Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to upset DD by moving 20 miles away

136 replies

Scandimandy · 26/05/2023 15:51

We have just put our house on the market and being in our 50's and 60's my partner and I decided we would like to move to a more rural area and near the sea. We are both self employed so can effectively live anywhere. We have found the ideal village about 20 miles away from our current location but my adult DD who still lives with us (she is 23) is very upset for us contemplating moving this far away from our current house, I think mostly because all her friends are local. DD drives and works full time locally but is going to give up her job in November and go travelling for a year so she'd be looking for a new job when she arrived home anyway. Obviously she doesn't have to live with us, she is a grown up and could make her own way in the world. She doesn't earn loads but she has some inheritance money - she has enough for a deposit but doesn't earn enough to sustain a mortgage. Is she behaving selfishly and spoilt or are we being unreasonable for moving this far away from our current location? In one way I feel she shouldn't be living at home now at her age anyway - she has moved away for uni and then come back - but on the other hand I feel like we are forcing her out if she doesn't want to come with us. Have we raised an entitled brat?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hufflepuffbutrequestinggriffindor · 28/05/2023 15:28

I think you've been very generous allowing her to move with you and give her an ensuite! 20 miles really is not far for her to travel for work or to see friends. Surely many of her friends anyway have moved away though and cope with not being near home. Many of my old school friends moved miles away and often stayed in or near their university towns. I stayed near where I went to university 500 miles away from home! You can't prioritise her requirements above your own anymore at her age.

Shopper727 · 28/05/2023 09:42

Surely if she’s that bothered she can move out, I mean at 23 I had my own house and a baby my mum moved to Australia so at least you are only going 20 miles away. She can’t have her own way, she’s an adult with a job who could live independently if she wanted.

She’ll be off travelling no doubt not giving you a second thought, but you have to consider her hurt sad feelings because you want to move - it’s 20 miles she can still see friends etc or even stay over with them.

JMSA · 28/05/2023 09:31

Laughing at the idea of calling one's adult child a brat as 'horrendous' Grin
Honestly, how do some of you get through life when you're this precious?

lonelylou09 · 28/05/2023 09:27

@Scandimandy you have to put your own needs first. I've just done a similar post where my ds 23 moved 200 miles away last year and has just come back. The home dynamics have changed since he's been gone and he's had to adjust and fit back in..rather than us changing everything back for him.
Whilst I disagree that it's time for her to fly the nest ext as long as you are providing her a roof over her head option it's up to her to either find something for herself or drive the 20 miles to catch up with her old friends ect.
You do have to bear in mind that it's not easy for young ones now to set themselves up in Thier own home..even if they have some money behind them.. because everything is so expensive.
I think you should find your dream home,move there and keep her a room which she will need if she's off traveling..maybe when she gets back she will have matured and see that 20 miles is nothing.

JMSA · 28/05/2023 09:20

She's the unreasonable one. You have done nothing wrong. She wouldn't even have to buy a house at this point ... she could do a house share with others!
www.spareroom.co.uk

AbreathofFrenchair · 28/05/2023 09:14

kingtamponthefurred · 26/05/2023 18:09

I'd be disappointed if a child of mine who was employed, solvent and mobile hadn't already made plans to move on.

But not everywhere is affordable, even rent. It amazes me that people don't consider this when they try to push the child out of the home.

A studio flat in my area is £900 plus Bill's a month. A 1 bed flat is £1250 and houses are around £1600 plus a month and don't allow you to divide the rent between friends.

Even HOMO are £650 plus bills and are often single bedrooms.

I just dont get why letting them struggle is preferable to having them living at home , its though you're trying to teach them some weird lesson. At least at home they have a better chance of saving to get onto the property market.

My children are teens and I cant ever imagine forcing them out of home because they have a job. My parents never did it to me and it never had a negative impact, despite beliefs on here.

AbreathofFrenchair · 28/05/2023 09:07

Scandimandy · 26/05/2023 15:51

We have just put our house on the market and being in our 50's and 60's my partner and I decided we would like to move to a more rural area and near the sea. We are both self employed so can effectively live anywhere. We have found the ideal village about 20 miles away from our current location but my adult DD who still lives with us (she is 23) is very upset for us contemplating moving this far away from our current house, I think mostly because all her friends are local. DD drives and works full time locally but is going to give up her job in November and go travelling for a year so she'd be looking for a new job when she arrived home anyway. Obviously she doesn't have to live with us, she is a grown up and could make her own way in the world. She doesn't earn loads but she has some inheritance money - she has enough for a deposit but doesn't earn enough to sustain a mortgage. Is she behaving selfishly and spoilt or are we being unreasonable for moving this far away from our current location? In one way I feel she shouldn't be living at home now at her age anyway - she has moved away for uni and then come back - but on the other hand I feel like we are forcing her out if she doesn't want to come with us. Have we raised an entitled brat?

Why can't she be upset though? And why does her being upset make her an entitled brat?

From what you've said she hasnt said you cant or that she isnt happy to move along with you, just that she is very upset yet you seem to think her feelings are something that are irrational. Has nothing ever upset you?

Whilst she doesnt get to have a final say in what happens, surely a normal family conversation would include letting her know the plans and your intentions as they happen, not just by the way we are moving 20 miles away without a thought to her.

But then it baffles me the amount of people on here who don't consider their children and do their best to get them out of the family home as soon as they turn 18 and refuse to have them back.

GrannyRose15 · 28/05/2023 08:46

My post was in reply to whoever asked why we were referring to an adult of 23 as a child. Couldn’t get the quote button to work🤫

GrannyRose15 · 28/05/2023 08:44

We refer to our children as children because we have no word in English to distinguish our offspring who are young and those who have grown. I’ve been trying to think of one for years. Any suggestions?

JudgeJ · 27/05/2023 22:12

YourWinter · 26/05/2023 15:56

Twenty miles is nothing if she drives.

I drive that far to go shopping, I once drove 45 miles each way to my job! 20 miles is nothing of she drives and if she doesn't like it she has a solution.

zingally · 27/05/2023 10:10

My parents did the same thing with my sister. Granted she was a bit older than your DD, more like 26/27.
Things had been tense for a while, with sister treating the place like a hotel, never spending any time with the parents etc (worth noting that I'm 3 years younger and had been moved out a couple of years at this point).

Parents basically said, "we're moving, and you're not coming with us." Sister moved in with her bf, and they've been happily together ever since.

I get the impression that you are more than welcoming to the idea of dd coming with you, which is far more generous than my parents were feeling! Frankly, she either comes, or she doesn't. Either way, don't let that stop you moving where you want to go. She's a fully formed adult, and it's time she grew up.

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2023 09:58

InanimateObjects · 26/05/2023 20:15

If that was aimed at me @UCknowitall then:

a) nobody said he is a malign influence. But many are, as they have no love for the child in many cases. And I've only ever heard a parent speak about their child in these terms when an unrelated partner has influenced them.

b) children ARE forever. Parents usually consider the impact of things we do or say on our children always and show them love and support, yes: even as adults. This is not being a martyr.

c) you can wonder whether you are "enabling your child" without referring to them as a "brat". That's horrendous. The child does not have to be "fabulous in every way" for the parent to consider how they feel and try to talk about them in a respectful manner and show enough empathy to try to understand how they might feel, and speak to them about it.

Some very strange attitudes to family on this thread. I didn't say the daughter was "correct" btw, I was just very peturbed by the way the OP spoke about her which made me wonder why that is.

@InanimateObjects

why do you keep saying child and children? OP’s daughter is 23 - an ADULT

oh and it definitely is being a martyr to base your entire life around, to pander to, and have all your decisions dictated by your adult offspring. Total martyr. It’s time for Op to start putting herself at the centre of things now

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2023 09:53

willWillSmithsmith · 26/05/2023 16:41

Twenty miles is nothing. It’s even less of a nothing as she drives. I also love having my children home but that wouldn’t stop me moving twenty miles.

@yepgoingforarun

surely you don’t want them living with you forever though?!

Scandimandy · 27/05/2023 09:50

😁😁😁😁 @UCknowitall 😘

OP posts:
HerbsandSpices · 27/05/2023 09:47

20 miles is nothing.

I have one at home that age and I wouldn't consider moving at this time. They have their own 'wing', so to speak, and we're close to public transport and work opportunities. So the house still works for us at this time. Eventually though, we'll have to make a move when we get older. Not in a hurry though, it's such an effort. Might consider it if two suddenly flew the nest.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 27/05/2023 09:34

It’s worrying how many people can’t see the difference between a parent worrying that their parenting wasn’t very good and asking if they’ve raised a selfish brat and outright calling their child a selfish brat.

Op, keep going. It’ll be a shock to the system for her but she’ll be fine. She’s old
enough to be travelling then she’s old enough to realise you are not just there to be placeholders for her life. You may find the year of travelling will be the making of her.
And of course, keep that room for her

MamaBear4ever · 27/05/2023 09:29

20 miles is nothing when you have a car. She is going travelling, its time to put yourself first after 23yrs of raising her. Move to where you want to she will adjust

MrsSkylerWhite · 27/05/2023 09:27

We’re moving to our retirement place in a year or so, when our youngest has finished their course. They’ll be 21 and are delighted for us.

She is being unreasonable.

celticprincess · 27/05/2023 09:25

I don’t think either are being unreasonable. She’s entitled to be upset. 20 miles where we live can take anything from half an hour to an hour. I went to uni when I was 18 and that was me moved out. What swayed it was my parents moving house, not far, and when I came home for the fort holiday I felt like a guest and that it wasn’t my home. My younger sibling lived there too and stayed living at home for uni and beyond. I went to uni a few hours away and did stay there after graduation as I had a boyfriend, friends and a job to go to. I soon got a mortgage after a year renting and bought. Quite a few years ago I needed to relocate back home and did live with my parents for a while but it didn’t feel like home, even for a year.

I think at 23 your DD is lucky she is able to travel. But with the COL and depending on where you live I think she was probably expecting to come back for a few more years. She might mellow after travelling. The change will do her good. I have 2 children and I know they will be living at home longer than I did. Especially one who is autistic (no learning disabilities and many wouldn’t know she is). I’ve talked about moving - this isn’t and was never a forever home but the cost of living and getting a divorce has meant I’ve stayed where I am. Neither kids are keen to move- even when I talk about lovely better homes nearby. Their dad has moved a few times but they’ve never felt his house is home.

You are entitled to move, she’s entitled to be upset. She will come around I think. If you’re happy for her to love with you when she’s home from travelling then make sure you’re buying a house with that in mind and that she will have a room as long as she needs it.

Aslanplustwo · 27/05/2023 01:56

because if she was an only child, then might partly explain her feelings more so than if had siblings. Her mother. Her only immediate family. Moving from the family home.

not an excuse but maybe a reason.

Here we go.with the "only child" rubbish again. I am an only child, my parents divorced and sold the family home, I didn't carry on like that. I was sad as I loved the house (not our original family home) but was old enough to realise that it was actually my parents' house, not mine.

Aslanplustwo · 27/05/2023 01:53

This is not a normal way to speak about your child, to use the word "brat" etc

Wow, you have lived a sheltered life! If a child is a brat there is nothing wrong with saying so.

Aslanplustwo · 27/05/2023 01:52

Or family home was sold when I was around 24, and I've never had one since (parents divorced). Somehow I coped, as will she, and tbh she is a little too old to be acting like a spoilt brat.

GrannyRose15 · 27/05/2023 01:00

There seem to be some very emotional reactions to this post which probably say more about the posters than about the OP and her daughter.

UCknowitall · 26/05/2023 21:08

InanimateObjects · 26/05/2023 20:37

What? I referred to her a "the OP's child". I did not say she was "a child". Your child remaims your child even when they are an adult. That is the name of the familial relationship.

I lived alone from 16 onwards and supported myself. What relevance has any of that? I even reiterated because you didn't seem to notice in my first post that I'm not saying the daughter is right. You seem to be having an emotional reaction to this because you moved away when your daughter was a teen. Did that happen to be a move with an unrelated partner by any chance? 😆

My point was not about whether the OP should move, rather how she is handling the situation and how she relates to her daughter, which given the way she speaks about her seems at best emotionally detached and at worst rather callous. This is not a normal way to speak about your child, to use the word "brat" etc. Hence the suspicion that a partner may be influencing how she views her daughter because generally parents do not speak about their children in such terms.

No sorry luv.. sorry to disappoint. I l moved with the kids dad ..

WiddlinDiddlin · 26/05/2023 20:53

She can 'not like it' if she wants - I mean I don't 'like' that we don't still own the house I grew up in. I don't like that I will never inherit to live in the house my father built and lives in now (because its too big, not accessible for me and would be half mine and half my sisters and neither of us can live in it if we did inherit it which of course, we may not.)...

Thats not a reason that should stop you doing as you want with your lives - I think you're being more than generous in factoring in a room with an ensuite for her, when she won't be living with you for a year at least and maybe longer.

Lots of people have to live with their parents and it is what it is, but shes saved to go travelling, shes comfortable enough to quit work and do that, she has a safety net of a room in your home if she needs it... I really don't see that she has any right to do anything more than quietly 'not like it', and let you get on with your lives!