Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you find this offensive?

659 replies

Meeting · 25/05/2023 12:55

The Theatre Royal Stratford East is putting on a show and have blocked out 2 dates as "Blackout" nights where they encourage (but I don't think plan to enforce) that only black people may attend these performances.

I saw them discussing it on Piers Morgan and neither of the guests advocating for it were able to convince me that this type of segregation was at all beneficial.

Does anybody think this is a good idea? Personally I think segregation based on skin colour has no place in society, no matter who benefits from it. But I'm interested to hear from others who might away it differently?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
bryceQ · 25/05/2023 17:13

Babdoc · 25/05/2023 16:45

So if my white sister and her black African husband were only able to see the show on a blackout night, she’d have to
miss out on it in order to not spoil the black audience’s enjoyment of their freedom from “white gaze”? Or go along, and feel uncomfortable knowing that the organisers preferred her not to be there?

🙄🙄🙄

As another white woman with a black husband I would hope I have the insight to see that supporting spaces so that black men and women feel comfortable is progressive. I want my black friends and husband to have spaces free from judgement and I wouldn't centre myself. Seeing the absolute bullshit my husband deals with on a daily basis, anything that helps him feel comfortable in a setting like the theatre I am massively in favour of.

JustBeKindItsEasy · 25/05/2023 17:13

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 14:41

Can't you just be racist without being called a racist these days??

I think if you’re racist you’re racist whether you’re called it or not.
Or am I not understanding your comment ?

JustBeKindItsEasy · 25/05/2023 17:11

Hadjab · 25/05/2023 17:06

Your white sister could go along and feel uncomfortable that her black husband and people like him have been subjected to the sort of shit that has lead to this point, and maybe be an advocate for change.

But this isn’t about advocating change. This is regressive.

Hadjab · 25/05/2023 17:06

Babdoc · 25/05/2023 16:45

So if my white sister and her black African husband were only able to see the show on a blackout night, she’d have to
miss out on it in order to not spoil the black audience’s enjoyment of their freedom from “white gaze”? Or go along, and feel uncomfortable knowing that the organisers preferred her not to be there?

Your white sister could go along and feel uncomfortable that her black husband and people like him have been subjected to the sort of shit that has lead to this point, and maybe be an advocate for change.

NewPinkJacket · 25/05/2023 17:02

Meeting · 25/05/2023 13:02

Something to do with the context of the show I think

I'm embarrassed for you that you were in such a rush to be offended, you didn't even research it properly so you could answer this very simple question.

Hadjab · 25/05/2023 17:02

Babdoc · 25/05/2023 15:35

Many couples in the UK, and especially London, are mixed race. How black do they have to be to be acceptable on the blackout night? And if one of them is white, do they have to go to the theatre on different nights? The organisers don’t seem to have thought this through for a multicultural society like Britain.

Oh my life! You are being deliberately obtuse, aren't you? It's one sodding night out of thirty, no one is saying no whites allowed, at any point! And if the couple is mixed race, presumably one half wouldn't be blind to their partner's experiences, so they would probably go to support them anyway.

FFS

Ponderosamum · 25/05/2023 16:58

JustBeKindItsEasy · 25/05/2023 16:17

Well I’m glad to hear I’m not the only black person with this opinion.
A PP assumed I was white because of my thoughts on the subject. Which I find rather sad.

This. if this were reversed it would be flamed completely as racist. It cust both ways in my opinion.

StayingZenInTheVipersDen · 25/05/2023 16:57

Doesn't affect me at all. I assume there's a reason for this and it doesn't bother me. (I'm a white woman fwiw)

Hadjab · 25/05/2023 16:56

CampervanKween · 25/05/2023 15:20

And yes, my son keeps sending me adverts for job applications he would have been interested in applying for except the criteria specifically states he is not allowed to apply.

I'd be interested to see these jobs he's applying for. Are they specifically saying he's not allowed to apply - which I'm sure is illegal - or are they saying they welcome applicants from X, Y & Z groups?

hiahiawatha · 25/05/2023 16:53

Avaynia · 25/05/2023 16:46

Well I’m a black woman and I don’t find it offensive or a step backwards at all. It’s one show that isn’t catering to white feelings. It is no different to me than women gathering to talk about women only experiences without being expected to justify and parade them around for men because they “don’t understand.”

The safety aspect only goes so far as well, I feel. In a breastfeeding group is the concern that dads are going to attack the women? No. It’s that they’re talking about something vulnerable and personal and shouldn’t have to do that in front of people who will minimize or not understand or center the conversations on themselves. Or if you want a woman doctor. Is it because you think you’ll be assaulted by a male doctors? It has happened but how often? “Rare” is somewhat subjective when it comes to frequency. But since racist attacks are “rare” then we shouldn’t allow black people to have black only experiences. Yet I would not fault a woman for wanting a woman doctor just because it makes her feel more comfortable rather than it being because she’s in danger.

White women on here have frequently invaded and complained about the black mumsnet board, and have also complained that they should be allowed to have their feminism board without men or TRAs or having the boards split. That has nothing to do with safety. But you know what happens when you let men in? They invalidate, take over, #notallmen, and pile on about male suicide rates or whatever. But I suppose we shouldn’t have those spaces anymore because equality with men will only be achieved by giving them access to our spaces and conversations all the time? I don’t want to argue with white people that the racism I experience isn’t just me being sensitive just like they don’t want to do the same about sexism and men.

There is plenty of nuance involved and black people aren’t a monolith, as was importantly pointed out to me again, but I think the talk of being banned and segregated are intentionally inflammatory and hypocritical. And predictable because white women, usually, like to call out all men and hold them accountable for the Patriarchy but don’t like it when all white people get the same treatment. Y’all understand power dynamics just fine when you’re on the receiving end.

I really don't think race and gender can be treated the same. Black is a skintone. The idea of a "black community" is nonsensical - what characterises black people's lifestyles is far too diverse to form such a category. Perhaps you could make an event for people of Jamaican heritage, or people descended from the Windrush generation, or 2nd generation Nigerian immigrants. But categorising people by their skintone alone is absurd.

Men and women, on the other hand, can be categorised into two groups because biologically, down to our very chromosomes, we fall into two obviously distinct categories.

JustBeKindItsEasy · 25/05/2023 16:52

BadNomad · 25/05/2023 16:28

No one is forcing anyone into careers. It's actually forcing those careers to accept everyone by being more open and welcoming. So people who do have an interest in those careers aren't put off by them being male/white/protestant dominant. Why do you think there are so few POC in teaching for example? Do you think it's because they have no interest in teaching or because they won't make good teachers? Or could it be because it's a career they've not seen many POC do and so it's not even on their radar when they're thinking about the future?

Now imagine if it was normal to see black faces standing at the front of the classroom, don't you think that might make more children consider teaching for their future?

All these heavily biased roles will remain heavily biased until it becomes normal to see diversity. But diversity does not just happen. Sometimes it has to be forced in the present so it can become normal in the future.

It's why we have so many Acts against discrimination. Because if you left it to people to be "fair and equal", well, you wouldn't be an architect and black people wouldn't be allowed in the theatre at all.

Acts against discrimination mean everyone is equal
Everyone has a choice, a say and an equal chance.
As long as POC see themselves as different,( I’m not referring to celebrating culture here btw ) and I include all colours here, then some POC msy avoid certain situations because they differentiate between themselves and others by colour alone.
So, surely, by not sounding anyone out as different they / we will not see ourselves as different and will follow our dreams irrespective of this.

I didn’t, my dh and dcs and relatives didn’t.
Black people we know are rising above this blame game. This idea we have more rights than white people. We don’t. If everyone had the same idea no one would label anyone and so no one would see the difference in the classroom if their teacher was a POC.

And so. OPs concerns are, to us, exactly that….a concern as we once again move in the wrong direction.

Justalittlebitduckling · 25/05/2023 16:49

PsychoHotSauce · 25/05/2023 13:09

Its a PR stunt imo. The language used was deliberately goady. Something about wanting an "all black identifying" audience to enjoy it "free from the white gaze".

I certainly wouldn't have known it was on without the controversy making the news.

Isn’t it usually dark at the theatre?

Beautyfadesdumbisforever · 25/05/2023 16:48

I did the whole that's awful etc etc to start with but heard the reason why being sensibly discussed “for once” on GMB and I get it now. Have a look at clip on YouTube.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 25/05/2023 16:48

I don't find it offensive. Where I live, there are few black people and in the gym this week I saw a black couple doing their workout. I wondered what it must be like for them to be in such a 'white' space, how they must feel? It's not intentionally a white demographic here, it just is, very little diversity.

I think the theatre 'black out' is a very good idea.

Avaynia · 25/05/2023 16:46

Well I’m a black woman and I don’t find it offensive or a step backwards at all. It’s one show that isn’t catering to white feelings. It is no different to me than women gathering to talk about women only experiences without being expected to justify and parade them around for men because they “don’t understand.”

The safety aspect only goes so far as well, I feel. In a breastfeeding group is the concern that dads are going to attack the women? No. It’s that they’re talking about something vulnerable and personal and shouldn’t have to do that in front of people who will minimize or not understand or center the conversations on themselves. Or if you want a woman doctor. Is it because you think you’ll be assaulted by a male doctors? It has happened but how often? “Rare” is somewhat subjective when it comes to frequency. But since racist attacks are “rare” then we shouldn’t allow black people to have black only experiences. Yet I would not fault a woman for wanting a woman doctor just because it makes her feel more comfortable rather than it being because she’s in danger.

White women on here have frequently invaded and complained about the black mumsnet board, and have also complained that they should be allowed to have their feminism board without men or TRAs or having the boards split. That has nothing to do with safety. But you know what happens when you let men in? They invalidate, take over, #notallmen, and pile on about male suicide rates or whatever. But I suppose we shouldn’t have those spaces anymore because equality with men will only be achieved by giving them access to our spaces and conversations all the time? I don’t want to argue with white people that the racism I experience isn’t just me being sensitive just like they don’t want to do the same about sexism and men.

There is plenty of nuance involved and black people aren’t a monolith, as was importantly pointed out to me again, but I think the talk of being banned and segregated are intentionally inflammatory and hypocritical. And predictable because white women, usually, like to call out all men and hold them accountable for the Patriarchy but don’t like it when all white people get the same treatment. Y’all understand power dynamics just fine when you’re on the receiving end.

hiahiawatha · 25/05/2023 16:45

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 25/05/2023 16:40

Segregation was the forced enactment of US racism under the law. Black Americans were forced permanently into inferior schools, hospitals, housing etc. They were not allowed to share the same bus seats or theatre seats at all. They were denied a full vote until 1965.

This is a voluntary gathering of black people to watch a play that reflects their experience of racism. In every other performance, mixed audiences can watch and learn together. In one performance, white audiences are asked to voluntarily abstain from the show so that black audiences can watch it in a different context.

These things are not the same.

///

Fantastic post

No one's saying they're the same. It's just the principle of dividing people up by colour that doesn't sit right.

AlizeeEasy · 25/05/2023 16:45

I think it’s an interesting idea. Less about segregation but about the collective historic trauma of the audience. Similar to if a play about the holocaust encouraged a Jewish only audience. It’s because the subject matter is something that would deeply affect those who are part of the group the play is about. Everyone in a room connecting on that level could be a powerful thing, which could change the viewing experience compared to an evening with a more diverse audience. Hope it goes well for them!

Babdoc · 25/05/2023 16:45

So if my white sister and her black African husband were only able to see the show on a blackout night, she’d have to
miss out on it in order to not spoil the black audience’s enjoyment of their freedom from “white gaze”? Or go along, and feel uncomfortable knowing that the organisers preferred her not to be there?

MoggyMittens23 · 25/05/2023 16:45

I don't find it offensive and have no issue with it. Fact is that it's not the same the other way round. I am sure that some black people will feel a lot more comfortable on this night and why shouldn't they get to go and enjoy something while not feeling uncomfortable in any way by the presence of some white people. They have stuff in common and can relate in a way that white people can't.

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 25/05/2023 16:41

Avaynia · 25/05/2023 14:51

My friend and I go to the theatre regularly and we always notice how white the audience is. More than once we’ve been the only POC there, for the smaller plays. At the ballet I saw one other black family and my mother and I talked about how inaccessible the arts can be to people of color either because it’s expensive, or the audience is hostile to anyone they think is too low class to be there, or because the content is so white focused that we don’t relate to it. You “don’t pay attention” because you’re one of them. I suspect you’d notice when walking into a place with only men there, however.

This!!! So many of you don't notice because you are the majority. Somehow it's ok for women to have special events, but black people??!! Never.

You sound like men fighting to be invited to women only spaces, except you aren't even being excluded.

Not everything is about white women.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 25/05/2023 16:40

Segregation was the forced enactment of US racism under the law. Black Americans were forced permanently into inferior schools, hospitals, housing etc. They were not allowed to share the same bus seats or theatre seats at all. They were denied a full vote until 1965.

This is a voluntary gathering of black people to watch a play that reflects their experience of racism. In every other performance, mixed audiences can watch and learn together. In one performance, white audiences are asked to voluntarily abstain from the show so that black audiences can watch it in a different context.

These things are not the same.

///

Fantastic post

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 25/05/2023 16:39

SimonsCow · 25/05/2023 16:06

They have said that the performance is aimed at black people. White people may attend if they wish but they are not the target audience. It’s like saying the show will be in Spanish but feel free to come along even if you don’t speak Spanish- you won’t understand a word of it though.

Get off your high horse.

This

2ManyPjs · 25/05/2023 16:39

MasterBeth · 25/05/2023 16:06

Segregation was the forced enactment of US racism under the law. Black Americans were forced permanently into inferior schools, hospitals, housing etc. They were not allowed to share the same bus seats or theatre seats at all. They were denied a full vote until 1965.

This is a voluntary gathering of black people to watch a play that reflects their experience of racism. In every other performance, mixed audiences can watch and learn together. In one performance, white audiences are asked to voluntarily abstain from the show so that black audiences can watch it in a different context.

These things are not the same.

Exactly how I'm reading it as well and finding the whole "but it's segregation" just completely warped and melodramatic. It's honestly no wonder Black Mumsnetters feel they need a board of their own. It's nothing more than a ONE night 'safe space', for an audience who might not otherwise feel comfortable watching a play exploring issues of race with a mixed audience. That's all it is. And to argue that it wouldn't happen the other way around is disingenuous and ignorant to say the very least. It's a successful inititive elsewhere already, so surely attempts to attract larger and more diverse groups to attend the theatre (and let's face it theatres took a hell of a knock during Covid) can only be a good thing.

But apartheid was, and is, inherently wrong.
It is a massively retrograde step in these supposedly enlightened and tolerant times to advocate for racial segregation.

That's not what's happening here, please stop being so stupid!

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 16:36

I don't like segregation at all. I understand the point of this and what the theatre is trying to do, but the more we segregate the longer racism will hang about.

One of the students I'm working with in my team says her uni is doing some separate teaching for BAME and non BAME people. It's to give the BAME people a safe space to discuss racism without being inadvertently offended by anyone non BAME. Personally I think it's a ridiculous idea. Racism and division will not end by people continuing to segregate on colour.

What if you are not sure where you fall? What if you are white looking with a black parent? What if the divisions are not so easy to see.

The colour of a person's skin tells us nothing more than the colour of their skin. We cannot make assumptions about cultural background, experiences of racism or anything else by looking at someone. Dividing people up based solely on colour is bonkers IMO.

ocs30 · 25/05/2023 16:33

This reply has been deleted

Sorry all, this poster is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

I would imagine that Martin Luther King Jr. would be more concerned with the amount of systemic racism and the rising tide of fascism in the world than a night at the theatre.

As a white woman, I don't tend to comment on these threads, but I do think it's very telling that whenever someone posts on here asking if something is racist, there's always a pile on of people shouting that it's not, and the poster is oversensitive (before rushing off to the feminism forum to rant about men taking over women's spaces).

Gives me a clearer understanding of why a safe space might be desirable in this instance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread