Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that I am not being transphobic

218 replies

Ijustneedtime · 25/05/2023 13:42

Few weeks ago my DB told me out the blue that she started hormone therapy to become a female.
It was a shock. She is 30 yo and married to a woman, i was 100% not expecting that.
I have many questions, but i reacted in the most positive way, showing support and understanding.
But there are a lot of things i am not ready for. I am not ready to tell this to my kids. I am not ready to tell this to husband and his family because i know they will not understand. I am not ready to go against my parents to fight for this.
I know i could be better, but from a certain perspective i am still digesting everything. I occasionally still use her old name, or use the masculine. I am not ready to call her Sister.
I am struggling and while she is followed by therapists and support, i am by myself with no one to talk to.

She wrote me a messagge yesterday saying how disappointed she was by me. That my support was fake. That i am a transphobic person and i just want to give this fake nice appearance, and i am the worst disappointment.

I just need time. Or maybe i am really that bad and cannot admit it?

OP posts:
Lottapianos · 26/05/2023 09:24

'No. no no no.

You can't tell small children that sometimes people change from men into women. That's not true, and you know that. We all know that. Even 5 year olds know that. Do not lie to your children. Lying about reality is not socially normalised for kids,no matter how much some people try and make it so.'

Absolutely right. Well said

MwahHaHa · 25/05/2023 23:07

Rinkydinkydoodle · 25/05/2023 14:51

Sounds like your sister is struggling and lashing out at a vulnerable time, by the time-honoured family method of being really unpleasant to someone she loves and trusts who is doing their best.

She could stand to take a breath and consider that she’s lived with this information a lot longer than you have, and she has had a lot more time to come to terms with that information.

The transphobic accusation is a red herring, which I wouldn’t dignify with a denial. You are understandably worried about extended family fall-out from this, and as an adult who lives in the world, your sister should know that reactions may not be uniformly positive and encouraging. The reasons for that can be as varied as the people involved and may be little or nothing to do with transphobia- case in point, you. It’s not fear or loathing of her, or of transpeople, it’s fear and loathing of conflict. Family reactions aren’t controllable by either of you, but will have consequences for both of you. Your DH’s family won’t be near the top of her list of things to care about, however, it’s very relevant to you.

I’d be inclined to say to her that while I support her right to exercise her choice, want her to be fulfilled and happy and love her very much, I am also a person with my own life and concerns and cannot be commanded to react according to someone else’s wishes or timescale. Presumably your sister knows first-hand how it feels to be put under pressure by the expectations of others.

That said, other adults’ reactions aren’t your responsibility either. You don’t need to ‘go against your parents to fight for this.’ Her transition is a fact, regardless of what they think, and they don’t have the right to control your interactions, nor influence your relationship.

Like other PPs, I’d say there’s no real percentage in keeping it a secret. You are entitled to love and support your sister as you see fit, and no-one gets to say otherwise. You don’t all have to agree. If ILs or DH or your parents can’t accept that you’re okay with it, that’s really their problem to solve, not yours.

As to your kids, they will likely be less perturbed than you think, and a brief age-appropriate explanation will hopefully be fine. I don’t know if you’re in the UK but I have a little kid who has known ‘sometimes people change from a man to a woman or a woman to a man’ for so long I can’t remember when we first discussed it. Your sister’s story is comparatively common now, and the concept has been societally normalised for kids. The likelihood is they will have trans peers either now or in the future, and the less fuss made of it the better for them as well - I’d point that out to anyone who’s openly hostile about your sister’s choices in front of the kids as well.

No. no no no.

You can't tell small children that sometimes people change from men into women. That's not true, and you know that. We all know that. Even 5 year olds know that. Do not lie to your children. Lying about reality is not socially normalised for kids,no matter how much some people try and make it so.

He is not her sister, he is a man. He is her brother and always will be. He cannot ever become a woman.

She can tell her children the actual truth, that Uncle X wants to dress like a woman and pretend to be one, because it makes him happy. That is the reality.

Coyoacan · 25/05/2023 22:54

It's so regressive and 1950s to think that if a child likes pink it must be a girl, and if a child likes riding a bike and climbing tree it must be a boy. How sexist and homophobic is that?

As someone who spent part of my childhood in the 1950s and is well aware that that was the worst decade in the 20th century for women and girls, it was still downright progressive compared to the transagenda. I spent my entire childhood either up trees and playing football and I was never put down by anyone for doing that. According to the children's books that promote the transagenda, any girl that does stuff is really a boy.

Pluvia · 25/05/2023 22:39

PurpleBugz · 25/05/2023 22:37

Oops. Yea I did. Thanks for correcting

More chance of people finding the information if they use 'cotton'!

Pluvia · 25/05/2023 22:38

Same goes for queer people and gay people I feel.

Whenever I've asked what 'queer' means no one has been able to explain it to me. Can you? How would I know if I was queer? How do I know someone else is queer? What is it about them that's different?

PurpleBugz · 25/05/2023 22:37

Pluvia · 25/05/2023 22:35

For those reading who would like to understand this a bit better looking up 'cloth, ceiling' will be informative

I think you mean 'cotton ceiling.'

Oops. Yea I did. Thanks for correcting

Pluvia · 25/05/2023 22:35

For those reading who would like to understand this a bit better looking up 'cloth, ceiling' will be informative

I think you mean 'cotton ceiling.'

Pluvia · 25/05/2023 22:27

mn29 · 25/05/2023 21:02

One of the trans girls in my child’s school has been wearing fairy wings, dresses etc and wanting to be a girl since reception age - I remember being a bit taken aback at the time as this was a decade ago so being trans was much less widely discussed. Am I to think that she only wants to be a girl because she’s been watching some special kind of porn since the age of 4 or younger? According to a lot of posts on this thread, the answer is yes 🙄

Why can't he just be a swishy boy who likes wearing fairy wings? So many children who are now defined as trans are lesbian or gay. The staff at the Tavistock Clinic where so many of these children ended up used to make dark jokes about being employed to trans the gay away. Just because a boy likes fairy wings and frocks doesn't mean he's a girl.

It's so regressive and 1950s to think that if a child likes pink it must be a girl, and if a child likes riding a bike and climbing tree it must be a boy. How sexist and homophobic is that?

There are loads of different types and 'causes' of transgenderism. In older married men with kids it's almost always autogynephilia — a sexual thrill at the idea or image of themselves as women. These are the men lesbians are having to deal with in their social circles. In the case of boys liking dresses and girly things, it can sometimes/ often be that they're gay. In the case of adolescent girls identifying as boys, it's often autism, sexual abuse or the fear and discomfort of their bodily changes and becoming sexual objects in the eyes of half the population. It's a way of opting out of all the shit that girls are subjected to.

The best book on the subject is Trans by Helen Joyce: you'll learn a lot.

Helleofabore · 25/05/2023 22:18

Damnspot · 25/05/2023 20:52

I can't remember what it said. I think something about mumsnetters constantly mentioning the worst types of people when pretending to care about trans people.

So you made negative generalisations about mumsnetters? Well, of course that is not allowed. Just like no mumsnetter could make a negative generalisation about trans people or any group of people and not be deleted.

Why do you think people on this thread don’t care about the people in their life who have trans indentures?

PurpleBugz · 25/05/2023 22:17

QueenCamilla · 25/05/2023 22:13

@Linning Hmm. I don't think there's much love&understanding between lesbians and trans-women. In fact, LGB community generally seem to want their space back. Understandably so - it's a tenuous link at best between minority sexuality cause and that of people with body dysmorphia.

Indeed

For those reading who would like to understand this a bit better looking up 'cloth, ceiling' will be informative

QueenCamilla · 25/05/2023 22:13

@Linning Hmm. I don't think there's much love&understanding between lesbians and trans-women. In fact, LGB community generally seem to want their space back. Understandably so - it's a tenuous link at best between minority sexuality cause and that of people with body dysmorphia.

PurpleBugz · 25/05/2023 22:09

@Linning

I see what you are saying. I just don't agree. Party because I don't believe in gender identity I believe in binary sex, whereas the existence of sexuality is irrefutable. To me gender is a harmful social construct and belief system not a universal truth. But mostly I disagree because a sexuality is a personal thing, something others may or may not accept about us but our sexuality doesn't affect or harm others . Gender identity and transgenderism I believe to be harmful to women and children and to be homophobic

Linning · 25/05/2023 21:54

Queer & trans I meant to say at the end not queer & gay. *

Linning · 25/05/2023 21:53

@PurpleBugz

They are definitely different things but to me they are extremely similar because both trans people and gay/bisexual folks (some of whom are trans) go through similar processes which are learning to accept parts of our identities (whether it’s our sexuality or gender identity), despite society so desperately wanting us to hate ourselves for it and to fit within what they consider the acceptable norm. We similarly face coming out and meeting often extremely harsh reactions or complete rejection (and in horrible cases violence) for just being who we are and learning to survive/live in a society that mainly wish we didn’t exist.

Being trans and being gay isn’t the same but there is a reason why trans people usually are and feel more welcomed within the queer community than in the overall straight and heteronormative society we all live in and it’s because we can relate to each other on many points. So usually our stories are a lot more similar (especially when it comes to the experience of coming out to people we care about and who have known us a while) than not.

Two lesbians wouldn’t have the same story either but would likely both relate to some aspects of being gay and feel completely opposite on other aspects of being gay based on their own personal experiences and what kind of lesbian they are/who they date/who they hang out with. Same goes for queer people and gay people I feel.

QueenCamilla · 25/05/2023 21:48

Nah, I wouldn't want to play that game.

My brother has made a decision to gamble on the financial markets. I don't support it. I have expressed my concerns and have left it at that. He's not narcisisstically driven to involve me in cheerleading him along, and he respects my preference of not hearing what the next "big thing" in investments is going to be.

Equally, I could only handle my brother transitioning if it was understood that I'm in favour of mental support vs medical transitioning, that I won't be his carer if his self-harm ends up in disability and I'd rather not hear about any "big news" of the process and the details (as I find it horrifying). There's other stuff to talk about.

Lottapianos · 25/05/2023 21:44

'Gender ideology denies the beautiful breadth of humanity. Within the sex binary, are billions of unique women & men, girls & boys.'

Beautifully expressed. Everyone is either male or female, but there are SO MANY ways to be a man or a woman, or a boy or a girl

PurpleBugz · 25/05/2023 21:34

@Linning

I appreciate you sharing your experience. It was an insight for me into how it can feel to come out as a lesbian.

But I really don't think coming out with a sexuality is the same as a different gender. Lesbians are attracted to women. Trans people are trans AND have a sexuality like lesbian gay straight. They are different things

Okshacky · 25/05/2023 21:22

Damnspot · 25/05/2023 21:17

Well, in this case it was indicative as the pp explicitly says.

No in this case it was a coincidence just like eye colour or religion or eating a lot of sprouts.

Linning · 25/05/2023 21:21

Not completely related but I remember having a lot of anger towards certain of my closest friends/family when I came out (as a lesbian) and was faced with the fact that while they were trying to be supportive out of love for me, a lot of them were clearly uncomfortable, and dare I say it a bit ashamed/weirded out by it.

I was only mad for a hot second until I realized that it had taken me 19 years to accept myself so it was maybe fair enough if they needed a minute also. In all cases, coming out (as part of the LGBTQ+ community) is hard and often the anger can be enhanced after coming out when we don’t get the support we hoped for because it’s a reminder that it’s those kind of reactions (or fear of them) that has kept us so uncomfortable and closeted for so long.

To be fair I don’t think your reaction was bad but I do understand how you choosing to hide it from your family, can be hurtful to your sibling. Why not mention it? Does your husband truly needs to understand? personally I don’t ask people to understand my sexuality or to be in favor of it (I 100% do not care if they are or not) I just ask them to accept that that’s the way it is and that therefore their opinion is irrelevant. I am not asking for their opinion or their approval when I come out, I am only letting them know something about me.

So you could just let it be known to your husband without expecting him to « get it » or understand it & just as a simple acknowledgment.

Also I do find your follow up message inappropriate. Saying you are angry it’s coming out of the blue or angry you will never have nephews is definitely something you need to ideally keep to yourself. It’s very rare that people come out out of the blue in their 30’s especially if in a long-term relationship and in a family that’s unlikely to be supportive. It’s a lot more likely that it’s something that they have been through for years and that you simply didn’t notice and that is now finally coming to the surface.

My step dad (who raised me) had a very hard time accepting that I wasn’t suddenly turning gay at 19, because in his mind it was out of the blue when in reality I remember having crushes on girls since as little as 3yo and also equally remember trying to force myself to like boys as that’s what everybody seemed to expect from me. For people who can’t picture someone not being what they see of them it will always come out as a shock to them. For people who live through it, it’s a hard, long grueling process with lots of self-hatred and often trying to force ourselves to change for years.

Something else I found incredibly irritating when I came out was people somehow grieving my straight self (a self that never technically existed). One of my closest friend almost needed support from me to process that we would never have the BBQ on her terrace with both our husbands like she always pictured it, and she really felt like I had burst her bubbles of our future together. As well as people assuming it meant I wouldn’t have kids etc…

That was incredibly strange to me. Like I get it (when you think you know someone but then reality is different etc…) but I found it so inappropriate that they even held me to a standard I might not even have wanted to live up to even if I was straight. Your sibling might never have wanted kids to start with irrelevant of her gender identity. Also being transgender doesn’t mean no kids, it also doesn’t mean you will have to look after her (?), yes you do get to grieve for the sibling you maybe thought you had or wish you had, but don’t put your own (self-created) expectations of them and their future life on their shoulders. Grieve with the people who are going through the same process.

As someone who is gay, I had to spend 19 years of my life grieving the fact that who I was would disappoint some people, including some of my closest and dearest and then I realized I was most disappointed in the fact that those same people caring so much about other people’s sexuality and lives meant that people like me spent years hating themselves instead of loving themselves, which in the end is a lot worse trait than being gay.

So, to answer your OP, you aren’t technically being transphobic, but you also aren’t being as supportive as you think you are. Yes, you are grieving and that’s okay, but also part of being supportive (truly) is to accept that being trans (or gay, or married to someone of a different culture/religion/race) isn’t the end of the world. It doesn’t have to be dramatic, it doesn’t have to be traumatizing. It doesn’t even need to be sad. But what it is will have a lot to do with how you (and everyone who love your sibling) react. If you treat it like you would someone who tells you they don’t eat seafood and just adjust at your level and are supportive without making a big deal of it (one way or another). Then that’s probably the best approach. They are still your sibling, irrelevant of what they look like, are called or dress like. If you would feel more comfortable accepting them being gay then imagine that’s what they have just announced to you and deal with it the same way. Don’t start worrying about their fertility, their relationship, etc… it’s for them to figure out and as a grown adult I am sure they are and have considered it and have weighed the pros and cons of coming out vs not. So just be there for them, as their sibling.

ThorThumb · 25/05/2023 21:21

mn29 · 25/05/2023 21:02

One of the trans girls in my child’s school has been wearing fairy wings, dresses etc and wanting to be a girl since reception age - I remember being a bit taken aback at the time as this was a decade ago so being trans was much less widely discussed. Am I to think that she only wants to be a girl because she’s been watching some special kind of porn since the age of 4 or younger? According to a lot of posts on this thread, the answer is yes 🙄

No of course not.
He’s a boy who likes fairy wings and dresses, but sadly lives in a society where not complying to strict gender stereotypes is seen as problematic.
The only reason this poor boy thinks he is a girl is because stupid adults in his life have told him he’s a girl because boys aren’t allowed to wear fairy wings or dresses, and other stupid adults have gone along with it.
He’s a boy. He will never be female, will never totally fit in with girls/women because he’s not and never will be female. And that’s NOT transphobic, it’s just pointing out how unbelievably cruel it is for any child to be…
1 Told that their clothes and toy preferences are wrong.
2 Aren’t accepted as who they really are and instead pushed down a road where they are pressured to irreversibly damage their bodies to fix themselves to fit into a screwed up world that wants to put young people in boxes with various labels on them, instead of, you know, allowing them to explore who they are safely without any permanence set onto a rather common child/teenage phase.
3 Are told that anyone not accepting that trans people are their desired sex (even though that’s an out and out lie) literally hates them and because of that they’ll likely be suicidal (looking at you Mermaids) which exposes them to more socially contagious mental shitstorm.

LEAVE CHILDREN ALONE.

WhereYouLeftIt · 25/05/2023 21:20

Ijustneedtime · 25/05/2023 14:55

So many messages! I am with DC now but I will come back to reply to all later.

The reason why i am not telling DH is because i know he will be very against it and he will tell me to cut contact. He is already not very happy with DB for other reasons, he does not like DB very much personality wise.

Interesting that your husband "is already not very happy with DB for other reasons". Not asking for details, but would it be anything to do with your brother behaving selfishly in some way?

Also, part of your struggle is to do with this coming "out the blue". You grew up with your brother, he's 30 now and it's from out of the blue. You had no inkling. Nothing from your shared childhood suggested any issues. I wonder if there's a nagging doubt at the back of your head about his sincerity.

And like other posters, my sympathy lies with your sister-in-law, his wife. She's just had her world blown apart.

Damnspot · 25/05/2023 21:17

Okshacky · 25/05/2023 21:15

Yes what I was saying was that the behaviour described isn’t indicative of wanting to be anything and shouldn’t be seen as such. If the child had wanted to be a lumber Jack would that mean she had to grow up to be an alpha male?

Well, in this case it was indicative as the pp explicitly says.

Okshacky · 25/05/2023 21:15

Yes what I was saying was that the behaviour described isn’t indicative of wanting to be anything and shouldn’t be seen as such. If the child had wanted to be a lumber Jack would that mean she had to grow up to be an alpha male?

Damnspot · 25/05/2023 21:08

Okshacky · 25/05/2023 21:06

Little boys wanting to wear sparkly fairy wings categorically doesn’t mean they want to be a girl. If they do want to be a girl it’s no different than wanting to be a pony or a Dr or a train driver.

And yet the post you are referring to explicitly says this child wanted to be a girl.

Swipe left for the next trending thread