Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have an electric vehicle? Would you recommend it?

180 replies

LordGribeau · 25/05/2023 18:40

Just that really. We are looking at replacing our current mitsubishi outlander with an EV. Possibly a Kia Niro or Peugeot 2008. If you have one, would you recommend it? Are they good as a family car? DC are no longer in booster seats, so fit a bit more comfortably in the back.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
PuzzledObserver · 26/05/2023 17:45

GCWorkNightmare · 26/05/2023 14:57

I can’t see us going full electric until we absolutely have to. By which point the oceans will probably be full of this set of electric cars. How green.

Why would the expensive, rare elements used in EV’s (and a lot of other things, actually) be dumped in the ocean? They will be reused, recycled, repurposed.

Just as a lot of the components in ICE cars are, actually.

FergalforPM · 26/05/2023 16:44

I'd love something like a Tesla but I'd have to sell my house to pay for it - I am astonished by all these people driving new or nearly hyper expensive cars. I confess I drive old bangers - by buying sensibly I have achieved really low cost motoring for many years. I am not sure how I'll ever make the transition - I tend to buy cars that already have a high mileage at the point where others are running away from them. Then I keep them running for many more years.

I understand the environmental arguments and I am lucky that I could charge at home, but there are going to have to be a lot more banger territory (price!) electric cars around before I can switch.

junglejane66 · 26/05/2023 15:47

mobear · 25/05/2023 20:34

We have a Tesla Model Y and a toddler. We love it. I would definitely recommend it.

The Tesla or the toddler?

GCWorkNightmare · 26/05/2023 14:57

mondaytosunday · 26/05/2023 08:39

Im finding this very encouraging. In 2020 we test drove a number snd my daughter said riding in the back seat wasn't good due to the shape of most windows. As it happens her brother moved out so she's only in the back and handful of times. Also I was worried moving to a mid terrace with no way to charge at home. Then I actually moved, and found out there are three charging spots at the end of every block, the supermarkets all have charging spots - anyway charging near home not an issue.
I think it's more environmentally friendly to drive my current car for a bit longer and hopefully in the next few years they'll increase the range of electric cars.
My question: I heard the battery only lasts ten years and then it's a huge amount to replace them? Or do people sell their cars before that becomes an issue?

I can’t see us going full electric until we absolutely have to. By which point the oceans will probably be full of this set of electric cars. How green.

GCWorkNightmare · 26/05/2023 14:54

Also looking for a replacement for a diesel outlander and can’t find anything that’s a close match at all.

MidlandCatGirl · 26/05/2023 14:51

Actually picking up our Tesla tomorrow - starting to get a little bit excited about it now 😂

weightymatters73 · 26/05/2023 14:48

hattie43 · 26/05/2023 06:02

Nope not ready yet . My diesel suv is at the age where I'd normally swap it up but I'm not ready for electric .
From what I've heard from others they are fine little local runaround's if you can charge from home but not good for long journeys that have to be meticulously planned . The infrastructure is not ready .
I also feel sorry for the queue of people in the supermarket car park having to waste Saturday morning charging the car .
I also didn't realise until I read the article in the Times that the batteries can explode in real hot weather .
All in all I think at the moment all the trying to be trendies will rush off and buy them but the majority, me included , will wait longer to see if they are a viable alternative as time goes on .

Spoiler alert - batteries do not explode in hot weather....

weightymatters73 · 26/05/2023 14:44

jannier · 25/05/2023 20:51

Ask someone who's coming to the end of the 7 year battery life and have a pile of valueless junk

😂I smell an EV troll.... EVERYTHING you have said is a complete load of💩

EV's are 9 times LESS likely to catch fire. and 19 times less likely to catch fire than hybrids.
Lithium mines where kids are exploited are mostly for cheap L-ion batteries in calculators and cheap phones not cars.
"Lithium lakes" - batteries a) aren't yet being ditched from most working cars and b) for scrapped cars they are either sold on 2nd hand or repurposed into battery storage units for solar.l
7 year old cars are holding their value and the batteries are lasting WAY longer than predicted.
Batteries do occasionally need repairing and/or replacing, but you DO NOT do it at the main dealer, just like you wouldn't with an engine. Main dealers are, surprise surprise, expensive.

PuzzledObserver · 26/05/2023 14:43

Newspeaker · 26/05/2023 13:37

Nobody really cares about the damage these cars are causing to the environment and living conditions in other countries do they?

Strangely, some people seem to really worry about the damage that EV’s do to the environment while glossing over the damage that petrol and diesel cars do.

goodkidsmaadhouse · 26/05/2023 14:30

Newspeaker · 26/05/2023 13:37

Nobody really cares about the damage these cars are causing to the environment and living conditions in other countries do they?

Well, tell us about the more environmentally friendly alternatives?

Newspeaker · 26/05/2023 13:37

Nobody really cares about the damage these cars are causing to the environment and living conditions in other countries do they?

xabia · 26/05/2023 10:31

We absolutely love our Tesla!

motherofawhirlwind · 26/05/2023 10:25

jannier · 25/05/2023 20:51

Ask someone who's coming to the end of the 7 year battery life and have a pile of valueless junk

So 10 year old Ampera here - battery still good, resale value decent (£8k) and we've saved a fortune over the years Smile

BankMum · 26/05/2023 10:20

We have a hybrid and several of my colleagues have EVs thanks to our company's green lease scheme. I think there is a huge variation between cars and where you are in the country.

My colleagues with Teslas all love them, no exceptions. One disorganised colleague hates her BMW not because of thìe car itself but because she finds it so difficult to figure out where the decent charging points are and factor in the time it takes to charge. You do forget that ICE cars are filled in minutes whereas with EVs you usually need hours to fully charge if you can't use a super charger. One colleague feels hard done by because his car seems to be really slow to charge and he is limited on which chargers he can access.

Also as PP mention, driving at high speeds, hills, using lights, heaters etc. decrease your available miles which can be hard to get your head around. I think EVs are great but probably not for everyone right now.

Fourmagpies · 26/05/2023 10:19

hattie43 · 26/05/2023 07:13

Yes it was an article about a lady who owned a cafe in a row of 8 shops . Her battery exploded in the heat , knocked out her cafe and damaged other properties and the insurers wouldn't pay , she lost her car and her premise / livelihood.

It also says in that article that non electric cars are more likely to catch fire.

CurlewKate · 26/05/2023 10:04

I think you have to think very carefully about what you need from a car. Ours is perfect for the life we lead now. We live in the country, and do a lot of short journeys-it's 10 miles to the town/supermarket, 8 to our son's house, 3 to the station. We both mostly wfh and always use public transport for any long journeys. And we can easily plug in outside our house. When we had small children we used to drive to visit grandparents regularly-250 miles- and go on a lot of camping trips. I honestly don't think it would have worked-public charging still isn't reliable enough for me to feel happy going further than a single charge range with a carful of children,dogs and tents. But the way we live now it's great. And like driving a dodgem car!!

Newspeaker · 26/05/2023 09:50

We had an electric car on lease and returned it. Not as much range as advertised and the stopping to charge was a pain.
We now have, among our car collection (!) a hybrid and a diesel that's ULEZ compliant.

I'm deeply uneasy about the rush to electric cars. It feels as if we're improving out environment at a huge cost to others - the issues around lithium, child slavery, disposal of batteries etc have already been mentioned. It's OK for us isn't it? Shut our eyes to the wider implications and human cost?
There are better alternatives out there that should have investment for development. Alternatives that don't have such a massive environmental cost. Even typing that I'm thinking what a bloody farce this all is.

BBNoM · 26/05/2023 09:37

@jannier we have an 8 year old Leaf that's still going strong

JuneShitfield · 26/05/2023 09:19

Niro and 2008 are much smaller than an Outlander. Neither were designed ground-up to be full EVs so the packaging is a bit compromised.

You could look at an MG 4 or a Cupra Born. Both EV only so better packaged for the platform and therefore more space. Hyundai Ioniq 5 worth a look too. Genesis GV60 too.

There’s a new one coming later this year — the Fisker Ocean. It’s a mid-size SUV and will have a really good range.

If you need the space, and can hold on, there are some bigger EVs on the way. Kia has the EV9 coming out and the next Peugeot 5008 will likely have plug-in and full EV versions.

TorviShieldMaiden · 26/05/2023 09:14

I have a Kia EV6 and I love it. 300 miles range in the warmer weather, 250 in winter. Does a fast charge at services in 25 minutes, which is fine to stop and have a coffee or lunch. I don’t regularly travel so far that I need to charge at services. I have a charger at home and charge overnight Ona special rate.

KingofCats · 26/05/2023 09:13

modgepodge · 26/05/2023 08:35

Are you using zap map? I thought that one had them all…agree the individual company’s apps which only show their own chargers are a pain.

I have no idea why chargers could’ve be like paying for petrol, just pay in advance/at the end for what you’ve used, rather than faffing around with multiple apps. That’s my biggest bugbear really.

There are a few not on zap map!
This was a SWARCO charger.

also what REALLY annoys me is they don’t show the price on the charger so you could stop it you only say want to spend £20. Often you have to google for the price per KW from that particular company and calculate it. Drives me mad. Surely not fair trading for consumers.

waterlego · 26/05/2023 09:11

Love seeing shocked Audi/BMW drivers as I zoom away from the lights etc!

Haha, yes! I missed your comment and then wrote something similar. It’s very satisfying!

waterlego · 26/05/2023 09:10

We’ve got a Nissan Leaf which we’ve had for about 7 years. It can only do 100 miles on a charge but it’s perfect for me as I work at various venues- all of which are local. other than that, the only driving we do is to local supermarkets/ferrying the kids to and from friends’ houses etc. We also have a large diesel car which we use for longer journeys.

The Leaf is so easy to drive and I love how quick the acceleration is. I’m always the first away from the lights 😂 Almost all of my driving is on smaller road under 60mph. The car will easily go 70mph but it gets through the charge very quickly at that pace. I think the technology has improved a lot in the time we’ve had ours.

We’re hoping to get a bigger EV with a much longer range but just saving up at the moment!

malmi · 26/05/2023 09:10

Battery degradation on modern EVs is minimal compared to the ones from just 15 years ago. Very unlikely you will need to replace the battery in the car's lifetime.

Swansandcustard · 26/05/2023 09:01

I have the e-Corsa. Easiest driving ever, like having a go-cart. The charging thing is just a mindset change, and the network is improving all the time (Thank you Kings Lynn Starbucks and your super-fast charging!). Goes like shit off a shovel too. Love seeing shocked Audi/BMW drivers as I zoom away from the lights etc!

Swipe left for the next trending thread