Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder about women who claim to have had their periods throughout pregnancy

86 replies

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:13

Something I read got me wondering...

It's clear you can't have a period in pregnancy biologically. And all online information say you might have some bleeding and spotting. But then, anecdontally, some women claim that they had regular bleeding that was just like their periods.

Did these women always have light/ irregular periods? Or is it possible? The contrast in what seems biologically possible and what women is experience has me a little confused!

OP posts:
Doormatnomore · 25/05/2023 14:05

FourTeaFallOut · 25/05/2023 13:53

I don't know, but my periods fired up again, back on a regular 5 days in 28day schedule, the moment he was born despite breastfeeding exclusively on demand and him gaining a gazillion pounds. 🤷 I had hoped for at least a ten week hiatus which is typically described as the accepted minimum. And this was true across all three of my children.

I’d forgotten about this part too! First time round there was a whole chapter in thr book about if your period came back after birth and you were exclusively breastfeeding you were deathly ill (I’m paraphrasing) but nope everytime there’s my flipping regular period despite producing like a Friesian cow. Again impossible but I’m guessing cause despite 5 billion possible case studies “they” understand the broad strokes so that’s enough.

Foodie6 · 25/05/2023 13:59

I don't think you're wrong to wonder OP. Period talk is typically taboo so you grow up only really knowing your own experiences and nothing else. I also can't comprehend how someone can think they're having a period through pregnancy, but that's because my period is heavy I guess, the sort of bleeding of if it happened during pregnancy I doubt all would be ok. But I guess some women must just have lighter periods and could easily mistake irregular within the realms of normal bleeding during pregnancy for their periods. If I had a medium - light flow for a period one month I'd wonder wtf was wrong with my body it's so foreign to me. Envious of those who don't have heavy periods though!

Jengnr · 25/05/2023 13:59

I had bleeding that aligned with my period for the first couple of months. Had I not known I was pg Iwould have assumed I wasn’t.

thecatsthecats · 25/05/2023 13:58

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:44

See this is interesting. In my mind, noone would mistake a period with spotting. Spotting - to me - is light and occasional. Not the continuous flow of a period. So, as you allude to, perhaps the issue is with how the medical profession bothers to deal with or talk about that sort of thing.

On this point I definitely agree.

I mean, obviously it's different for everyone, but I always took this to mean literal spots - 1cm ish max, or a pink wipe that went away after the first one.

When I went to hospital at 8 weeks pregnant I was asked all sorts of condescending questions and snipped at by the doctor because I "hadn't filled a pad yet" - even though I was bleeding and passed a 2cm clot.

Had I had cramps? Yes, light cramps.
But not so bad as you had to take medication? No.

Well how the fuck am I supposed to know exactly what specific degree of cramps and bleeding I am supposed to have before I bother you? The midwife told me to come (after telling me to call the EPAU who also weren't interested), so I came.

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:57

justasking111 · 25/05/2023 13:54

My mum had this with third child so didn't occur to her that she was pregnant she wasn't showing, wasn't sick, so just cracked on with two young children. She was nearly six months when she had an inkling.

I was 20 weeks when my BIL asked if I was pregnant because my hips looked wider. I scoffed but made an appointment with GP. This was my second child.

I find these stories so interesting. Did you have regular bleeding?

I am prone to bloating and sometimes have twitches in my stomach (gas I assume) which feels exactly like early kicks. But I also have very regular periods which tells me I am not pregnant. It's just quite crazy to think that that could be wrong (I mean in my case it's not or I would be about 4 years pregnant by now!!). The whole thing is fascinating.

OP posts:
FourTeaFallOut · 25/05/2023 13:55

I was 20 weeks when my BIL asked if I was pregnant because my hips looked wider.

😁 That was brave.

justasking111 · 25/05/2023 13:54

My mum had this with third child so didn't occur to her that she was pregnant she wasn't showing, wasn't sick, so just cracked on with two young children. She was nearly six months when she had an inkling.

I was 20 weeks when my BIL asked if I was pregnant because my hips looked wider. I scoffed but made an appointment with GP. This was my second child.

FourTeaFallOut · 25/05/2023 13:53

I don't know, but my periods fired up again, back on a regular 5 days in 28day schedule, the moment he was born despite breastfeeding exclusively on demand and him gaining a gazillion pounds. 🤷 I had hoped for at least a ten week hiatus which is typically described as the accepted minimum. And this was true across all three of my children.

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:53

steff13 · 25/05/2023 13:50

I've known several women who continued to have periods while they were pregnant. That was not my experience, but that doesn't mean it wasn't theirs. I've never really felt the need to try to disprove their claims. 🤷‍♀️ Sometimes we just have to accept that other people's experiences can be different from our own.

Urgh 🙄 not trying to disprove anything. Just curious really. And, as I said, wondering if it just perhaps is the literature and medical profession denying what women say they are experiencing.

OP posts:
Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:51

thecatsthecats · 25/05/2023 13:46

Implantation - could happen at pretty much the time you'd expect your period, with similar bleeding to a light period.

Hematoma/random bleeds - next common week for bleeds is 8 weeks (I luckily had a very light one, and was told by the nurse at the hospital that they saw a few at eight weeks).

Sex and thrush can cause light bleeds too.

Let's say you have a bit of sickness. Puts you off sex, or maybe you've split up with a partner so you're not even having sex. So your next "missed" period - well, you can't be pregnant, can you? Not even worth testing.

I can see how you can stack up to four months quite easily, and that's as someone with a regular cycle.

(go on, ask about celebrities and their "moon bumps" next - and I'll regale you with the fact that mine comes and goes still at 18w depending on how much I need a fart)

Not sure what you mean re moon bumps.

Look I am not doubting women - I was just curious as to what the circusmtances were. Like i said, if irregular and light anyway, I can see why it would be described that way and that is consistent with information on it, but if women are having regular bleeds over several days why is information adament that that can't happen.

OP posts:
steff13 · 25/05/2023 13:50

I've known several women who continued to have periods while they were pregnant. That was not my experience, but that doesn't mean it wasn't theirs. I've never really felt the need to try to disprove their claims. 🤷‍♀️ Sometimes we just have to accept that other people's experiences can be different from our own.

thecatsthecats · 25/05/2023 13:46

Implantation - could happen at pretty much the time you'd expect your period, with similar bleeding to a light period.

Hematoma/random bleeds - next common week for bleeds is 8 weeks (I luckily had a very light one, and was told by the nurse at the hospital that they saw a few at eight weeks).

Sex and thrush can cause light bleeds too.

Let's say you have a bit of sickness. Puts you off sex, or maybe you've split up with a partner so you're not even having sex. So your next "missed" period - well, you can't be pregnant, can you? Not even worth testing.

I can see how you can stack up to four months quite easily, and that's as someone with a regular cycle.

(go on, ask about celebrities and their "moon bumps" next - and I'll regale you with the fact that mine comes and goes still at 18w depending on how much I need a fart)

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:44

Doormatnomore · 25/05/2023 13:39

I didn’t know I was pregnant did I was really late on. The charming team at the hospital explained I didn’t need to lie to them even if I wanted to lie to everyone else. Next time I got a “period” I went to the hospital who said it was a miscarriage cause of the amount of blood, 3 days later it stopped and everything was fine. They said it was just spotting despite changing pads hourly.

im not having a go, they were dealing with the information they had to hand but there was enough fresh red blood to be convincing. My darling granny said it was because I was working to hard and I should take to my bed. Who knows. But despite everyone on the planet being grown in a woman I think there’s plenty more research than can be done.

See this is interesting. In my mind, noone would mistake a period with spotting. Spotting - to me - is light and occasional. Not the continuous flow of a period. So, as you allude to, perhaps the issue is with how the medical profession bothers to deal with or talk about that sort of thing.

OP posts:
Fink · 25/05/2023 13:44

I had lots of incidents of bleeding during pregnancy, I didn't track the dates to see whether it was in line with a standard cycle. Like a pp's friend, I ended up spending a lot of time in hospitals getting extra scans but the pregnancy was otherwise normal and the baby turned out healthy. Some was kind of spotting, other times it was heavier. Before conceiving I hadn't really paid much attention to my periods so I wouldn't even have known how long my cycle was or how heavy. The bleeding in pregnancy I could conceivably have thought of as normal periods, except that I knew I was pregnant.

Since periods returned after giving birth I have had various gynae issues which mean that I now always have very heavy and long periods. I wouldn't mistake what I have now for what I had in pregnancy, but what I had then was similar enough to what I had before to be unremarkable (though scary).

mondaytosunday · 25/05/2023 13:43

My mother's carer, who was a nurse, didn't know she was pregnant til she almost had the baby in my mother's bathroom!
She didn't look pregnant (was maybe a stone overweight but certainly not round in her tummy), had bleeding throughout. I'm not sure how regular, but enough to fool her. Her mother was also a nurse and didn't suspect either (they saw each other every day).

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:42

FourTeaFallOut · 25/05/2023 13:39

So your interest is in the language women use when they experience regular bleeding during pregnancy?

My bleeding wasn't like a period is was much shorter and far less than that. So, double wombs aside, I think you just need to cut women a little slack.

Forty percent of women don't even know what a cervix is - a large reason why we shouldn't dick around with with sexed language in nhs literature, but I digress - so it wouldn't surprise me if women cling to language which is familiar - using period to describe regular bleeding which didn't threaten the foetus - to describe what is happening to them.

No, more with the concept of regular bleeding. As I said, if you google it everything seems to say that it doesn't happen and is irregular spotting/ bleeding. Maybe those articles only thing of women's periods as the 5 days relatively heavy bleeding every 28 days, which could be in (ref my OP) OR the experiences of women are just very different (regular bleeding that could easily be confused with a "traditional" period. As i said, I am mainly just curious...

OP posts:
Doormatnomore · 25/05/2023 13:39

I didn’t know I was pregnant did I was really late on. The charming team at the hospital explained I didn’t need to lie to them even if I wanted to lie to everyone else. Next time I got a “period” I went to the hospital who said it was a miscarriage cause of the amount of blood, 3 days later it stopped and everything was fine. They said it was just spotting despite changing pads hourly.

im not having a go, they were dealing with the information they had to hand but there was enough fresh red blood to be convincing. My darling granny said it was because I was working to hard and I should take to my bed. Who knows. But despite everyone on the planet being grown in a woman I think there’s plenty more research than can be done.

FourTeaFallOut · 25/05/2023 13:39

So your interest is in the language women use when they experience regular bleeding during pregnancy?

My bleeding wasn't like a period is was much shorter and far less than that. So, double wombs aside, I think you just need to cut women a little slack.

Forty percent of women don't even know what a cervix is - a large reason why we shouldn't dick around with with sexed language in nhs literature, but I digress - so it wouldn't surprise me if women cling to language which is familiar - using period to describe regular bleeding which didn't threaten the foetus - to describe what is happening to them.

ShakeYourFeathers · 25/05/2023 13:37

I can see how it happens my periods are very irregular. I sometimes go 9months without one. I was single at the time and o hadn't had sex so I knew I wasn't pregnant but yeah.

Then I'm regular as clockwork for a few months then get irregular again.

Also theres contraception which stops your period, with 99% rate. But say that 1% happened you wouldn't know because you don't get periods in the first place

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:37

Interesting with two uteruses btw!

OP posts:
Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:36

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 13:34

Odd and unlikely for you. Plenty of women have period that are different to yours.

Yes, I know. But is exaclty what I am wondering. You often hear or read "I had periods throughout". That makes sense if someone only has a few days of spotting every couple of months. So I was curious if that is most often the case or whether some women have "typical" monthly periods. As I said in my OP....

OP posts:
Sissynova · 25/05/2023 13:34

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:32

welli guess this is what I am wondering and why I ask whether people who experience this have light/ irregular periods. My periods last 5-6 days and are pretty regular. I would seem odd, and unlikely, if I was pregnant that I would have heavy(ish) bleeding/ spotting for 5-6 days at a time every month.

Odd and unlikely for you. Plenty of women have period that are different to yours.

roseopose · 25/05/2023 13:34

I have two uteruses but didn't bleed when pregnant or have periods. I wouldn't say this is impossible though, but I was told that the hormone changes 'shut down' ovulation so that would be for both uteruses. I don't have 2 periods a month either so they obviously work in sync, thank god Grin

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:32

Lovingitallnow · 25/05/2023 13:29

Can I ask though how would you know if you've a period or just bleeding? Like it's not like each month there's a test you take to determine that the blood coming out of your vagina is the lining of your uterus shedding or just random bleeding? Most people just assume based on timing that they're experiencing a period.

welli guess this is what I am wondering and why I ask whether people who experience this have light/ irregular periods. My periods last 5-6 days and are pretty regular. I would seem odd, and unlikely, if I was pregnant that I would have heavy(ish) bleeding/ spotting for 5-6 days at a time every month.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread