Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you find this offensive?

659 replies

Meeting · 25/05/2023 12:55

The Theatre Royal Stratford East is putting on a show and have blocked out 2 dates as "Blackout" nights where they encourage (but I don't think plan to enforce) that only black people may attend these performances.

I saw them discussing it on Piers Morgan and neither of the guests advocating for it were able to convince me that this type of segregation was at all beneficial.

Does anybody think this is a good idea? Personally I think segregation based on skin colour has no place in society, no matter who benefits from it. But I'm interested to hear from others who might away it differently?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
MasterBeth · 28/05/2023 12:30

CandyLips · 28/05/2023 00:17

Surely if it is not wanted and even labelled then it is a negative thing?

It's not offensive or negative. It's just inevitable.

I am white. I see things through the perspective of 50 years of living my life without being made aware of my race in a majority white country.

On those occasions when I am in a space where the majority is not white, I am made aware. I don't think that the guests at a Sikh wedding or the audience at a black music event are thinking badly of me, but I see that they are checking me out more than they would be if I shared their heritage. I can try and imagine how that might feel if it happened on a daily basis, but I can't experience it.

"White gaze" doesn't have to be malicious or negative. It doesn't mean white people are bad or racist or should be ashamed or guilty, or that they are are a homogeneous lump who all feel the same way. We can't help our white gaze, just as men can't help the male gaze. But thoughtful white people and thoughtful men understand that sometimes other people may wish not to have to be gazed on by them.

Summerfun2023 · 28/05/2023 12:05

TreadLight · 27/05/2023 23:08

We have never had segregation in this country and I desperately hope we never do. These theatre productions are the thin end of the wedge.

Where did you read that from honestly who taught you to think that was true?

Summerfun2023 · 28/05/2023 12:00

@CandyLips You should go if you want to and tell us all about it on Mumsnet.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 11:55

Thatladdo · 28/05/2023 11:37

Absolutely!
Its almost as if victimhood suits and its intentinaly kept going.
Its not acceptable and wouldnt be tollerated if it was the other way around.

Tbh I'm struggling to see what emotional or problematic issues could need to be discussed in a group of white people that would call for the need of a white night?

Sections of people who are white absolutely, but not by their whiteness.

So disabled people, but that wouldn't need to be limited to white disabled people, or LGB people, or women. But again not just white women for example (although I would defend the need for black women to have their own space because they have more issues to contend with than white women)

So the whole 'it wouldn't be tolerated if it was the other way around' sounds a bit like hyperbole that racist people come out with to justify racism. See also: "people say things about Christianity that wouldn't be tolerated about Muslims"- in a country whether the media is tolerated saying Islamaphobic things, and Muslims are assaulted because people assume they are terrorists and Chrisitians are complaining someone is referring to God as a sky fairy. (I say this as a Christian).

If you think there are no places where black people aren't allowed any more walk into an IT department in most large companies in the UK and ask yourself where the black people especially women are. White people yes, Asian people yes, but black people will be massively underrepresented due to stereotypes and conscious and unconscious bias.

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 28/05/2023 11:43

Has anyone changed their mind after reading the thread?

monsteramunch · 28/05/2023 11:39

@Thatladdo

Its almost as if victimhood suits and its intentinaly kept going.

Can you explain what you mean by 'it's almost as if victimhood suits'? In what sense do you believe that and how does that belief, in your opinion, manifest itself?

Thatladdo · 28/05/2023 11:37

Meeting · 25/05/2023 13:12

I'm a gypsy and I can't count the amount of times that I've been refused entry or service due to my race. I don't want 'gypsy only' nights. I just want to be equal.

Absolutely!
Its almost as if victimhood suits and its intentinaly kept going.
Its not acceptable and wouldnt be tollerated if it was the other way around.

ecuse · 28/05/2023 11:36

I'm white, I don't find this offensive.

I also think it's hyperbole to call it segregation. I haven't clicked through to the show website but from other remarks on the thread it sounds like it touches on difficult or traumatic topics - I assume related to racism.

I think it's a thoughtful gesture to offer a handful of showings where black people have the choice to process that together without white people.

The OP says she's also from a minority ethnic group and wouldn't want to go to an equivalent session and that's fine. Nobody is forcing them to. But I don't see why it's a problem to offer the option for those who would prefer it.

Sounds like there are plenty of sessions open to people who aren't black too.

AtchinTan · 28/05/2023 11:19

@EmptyBedBlues Given what I've read and heard about the content, contentiousness, and racial slurs in the play at the Almeida, it seems pretty reasonable.

I wouldn't have had an issue if they'd asked heterosexual people to consider not booking on a specific night involving discussions about power in/balance in Gay relationships either.

I wonder if there would be so much objection if it was Gay people asking heterosexual people to consider not booking for two nights out of a run?

passthegingordon · 28/05/2023 11:16

TreadLight · 28/05/2023 10:33

These images belong in US history, not future Britain. Segregation is abhorrent in all its forms, no matter what the justification is.

Yeah, legally enforced racial segregation isn't what's happening here, in any "form". Back to the history books for you!

EmptyBedBlues · 28/05/2023 10:55

TreadLight · 28/05/2023 10:33

These images belong in US history, not future Britain. Segregation is abhorrent in all its forms, no matter what the justification is.

I’m assuming you are being deliberately obtuse, because surely it’s not difficult to grasp the difference between the Jim Crow laws which saw African-Americans segregated, lynched, deprived of education and civil rights as part of a conscious attempt to disenfranchise them, and an attempt to attract more Black audiences to theatre by arranging a single night in a play’s run when a non-white audience is encouraged to attend a play about the history of slavery, written by a Black playwright?

I don’t know whether anyones already pointed out that this isn’t a new thing? Common in the US for a while, I know the Almeida has done it before, and I assume other theatres too.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 10:41

TreadLight · 28/05/2023 10:33

These images belong in US history, not future Britain. Segregation is abhorrent in all its forms, no matter what the justification is.

So do you also want to get rid of Guides, the WI, Merched Y Wawr, ladies day at the races, men's sheds, andys man club etc

Or is it just when a theatre invites an under represented audience to come to a play that's about an issue that impacts them in a different way to other parts of the traditional audience, on two nights out of the whole run without even stopping other people from other ethniticies from coming that you have a problem?

TreadLight · 28/05/2023 10:33

These images belong in US history, not future Britain. Segregation is abhorrent in all its forms, no matter what the justification is.

Do you find this offensive?
Do you find this offensive?
Beezknees · 28/05/2023 10:14

CandyLips · 28/05/2023 00:13

Well I don't consider all men to be the same. I think it is a very narrow way of looking at life.

But when women are talking about issues that mainly affect women, such as sexual assault, being scared to walk places alone, etc. And men pipe up with "well it's not ALL men" and totally dismiss our concerns. It's annoying, no? Same principle applies here.

Beezknees · 28/05/2023 10:09

CandyLips · 28/05/2023 00:21

Can you explain why a white person in an audience would make you feel less comfortable? What is it? You think they are looking at you and judging your reactions to the play? ( As some previous poster alluded to) I really dont understand this.

You never know who is secretly a racist. I'm white and am mainly surrounded by white people as I live in quite a white area. The amount of people who I've heard say casually racist things is astounding.

The white people in this thread saying they're offended by black people not always feeling comfortable around white people - you are doing the "not all men" thing as the men do when women say they don't always feel comfortable around men.

AtchinTan · 28/05/2023 09:55

@Isittimeformynapyet
Meeting told you about this, and you’re responding to her, and she and I heavily disagree politically, so I hope she’ll be ok with me shoving my oar in to say: think about how exhausting it is telling people this is what happens, and getting 'I can’t tell what you are, so how do others of my kind, in order for this to be happening to you?'
Do you think you might sound like you’re denying this is happening to her? Genuine question to you.

IMO it’s sometimes clothing, skin tone can play a part, but generally, because they are actively looking out for you. They may have had an issue at some time with a group, often not actually your heritage, or they heard someone else has, and now they’re looking. There may be a local site or planning proposals for one, and no negative interaction, but they want to make a point. They may have taken out a planning application to build flats where you live and are angry you/yours won’t sell so they can’t make money.
Local Facebook may be full of claims of stuff ranging from 'saw Gypsy's in a van, to found a pavement chalk mark/ leaflet half out of my letterbox, watch out, Gypsies about!

Done to other races they’ve had individual poor interactions with, we call it racism, done to 'Gypsies' we call it understandable.

TBF I can spot most Romanitchel, Romanichal, Roma, Dom, and other forms of Rom a mile away, regardless of if they’re wearing variants of traditional dress or not. I can also tell Irish Travelers at a glance.

With schools, HE, council, HMRC etc things follow us on paperwork. We aren’t let put our children to school under White/Brown British or Other. They reassign when we do. If a child’s Posh rat (mixed race) the 50% of their parentage that might count for them, is discounted.

