Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Governor removed child from school

82 replies

Schooldinners1 · 26/05/2023 09:01

AIBU for more traction. Governor at our primary stepped down and removed her daughter from reception. What would you make of this? There's been a bit of chatter.

OP posts:
Stepbystep100 · 26/05/2023 10:42

You aren't to know. But don't gossip. She may have become a Governor thinking she could get some sort of special treatment for her child and it didn't work. Probably wasn't that but bear in mind it can be any number of reasons that this has happened.

PicaK · 26/05/2023 10:40

Ask the Clerk for copies of the minutes since Sept.

notsorighteousthesedays · 26/05/2023 10:38

It's quite a long time ago now but still rankles.... I was vice chair of governors at a faith school, firstly parent governor and then asked to stand again as a faith governor. Huge mistake because my position then was in the gift of the Bish.

Anyway I ended up chair of some committees, including the renumeration which had delegated responsibility for the salaries of the SMT.

The Head was at the top of the salary scale and due to retire in a year or two, and the parish priest, who was Chair of Governors, asked my committee to approve an exceptional increase to the salary scale so that they would get an annual increment each year until retirement (on top of any general pay increase). The committee discussed it at length and decided that the Head was fairly paid considering other factors such as size and student population and that it couldn't justify authorizing such an increase. All ok we thought and duly reported up the chain.
However priest and HT had already assumed this was a done deal!

HT went off sick and PP complained about 'my' decision. It resulted in the Diocese requiring me to step down as I was bringing governors into disrepute. As the cttee then had no chair the Chair of governors was then able to approve the change and the HT coasted along another couple of years sucking up a chunk of the staffing budget which could have been better spent elsewhere.

If I had remained a parent governor they would not have been able to do this. It really shocked me and left me feeling very vulnerable. With hindsight I was outmanoeuvred because as a parent governor I had pushed through some changes regarding safeguarding and equal opportunities that the school were reluctant to take on board.

Phew! It still hurts. Congratulations if you've read to the end. 😊

MwahHaHa · 26/05/2023 10:33

Posters are going to fall over themselves to tell you its not your business and there is something wrong with you for asking.

In reality though, of course you are going to wonder if they know something about the school that you don't. Every other poster here would too.

YourFault · 26/05/2023 10:32

It’s got absolutely nothing to do with you. Keep your nose and shit out of it.

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 26/05/2023 10:15

Honestly, keep your beak out. Unless you personally have an issue with the school just carry on as you were.
No wonder schools struggle to get parent governors.

Plasticplantpot · 26/05/2023 10:13

I resigned as a governor as I didn’t feel the school was doing its best for the children. There was clear evidence of this. In the process of moving DC now. They and others were/are being failed.

SpidersAreShitheads · 26/05/2023 10:12

I was a school governor for many years.

Parent governors have the same rights and influence as any other type of governor. So even if their child leaves, they can still stay on and see out their term if they have a passion for supporting the school.

Not every school is a good fit for every child. That doesn't mean it's a "bad" school. Some schools cater particularly well for SEN children, others are a better fit for academic children. Others may have a better sports provision.

Our school was outstanding for SEN - and I really do mean outstanding. But some pupils who were at the top of their class and very gifted academically could have done better elsewhere. Sometimes we saw those children moved to another school, and honestly, it was probably the right decision. That's no reflection on the school where I was a governor.

OP, your posts sound very judgemental. If you have an issue with the school or you have concerns about safeguarding etc, then you absolutely need to raise them. But base your decisions on facts, not idle speculation about the actions of another parent.

Newspeaker · 26/05/2023 10:02

Op, this is really none of your business and it's such a shame, but inevitable, that parents will gather and make up rumours when they are not privy to the facts.
Parent governors are entitled to see out their term of office, even if their child leaves the school. That's usually a 4 year term and they can be really effective governors.
Some parent governors are really only on the board to feel they have an "in" on the things that affect their children, and in the hope they can use their influence to have things in place that are good for their child (they should get a big wake up call on that one!). A lot of parents have no further interest in the school, or being a governor, when their children are no longer there so they step down.
Governors resign all the time for many reasons, so this really isn't a big deal.

Newspeaker · 26/05/2023 09:59

cyncope · 26/05/2023 09:36

This thread could be about me except it was a couple of years ago and it was my son not my daughter Grin

I moved him because, strictly with my parent hat on, he wasn't getting a good enough education and was having lots of supply teachers in Reception. I felt it was an important year and he needed stability. The teacher went off sick mid year and it wasn't clear if/when she would return.
There was another local school that had spaces in Reception and much better staff retention so I moved him.

Although I was a governor and committed to the school, my first priority was my child.

The school then asked me to step down as a governor as they felt it would upset other parents if I stayed (I wasn't actually a parent governor so could have stayed).

Parent governors can stay too. They are entitled to serve out their term even if their child leaves.

welshmercury · 26/05/2023 09:59

Apply for the governor vacancy and find out what’s going on from the inside

BlibBlabBlob · 26/05/2023 09:58

It's hard to come up with a reason for somebody who is a governor moving their child to another school just down the road that doesn't reflect badly on the school. But there might still be one.

@Schooldinners1 Was the parent a very new governor? (Might well have been, if their child was only in Reception?)

Maybe it's all about them: perhaps they fell out with the HT without especially good cause and decided to throw their toys out of the pram and flounce because of that.

Or maybe it has something to do with their child personally; I was a governor for many years and would still recommend that school for the vast majority of children DESPITE them utterly failing my own child - resulting in serious anxiety and school-based trauma. I could and still can see both sides of that particular situation. If your own child is really struggling then it's a hard line to walk as a governor and I wouldn't blame someone for throwing in the towel if it was still very early days. Much easier to start afresh and just be a parent, not a parent governor.

Or maybe they uncovered, with all the extra information they were privy to as a governor that isn't available to parents, a serious issue that made them no longer feel it was a safe/suitable place for their own child to be educated. You'd hope they would take follow-up action on this, if so, but people often do what's easy rather than what's right.

Ultimately you won't know unless you actually ask the former parent/governor. But even then you'll only get their side of the story. And school won't talk to you about it, so you'll never get their side of the story.

Nameinspirationneeded · 26/05/2023 09:56

Dorisbonson · 26/05/2023 09:50

My parents moved me when my brother was bullied. My father was a governor, he thought it was only right to resign as his kids were no longer at the school.

I would say it's personal and none of your business really.

This - would you prefer that they stayed as a governor with no stake in the school. If you want to know more about the school put yourself forward as a governor. From interacting with a number professionally it’s a difficult, often thankless task. If there was gossip about a former governor I’d probably resign myself if I was on the board.

Dorisbonson · 26/05/2023 09:50

My parents moved me when my brother was bullied. My father was a governor, he thought it was only right to resign as his kids were no longer at the school.

I would say it's personal and none of your business really.

MichelleScarn · 26/05/2023 09:47

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 26/05/2023 09:02

Fuck all to do with you. Steer clear of gossip, it’s unfair.

And that should be used on so many threads!!

Schooldinners1 · 26/05/2023 09:46

Yes I think rightfully so the concerns were over standards or safeguarding so I don't think people are talking out of turn to be concerned over that.

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 26/05/2023 09:42

Dh was a governor at dc's school.
DD1 had had a (generally popular) teacher who I knew wouldn't suit dd2 at all.
There were two forms a year so she had a 50/50 chance of having them. Me and dh discussed what we did if she was allocated this teacher and we decided we felt strongly enough to move her. Dh felt that if we did that (we had no other dc at the school then) then he would also resign from being a governor as he wouldn't feel right being a parent governor at a school he'd removed his dc from. However we would still have applied for ds to that school.

We hadn't decided whether I (not dh because of being a governor) would have a quiet word with the head and let her know about dd. As they mixed the classes up, it wouldn't have been hard to make sure dd2 didn't have this teacher and it wouldn't have effected anyone else. But equally well, we didn't want it to sound like a threat, or blackmail-it wasn't meant to be one, simply what we'd decided.
Thankfully before we'd made the decision, that teacher announced her retirement, so we never had to decide.

There was no point we thought it wasn't a good school.

cyncope · 26/05/2023 09:36

This thread could be about me except it was a couple of years ago and it was my son not my daughter Grin

I moved him because, strictly with my parent hat on, he wasn't getting a good enough education and was having lots of supply teachers in Reception. I felt it was an important year and he needed stability. The teacher went off sick mid year and it wasn't clear if/when she would return.
There was another local school that had spaces in Reception and much better staff retention so I moved him.

Although I was a governor and committed to the school, my first priority was my child.

The school then asked me to step down as a governor as they felt it would upset other parents if I stayed (I wasn't actually a parent governor so could have stayed).

Redebs · 26/05/2023 09:30

Quite possibly a personality issue, unrelated to standards or safeguarding.
Other parents will have no more information than you, so don't get drawn into gossip. Or create any.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 26/05/2023 09:29

I would guess they didn't get their first choice school last year but have been offered it now and decided it is still early enough to change over.

Schooldinners1 · 26/05/2023 09:26

They've moved their child to a school around the corner 3-5 minutes away.

OP posts:
Schooldinners1 · 26/05/2023 09:24

Well they seemed to be quite judgemental and now it seems they decided things weren't to their standard.

So it makes sense that others are thinking is what your child has not good enough after inspection?

OP posts:
Idtotallybangdreamoftheendlessnotgonnalie · 26/05/2023 09:23

There's a primary school near me that is hemorrhaging pupils like crazy because it is so mismanaged. 7 have left in year 1, and I've heard of 3 in reception, and a few more in the upper years.

I'd suspect if the family have moved to a nearby school then the governor has uncovered a practice that she didn't like, or her child has been failed.

Pixiedust1234 · 26/05/2023 09:20

Maybe they are in the process of moving house.

Maybe a parent is being nasty because of their role as Governor, so removed child as a precaution.

Maybe they feel uncomfortable because after stepping down as Governor due to new work shifts, people are gossiping and posting on sm and generally making their life unpleasant so removed their child to start fresh elsewhere.

It could be anything.

Schooldinners1 · 26/05/2023 09:18

I think it's just the concern of them being a parent as if it's something that would be concerning to other parents too.

OP posts: