistence that daddy ‘tries bananas’ - which he hates - and mummy ‘tries steak’ - I’m a vegetarian).

HappiDaze · 26/05/2023 19:35

DS hated food like lasagne or anything with a sauce at the time - still hates lasagne but will occasionally have Spag Bol but prefers rice so I just say he's having a mild chilli con carne whilst we eat Spag Bol Grin

VivaVivaa · 26/05/2023 19:35

I’ve found 3 generally much tougher than 2 so far. As a PP said, they want control and to exert their own will. They push the boundaries to test them. It’s probably not even about the food fundamentally, it’s about autonomy. DS has been a brilliant eater but recently he’s started refusing to come to the table even though he’s clearly hungry - just because it’s the opposite of what we want him to do.

I think all you can do is continue offering 3 meals a day and 2 small, healthy snacks at predictable times. Always offer something safe on the plate. Keep strong and don’t give into the whining or tantrums. Empathise that it’s difficult when we don’t get what we want but don’t translate that into biscuits on demand. And console yourself this won’t last forever!

Swipe left for the next trending thread