When Anne Frank had a truck full of young girls standing stripped naked pass her, she knew they were 'Gypsy girls' being taken away. How do you think?

Rom police officers quite often get ‘you can’t arrest me, you’re a fucking Gypsy!’ How do your criminals tell, because it gets read out in court enough, as a defense for resisting arrest.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 09:43

Makes perfect sense to me especially if there is a Q&A

We had an international womens day event at work in a majority male workplace, everyone was included. The idea was to address some of the barriers facing women entering the male dominated industry. We never got as far as coming up with ideas to address the barriers because instead every time an issue came up we had to spend forever explaining to the men why it was an issue even though it was subjects raised and discussed before. And these were men genuinely interested in helping and being supportive. But the entire conversation was dominated by them and the women who were there, instead of discussing what they wanted to discuss, were instead expected to use their time and effort energy educating the men.

The overwhelming feedback afterwards was that whilst the mixed sessions were good having at least one women's only session would have been beneficial.

So I can absolutely understand if there is a q and a why it would be more comfortable and less frustrating as a black person to just go on a night dedicated to black people where they aren't expected to be there solely to educate other people.

I think given some of the responses on this thread it's fairly obvious how quickly a conversation about issues facing black people can end up centering white people even if it's only a few white people doing the demanding.

AtchinTan · 28/05/2023 09:31

@Refrosty I entered it for the same simple reasons, and really glad you got invested! The problem's universal for many groups and others often feel threatened at attempts to talk unscrutinized.

@Candy Lips you need to start at the beginning tbh. The pic might help you understand your problem with as you see it: "Rules for one and different rules for others" You're the person in the blue shirt.
Different groups with similar problems want to try and figure out ways to get the fence dealt with without others turning into a debate about if the fence is really a problem because they can't see a problem with it.

Do you find this offensive?
monsteramunch · 28/05/2023 09:29

@CandyLips

People with your attitude towards race are the reason events like the one being discussed are created.

You are part of the problem. Yet you claim there is no problem and even when people take time to explain their personal experiences and issues (as multiple posters have on this thread) you continue to demand more answers as you don't deem those provided to be sufficient.

You are either extremely ignorant or wilfully disingenuous when it comes to race.

TeaKlaxon · 28/05/2023 09:18

Waitymatey · 28/05/2023 01:04

That theatre tends not to have a white audience in any case, largely due to its location. So to insist white peoples are banned is unnecessary
Given we are meant to learn from history to prevent its more harmful aspects recurring, not to replicate them, then yes, I do find this unnecessary and I am appalled that a race seeks to ban another.
What would happen if white people insisted on white only spaces, in 2023.

Except white people aren’t banned, as has been pointed out multiple times.

Another example of someone just making things up to suit their agenda - and therefore making the point very strongly that there is merit in events like these.

TeaKlaxon · 28/05/2023 09:16

CandyLips · 28/05/2023 00:15

Why would someone asking a question be making it all about them as opposed to eg discovering things they didn't know about about someone else?

It’s not the responsibility of minority groups to educate majority groups.

That is precisely the sort of centring of white people’s issues that this type of event is designed to address.

CandyLips · 28/05/2023 08:56

Refrosty · 28/05/2023 00:55

You were, just now, offended because of a phrase you've never heard before, and went off on a rant without understanding its meaning.

So, instead of discussing the topic at hand, to placate you, we must try to explain what we mean when we said it.

20 pages in and you still haven't learned possible reasons this night exists, or what the phrase means? Maybe you should ask less questions and listen more.

I am not the one to explain it further, sorry.

and this isn't a rant? Rules for one and different rules for others. I won't be returning to this as there is nothing to be gained in genuine discussion which is turned into accusations. Good luck with how that works out for you.

CatkinToadflax · 28/05/2023 08:44

My goodness. The “All Lives Matter” brigade are clearly out in force on this thread. 🤦‍♀️

DojaPhat · 28/05/2023 01:37

I really wish mumsnet was around when I was much younger! The energy I could have saved myself by refusing to explain things like this to white people who are intent on misconstruing and misunderstanding my words could have generated enough energy to power America and China for a century.

Refrosty · 28/05/2023 01:22

I don't even know why I'm so invested in this, I have no intentions of viewing the play. I only entered the thread because I had a fair amount of empathy for any black person who would want to attend a night like this, based upon my own experience. Now I'm totally sold on the idea! Not just for black people, I see the need for other groups to feel empowered enough to create safe spaces to discuss their shit without offending people they weren't even offending. Bloody hell. I see it now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread