Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's bothering me that some people appear to be pitying me because I have 3 girls

209 replies

Hello55 · 26/05/2023 11:55

I had my 3rd girl last year and i hate that during this time a few people have made comments like they are pitying me for having 3 girls. I love them they are my world. It bothers me how dare they? Anyone else experienced this and how have you stopped it bothering you? I'm trying not to let what other people think bother me but I can't help it sometimes and it eats away at me. What can I do? For background I am Asian and traditionally boys are more favoured by people. Have had the odd comment from people from other backgrounds.. 1 person from a white background asking if we would try for a boy!

Also since having my 3rd i have become more conscious about things down the line when they get older.. i worry for them as it is a scary world we live in. Anyone else do this and how do you deal with it?

AIBU for letting peoples comments bother me and also having these future worries?

Tia X

OP posts:
Meixo · 26/05/2023 16:26

I would only want girls, a daughter is your daughter for life as the saying goes.

phoenixrosehere · 26/05/2023 16:21

windowsopen · 26/05/2023 15:00

I'm one of three girls, and two of us were very easy as teenagers, I'd say. Yes, we could be moody, but we never gave our parents reason to worry or despair. The third of us was probably more of a worry for a while, but that wasn't related to her being a girl. The idea that girls are worse as teens seems strange to me. It's largely down to up-bringing and fate/genetics/mental health. If anything, I'd worry more about the teen years with a son than a daughter.

YANBU to be annoyed. People should keep their negative opinions to themselves. In general, don't daughters tend to be more involved in their parents' lives than sons, more likely to visit, offer help, etc.? It seems to be the case, in my experience.

The idea that girls are worse as teens seems strange to me. It's largely down to up-bringing and fate/genetics/mental health. If anything, I'd worry more about the teen years with a son than a daughter.

Same. I’m one of two girls, dad hoped to try for a son, but mum wasn’t going through a third pregnancy due to having pre-eclampsia and us born 2 months prematurely. My sister and I did well in school, won awards, both have degrees, independent and successful. We were rarely ever in trouble, and parents could say that they didn’t really have to worry about us, who we were with, and who are friends were.

BQ91 · 26/05/2023 16:19

we have 2 daughters and when we found out the second was a girl my husband was delighted and told everyone at work, to which someone he knew said ‘oh I’m gutted for ya mate’!!

Thethreegirls · 26/05/2023 16:19

I have 2 sisters and no brothers and I am from Indian background.
I remember whole of my childhood people asking me about my siblings and I telling them that we are 3 sisters and then them clarifying no brother?!
It's like I would remove brother from my sibling list!!!

Also my dad's brother has 5 daughters so we are like 8 cousin sisters in 2 families. You can imagine the gloom and doom that surrounded all of us!

In all of my family, us girls have done far far better than the boys and have been there for our parents, whenever needed. One of my sister and my cousins have managed to have successful careers in the same town where our/their parents live, so that they are always closer.

Now the same people who questioned all of our parents choices and independence we were given(even after being girls, the horror!), do not stop singing praises.

Now I am also having my first child(that too rainbow) , a girl, I am preparing myself to answer such people. I have had some passing comments but I am waiting for her to be out in the world before I start the war, lol!

I find girls far more compassionate and are closer to their parents, especially in South Asian context. They see their parents combating the prejudice, it makes them stronger too.

So don't worry about it and don't let the comments bother you. People are set in their ways and cannot see beyond what they have seen/experienced. It is on us to ensure our daughters are strong enough to stand up to such prejudices.

Hello55 · 26/05/2023 16:16

RoseGoldEagle · 26/05/2023 13:19

Is there a part of you that would have liked a son OP? (I think it’s fine to say that if so, it’s not the same as saying you didn’t want your girls). I think peoples comments can be annoying, but only really hurtful if they hit a nerve. I would have loved to have three girls so I know those opinions wouldn’t have bothered me, other than rolling my eyes a bit. (I have a mixture which I also love, they’re all such different personalities and their sex doesn’t really come into it). Congrats on your gorgeous girls 😊

Aww thank you. We didn't find out the gender we always wanted 3 children and that was that.. we loved the idea of them having more support between them through life . If I had had a son I would have seen him in the same way as my daughters.. my child who i will always love and adore x

OP posts:
Opaque11 · 26/05/2023 16:07

Yanbu, I never understand why people do this. It's not like they get to keep the child they 'wish' for so what does it have to do with them. I would have to say something about this in case her words extend to her treatment of your children.

MidsummerNightsDream · 26/05/2023 16:06

Ilovemycatalot · 26/05/2023 15:06

My parents had 2 girls and a boy. The boy (my brother ) never bothers with anyone and is only interested in what his wife wants. Me and my sister are close and always bother with my parents. I’ve seen this a lot with sons once they marry everything is about their partner and partners family. If you have a son you will just be the dreaded MIL that you read about on here so much. Very happy I have a dd.

Huge generalisation there!

Onomatopoeia4 · 26/05/2023 16:05

DontTouchMyMug · 26/05/2023 15:58

I do sometimes comment to twins. I just think they seem so wonderful and special 💕 (and I know how hard it was to look after just one baby at a time) it's a mixture of wonder and awe and just their cuteness.

I'm the same. I also think that twins are great 😍

MidsummerNightsDream · 26/05/2023 16:03

I have 2 boys (teenagers now) and learned a long time ago to shut this down with the truth so my standard reply was always that after 2 miscarriages, I felt extremely blessed to have 2 healthy babies. People don’t comment on it now my boys are older.

Congratulations on your 3 lovely daughters, OP.

DontTouchMyMug · 26/05/2023 15:58

I do sometimes comment to twins. I just think they seem so wonderful and special 💕 (and I know how hard it was to look after just one baby at a time) it's a mixture of wonder and awe and just their cuteness.

Onomatopoeia4 · 26/05/2023 15:57

Ignore those people, they are stupid.

I have one boy and one girl. I am currently pregnant with my third.

I wouldn't have minded if my two were the same gender and I don't care what my 3rd baby is.

The main thing is that they are healthy. That's all that matters.

bittertwisted · 26/05/2023 15:33

I have 3 boys
Got told when DS3 was a baby, and I was in the supermarket with them, that I must be devastated
I breezily replied not to worry, I was going to get him adopted and get a girl instead 😂

He is 16 tomorrow, nearly didn't have him because I was in a DV situation, he is my greatest blessing

Children are people, they are all different

I am the girliest girl ever, one of 3 girls, went to a single sex school
and have LOVED being a mum to only boys

Someone pitying only girls is highly unusual in my experience

IAmTheWalrus85 · 26/05/2023 15:32

windowsopen · 26/05/2023 15:00

I'm one of three girls, and two of us were very easy as teenagers, I'd say. Yes, we could be moody, but we never gave our parents reason to worry or despair. The third of us was probably more of a worry for a while, but that wasn't related to her being a girl. The idea that girls are worse as teens seems strange to me. It's largely down to up-bringing and fate/genetics/mental health. If anything, I'd worry more about the teen years with a son than a daughter.

YANBU to be annoyed. People should keep their negative opinions to themselves. In general, don't daughters tend to be more involved in their parents' lives than sons, more likely to visit, offer help, etc.? It seems to be the case, in my experience.

The idea that girls are worse as teens seems strange to me. It's largely down to up-bringing and fate/genetics/mental health. If anything, I'd worry more about the teen years with a son than a daughter.

I agree with you. I think that the idea that girls are worse as teenagers comes from the general perception that boys don’t/shouldn’t share their emotions, so are less ‘hassle’. Which of course is completely unhealthy.

IAmTheWalrus85 · 26/05/2023 15:30

It must be hard to have girls in a culture where sons are valued more than daughters.

I can only relate in the sense that I have two boys and people often assume I must be disappointed (but weirdly assume my husband must be delighted - he is, but he would have been thrilled with 2 girls too!)

But I don’t think that’s the same as a cultural preference for boys.

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/05/2023 15:29

I have no children but my much loved younger brother has 2 daughters (and no sons).

He has said several times that he loves being a Dad of daughters only and he cannot even imagine having boys in the house.

KirstenBlest · 26/05/2023 15:26

@RoseGoldEagle , I wanted to ask that too, but wasn't brave enough. The 'one of each' hadn't crossed my mind until i had DD2.

Amuseaboosh · 26/05/2023 15:22

frazzledasarock · 26/05/2023 14:57

I’m from an Asian background and have four girls.

I do get pitying looks and questions if I’ll have another in the hopes of a boy.

I did ask my mother who was utterly bitchy about my older girls what amazing accomplishment her son has achieved that surpass her daughters.

and to be frank my older girls have achieved more than that.

so now I get the same women who looked down on me for having girls wanting their sons to marry my girls.

People have too much time on their hands.

enjoy your family.

Keep those people away from your amazing girls!!!! Let them blaze their own trail 🔥🔥🔥🔥❤️

Amuseaboosh · 26/05/2023 15:19

Another Mamma to 3 daughters here, also Indian so completely understand your feelings.

When my 3rd daughter was born, I was read. All the busy bodies that made their sad face comments were promptly handed a box of pink Ladoo's (Indian sweets, traditionally yellow and are handed out when a boy is born), and told to celebrate her arrival. Their faces were a picture!

I'm currently pregnant, very early, and if all goes well, I'd LOVE to have a healthy baby, boy, or girl!!

As for the future, teach your girls to advocate, advocate, and then advocate some more. Also, teach them about autonomy and that they will absolutely have to speak up for themselves because when it comes down to it, they are their own greatest strength and voice!!

You've been blessed with 3 healthy children, screw everyone else, and just enjoy them.

3sthemagicnumber · 26/05/2023 15:09

Lots of good advice and suggestions on here. My kids are teens now, and the comments about the shape and make-up of your family definitely tail off as they get older, so hopefully you can look forward to it naturally easing anyway.

People do say stupid things about kids. My sister has one of each, and was taken aback at how many people congratulated her on that specific 'achievement' when her second was born.

People just don't think. I have twins and when they were babies you couldn't walk down the street without someone commenting (very often in a nice way!). I remember one elderly woman stopping me, peering into the buggy, announcing that they were twins and following it up with: 'I'm a twin. I hated it. I still hate it.' And off she went. I have no idea what possible reason you would have for saying that to a new mum of twins!

Ilovemycatalot · 26/05/2023 15:06

My parents had 2 girls and a boy. The boy (my brother ) never bothers with anyone and is only interested in what his wife wants. Me and my sister are close and always bother with my parents. I’ve seen this a lot with sons once they marry everything is about their partner and partners family. If you have a son you will just be the dreaded MIL that you read about on here so much. Very happy I have a dd.

Saucemonkey · 26/05/2023 15:01

I have 3 DDs , our family is great . I often hear my dh saying how lucky he is to be surrounded by women ! Lol!

windowsopen · 26/05/2023 15:00

I'm one of three girls, and two of us were very easy as teenagers, I'd say. Yes, we could be moody, but we never gave our parents reason to worry or despair. The third of us was probably more of a worry for a while, but that wasn't related to her being a girl. The idea that girls are worse as teens seems strange to me. It's largely down to up-bringing and fate/genetics/mental health. If anything, I'd worry more about the teen years with a son than a daughter.

YANBU to be annoyed. People should keep their negative opinions to themselves. In general, don't daughters tend to be more involved in their parents' lives than sons, more likely to visit, offer help, etc.? It seems to be the case, in my experience.

neonjumper · 26/05/2023 14:59

Hello55 · 26/05/2023 11:55

I had my 3rd girl last year and i hate that during this time a few people have made comments like they are pitying me for having 3 girls. I love them they are my world. It bothers me how dare they? Anyone else experienced this and how have you stopped it bothering you? I'm trying not to let what other people think bother me but I can't help it sometimes and it eats away at me. What can I do? For background I am Asian and traditionally boys are more favoured by people. Have had the odd comment from people from other backgrounds.. 1 person from a white background asking if we would try for a boy!

Also since having my 3rd i have become more conscious about things down the line when they get older.. i worry for them as it is a scary world we live in. Anyone else do this and how do you deal with it?

AIBU for letting peoples comments bother me and also having these future worries?

Tia X

You might want to follow pink ladoo project ... it challenges gender prejudice in south Asian communities.

This prejudice sometimes also rears its head in other communities.

Families that have boys may also face this but both responses are usually still centred around the worth of girls being less ... something to dress up , protect and bring a 'gentleness' to family dynamics .

frazzledasarock · 26/05/2023 14:57

I’m from an Asian background and have four girls.

I do get pitying looks and questions if I’ll have another in the hopes of a boy.

I did ask my mother who was utterly bitchy about my older girls what amazing accomplishment her son has achieved that surpass her daughters.

and to be frank my older girls have achieved more than that.

so now I get the same women who looked down on me for having girls wanting their sons to marry my girls.

People have too much time on their hands.

enjoy your family.

Moooooooooooooooooo · 26/05/2023 14:56

What other people think and say doesn’t matter.

Sit and think about it for a moment … no matter what the subject is, unless someone close has died/had an accident/is very ill, what difference is it going to make to your life? Will them saying things change your life? Will them thinking things change your life? No! Nothing will change. But YOU have to change the way you react. Simply realise none of it matters and then you’ll free yourself from all that worry and anxiety.

Swipe left for the next trending thread