Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you find this offensive?

659 replies

Meeting · 25/05/2023 12:55

The Theatre Royal Stratford East is putting on a show and have blocked out 2 dates as "Blackout" nights where they encourage (but I don't think plan to enforce) that only black people may attend these performances.

I saw them discussing it on Piers Morgan and neither of the guests advocating for it were able to convince me that this type of segregation was at all beneficial.

Does anybody think this is a good idea? Personally I think segregation based on skin colour has no place in society, no matter who benefits from it. But I'm interested to hear from others who might away it differently?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
TreadLight · 28/05/2023 17:07

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 28/05/2023 16:55

I am slightly surprised about how much of this thread could equally apply to gay people
I'm not - threads with bigotry in always follow the exact same argument and pattern, whether it be racism, Islamophobia, homophobia etc -

I think there is a stronger argument for gay spaces. This country, until very recently, legislated against and criminalised gay people. They were excluded, by law, from certain jobs. The remnants of those homophobic laws still exist in society.

This country hasn't had statutory racism in the same way it has had statutory homophobia, certainly not in living memory.

AtchinTan · 28/05/2023 17:04

@ HeartBrokenWife "No-one should be excluded on the the basis of their skin colour which is an immutable characteristic and one that’s not chosen and cannot be identified into or out of."

Outside of people are being asked to consider not booking, not being excluded from doing so: Race of all forms 'is an immutable characteristic and one that’s not chosen and cannot be identified into or out of.'

Some people can lie about what they are, usually to survive, though they pay their own price with dissonance. Some can lie to take advantage as racefakers and don't seem to suffer for it. But no one can identify in and out, they can only live with passing for something different, or lie about who they are, and obviously it's harder for some to get away with any of that than others.

Would you object to Maori people asking other races to not book one night to discuss issues around their race in a play, or is it because 'Black people' are grouping together identifying by communal skin coloration rather than a specific race?

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 17:00

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 28/05/2023 16:55

I am slightly surprised about how much of this thread could equally apply to gay people
I'm not - threads with bigotry in always follow the exact same argument and pattern, whether it be racism, Islamophobia, homophobia etc -

That's both inaccurate and offensive. Name calling and ad hominem attacks are the refuge of those without the ability to debate intelligently. Playground level argument rather than informed discussion. Sad really. Where is your evidence of bigotry? Or Islamaphobia et al? Receipts please.

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 28/05/2023 16:55

I am slightly surprised about how much of this thread could equally apply to gay people
I'm not - threads with bigotry in always follow the exact same argument and pattern, whether it be racism, Islamophobia, homophobia etc -

TeaKlaxon · 28/05/2023 16:54

TreadLight · 28/05/2023 16:45

You are using the language of Critical Race Theory which is based on American society, legal system and history and has been criticised for encouraging segregation.

I have done my best to educate myself but haven't found robust evidence that CRT is applicable in the same way to British society.

You should read Why I’m No Longer Talking to White People About Race.

Trying to shoehorn critical race theory in here is a red herring.

The only relevant question is whether minority groups with a history of oppression, and ongoing experiences of discrimination, hostility or exclusion, should be free to create spaces that are focused on those groups, rather than focused on the majority group.

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 16:53

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 28/05/2023 16:38

@HeartBrokenWife - can you explain why people of colour do not ever need to gather together, without the presence of white people? Can you honestly not see how an oppressed group of people might want and need to meet up alone, without having to include members of the oppressor group?

Can you explain where I said that? It's not what I think at all.

TeaKlaxon · 28/05/2023 16:50

AmeliaWarnerBros · 28/05/2023 15:44

White woman here, & while I have no issue with this (why would I?); surely it is segregating races? I have no idea what it is like to be black but surely this makes black people feel different or as if they are different?
I do not know how to articulate this- & I'm sure someone more articulate/knowledgeable can express this- but isn't it a sort of "marking out" thing- all the blacks in one place sort of thing??
Haven't read the thread yet (which I will) but can someone who is black translate what I mean?

On the plus side; as PPs have said, it could be a great way to get a more diverse audience into the theatre.

But black people are different! They have different experiences that shape their engagement with the world.

There is a tendency among some people to think that equality necessitates us to deny the differences among us. Different people have different experiences, they often have different communities, they often have different cultural reference points. They shouldn’t have to deny all of that just to have equality. They shouldn’t have to pretend that they are just the same as white people.

I am slightly surprised about how much of this thread could equally apply to gay people - there is also a strain of thinking that gay people should be just the same as straight people, when in fact our differences exist and should not have to be denied in order to have equal treatment.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 28/05/2023 16:49

I thought I was saying it was OK for minority groups to create space where they are centred, as @TeaKlaxon so eloquently put it, @TreadLight. I haven’t studied critical race theory - I was simply expressing my opinions.

TreadLight · 28/05/2023 16:45

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 28/05/2023 16:38

@HeartBrokenWife - can you explain why people of colour do not ever need to gather together, without the presence of white people? Can you honestly not see how an oppressed group of people might want and need to meet up alone, without having to include members of the oppressor group?

You are using the language of Critical Race Theory which is based on American society, legal system and history and has been criticised for encouraging segregation.

I have done my best to educate myself but haven't found robust evidence that CRT is applicable in the same way to British society.

TeaKlaxon · 28/05/2023 16:43

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 14:11

You cannot judge me to be acting in bad faith. I believe whatever I say I believe and you cannot tell me otherwise. I am offended by your judgement. You should accept me for who I am.

You’re someone who draws an equivalence between minority communities creating space where those communities are centred, and the actual forcible segregation based on race.

That in itself is enough to mark you out as someone with fairly abhorrent views on race.

Should women also not have spaces that centre women? Should gay people not have spaces that are about the gay community?

Is it just racial minorities you think should not have spaces that are centred on their own communities and experiences?

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 28/05/2023 16:38

@HeartBrokenWife - can you explain why people of colour do not ever need to gather together, without the presence of white people? Can you honestly not see how an oppressed group of people might want and need to meet up alone, without having to include members of the oppressor group?

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 16:37

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 16:29

to refuse to listen to dissenting black voices is, to put it bluntly, racist.

Says the person literally refusing to listen to black voices they dont agree with.

I’ve read about both viewpoints extensively for several years before reaching my own conclusions as I’ve already mentioned. Please keep up!

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 16:35

Beezknees · 28/05/2023 16:23

But you're only interested in the opinions of the people who agree with you. Why are you not listening to the black women on this thread who have explained why they are comfortable with this?

I have no idea who is white or black on this thread do I? Even if I did, how can white people speak on behalf of black people and do black people speak with one voice? They don’t, I can assure you.

Re not being interested in diverse opinions, erm, you’re clearly not so people in glasshouses…

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 16:29

to refuse to listen to dissenting black voices is, to put it bluntly, racist.

Says the person literally refusing to listen to black voices they dont agree with.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 16:27

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 16:13

I’m simply against racial segregation, no matter who’s imposing it on whom. No-one should be excluded on the the basis of their skin colour which is an immutable characteristic and one that’s not chosen and cannot be identified into or out of.

And how is that different to Guides or the WI if sex is immutable (not trying to turn this into a trnas debate)?

Out of interest who is being excluded from this theatre?

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 28/05/2023 16:26

Even when that would mean that an oppressed group could not gather together to discuss their lived experience of oppression, or to support each other, without members of the oppressor class present, to potentially disrupt or change the focus of the discussion, @HeartBrokenWife?

It’s like saying that women, biological human females, cannot meet with other biological human females to discuss the effect of patriarchal oppression on them and on women and girls world wide, without having to include men - which would change and inhibit the discussion, or to support each other free from the presence of the sex class we need support to deal with.

I am not saying that there isn’t a place for discussions/groups which include women and men, or people from any oppressed group and others from outwith that group - but if you insist that, for example, people of colour cannot meet up without including white people too, that would add more disadvantage to people who are already experiencing it.

Beezknees · 28/05/2023 16:23

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 16:20

I’m quite shocked that some of those in favour of racial segregation based on skin colour are presuming that all black people form a homogeneous mass. Please educate yourselves and understand that they, in exactly the same manner as white and Asian people, are individuals. Saying all black people think the same as every other black person is offensive. Clearly, not all white people think alike, so to refuse to listen to dissenting black voices is, to put it bluntly, racist.

But you're only interested in the opinions of the people who agree with you. Why are you not listening to the black women on this thread who have explained why they are comfortable with this?

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 16:20

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 28/05/2023 16:05

Haven't read the thread yet (which I will) but can someone who is black translate what I mean?
Yes, read the thread but not sure why someone who is black should translate for you?
Thread gives explanation

I’m quite shocked that some of those in favour of racial segregation based on skin colour are presuming that all black people form a homogeneous mass. Please educate yourselves and understand that they, in exactly the same manner as white and Asian people, are individuals. Saying all black people think the same as every other black person is offensive. Clearly, not all white people think alike, so to refuse to listen to dissenting black voices is, to put it bluntly, racist.

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 16:13

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 15:58

How is it going to lead to racial segragation, thats the bit thats missing.

So racial segragation was the part of society with the power keeping the part of society without the power out of the places they didn't want them e.g. White people controlling where black people went.

But this is black people, who still do not have power in the UK, making their own space.

So I'm unsure as to whether you think this is going to lead to black people segregating white people, or white people using this as an opportunity to re-segregate black people?

That's what's confusing, the how.

I’m simply against racial segregation, no matter who’s imposing it on whom. No-one should be excluded on the the basis of their skin colour which is an immutable characteristic and one that’s not chosen and cannot be identified into or out of.

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 16:08

beachcitygirl · 28/05/2023 15:03

Privileged person unhappy because someone else getting something nice feels like they're losing out.🤦🏻‍♀️

Diversity means that different people have different tastes. This play isn’t my cup of tea, mind you even a cup of tea isn’t my cup of tea since I hate tea 🤣 I’m really not at all jealous that I can’t go to see this play on Monday or Tuesday or whenever because I don’t want to see it at all. I’m anti racial segregation, that’s all.

BodgerLovesMashedPotato · 28/05/2023 16:05

AmeliaWarnerBros · 28/05/2023 15:44

White woman here, & while I have no issue with this (why would I?); surely it is segregating races? I have no idea what it is like to be black but surely this makes black people feel different or as if they are different?
I do not know how to articulate this- & I'm sure someone more articulate/knowledgeable can express this- but isn't it a sort of "marking out" thing- all the blacks in one place sort of thing??
Haven't read the thread yet (which I will) but can someone who is black translate what I mean?

On the plus side; as PPs have said, it could be a great way to get a more diverse audience into the theatre.

Haven't read the thread yet (which I will) but can someone who is black translate what I mean?
Yes, read the thread but not sure why someone who is black should translate for you?
Thread gives explanation

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 15:58

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 15:52

Ok, I’ll explain for the umpteenth time that my fear is racial segregation which I don’t want to see making a comeback. My argument is very, very simple and I’m sorry you can’t seem to grasp it. Just as I was advised to do, it would be easy for you to understand my point of view if you chose to educate yourself by reading/ watching a diversity of viewpoints instead of assuming that yours is the only voice in this debate.

How is it going to lead to racial segragation, thats the bit thats missing.

So racial segragation was the part of society with the power keeping the part of society without the power out of the places they didn't want them e.g. White people controlling where black people went.

But this is black people, who still do not have power in the UK, making their own space.

So I'm unsure as to whether you think this is going to lead to black people segregating white people, or white people using this as an opportunity to re-segregate black people?

That's what's confusing, the how.

HeartBrokenWife · 28/05/2023 15:52

Summerfun2023 · 28/05/2023 14:44

I will repeat again Live and let Live means you should tolerate the opinions and behaviour of others so that they will similarly tolerate your own.

Again I will ask you what is your fear around this 1 night?

Ok, I’ll explain for the umpteenth time that my fear is racial segregation which I don’t want to see making a comeback. My argument is very, very simple and I’m sorry you can’t seem to grasp it. Just as I was advised to do, it would be easy for you to understand my point of view if you chose to educate yourself by reading/ watching a diversity of viewpoints instead of assuming that yours is the only voice in this debate.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 15:47

AmeliaWarnerBros · 28/05/2023 15:44

White woman here, & while I have no issue with this (why would I?); surely it is segregating races? I have no idea what it is like to be black but surely this makes black people feel different or as if they are different?
I do not know how to articulate this- & I'm sure someone more articulate/knowledgeable can express this- but isn't it a sort of "marking out" thing- all the blacks in one place sort of thing??
Haven't read the thread yet (which I will) but can someone who is black translate what I mean?

On the plus side; as PPs have said, it could be a great way to get a more diverse audience into the theatre.

Do you feel the same about women's spaces?

There are a few black women (I assume women) on the thread. they are comfortable with this and have articulated why, it may be worth taking your cue from them rather than asking them to translate your feeling that they might not share.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 28/05/2023 15:45

I wonder where the posters who are so determined that having a mainly black space for one night is wrong and disgusting and unacceptable are when there are threads about guides or the wi, or other female only spaces?

Literally nowhere to be seen...

If you are okay with female only spaces, and gay clubs etc but your immediate reaction is that a black space is disgusting, you might want to think on that. If you have read all the thread and still think that then that says a lot.