Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have an electric vehicle? Would you recommend it?

180 replies

LordGribeau · 25/05/2023 18:40

Just that really. We are looking at replacing our current mitsubishi outlander with an EV. Possibly a Kia Niro or Peugeot 2008. If you have one, would you recommend it? Are they good as a family car? DC are no longer in booster seats, so fit a bit more comfortably in the back.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Kaftanesque · 31/05/2023 16:22

Been driving electric for 7 years .A Leaf and now a Tesla.We have solar panels and mainly charge at home. I would never go back to petrol or diesel now and love not going near petrol pumps in particular. Plus great to drive.

FergalforPM · 31/05/2023 16:17

weightymatters73 · 31/05/2023 13:15

@CutYourCloth You need a model 3 or model Y - much much faster charging then the 100D's.... I know they are lovely cars but older charging tech.

@FergalforPM I would have a very careful calculate about what your car is costing you.... having done this both ways I found a Nissan Leaf on lease/pcp has about the same cost as my well looked after 10 year old petrol car as well as being much better for the environment. On one hand the "car" itself costs more, (but that can be offset or spread with finance) vs the servicing, repairs and petrol on the older vehicle. We now both have new lease EV vehicles and the cost overall is lower. You find that the repairs, servicing and petrol costs can mount up considerably on an older car.

Yeah, done the calcs, but also the convenience is low. I make a 336 mile round trip (168 each way) once a fortnight. I'd have to make at least one stop per leg, possibly more and though I can charge at home there's nowhere to charge overnight at the destination.

My current car is 20 years old, diesel and averages 50mpg on the trip. It's also an estate car so I can take my dog or carry stuff if I need to.

A 4K Leaf (cheapest I can find at present) would get me 80 miles on a (very) good day.

Current car will do 600+ miles on a tank of fuel, and I don't need to worry about using the aircon/heater of doing 70 on the motorway.

Having a Tesla would solve most of those problems, but they can't be had for £1850 outright purchase cost.

Oh, and servicing and MOT cost me less than £300.

FergalforPM · 31/05/2023 15:51

Panda89 · 31/05/2023 13:41

Most people we talk to are surprised by the price of our Tesla, they thought it would be much more expensive.
We lease it, my previous lease was a Volvo xc40, a new xc40 was the same price as the Tesla so it made sense to switch over as DH can charge for free at work.

Was your Tesla £1850 to buy outright like my latest car?

Until they are in that territory they are just a dream for me and no doubt plenty of others.

Panda89 · 31/05/2023 13:41

Most people we talk to are surprised by the price of our Tesla, they thought it would be much more expensive.
We lease it, my previous lease was a Volvo xc40, a new xc40 was the same price as the Tesla so it made sense to switch over as DH can charge for free at work.

GasPanic · 31/05/2023 13:36

I think if you do the mileage they are good.

A salesperson doing 200 miles per day, plus stuff like the company car tax relief they are going to work well.

If you are just buying a tesla to pop backwards and forwards to the shop though its going to be expensive motoring because you aren't recovering the money on fuel costs.

People say that the fuel top up is cheap (it is) but don't point out that they cost a lot more to start off with than petrol/diesel.

There is also the issue that with relatively new tech something may go horribly wrong and cost a fortune. Although every indication so far is that they are pretty reliable and cheap to maintain.

weightymatters73 · 31/05/2023 13:15

@CutYourCloth You need a model 3 or model Y - much much faster charging then the 100D's.... I know they are lovely cars but older charging tech.

@FergalforPM I would have a very careful calculate about what your car is costing you.... having done this both ways I found a Nissan Leaf on lease/pcp has about the same cost as my well looked after 10 year old petrol car as well as being much better for the environment. On one hand the "car" itself costs more, (but that can be offset or spread with finance) vs the servicing, repairs and petrol on the older vehicle. We now both have new lease EV vehicles and the cost overall is lower. You find that the repairs, servicing and petrol costs can mount up considerably on an older car.

HashBrownandBeans · 28/05/2023 05:41

FergalforPM · 26/05/2023 16:44

I'd love something like a Tesla but I'd have to sell my house to pay for it - I am astonished by all these people driving new or nearly hyper expensive cars. I confess I drive old bangers - by buying sensibly I have achieved really low cost motoring for many years. I am not sure how I'll ever make the transition - I tend to buy cars that already have a high mileage at the point where others are running away from them. Then I keep them running for many more years.

I understand the environmental arguments and I am lucky that I could charge at home, but there are going to have to be a lot more banger territory (price!) electric cars around before I can switch.

We do the exact same as you, though our current car is beautiful and has low mileage, weve had some right old bangers in the past. We can often get a couple of years out of a £1000 car. It’s a very economical way to own a car. We often get the same scrap value that we paid for the car two years later.
there is no way we will ever have £10k for an EV. And our house is 500 yards away from our private parking space so no option for a charging point.

allhailthebrain · 28/05/2023 02:03

Had a Nissan Leaf for over 5 years - would never go back! We both drive my car, from preference, if we can!

CutYourCloth · 28/05/2023 01:50

Only get an EV if you have a charger installed at home and you’re driving locally. E.g., if you live in London, daily distances not too far outside of the M25.
Or if you have access to another vehicle that is not an EV.

You’re stuffed if you need to do longer journeys, as the U.K. have been slow to implement the infrastructure for charging points, esp. fast chargers.

We had two Teslas P100D for four years. The network of Tesla superchargers were great, but added a lot of time to journeys further afield. The battery on one of the Tesla’s died twice and had to be replaced. Long wait for the battery replacement. The first battery replacement took several months towards the end of one of the last two Covid lockdowns.

Tesla give amazing Customer Service and we were given a replacement Tesla car immediately, but the only downside to that was we had return the loan Tesla car to the dealership that we had collected it from when our repaired car was ready for collection. Not ideal when you’ve broken down 2 hours away from home. We had do so that journey up and down the M1 at stupid o’clock more than a few times to avoid traffic and make it back home in time for work and the school run.
We luckily had one Tesla each, so had at least one car to drive each time the battery died on the same car. The last time the car battery died, the car broke down at a motorway service station. Tesla swiftly organised an Uber to collect DP from the service station, which then took him to the nearest Tesla Dealership to pick up a loan car so he could continue on with his journey. I was luckily not driving with the kids in the dead of night, in the back of beyond each time the car battery died.

The plus side of having a Tesla loan car was the free charging at the Tesla superchargers, so we saved a lot of money not having to charge overnight at home for months. Especially when had a loan car for a couple of months last year when energy prices went through the roof.

Another plus, is that Tesla car repairs can be carried out at home by a technician, and you don’t have to be at home to give access to the car which is brilliant.

We recently went back to a petrol car, and we’re planning on getting a 2nd car soon which will be another EV. We’ll only use the petrol car for longer journeys.

We’re also relived that we got rid of both Teslas not too long after Musk took over Twitter, and he subsequently exposed himself for who is really is, and the Tesla share price plummeted. We wouldn’t get another Tesla.

I’m not sure exactly how much brand new Teslas currently cost now, but they initially were extortionately overpriced. We were able to off-set the high costs, as DP sourced a few through his business as company cars. It’s not worth it if you cannot off-set the cost this way.

TorviShieldMaiden · 28/05/2023 00:36

Yeah it’s for solar panels and other green energy storage I think.

VanGoghsDog · 28/05/2023 00:27

TorviShieldMaiden · 27/05/2023 08:42

For power, I don’t know the details, but lots of people on a previous thread said they had them i their house. Presumably use them for electricity.

So, charge them, then use them for electricity? I thought we had mains electric these days?

I suppose if you have solar panels it makes sense. Or maybe low overnight rates? Other than I can't see any reason for having them.

GCWorkNightmare · 27/05/2023 21:05

excab · 27/05/2023 19:15

If money is no object, what about Genesis GV70? I assume GV60 would be far too small for you.

Driving the petrol one in a couple of weeks. It’s a decent price for the spec!

excab · 27/05/2023 19:15

GCWorkNightmare · 27/05/2023 10:32

Wasn’t impressed on a test drive. It’s much smaller than the outlander and a very boring drive.

ford mach e was fun (in “untamed” mode) But terrible boot space and no good for the mileage I do.

quite liked the Tesla but husband won’t give Musk money.

they’re all several button presses to disable the safety features too. And have to do it every time you start the car.

may end up building a new car myself at this rate.

couple of petrol options I could possibly compromise on.

If money is no object, what about Genesis GV70? I assume GV60 would be far too small for you.

TheMooney · 27/05/2023 11:20

waterlego · 26/05/2023 19:16

Driving personal cars is bad full stop for the environment, but so is building houses and lots of other things we need to do for economic productivity.

True. The internet itself is one of the biggest offenders in terms of CO2 production, so using the internet to tell other people off about the environment is always going to seem rather ironic.

Also, the reality is that there just isn't the public transport and cycling infrastructure in place for a lot of people. I can support the development of those things and drive my ev for now, and I hope that one day I won't need a car.

Mummyford · 27/05/2023 11:16

GCWorkNightmare · 27/05/2023 10:32

Wasn’t impressed on a test drive. It’s much smaller than the outlander and a very boring drive.

ford mach e was fun (in “untamed” mode) But terrible boot space and no good for the mileage I do.

quite liked the Tesla but husband won’t give Musk money.

they’re all several button presses to disable the safety features too. And have to do it every time you start the car.

may end up building a new car myself at this rate.

couple of petrol options I could possibly compromise on.

@GCWorkNightmare

quite liked the Tesla but husband won’t give Musk money.

Yeah, I don't know whether to be relieved or chagrined that we bought ours before it became obvious he was a psychotic prick.

Mummyford · 27/05/2023 11:15

weightymatters73 · 27/05/2023 07:27

I have to say the first thing you find being a (long term!) EV owner is you very quickly find all the misinformation is just that! Particularly the one about deaf people getting run over in car parks, I wouldn't be exaggerating to say I have seen that one a million times....despite the fact all EV's have a noise at slow speed, so they aren't noiseless.

Anyhow, You asked a question. For £4000 you are going to find it hard to pick up a good EV, however do consider the costs, particularly if you have home charging or access to any free chargers.....

Nissan Leafs do exist near this price range, but if you are travelling any distance it wouldn't be suitable. You probably need to spend a bit more to get one with a decent range.

Bear in mind; Fuel costs are far less, servicing costs are far less, my experience is that repair costs are far less as there is less to go wrong...

I would buy an older nissan leaf every day of the week as a second car, they are fantastic, but the tech is getting old now and you need to charge them at home only.

We have a Tesla X, which we love, although wouldn't mind if it was slightly narrower as we live in London. The mileage range is great, particularly if driven in chill mode for city driving, and the charging infrastructure is really good, although I'm not sure how seamless it would be for EVs without access to the Tesla chargers. Ours came with free lifetime super charging, which they might not offer anymore(?), but that offers a significant saving over time. Whenever we're away and rent a car, I'm reminded how much nicer EVs are than petrol cars in every way.

For me it was like the switch from a gas hob to induction. Some reluctance, a very slight learning curve and then the realisation you would have a hard time going back.

@weightymatters73

I have to say the first thing you find being a (long term!) EV owner is you very quickly find all the misinformation is just that! Particularly the one about deaf people getting run over in car parks,

Ours did an automated emergency stop once when someone stumbled off a curb, not quite into the path of the car, but very near it. I was going at a pretty low speed in normal driving mode and it was quite an emphatic hard stop - I find it hard to imagine many people being run over.

GCWorkNightmare · 27/05/2023 10:32

excab · 27/05/2023 00:47

Would the Skoda Enyaq work at all?

Wasn’t impressed on a test drive. It’s much smaller than the outlander and a very boring drive.

ford mach e was fun (in “untamed” mode) But terrible boot space and no good for the mileage I do.

quite liked the Tesla but husband won’t give Musk money.

they’re all several button presses to disable the safety features too. And have to do it every time you start the car.

may end up building a new car myself at this rate.

couple of petrol options I could possibly compromise on.

jannier · 27/05/2023 10:05

weightymatters73 · 27/05/2023 07:27

I have to say the first thing you find being a (long term!) EV owner is you very quickly find all the misinformation is just that! Particularly the one about deaf people getting run over in car parks, I wouldn't be exaggerating to say I have seen that one a million times....despite the fact all EV's have a noise at slow speed, so they aren't noiseless.

Anyhow, You asked a question. For £4000 you are going to find it hard to pick up a good EV, however do consider the costs, particularly if you have home charging or access to any free chargers.....

Nissan Leafs do exist near this price range, but if you are travelling any distance it wouldn't be suitable. You probably need to spend a bit more to get one with a decent range.

Bear in mind; Fuel costs are far less, servicing costs are far less, my experience is that repair costs are far less as there is less to go wrong...

I would buy an older nissan leaf every day of the week as a second car, they are fantastic, but the tech is getting old now and you need to charge them at home only.

To further complicate things I need 7 seats......basically I think I'm out of a job come the end of August.

TorviShieldMaiden · 27/05/2023 08:42

VanGoghsDog · 26/05/2023 23:05

What for?

For power, I don’t know the details, but lots of people on a previous thread said they had them i their house. Presumably use them for electricity.

JuneShitfield · 27/05/2023 08:35

grass321 · 27/05/2023 07:42

I think that’s Nio (one of the Chinese manufacturers that is looking to go global). Really interesting idea.

I've just dug up my report and you're right, it was Nio.

The Chinese companies seem pretty advanced in this area. BYD dethroned Tesla by global car sales last year. We just don't hear a lot about them in the U.K. market.

Yes, some of the Chinese makes are doing some really interesting stuff, tech-wise. I think Nio is coming to the UK, possibly Xpeng and one or two others as well.

I guess there’s an opportunity for these relatively new and unknown brands and companies to enter a market that up to now has been very sniffy about companies that don’t have 50+ years of heritage and a motor racing background. Electric changes that.

Plus some of the established brands are actually part- or fully owned by Chinese companies now. MG, Volvo, Polestar, Lotus, Smart.

Blueuggboots · 27/05/2023 07:46

I've got a Hyundai ionic. I love it.
My partner has a second hand Tesla. She also loves hers.

grass321 · 27/05/2023 07:42

I think that’s Nio (one of the Chinese manufacturers that is looking to go global). Really interesting idea.

I've just dug up my report and you're right, it was Nio.

The Chinese companies seem pretty advanced in this area. BYD dethroned Tesla by global car sales last year. We just don't hear a lot about them in the U.K. market.

JuneShitfield · 27/05/2023 07:32

grass321 · 27/05/2023 07:17

My brother's convinced that green energy could use a massive battery wall in our houses (I slightly drifted off 30 minutes in but I think charged by solar power and the like).

I wrote a report on EV vehicles for work and, I can't remember which company (there's a theme here...) but it let you swap your battery for a fully charged battery at service stations. Not sure how they regulate everyone trying to swap their six year old battery for a nice new version but it seemed an innovative approach...

I think that’s Nio (one of the Chinese manufacturers that is looking to go global). Really interesting idea.

weightymatters73 · 27/05/2023 07:27

jannier · 26/05/2023 21:24

Not a troll....haven't said anything about fires or safety. I've just heard battery life is 7 to 10 years and warranty only with the original owner. Replacements are very expensive so second hand is not a good option.....so I'd like to hear from people who have old EVs.
I've also heard disposal is a problem with them being shipped to 3rd world and causing pollution.....but as I'm in the new Ulez zone if you can provide info to say it's okay to go for a 7 year ev I'd love it ....my car budgets about £4000 if I'm lucky

I have to say the first thing you find being a (long term!) EV owner is you very quickly find all the misinformation is just that! Particularly the one about deaf people getting run over in car parks, I wouldn't be exaggerating to say I have seen that one a million times....despite the fact all EV's have a noise at slow speed, so they aren't noiseless.

Anyhow, You asked a question. For £4000 you are going to find it hard to pick up a good EV, however do consider the costs, particularly if you have home charging or access to any free chargers.....

Nissan Leafs do exist near this price range, but if you are travelling any distance it wouldn't be suitable. You probably need to spend a bit more to get one with a decent range.

Bear in mind; Fuel costs are far less, servicing costs are far less, my experience is that repair costs are far less as there is less to go wrong...

I would buy an older nissan leaf every day of the week as a second car, they are fantastic, but the tech is getting old now and you need to charge them at home only.

grass321 · 27/05/2023 07:17

TorviShieldMaiden · 26/05/2023 21:38

Lots of people use the old batteries in their house after they are no good for cars

My brother's convinced that green energy could use a massive battery wall in our houses (I slightly drifted off 30 minutes in but I think charged by solar power and the like).

I wrote a report on EV vehicles for work and, I can't remember which company (there's a theme here...) but it let you swap your battery for a fully charged battery at service stations. Not sure how they regulate everyone trying to swap their six year old battery for a nice new version but it seemed an innovative approach...

Swipe left for the next trending thread