Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To change my opinion of my own parents since having kids

107 replies

Froggles1 · 26/05/2023 14:37

Just wondering if anyone has experienced similar as I feel guilty feeling like this but since becoming a parent, I feel really hurt and annoyed by the way my parents are.

There is probably too much to explain here but growing up they always had a volatile relqtionship (not abusive but argued a lot and mum would often leave with bags packed etc then return as if nothing happened). They dont discuss things ever & just continued this pattern (still together)

Both can be kind people but I feel like everything is on their terms. They live about 45 mins away so not far but theh very very rarely visit us. We work full time etc so we typically can only do the journey once a month. My mum comments that they never see our children a lot and insists on buying them things to make up for this. I confided once that I felt our son was missing them and her response was “well then he should come see us more”. 😒I think this is completely unfair to expect a 5 year old to maintain their relationship! They also see my sisters children a lot more & subsequently my kids are less comfortable there than them just due to familiarity.

throughout my life my parents, although I know loved me, very much put their social lives, friendships and wider family members before me. I was slso given silent treatment (mum) if i did something wrong or she would share too much with me regarding her life etc. Now, I feel they dont really listen to me or have much interest in me. Mum in particular talks over me and monologues about her life, ranting etc whereas Dad barely says a word

i have had a lot of counselling and have built a lovely family. I have a good job and a lot to be proud of but I feel so heartbroken that they dont ever acknowledge me, say they are proud etc

they have very different values to me and whereas i always felt we were close, over the last few years I have really noticed these things and feel a distance due to them.

aibu to be upset?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ilovecleaning · 28/05/2023 23:35

onefinemess · 26/05/2023 14:50

Why do you believe that you should have been the focus of your parents lives?

I'm guessing that to them, you were a product of their relationship, not the reason for it.

You were healthy, had a roof over your head, food in your belly, clothes on your back.

What more did you expect?

Jesus! Why do you even bother to type such a nasty mean-minded reply? Uncalled for.

JessandJupiter · 28/05/2023 23:26

Lilyhatesjaz · 28/05/2023 00:31

I am not convinced that parenting was so very different in the past. I was a child in the 70s and always felt loved and cared for, myself and my sibling were mostly put first within the family.
My grandparents had been good parents too and there was a lot of love.
I do my best with my children I have got a lot right but I am sure some wrong.
I work with young children and see a lot of good or good enough parents but also a fair number of really awful ones I don't agree that parents are better now, there are good an bad in all generations

I think both can be true - that parenting was different in the 60s and 70s - and that there are good and bad parents in every generation; it’s not an either-or!

The differences in parenting between the 70s and now, very generally, relate to: corporal punishment in school, smacking at home, far more lax health and safety practices, far fewer child-centric activities, less variety and availability of food, clothing, toys, and travel, more sahms, less geographical distance between family members, less sensitivity to, and awareness of, children’s emotional well-being and also a poorer understanding of potential SENs and neurodiversity, fewer teens going on to university.

mrlistersgelfbride · 28/05/2023 18:17

YANBU.
When you are young, you think what your parents do is normal. Then you grow up and realise they have flaws, sometimes many.
My parents had and still have a very fucked up relationship. My dad also was violent to us all including my mum and mum used to alternate between saying she was leaving him to making excuses for his short temper. He now says it never happened and we imagined it. So does m
mum 🙄
I now know having children is very hard, but I don't think my dad ever wanted to have kids really. Whilst we never wanted for anything, we never did anything geared towards children as dad didn't like it, my mum didn't drive so we never went anywhere unless dad wanted to go. I wasn't allowed friends in the house or to sleepover. No suprise I left at 18 and have barely been back since 🤣
I used to blame my mum for me having no confidence, but I don't now.
It's depressing to admit my folks are very negative people.
However it's important to break the cycle.

So yes I too changed my opinion of my parents after I became a parent.

You learn how to be a parent and how not to be from your own.

Issania87 · 28/05/2023 17:41

I think having children makes you think about what kind of parent you want to be. There are always things we didn't like about our own parents, so we take steps to not do that with our own. Smacking for example, I was smacked, I don't smack my children. My Dad was very much children should be seen and not heard, and as a result as an adult I struggle to understand and convey how I am feeling. I want my children to know that emotions are okay to feel and I hear what they are saying. But I wouldn't say my parents are bad parents by any means, they did the best they could given the information they had at the time and the example they were set by their own parents. And they are both excellent grandparents now.

Puffalicious · 28/05/2023 12:00

Lilyhatesjaz · 28/05/2023 00:31

I am not convinced that parenting was so very different in the past. I was a child in the 70s and always felt loved and cared for, myself and my sibling were mostly put first within the family.
My grandparents had been good parents too and there was a lot of love.
I do my best with my children I have got a lot right but I am sure some wrong.
I work with young children and see a lot of good or good enough parents but also a fair number of really awful ones I don't agree that parents are better now, there are good an bad in all generations

Agree that there are good and bad in all generations. I see many poor parents, particularly those struggling with teens and the stresses teens/ parents of teens have in our modern society. Things were far simpler to navigate in the 80s when I was a young teen.

Lilyhatesjaz · 28/05/2023 00:31

I am not convinced that parenting was so very different in the past. I was a child in the 70s and always felt loved and cared for, myself and my sibling were mostly put first within the family.
My grandparents had been good parents too and there was a lot of love.
I do my best with my children I have got a lot right but I am sure some wrong.
I work with young children and see a lot of good or good enough parents but also a fair number of really awful ones I don't agree that parents are better now, there are good an bad in all generations

Puffalicious · 27/05/2023 22:46

JessandJupiter · 27/05/2023 09:51

For me it’s the other way around! I am much much more sympathetic to my mother having raised my own children!

I used to feel very upset with my mother in particular for being so undemonstrative in their love and parenting in the 70s was very different to how it is today. We now know more about attachment and early childhood development for one thing.

At the same time, I’ve come to understand that my late parents were products of their own quite harsh parenting and they were both teenagers who were evacuated during the war which must have had a profound effect on them, as did their religious faith which discouraged contraception.

But the thing that led to me finally forgiving my mother for what I perceived as her parenting “deficits” was raising two teenagers of my own, one of whom was quite challenging.

That experience made me look at my own parenting faults very closely and understand how things I did with the best of intentions could be misconstrued or misunderstood and how I still don’t always get things right, despite really trying hard. I don’t mind admitting that I fucked up on quite a few occasions and when I thought I had learned lessons and knew what I was doing with my second teen; they needed totally different parenting to the first.

Some people are naturally and intuitively good parents. I love the very bones of my two but parenting was never something that came very easily to me. Happily it came more easily to their father. I still constantly second guess myself now my dc are young adults.

I think success with teens partly with depends on how emotionally resilient and and mentally “successful” you are as an adult yourself, as at a certain point they stop needing hands-on parenting and they need a good role model instead.

And if you are fragile in any way or struggling with your mh, as I now realise my parents were to some degree, or if you are just not very confident like me, your teens will hold you to account for it as they need someone who is strong, to have their backs and be there as a very solid presence while they go through what for some is a tumultuous time during adolescence.

What’s good and positive though is that, in most families, parents and teens can both fuck up but eventually they pass through that challenging phase… and teens go on to develop a much more objective and realistic view of their parents, and adults stop being so anxious about their teens and let go and trust more … and both parties discover that they still love one another massively, and in the best scenarios they realise they still enjoy one another’s company too, and both parties on to reconcile as adults and develop a more level and mature relationship based on trust and forgiveness.

This is a great post.

I had a wonderful mother- strong, fun, clever, loving. I think the key was that she herself had a very secure, loving childhood- it's definitely cyclical, bit that doesn't mean people can't break their own cycle too.

My father loved us, but he had a hard, traditional upbringing and he never transcended that, bringing us up traditionally and having a stereotypically traditional narriage with mum (who was a bloody saint as she loved him). There are never excuses for behaviour, but always reasons. He was too set in his ways and could have changed if he'd had the emotional intelligence, but noone taught him that and he lived/ worked in a different world most of his life. I said as much at his funeral- I understood him and cared for him, but some of my siblings found it too hard.

I'm going through a tough time with a 2nd teenager too- who couldn't be more different than his brother, who has always been the easiest child imaginable and still is- so I've taken great comfort from your post that our relationship will survive and I look forward to the adult he'll become and will try even harder to be the voice of reason he needs, so thanks.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 27/05/2023 20:47

A little humility wouldn't go amiss.

100% agree. Anyone who is critical of past childrearing practices without understanding that future generations will view our practices with the same scorn is an idiot.

Octopus45 · 27/05/2023 20:25

sheworemellowyellow · 26/05/2023 16:24

There are an awful lot of smug new(ish) parents on this thread, complementing themselves on their superior parenting styles! Not to mention passing judgement on a different era with the benefit of newer and/or better and/or greater knowledge.

Every generation fucks up the next, to a greater or lesser extent, one way or another. Personally, I think it's pretty much a wash each time. Our children will undoubtedly criticize us, and our certainty that killing ourselves to provide the absolute best at all times for our precious children who we put at the center of our lives, is definitely the best possible parenting strategy ever.

Humans have been raising children since the beginning of humanity. It's never been perfect and never will be perfect. A little humility wouldn't go amiss.

I totally agree with this. I think future generations will be horrified by how childcentric this generation of parenting has been. Yes we are all impacted by the parenting we had. My parents made some mistakes which I have learnt from and parent differently cause of that, but they also did a lot of good things and I didn't grow up believing that I was the centre of their universe. Their marriage, jobs, the house etc were also priorities. I'm not sure all the focus being on the kids is such a good thing.

Tandora · 27/05/2023 19:49

onefinemess · 26/05/2023 14:50

Why do you believe that you should have been the focus of your parents lives?

I'm guessing that to them, you were a product of their relationship, not the reason for it.

You were healthy, had a roof over your head, food in your belly, clothes on your back.

What more did you expect?

🤣🤣🤣 most mumsnet post time of all time. Unbelievable.

YANBU OP, I think one of the things no one really prepares you for when you have children is the ways in which it drags up your own childhood, often in painful ways.

Froggles1 · 27/05/2023 19:35

@Cloudburstings I couldnt bring it up with mine either as I’d get defensiveness too. Its hard as I used to feel like I could tell them anything but actually reflect now on how much of a people pleaser I am due to the eggshells I sometimes had to walk on as a child.

@HerMammy I agree its not far hence why we usually are the ones making the journey. Its just nice if it could be shared but they always seem to want to be on their turf so to speak.

OP posts:
TheThinkingGoblin · 27/05/2023 19:01

sheworemellowyellow · 26/05/2023 19:42

Oh my word, this thread is like the twilight zone! How do you know when I was born? It wasn't between 1940 and 1960!

Do you really think humans started "studying" being parents only in the last 30 of our 300,000 year long history? Seriously??!

Do you think people born between 1940 and 1960 "knew little about parenting beyond generational word of mouth"? Do you think the printing press was invented after 1960?

Finally, are you really - REALLY - saying "the current generation of parents is much better at [parenting] because they are better prepared (educated)"?

Are you 17 years old?

You are very much uneducated about parenting, and it shows.

And no, we did not "study" things like emotional abuse, physical abuse, and other childhood issues until very recently (last 30 years or so).

Nobody really cared before then. It was just expected that children would suck it up, and parents would continue doing their own thing.

The current generation of parents now understands the reality of what a terrible way of raising children that was.

HatchetJob · 27/05/2023 18:43

I wasn’t a huge fan of MIL before I had children but even less so after I had DC.
She was incredibly disinterested in her children. I think I was always aware of this but having my own made me wonder how someone could be like this.
She lived a big distance away and we did see her regularly but I realised she just had no idea or interest in us at all really. She didn’t even know what we really did for work, just the fact it wasn’t near her and what an inconvenience it was to her.

DH always used to go on about her being brilliant but I think he’s realised too. She didn’t care how they did in school, not interested in his friends. Not interested in the out of school activities. Doing well and going to uni was just an inconvenience, they should stay home and do her shopping for her.

when DH and I were young he was very very unwell and was in hospital and she just didn’t seem very interested. She never visited (nothing to stop her coming). My FIL did ring once. When he came out of hospital she complained there had been nothing wrong with him (he was still very unwell) and he should come see her as she had a cold and refused to speak to him for weeks. Now I have DC even when they are adults nothing would stop me going to see them.

VWRabbit · 27/05/2023 18:32

Also- the difference suddenly becomes glaring in adulthood when you and your peers start getting married and having babies.. I have had some extremely bittersweet feelings, seeing my lovely friends more "normal" families being...well, normal. Being loving and proud and involved at life's milestones, where mine were heartbreakingly lacking. I wasn't expecting that blow. Of course I do not begrudge my friends their decent families, but damn if it didn't underscore it all for me.

VWRabbit · 27/05/2023 18:28

It really bothers me, since my DD turned the same age, that my mum used to let my 21+ year old bf sleep over (in my bed) when I was 14/15 onwards. No one looked out for me (neither did my non resident dad), and I would absolutely never tolerate such a thing with my own children. In fact I've had to access therapy over it (and maaaaany other things). Kids need boundaries built on love and their parents actually giving a shit. And I have had to distance myself from my parents, before the resentment and hurt about the past ate me up.

NotAHouse · 27/05/2023 18:19

Damn, did I write this in my sleep?! I know exactly how you feel, OP.

Choochoochooseyou · 27/05/2023 18:17

Yes and no. When mine were babies I couldn’t believe that my mum did it 5 times! She was also such a help when my 2 were newborns. However having children was a catalyst for me questioning so much about my life. I grew up a evangelical Christian and having children made me question my faith and ultimately reject it all.

I now really struggle with the religious upbringing my parents gave me. I was essentially brain washed from birth! I also think teaching children concepts like heaven and hell is abusive and I am so glad I am not bringing my children up like this.

My parents love me but they were very controlling. I have also realised they can’t except anyone who has different views than their own. My children are getting older now and instead of appreciating the people they are my parents are just sad they aren’t Christians. It’s an awful way to be.

HerMammy · 27/05/2023 18:11

Not dismissing anything you've said OP, but 45mins drive is nothing, the effort could be made on both sides.
I only ever find it on MN that anything other than 10mins is a journey.

TheLemon · 27/05/2023 17:59

For those of us who were disciplined physically, perhaps not abusive by the standards of the day, but certainly by today's standards, 💐

I remember being hit across the face regularly from the age of 7 or so, and when my DC turned 7 having a revelation that literally nothing they did would make me do that to them. So, it wasn't my fault when I was a kid.

It's hard to reconcile that with the narrative of a "happy childhood".

EsmeSusanOgg · 27/05/2023 17:14

As a parent myself, I realise that whilst not perfect my mum worked damned hard and was totally carrying all of the mental load. She also had to be the consistent one (my dad could be quite emotionally volatile). I loved them both as a kid and still do - but dad did the 'fun stuff' so got an easier ride especially when I was a teen. Mum did all the actual parenting, and to be frank her work ensured there was fun stuff planned in the first place.

Divorcedalongtime · 27/05/2023 16:58

I see my dads failures as a single parent of two daughters in a kinder light now that I’m also a single parent. yes for sure .
I wonder how my mum could have left her young daughters even more now that I have my own children.

GCalltheway · 27/05/2023 16:25

stayathomer · 27/05/2023 10:22

In 20 years I honestly think most people on mn who were saying about parents not visiting enough will be saying‘I have a rubbish back/health, work and am just wrecked aibu for thinking my family should visit me and not me them?’ I’m only 43 and am thinking when my kids have kids I’ll be struggling to be the energetic fun granny (back and knees are very bad, I have 4 kids and work in retail). How on earth do you see things in that light now? Do you not see all the stresses they had and feel for them now?

There is no excuse for cruelty and neglect. It’s as simple as that. If that’s the best they can do, it’s okay to say it wasn’t good enough and you damaged me.

There is a world of difference between good enough parenting and hobbling along loving your kids and doing your best, life is really hard and exhausting but no one gets excused for throwing plates at their child or making them live in fear day in and day out, nope. These people should not have had kids in the first place, and it’s very damaging to children.

Usernamen · 27/05/2023 13:27

Namechangedforthis25 · 27/05/2023 10:32

Yes agree with this - my feelings about my parents have drastically changed since having DC1 and 2 - I feel quite a lot of anger and bitterness towards them which I never did before

My dad always had a temper but I’ve realised that they were so abusive and manipulative when younger and my mum often sides with my dad now about this stuff - defends him etc

At 7 my dad once pretended to be dead to see how much I love him, he was so narcissic and to this day thinks he knows best and is controlling. He said I was a parasite when I was born as he needed to spend his finances on me. He would always blame me for everything - eg he Once hit a lamppost in the car and said I was distracting him

he would blame me for their financial situation eg if I just listened to his ideas about generating wealth at 17 and helped him find a way he/we could have been millionaires by now. But it’s my fault that he isn’t

he was physically violent at times eg throwing plates which is a whole other thing - and I spent much of my young life hiding in the bathroom as it had a lock - or just being scared

he didn’t want me to move out to live in a flat as I wouldn’t be able to survive or cope

when I didn’t get offered a long term job after my training/probationary period due to lack of space he and my mum said I should have worked harder - I worked incredibly hard for a long time (late nights, weekends) - it was just an error by the firm and they literally created a job the next morning to keep me.

he embarrasses me in front of my husband by talking about the one silly thing I did 20 years ago as a teen- speaking for hours with a friend on the phone and generating a large phone bill. It’s the worst/only bad thing I’ve ever done as a teen

he demands money even now and finds it difficult to understand that I must provide for my children over them

they say I was awful for goikg to ibiza as a 20 year old - like I was wasting money - and like I was a layabout wasting my life.

it’s emotionally immature, toxic, unpredictable, narcisstic behaviour

I always felt like they loved me in their own way - but loved themselves more and were really bad at regulating feelings or behaviour - and never bothered

There’s a lot there and I probably need therapy

Go NC with him, seriously.

I can relate to a lot of what you’ve described with my highly narcissistic parent, and being so scared as a child - I lived in a constant state of anxiety. Going NC as an adult has been one of the best decisions of my life.

Cloudburstings · 27/05/2023 11:53

@Froggles1

i also think part of parenting well is being open to hearing what you children have to say about it, whether when they’re children or as adults looking back.

this isn’t a conversation I could have with my parents that would get us anywhere.

is get a lot of defensiveness and self justification and minimising of my experience.

hearing a genuine ‘yes I can see that was hard for you and I’m sorry, I wish I could do it differently’ would be healing but isn’t available.

Iamafaithful · 27/05/2023 11:30

I barely have a relationship with my DM any more. It's only since having children and realising that I wasn't happy with how my DM treated my DC and also that I could never do or say some of the horrible things she has done and said to me when I was young, that I've realised that she wasn't (and still isn't) 'doing her best' at all. It's been devastating and I can never go back to 'not seeing' how very selfish and unkind she is. I can still remember how lucky I felt when I was first pregnant that my child would have such a loving grandmother. I was so so wrong.