Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to upset DD by moving 20 miles away

136 replies

Scandimandy · 26/05/2023 15:51

We have just put our house on the market and being in our 50's and 60's my partner and I decided we would like to move to a more rural area and near the sea. We are both self employed so can effectively live anywhere. We have found the ideal village about 20 miles away from our current location but my adult DD who still lives with us (she is 23) is very upset for us contemplating moving this far away from our current house, I think mostly because all her friends are local. DD drives and works full time locally but is going to give up her job in November and go travelling for a year so she'd be looking for a new job when she arrived home anyway. Obviously she doesn't have to live with us, she is a grown up and could make her own way in the world. She doesn't earn loads but she has some inheritance money - she has enough for a deposit but doesn't earn enough to sustain a mortgage. Is she behaving selfishly and spoilt or are we being unreasonable for moving this far away from our current location? In one way I feel she shouldn't be living at home now at her age anyway - she has moved away for uni and then come back - but on the other hand I feel like we are forcing her out if she doesn't want to come with us. Have we raised an entitled brat?

OP posts:
gamerchick · 26/05/2023 16:58

Tell her she'll always have a bed if you and she wants but that it's time you move on to the next stage of your lives. Let her tantrum and carry on with your plans.

piedbeauty · 26/05/2023 16:56

You're moving 20 miles, not 2000. You're not being u.

Scandimandy · 26/05/2023 16:55

Very eloquently put @ditalini, thanks. Will have another chat with her this evening x

OP posts:
ditalini · 26/05/2023 16:48

I'd be a bit disappointed by my child if they sounded off like this about a move that they knew was on the cards when they're - quite rightly - making their own plans and moving on with their life themselves.

Having a good moan to her friends would be reasonable, but to you she should be putting on a brave face and helping you plan for the move and the next step in your life. Just like you would put on a brave face and wish her the best if she was moving away.

Op, it's not reasonable for you to put your life on hold indefinitely for your adult child when the inconvenience to them is really very minimal. You're not chucking her out or depriving her of a home.

Part of growing up is recognising that your parents live a life that's separate from you. It doesn't mean they don't love you or want the best for you, but that quite naturally your wants and needs will diverge. Loving and providing for your child wholeheartedly doesn't need to mean preserving their childhood room at all costs in case they ever want to move back again.

LakieLady · 26/05/2023 16:47

Twenty miles is no distance. Plenty of people do a daily commute of more than that.

2bazookas · 26/05/2023 16:47

Astonishing that she wants to make her own life but resents her parents doing exactly the same. It's high time she was weaned and potty trained.

MooMooSharoo · 26/05/2023 16:45

20 miles is nothing. I live 20 miles away from work. That said, 20 miles in the centre of London, or 20 miles in the wilds of Norfolk feels a lot further than 20 miles along a motorway.

I am, however, in my 40s and have matured. Your DD sounds immature and self-centered as many late teens/early 20s are, when they believe the whole world needs to revolve around them.

Move, let her go off travelling and if/when she wants to move back home, set her a timescale for getting a job and then take a reasonable amount of housekeeping from her, even if you ultimately bank it to give back to her when she moves out properly.

AgnesX · 26/05/2023 16:45

Children expect their parents and everything associated with them to stay the same so it generally comes as a bit of a surprise when something like this happens.

She sounds a bit immature and you perhaps need to gently explain that you do have lives away from her, that life moves on and 20 miles isn't that far really.

yepgoingforarun · 26/05/2023 16:44

willWillSmithsmith · 26/05/2023 16:41

Twenty miles is nothing. It’s even less of a nothing as she drives. I also love having my children home but that wouldn’t stop me moving twenty miles.

I was meaning from the convenience point of view.

Pot8ohs · 26/05/2023 16:43

Sounds like she has regressed to being a self absorbed 15 year old!

20 miles is nothing. She ought to have anticipated this really. It’s what lots of people choose to do, or have to do.

It’s a slight inconvenience for her but she ought to have the grace to realise she has been lucky until now. Complaining just makes her sound spoilt and immature. Cringe!

YukoandHiro · 26/05/2023 16:42

YANBU. She's being ridiculous. My parents moved abroad when I was a 20 at uni.
It was an adjustment but basically fine - I loved my "holidays" at their house.
She's 23 and lives very nearby. If she wants to move nearer you later on, that's her choice too.

willWillSmithsmith · 26/05/2023 16:41

yepgoingforarun · 26/05/2023 15:54

I’d wait until she’d gone off travelling myself but then again - I love having my children at home!

Twenty miles is nothing. It’s even less of a nothing as she drives. I also love having my children home but that wouldn’t stop me moving twenty miles.

loislovesstewie · 26/05/2023 16:41

It's 20 miles away for goodness sake! She is confident enough to travel around the world, so 20 miles is nothing. She might do what a friend did:get to Australia and decide to stay! Look, I suspect that whenever, wherever you moved she would complain. You are of an age where having, in all likelihood, had to make certain sacrifices for your kids, now want a bit of 'me time'. And that's fine. Just get on with what you want and wave her off on her adventure when the time comes.

TrashyPanda · 26/05/2023 16:38

Grumpy67i8 · 26/05/2023 16:19

So she has enough money for a deposit but instead of getting a job to get on the housing ladder, she's going travelling for a year? Yeah, she's spoiled.

You should not feel guilty at all, she's going away when you move house!

Totally

do not let her dictate your life.

oakleaffy · 26/05/2023 16:37

YourWinter · 26/05/2023 15:56

Twenty miles is nothing if she drives.

This! It’s hardly Emigration.
20 miles isn’t far if you drive.

ManateeFair · 26/05/2023 16:36

Surely her feelings are very normal.

It's normal that she might feel a bit stressed by the inconvenience/change, yes. What's not normal is kicking up a fuss about it and/or complaining that it's unfair, because she is 23 and not 12.

yepgoingforarun · 26/05/2023 16:36

Scandimandy · 26/05/2023 16:33

@yepgoingforarun It may sound a bit odd but I think my way of seeing things sometimes isn't the same as others would be so I just wanted to ensure I'm not being unreasonable. I wasn't suggesting she was an entitled brat I was asking if I was turning her into one :)

shes your daughter. Of 23 years.
you live with her
and you say you are close to her

So you were going to take the word of anonymous posters as to whether she was spoilt and entitled over one incident?

MammaTo · 26/05/2023 16:34

If she is a good daughter I think you should of had the discussion with her on what her thoughts are.
It’s really hard to live on a single income these days, it’s all well and good having money for a deposit - but the rest is out of her hands a little.

ManateeFair · 26/05/2023 16:34

I can't believe you're even having to ask this question. Your DD is being spoilt, infantile and downright weird about this. She's a grown woman and you're only moving 20 miles. She should, frankly, be embarrassed at her own immaturity.

SchoolShenanigans · 26/05/2023 16:33

Neither of you are unreasonable.

YANBU to want to move away and do so, it's completely your choice. She also isnt unreasonable to want you to stay, wouldn't everyone want their parents to stay if they lived with them? Surely her feelings are very normal.

Sounds like she's going to have to just accept it. Chances are it will tie in nicely for when she travels.

Scandimandy · 26/05/2023 16:33

@yepgoingforarun It may sound a bit odd but I think my way of seeing things sometimes isn't the same as others would be so I just wanted to ensure I'm not being unreasonable. I wasn't suggesting she was an entitled brat I was asking if I was turning her into one :)

OP posts:
nosunshinewhenshesgone · 26/05/2023 16:31

I know some people whose parents moved whilst they were at university, and whilst they were adults, that was really unsettling for them because they lost a permanent base and, in some cases, their childhood home.

Most people don't like change, even when it's reasonable and expected. I'd allow her to have feelings about the move and to express those feelings, but not to guilt you into changing your plans.

I assume she's still welcome to visit (or perhaps even live with you), and her friends are also willing to put her up - so she can go off travelling the world, having grand adventures and then find herself a permanent base wherever she likes when she's back. She's not being made homeless or friendless; she's just having to think a bit more about her plans.

Your moving has probably forced her to think about growing up, and let's face it, who wants to be an adult?

yepgoingforarun · 26/05/2023 16:29

The reason I wondered if a backstory is because I honestly can’t imagine talking about my daughter as you did in your op… wondering if she’s selfish, entitled, spoilt, a brat…. Unless there was a backstory

pigsDOfly · 26/05/2023 16:27

She's 23, it's 20 miles, she's being ridiculous.

So what is she going to do while she's travelling? I'm assuming she's going to be more than 20 miles away from you during that year.

Meanwhile, you've got to say put so that when she decides to come back from her travels you will still be where she wants you to be so you can provide a home for her.

Yes, she's spoiled.

yepgoingforarun · 26/05/2023 16:26

SpookySpoon22 · 26/05/2023 16:12

Lazy response

Yours is the lazy one

because if she was an only child, then might partly explain her feelings more so than if had siblings. Her mother. Her only immediate family. Moving from the family home.

not an excuse but maybe a reason.

and another reason Why relevant to ask is because my follow up would be”and how are your other children taking it”

so you can get off your high horse! 😂