Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if you have an electric vehicle? Would you recommend it?

180 replies

LordGribeau · 25/05/2023 18:40

Just that really. We are looking at replacing our current mitsubishi outlander with an EV. Possibly a Kia Niro or Peugeot 2008. If you have one, would you recommend it? Are they good as a family car? DC are no longer in booster seats, so fit a bit more comfortably in the back.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
SamanthaCaine · 07/06/2023 15:07

FergalforPM · 07/06/2023 13:43

What is misinformation in what he says?

Within a few lines he claims they're marketed as a panacea, which is wrong. Most people know they're not a silver bullet because, duh, manufacturing anything requires resources.

He then goes on about tailpipe emissions being the main consideration when the CO2 throughout manufacture has already been looked at. BMW manufactured the i3 using green electricity for instance.

He then bangs on about batteries and mining. Conveniently neglecting, as an electronic engineer, that the devices he uses are responsible for far more lithium mining than electric cars. Battery technology is moving away from lithium anyway as you can't get the density required for low mass, long range.

I read the article with interest but it's just the usual nonsense.

weightymatters73 · 07/06/2023 14:51

FergalforPM · 07/06/2023 13:43

What is misinformation in what he says?

@VanGoghsDog

Basically there are five elements on car pollution. 1) Making the car 2) Making the fuel for the car 3)Running the car for it's lifetime and 4) Scrapping the car 5) how long the car lasts for

EV's generally have between 1/5 and 1/3 of the pollution of ICE (petrol and diesel) vehicles when adding together the first 4 things.

Mr Atkinson is just talking about 1).

The BIG one is actually 3) as running a vehicle for it's lifetime is the biggest polluter and EV's are far better.

Basically 1) ICE vehicles are best 2) EV's are best by far 3) EV's are best by far and 4) jury is out, but if the model of reusing batteries as storage works, they are about equal. 5) jury still out BUT we are seeing EV's at 250k+ miles still completely usable and with good batteries, which definitely wouldn't be the case with ICE. Probably generally EV's are going to last longer than ICE.

DisappearingGirl · 07/06/2023 14:33

I like the idea of going electric but we live in a terrace with no off-road parking, and neither of us have parking available at work either (we live in a city and both walk to work). Anyone have any idea if there are any future plans for how those of us without off-road parking can regularly charge up?

VanGoghsDog · 07/06/2023 14:26

Yes, what misinformation?

FergalforPM · 07/06/2023 13:43

SamanthaCaine · 07/06/2023 13:06

Rowan Atkinson is an idiot of the highest order. Starts by boasting about his credentials and then spouts a load of the usual misinformation. He should stick to Mr Bean.

What is misinformation in what he says?

FooFighter99 · 07/06/2023 13:09

I have an eGolf, and it's honestly the best car I've ever driven. I absolutely love it!

Mines a 2020, so has the larger battery, meaning in the summer I get about 160 miles per charge and in winter it's about 90

My commute is 10 miles, and I've only done 12900 miles in 3 years, so I can't comment on batter degradation

Just make sure you can have a home charger fitted, we couldn't as we're a mid-terrace and it wasn't practical to install one, but my husband can charge it at work for free (we haven't paid to charge in well over a year!!) and also download Zap-Map as you can use it to plot journeys using public charging points

SamanthaCaine · 07/06/2023 13:09

Love my EV and it's been a great alternative to the ICE.

As with everything it has pros and cons and depends on whether you can live with the cons. But let's not fool ourselves that petrol/diesel is all flowers. Sure you can fill one up in 5 minutes but there are tonnes of other drawbacks that we moaned about loads before EV's turned up.

SamanthaCaine · 07/06/2023 13:06

Rowan Atkinson is an idiot of the highest order. Starts by boasting about his credentials and then spouts a load of the usual misinformation. He should stick to Mr Bean.

dancinginthesky · 07/06/2023 13:02

Have one, love it, wouldn't go back

Nordicrain · 07/06/2023 12:55

DH has one he uses for commuting. It's a great car and really cheap (£300 a month in petrol vs about £60 a month in electric) BUT we also have a petrol car (mine) that we use for longer trips. Both due to range, but also I think charging publically can be both time consuming, (in some areas) unreliable and expensive.

Reluctantadult · 02/06/2023 20:54

mafsfan · 02/06/2023 20:06

Presume you've tried ZapMap? I don't know the area but the Instavolt ones at a couple of Booth's (Windermere, Kendal) look like the kind of place we'd stop with the kids. No idea about traffic though sorry!

Thanks! Yes looking at zap map there are good sounding charge station options, I'm just not sure whether trying to get into a town in the Lakes on a Sat in half term would be silly busy..!

Badgergirl123 · 02/06/2023 20:40

We've had a Kia Nero for 4 years and love it. We charge from electricity generated by solar panels so from around April to September we pay nothing to charge unless we're away. Wouldn't go back!

mafsfan · 02/06/2023 20:06

Presume you've tried ZapMap? I don't know the area but the Instavolt ones at a couple of Booth's (Windermere, Kendal) look like the kind of place we'd stop with the kids. No idea about traffic though sorry!

Reluctantadult · 02/06/2023 18:44

I'm looking to do a rapid charge in the Lakes tomorrow. Does anyone know the area, and able to tell me anything about Keswick, Kendal, Windermere or Kirkby Lonsdale for charging, but also more in terms of getting in and out without a traffic jam and finding somewhere to eat and break up the journey for the kids?

chupachucks · 02/06/2023 04:46

mafsfan · 31/05/2023 19:14

The problem with hybrids is you've got the worst of both worlds in that you've still got all the mechanical things that can go wrong with an ICE car.

With an EV there is less mechanically to go wrong other than the fairly basic things like brake pads, but if the system goes wrong (like a computer running the car) it does need somebody who knows what they're doing. It's not a regular mechanic job but more people are training to be able to deal with EVs so that will be come more common place.

Our servicing costs have been much lower with our EVs because there is less to check and and less that can go wrong. There have been rumours for years about battery replacement but they continue to just be rumours. As far as I know there hasn't been an influx of even the older EVs needing battery replacements.

The upfront cost is an issue - no doubt about that. However, that will come down and more and more older EVs will become kore available with each year. A lot of the other things said about EVs, especially the modern EVs, is not true (e.g. needing to charge on a 100 mile trip).

Complete and utter rubbish, both myself and my partner have driven self-charging Toyota hybrids for more than a decade. Never had a single issue and the milage is phenomenal on them as we do really high mileage trips.

What are these worst of both worlds you speak of? 🤔

Fact the Toyota hybrids are the world's best selling and most popular cars, most taxis are Toyota self-charging hybrids or do taxi drivers like having the worst of both worlds lol.

Toyota hybrids are also one of the most reliable cars on the road.

If you want to prise your EV but dont so but don't spout generalised bollocks like that.

CutYourCloth · 02/06/2023 01:18

Also, if you can avoid it do not install the car charging unit externally on the side of your property, as criminals are stealing them!

Our charging unit is installed inside the garage. The soft rubber tubing along the bottom of our garage door allows enough space for the charging cable to be positioned under the closed garage door when charging. We did this for four years and there was no damage or kinks to the charging cable.

If anyone is considering a particular MINI Hybrid, beware that you’ll only get 30 miles electric charge capacity before needing to re-charge! My longtime MINI sales contact advised against it unless you’re only driving locally.

CutYourCloth · 31/05/2023 20:34

weightymatters73 · 31/05/2023 13:15

@CutYourCloth You need a model 3 or model Y - much much faster charging then the 100D's.... I know they are lovely cars but older charging tech.

@FergalforPM I would have a very careful calculate about what your car is costing you.... having done this both ways I found a Nissan Leaf on lease/pcp has about the same cost as my well looked after 10 year old petrol car as well as being much better for the environment. On one hand the "car" itself costs more, (but that can be offset or spread with finance) vs the servicing, repairs and petrol on the older vehicle. We now both have new lease EV vehicles and the cost overall is lower. You find that the repairs, servicing and petrol costs can mount up considerably on an older car.

We had use of both the Model Y and Model 3 for months as loan cars, and charging these two newer models took the same amount of time to charge overnight as our Model X P100D’s. Longer in fact re. the Model Y.
I only drove my Model X in Chill Mode around London, and only occasionally in Ludicrous Mode. DP drove his in Ludicrous Mode at all times. Maybe this is why his Model X Tesla went through two batteries within 3 years?

I also drove in gloves and a blanket over my legs for a week or so, when the air con was faulty in my Model X.

We also had issues with the driver window getting stuck and not going all the way up on both Model X’s, and more than once on one car.

I was unfortunate enough to get into two different Uber Tesla’s twice on one day last week when the weather was warm. Both Uber drivers had all the windows open whilst driving fast on a 40 mph A road and also when we were stuck in slow moving polluted London traffic, as they were reluctant to use the air con. I asked one of the Uber drivers to put the windows up as my son was complaining that he was cold.

Uber driver had initially agreed to take me back to my pick up destination after I had dropped off my son. He then changed his mind as we were reaching the destination, as he didn’t want to sit in the same traffic again and took another job instead to a destination in the opposite direction and with a Tesla Supercharger on route (he told me so), effectively kicking me out of the Uber!
I then had to wait 20 mins for another Uber, which was yet another damn Tesla with all the windows down in a London traffic polluted hotspot and was late for my meeting!

I will most definitely avoid booking EV cars as taxis in future.

AGreatUsername · 31/05/2023 19:15

I have a Cupra Born and I love it. It costs anywhere between 20-50% the cost of petrol (it uses more electric in cold and wet weather as that reduces the range by 30% or so!) I’ve had it 6 months now and don’t ever want to go back to fossil fuel.

mafsfan · 31/05/2023 19:14

Busbygirl · 31/05/2023 17:21

I’ve got a hybrid car (Ampera). Definitely would not recommend anything electric.
When it goes wrong I can’t take it to my local garage man but have to book it into the Vauxhall repair centre. He hasn’t got the equipment to repair a lot of the problems.
Vauxhall charge £300 just to put it through a diagnostic test before they’ve even done any repairs!
I think a lot of people will change their minds about electric cars once they start going wrong.
Also there’s a severe shortage of charging points.
I’m moving back to petrol asap

The problem with hybrids is you've got the worst of both worlds in that you've still got all the mechanical things that can go wrong with an ICE car.

With an EV there is less mechanically to go wrong other than the fairly basic things like brake pads, but if the system goes wrong (like a computer running the car) it does need somebody who knows what they're doing. It's not a regular mechanic job but more people are training to be able to deal with EVs so that will be come more common place.

Our servicing costs have been much lower with our EVs because there is less to check and and less that can go wrong. There have been rumours for years about battery replacement but they continue to just be rumours. As far as I know there hasn't been an influx of even the older EVs needing battery replacements.

The upfront cost is an issue - no doubt about that. However, that will come down and more and more older EVs will become kore available with each year. A lot of the other things said about EVs, especially the modern EVs, is not true (e.g. needing to charge on a 100 mile trip).

Busbygirl · 31/05/2023 17:21

I’ve got a hybrid car (Ampera). Definitely would not recommend anything electric.
When it goes wrong I can’t take it to my local garage man but have to book it into the Vauxhall repair centre. He hasn’t got the equipment to repair a lot of the problems.
Vauxhall charge £300 just to put it through a diagnostic test before they’ve even done any repairs!
I think a lot of people will change their minds about electric cars once they start going wrong.
Also there’s a severe shortage of charging points.
I’m moving back to petrol asap

FergalforPM · 31/05/2023 17:00

weightymatters73 · 31/05/2023 16:57

@FergalforPM Your Diesel will be a big cost though....for me a 336 mile trip would cost around £10 in electric, so I'm £1000 per year up on your long trip alone....we calculated based on 16,000 miles a year which for us saved about £2000 per year in fuel alone.

We weren't as lucky as you with £1000 in servicing, MOT and repair costs per year on the petrol car. The EV is zero, as its on a maintenance inclusive lease.

It's a choice, and BTW (whispers) I do have the aircon on and do motorway speeds.

Fuel costs me more but I can buy a lot of fuel for the purchase price of an EV. And I don't have the cash available to either buy or lease and kind of EV - that's the point I am making.

weightymatters73 · 31/05/2023 16:57

@FergalforPM Your Diesel will be a big cost though....for me a 336 mile trip would cost around £10 in electric, so I'm £1000 per year up on your long trip alone....we calculated based on 16,000 miles a year which for us saved about £2000 per year in fuel alone.

We weren't as lucky as you with £1000 in servicing, MOT and repair costs per year on the petrol car. The EV is zero, as its on a maintenance inclusive lease.

It's a choice, and BTW (whispers) I do have the aircon on and do motorway speeds.

Digestive28 · 31/05/2023 16:34

Have a Kia Nero. Would recommend it. 270ish miles per charge and to be honest most journeys are significantly shorter running kids around town to various clubs/friends or commuting to work. So can’t comment on long journeys but plenty of boot space, can get a shop, paddle board or dog in boot no problem (not at the same time obviously) with plenty of space in the back. Works well as a family car - would be nicer if kids hasn’t sprayed sun cream all over the back but can’t win them all

Swipe left for the next trending thread