Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to upset DD by moving 20 miles away

136 replies

Scandimandy · 26/05/2023 15:51

We have just put our house on the market and being in our 50's and 60's my partner and I decided we would like to move to a more rural area and near the sea. We are both self employed so can effectively live anywhere. We have found the ideal village about 20 miles away from our current location but my adult DD who still lives with us (she is 23) is very upset for us contemplating moving this far away from our current house, I think mostly because all her friends are local. DD drives and works full time locally but is going to give up her job in November and go travelling for a year so she'd be looking for a new job when she arrived home anyway. Obviously she doesn't have to live with us, she is a grown up and could make her own way in the world. She doesn't earn loads but she has some inheritance money - she has enough for a deposit but doesn't earn enough to sustain a mortgage. Is she behaving selfishly and spoilt or are we being unreasonable for moving this far away from our current location? In one way I feel she shouldn't be living at home now at her age anyway - she has moved away for uni and then come back - but on the other hand I feel like we are forcing her out if she doesn't want to come with us. Have we raised an entitled brat?

OP posts:
InanimateObjects · 26/05/2023 20:37

What? I referred to her a "the OP's child". I did not say she was "a child". Your child remaims your child even when they are an adult. That is the name of the familial relationship.

I lived alone from 16 onwards and supported myself. What relevance has any of that? I even reiterated because you didn't seem to notice in my first post that I'm not saying the daughter is right. You seem to be having an emotional reaction to this because you moved away when your daughter was a teen. Did that happen to be a move with an unrelated partner by any chance? 😆

My point was not about whether the OP should move, rather how she is handling the situation and how she relates to her daughter, which given the way she speaks about her seems at best emotionally detached and at worst rather callous. This is not a normal way to speak about your child, to use the word "brat" etc. Hence the suspicion that a partner may be influencing how she views her daughter because generally parents do not speak about their children in such terms.

UCknowitall · 26/05/2023 20:28

InanimateObjects · 26/05/2023 20:15

If that was aimed at me @UCknowitall then:

a) nobody said he is a malign influence. But many are, as they have no love for the child in many cases. And I've only ever heard a parent speak about their child in these terms when an unrelated partner has influenced them.

b) children ARE forever. Parents usually consider the impact of things we do or say on our children always and show them love and support, yes: even as adults. This is not being a martyr.

c) you can wonder whether you are "enabling your child" without referring to them as a "brat". That's horrendous. The child does not have to be "fabulous in every way" for the parent to consider how they feel and try to talk about them in a respectful manner and show enough empathy to try to understand how they might feel, and speak to them about it.

Some very strange attitudes to family on this thread. I didn't say the daughter was "correct" btw, I was just very peturbed by the way the OP spoke about her which made me wonder why that is.

Stop being so ridiculous !! This 'child' is a bloody ADULT.. who feels she can call the shots - despite being quite happy to plan and live her own life . Yet still wants to dictate her mother and stepfathers ..

I moved 20 miles away when my last was 17. I made sure she passed her driving test . She is at Uni now but guess what ? She drives for half an hour and visits her old school friends.

Everyone lives .

InanimateObjects · 26/05/2023 20:15

If that was aimed at me @UCknowitall then:

a) nobody said he is a malign influence. But many are, as they have no love for the child in many cases. And I've only ever heard a parent speak about their child in these terms when an unrelated partner has influenced them.

b) children ARE forever. Parents usually consider the impact of things we do or say on our children always and show them love and support, yes: even as adults. This is not being a martyr.

c) you can wonder whether you are "enabling your child" without referring to them as a "brat". That's horrendous. The child does not have to be "fabulous in every way" for the parent to consider how they feel and try to talk about them in a respectful manner and show enough empathy to try to understand how they might feel, and speak to them about it.

Some very strange attitudes to family on this thread. I didn't say the daughter was "correct" btw, I was just very peturbed by the way the OP spoke about her which made me wonder why that is.

UCknowitall · 26/05/2023 19:41

OP - you obviously don't know the RULES !!!

  1. Any man you live with who isn't the biological father to your children is at best a malign influence and at worst evil personified . It is OBVIOUSLY he who wants this move . You should definitely LTB for even suggestion it !
  1. Children are children for ever. They should always have every wish and desire catered for until they say otherwise. If they don't like it then tough - doesn't matter if they are 23 or 43 ITS THEIR CHILDHOOD HOME FGS stop being so selfish. You had kids . You must martyr yourself until you die.
  1. How can you possibly wonder if you are enabling your child to be a selfish brat. !!! Such introspection and self examination must be expunged from your mind. You child is fabulous in every way , every day and for always (even when displaying selfish behaviour because it's cos she's 'ankshush' about her childhood home (despite having been an adult for 5 years) innit. ?

You need to give your head a bloody good wobble whilst getting your ducks in a row !

InanimateObjects · 26/05/2023 19:34

Bluebellbike · 26/05/2023 17:32

My parents sold up and moved almost 25 miles away to a rural location when I was 20. My father and I were still working back in the city we moved from, so he drove us there and back Monday to Friday every week. I spent some week nights and most weekends staying with friends and relatives so I could have a social life. I felt like a bag lady.

After being snowed in a couple of times and unable to get to work or home from work I bought a house near work at the age of 21. Best thing I ever did and set me up for decent housing for the rest of my life. Mortgage interest rates were 15% but house prices were low.

Oh dear. Is this a story from the 80s trying to compare it to the 2020s? 🙄

InanimateObjects · 26/05/2023 19:30

yepgoingforarun · 26/05/2023 16:29

The reason I wondered if a backstory is because I honestly can’t imagine talking about my daughter as you did in your op… wondering if she’s selfish, entitled, spoilt, a brat…. Unless there was a backstory

This. It's disturbing that someone could speak about their child like this, whom they presumably adore. It isn't how parents normally refer to their child. Unless you have a very dysfunctional relationship. Or - as it sounded to me having seen this before - you are repeating phrases/ terms your partner uses about your DD and they are influencing your relationship with her and how you view her. Do they talk to you a lot about her without her present, say horrible things like this about her? Go on about how she should "grow up" and "move out", when something like two thirds of kids her age still live with parents?

SpookySpoon22 · 26/05/2023 18:45

yepgoingforarun · 26/05/2023 16:26

Yours is the lazy one

because if she was an only child, then might partly explain her feelings more so than if had siblings. Her mother. Her only immediate family. Moving from the family home.

not an excuse but maybe a reason.

and another reason Why relevant to ask is because my follow up would be”and how are your other children taking it”

so you can get off your high horse! 😂

Fair enough 🤣 I just hate when people jump to the conclusion that “an entitled brat” is likely to be an only child. Now you've explained, I appreciate you weren't meaning it that way and I'll happily get off my high horse now and sit in a comfy chair.

TinyRebel · 26/05/2023 18:33

I was 19 and my younger sibling was away at university when my parents decided that they would up sticks and move 2 hours away to the house they’d bought years ago and rented out.

I’d been in a flat share but had to leave as the LL was developing it, so had moved back ‘home’.
Parents spotted that some HA properties were being built in a local hamlet, and so dealt with the inconvenience of having me around (albeit temporarily) by writing to the council and informing me they were making me homeless.

It worked! I had my own rented flat in the middle of nowhere to carpet and furnish by myself, then worked F/T plus five evenings a week to just about afford it.

My sibling, who had serious mental health issues in sixth form, suddenly found they had no ‘home’ to go to where he could catch up with friends in the holidays.

By the time I was your daughter’s age though, I’d moved abroad. 20 miles away would have been nothing - my friends regularly used to drive far more than that for a night out!

Go for it OP. Just don’t chuck out all your daughter’s stuff during the move if she inadvertently leaves it behind (I’m sure you won’t).

MayThe4th · 26/05/2023 18:30

Honestly the way that adults are infantilised on here is ridiculous. She’s 23. She’s not a baby, and her mum hasn’t told her to move out, she’s suggested that they want to move, and given’t she’s going travelling anyway it’s not going to affect her.

And she’s got a car, and it’s twenty miles fgs. At 23 I moved out and did a three hour round commute every day until I got a job closer to home and then I got a mortgage.

We need to stop with the “but then covid” attitude. If we’re not careful we’re going to end up with a generation of adults who are expected to be pandered to like children.

If she wants to be close to the friends who she’ll only be seeing for another five months and who will probably have moved on before she gets back then she can drive to see them.

whiteroseredrose · 26/05/2023 18:28

Allthegoodusernamesareused · 26/05/2023 16:20

I personally wouldn't sell our family home if one of my children still lived with us. I'm a way off that, but have always planned to stay put until they are both permanently settled with homes of their own. I don't think my children should consider themselves lucky for that either.

My feelings on that may be somewhat coloured by the fact that my parents downsized when I went to university at 18 though!)

That being said, you are only talking about moving 20 miles, which really isn't that far.

Me neither.

And I'm also that DC. My parents moved when I went to University, also about 20 miles away, so two buses. I lost touch with my school friends because I never bumped into them. DH is still in touch with his (we have sold his family home at the age of 55!)

GrannyRose15 · 26/05/2023 18:21

kingtamponthefurred · 26/05/2023 18:09

I'd be disappointed if a child of mine who was employed, solvent and mobile hadn't already made plans to move on.

I wonder how old your children are. I think you may have to get used to being disappointed.

innerspace · 26/05/2023 18:19

PleaseJustText · 26/05/2023 16:25

Exactly @mrsbitaly she's already joking that she may never come back.

She might think she's joking now but you never know. I went backpacking for a year and it never occurred to me that I'd be gone any longer than that. I finally came back to the UK 7 years later. Luckily my parents weren't waiting for me. They'd already had the chance to move overseas and took it while I was gone.

Same here. Stayed for 6 years before coming back, and even then I wasn’t sure of moving back.

GrannyRose15 · 26/05/2023 18:18

This is a difficult one and one I have had to think about several times in my life. I have made it clear to my three children that there will always be a home for them with me if they need it while at the same time hoping that they will become independent. I do not think either you or your daughter are being selfish but I do think that maybe you should have a heart to heart with her and try to find out what is really worrying her. Is she reluctant to leave her family home? is she worried about being on her own? is she simply scared of the unknown? Don't give up your dream of moving to your desired house but let her know that it is not because you want to abandon her. 23 is still very young in today's world.

Sceptre86 · 26/05/2023 18:18

Is it her childhood home? If so then I think a little bit of understanding goes a long way but ultimately you have to be clear that she is an adult now and you will do what you want. Maybe she just wants to know she will still have a home with you if she wants it? I'd speak to her, let her know that once she comes back from travelling she can bunk at your new home for a while (if you are OK with that) but at some point she will have to strike out on her own.

I'll feel sad when my parents sell our family home but I haven't lived there for many years and know I don't get to sulk over it. She's young and sounds like she has been babies a bit. Be understanding but firm and don't entertain any sulking.

HerMammy · 26/05/2023 18:15

It's 20 miles not 200! The fact she can drive makes her reaction more silly.

Frenchtoadt · 26/05/2023 18:14

She isn’t an entitled prat OP .. 23 is very young still and it’s a lot harder for them to make their way than it was for our generation .. my first house was under £40k .. make your own plans but it’s ok for her to feel how she does ..it’s great that she’s going travelling

Dutchess46 · 26/05/2023 18:11

20 miles is managable

Seymour5 · 26/05/2023 18:10

slowrunner07 · 26/05/2023 16:04

20 miles is nothing, but also 23 is fairly young so it's pretty normal for her to be living at home still now property prices are so high. Suggest a house share with friends if she doesn't want to move with you.

Isn’t house sharing in their 20s the norm any more? Its what my DC did more than 20 years ago. After starting their careers, and finally earning reasonable money, they wanted to enjoy themselves for a bit before settling into home ownership. Most of their single friends did the same.

kingtamponthefurred · 26/05/2023 18:09

I'd be disappointed if a child of mine who was employed, solvent and mobile hadn't already made plans to move on.

MikeWozniaksMohawk · 26/05/2023 18:03

20 miles?! That’s hardly any distance! I live 120 miles from my parents’ house and have done since your DD’s age. My brother lives 75 miles from their house in a completely different direction. She needs some perspective. I suspect when she returns from travelling she will have some.

toomuchlaundry · 26/05/2023 17:59

@curtainsfringe 20 miles is close!

SleepingStandingUp · 26/05/2023 17:59

She's just having a wobble about being the sort of grown up that doesn't have a childhood home to return to. It might not be the most mature response, but given her brain isn't either, I'd let her off.

Remind her you love her. But she's going off and living her best life travelling and you have to do the same, in your own way.

MarkWithaC · 26/05/2023 17:58

I thought you were going to say your DD was about 6 and was upset at leaving her school friends!
She's being ridiculous. At 23 she could easily be living independently. Why can't she get a place in your current location if she wants to stay close to her friends?

inadarkdarkhouseinadarkdarkstreet · 26/05/2023 17:55

Sorry, missed your part about an ensuite! If you are happy to continue arrangement but in a new home you are being perfectly fair. Is it the shock at the change? Maybe she saw you living there for ever and it's shaken her a bit? Might just need time to adjust.

OriginalUsername2 · 26/05/2023 17:48

What’s the difference between “spoiled” and “supportive”?

Women who bristle at the thought of young women getting any extra kindness from their mothers make me feel uneasy.

It’s not easy to set yourself up right now. For example I left home at 16 and got a cheap room from a random man in the paper that I could afford working part time. Now you need a huge deposit, guarantor, history of reliable wage, a certain income, credit check, and you’re competing with 50-100 other applicatamts.

OP would be reasonable to move but equally reasonable to support DD through her transition to adulthood and make it easier for her if that’s what she wanted to do.

I imagine planning on traveling the world knowing you have your familiar home base and friends to come home to feel’s different to not knowing that.