Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you find this offensive?

659 replies

Meeting · 25/05/2023 12:55

The Theatre Royal Stratford East is putting on a show and have blocked out 2 dates as "Blackout" nights where they encourage (but I don't think plan to enforce) that only black people may attend these performances.

I saw them discussing it on Piers Morgan and neither of the guests advocating for it were able to convince me that this type of segregation was at all beneficial.

Does anybody think this is a good idea? Personally I think segregation based on skin colour has no place in society, no matter who benefits from it. But I'm interested to hear from others who might away it differently?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
ElizabethBest · 25/05/2023 19:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I'm sorry, I didn't realise you have issues with reading comprehension. I said that POC were underrepresented in the arts. This is a fact. There have been plenty of articles, academic studies and surveys that bear this out, if you don't believe me.

I never once said there are no POC in shows.

The fact that the last 3 shows that you, one person, have chosen to see out of all the hundreds of shows available in the West End alone, does not mean there is anywhere near equal representation of people of colour in the arts sector.

It's obtuse to claim otherwise in the face of a readily available volume of evidence.

SleepDreamThinkHuge · 25/05/2023 19:56

It is one show fgs! Plus no where did it say non black people cannot attend. The same people who on here talk about having women only spaces are outraged when minority groups do the same. More people need to educate themselves and understand that black people have been alienated from UK society for a long time and still are. No one bats an eyelid when you hear women only or LGBT only but when it is "black only" everyone goes mad. I do not think find it offensive when women, LGBT or other groups have their own shows/spaces. We hear a lot on this thread "check your privilege" for men. Which everyone agrees with. People on here really need to check their privilege when it comes to black people as well. They still suffer in the UK - more likely to die in childbirth, told to get over slavery cause it was a long time ago but no one says that about other atrocities like the Holocaust. Playing the "race card" when they have been racially abused.

2ManyPjs · 25/05/2023 19:53

I'm coming across ass racist but I haven't said anything racist? How do you work that out?

@Meeting Black people are telling you why they this kind of safe space is a positive thing for them, but you seem to begrudge that. You say you're asking for opinions but really, you're not interested in their opinions. They're telling you exactly why it's not segregation but no, you you seem to think you know better, even though it was black communities who had segregation enshrined in law and enforced on them. You just keep talking over them. But well done you for seeing 3 plays with black actors.

Summerfun2023 · 25/05/2023 19:52

Meeting · 25/05/2023 19:24

I'm coming across ass racist but I haven't said anything racist? How do you work that out?

I've seen the posts and I don't agree with them. I asked for opinions, which I've read. I don't agree with them and I've responded to many, I can't sit and respond to 13 pages worth of posts.

Do you know what the play is about and if you do why would you begrudge them two nights????

Meeting · 25/05/2023 19:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

itsmylife7 · 25/05/2023 19:43

Nope don't have an issue with it at all.

If you're interested you can delve deeper in to the reasons behind it, and white people are NOT actually banned from it.

ElizabethBest · 25/05/2023 19:40

Meeting · 25/05/2023 19:26

The last 3 shows I've watched have had a person of colour as the lead.

Good for you. But that's confirmation bias, not evidence.

Meeting · 25/05/2023 19:26

ElizabethBest · 25/05/2023 19:21

You need to properly read what the play is actually about, and then perhaps you’ll understand.

People of colour are hugely underrepresented in the arts, both on stage and in the audience - if a story is made by black people for black people about black culture, why shouldn’t there be 2 performances out of the 100 or so for its intended audience to engage with it without white people altering the dynamic with their inherent privilege?

If a play written by a former suffragette, about women’s suffrage put on 2 performances for a women only audience, would you feel the same?

The last 3 shows I've watched have had a person of colour as the lead.

OP posts:
Meeting · 25/05/2023 19:24

QuacketyQuack · 25/05/2023 19:17

@Meeting OP you are just coming across as ignorant and racist. Admittedly you haven't posted anything as racist but you've ignored posts explaining to you why they have encouraged black people only to attend. You're ignoring quite reasonable explanations and seems you are insisting on wanting to be right.

I'm coming across ass racist but I haven't said anything racist? How do you work that out?

I've seen the posts and I don't agree with them. I asked for opinions, which I've read. I don't agree with them and I've responded to many, I can't sit and respond to 13 pages worth of posts.

OP posts:
ElizabethBest · 25/05/2023 19:21

You need to properly read what the play is actually about, and then perhaps you’ll understand.

People of colour are hugely underrepresented in the arts, both on stage and in the audience - if a story is made by black people for black people about black culture, why shouldn’t there be 2 performances out of the 100 or so for its intended audience to engage with it without white people altering the dynamic with their inherent privilege?

If a play written by a former suffragette, about women’s suffrage put on 2 performances for a women only audience, would you feel the same?

QuacketyQuack · 25/05/2023 19:17

@Meeting OP you are just coming across as ignorant and racist. Admittedly you haven't posted anything as racist but you've ignored posts explaining to you why they have encouraged black people only to attend. You're ignoring quite reasonable explanations and seems you are insisting on wanting to be right.

DeathByReadyMeals · 25/05/2023 19:06

hiahiawatha · 25/05/2023 16:53

I really don't think race and gender can be treated the same. Black is a skintone. The idea of a "black community" is nonsensical - what characterises black people's lifestyles is far too diverse to form such a category. Perhaps you could make an event for people of Jamaican heritage, or people descended from the Windrush generation, or 2nd generation Nigerian immigrants. But categorising people by their skintone alone is absurd.

Men and women, on the other hand, can be categorised into two groups because biologically, down to our very chromosomes, we fall into two obviously distinct categories.

I can’t believe you think ‘skin tone’ is too broad, but ‘chromosome’ isn’t. Women-only spaces don’t exist so we can sit and talk about our chromosomes, do they? They exist because we want to discuss a shared experience in the way the world treats us, in the way men view us, difficulties we face because of our sex, instances of sexism, of assault, of discrimination. We have women-only spaces so we can talk about embarrassing or painful or traumatic events amongst other people who understand, and away from those who don’t.

Do you think women are some sort of cultural monolith, or would you agree that women also have diverse lifestyles?

Because although you’re right that there are cultural differences between Jamaicans/Windrush descendants, and second gen Nigerian immigrants. But there are likely to be shared experiences and situations between them, just as there are shared experiences for women of different ages and backgrounds and incomes. And if some black people choose to spend a single evening with people who share and understand those experiences, I’ve got no problem with it.

Outofthepark · 25/05/2023 19:06

Gigglemous · 25/05/2023 18:33

Its simple. It's a way of creating a safe space for people of colour who would otherwise feel uncomfortable watching something centred on their race, in the presence of people that are white.

I'm a person of colour. My parents are Punjabi. I wouldn't feel comfortable watching something that depicts the bloody partition of the punjab in 1947 in front of a crowd of white British people. You have no idea how uncomfortable these situations can be for a person of colour who is also immensely proud of being British.

I understand where you're coming from. But they haven't banned any race. They have encouraged a race instead. There's a difference in language.

You're focused on seeing it through a very specific perspective. One which actually makes you come across quite angry. Just see it for what it is. An encouragement for black youth to come and see it. I see no issue with that at all

I love his post @Gigglemous so well said.

Outofthepark · 25/05/2023 19:04

Bramblecrumble22 · 25/05/2023 12:57

It's also got WWII bombing connotations.

Wtf 😂 This forum is mental sometimes.

OP you're hardly going to get a balanced discussion on Piers Morgan are you? But I guess that's why you're asking so fair enough.

It's a great idea to have a black only night, and the big reason is lived experience and racism. It's like having a women only night for a discussion show that discusses the terrible treatment of women by the Met.

You're not saying in my example that men are below you, or they're not usually welcome, you're saying 'we just want a break from having to explain what mansplaining is, why a man's experience is different, why some men do not understand, how we've all had experience of being assaulted, or intimidated, or whatever, or just the need to explain key terms or concepts or justifications'. It means a different and often richer discussion that you couldn't have if men were there. They'll be there other nights, and their input will be interesting, but it's valuable to not have them there, too.

TeaKlaxon · 25/05/2023 18:52

JudgeRudy · 25/05/2023 18:40

I don't think it's about segregating audiences. I'd say it's more s gim8ck to target groups that in the past maybe haven't accessed the theatre. Ultimately I'd imagine it's a marketing ploy.

I don’t think it’s a ‘gimmick’, I think it is about providing a community with a particular relationship with artistic material being encouraged to experience that material within their community if they wish.

As I think about it more I’m not sure it’s that different to gay clubs, for example.

TeaKlaxon · 25/05/2023 18:50

DonnaBanana · 25/05/2023 18:48

I don’t mind the idea but I don’t like the name and find that a bit offensive. It should be something like BAME Day instead. We don’t use terms like blacklist or black sheep anymore due to the connotations.

I would assume the name was devised by black people who are also behind the event itself, so I think we can take their steer as to whether it is an offensive name.

DonnaBanana · 25/05/2023 18:48

I don’t mind the idea but I don’t like the name and find that a bit offensive. It should be something like BAME Day instead. We don’t use terms like blacklist or black sheep anymore due to the connotations.

JudgeRudy · 25/05/2023 18:40

Meeting · 25/05/2023 12:55

The Theatre Royal Stratford East is putting on a show and have blocked out 2 dates as "Blackout" nights where they encourage (but I don't think plan to enforce) that only black people may attend these performances.

I saw them discussing it on Piers Morgan and neither of the guests advocating for it were able to convince me that this type of segregation was at all beneficial.

Does anybody think this is a good idea? Personally I think segregation based on skin colour has no place in society, no matter who benefits from it. But I'm interested to hear from others who might away it differently?

I don't think it's about segregating audiences. I'd say it's more s gim8ck to target groups that in the past maybe haven't accessed the theatre. Ultimately I'd imagine it's a marketing ploy.

TeaKlaxon · 25/05/2023 18:38

Clarinet1 · 25/05/2023 18:30

I think it’s a shame that so many groups feel the need to cut themselves off from other groups although I understand some need for their own spaces at some times and for some things. I am white, middle class, straight, of British Anglican heritage but I am prepared to learn respectfully about others groups. I can’t walk a mile in a black/Asian/gay person’s moccasins if they won’t lend me their moccasins.

But the point is that not everything that minority communities do is about educating people outside that community. There are incredible opportunities for white people to learn about the experience of people of colour, or straight people to learn about the experience of queer people etc. More opportunities than ever. There are some incredible books out there (Why I'm No Longer Talking to White People About Race was an excellent way in to learn about the experience of people of colour), there are tonnes of opportunities to read lived experiences and perspectives online.

But minority groups don't owe it to majority groups to centre those majority groups in everything they do. So if your first reaction to a theatre night geared towards people of a particular minority group is that it might deprive you, from a majority group, of an opportunity to learn about that minority group's experience, that is precisely the sort of majority-centring that these sorts of initiatives are designed to address.

I'm a white gay woman - so I sort of understand the logic of black people who want white people to stop making race issues all about them, because I often have the exact same reaction to straight people who make gay issues all about them.

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 25/05/2023 18:37

Meeting · 25/05/2023 17:50

That is so unbelievably offensive I don't even know how to reply. Are you suggesting I should hide my race away and pretend I'm something else?
Don't dare try and tell me I'm privileged when a large portion of society are racist to me in ways that haven't been socially acceptable for other races in several years.

Dianne Abbott was right first time.

Gigglemous · 25/05/2023 18:33

Its simple. It's a way of creating a safe space for people of colour who would otherwise feel uncomfortable watching something centred on their race, in the presence of people that are white.

I'm a person of colour. My parents are Punjabi. I wouldn't feel comfortable watching something that depicts the bloody partition of the punjab in 1947 in front of a crowd of white British people. You have no idea how uncomfortable these situations can be for a person of colour who is also immensely proud of being British.

I understand where you're coming from. But they haven't banned any race. They have encouraged a race instead. There's a difference in language.

You're focused on seeing it through a very specific perspective. One which actually makes you come across quite angry. Just see it for what it is. An encouragement for black youth to come and see it. I see no issue with that at all

Clarinet1 · 25/05/2023 18:30

I think it’s a shame that so many groups feel the need to cut themselves off from other groups although I understand some need for their own spaces at some times and for some things. I am white, middle class, straight, of British Anglican heritage but I am prepared to learn respectfully about others groups. I can’t walk a mile in a black/Asian/gay person’s moccasins if they won’t lend me their moccasins.

Avaynia · 25/05/2023 18:28

hiahiawatha · 25/05/2023 16:53

I really don't think race and gender can be treated the same. Black is a skintone. The idea of a "black community" is nonsensical - what characterises black people's lifestyles is far too diverse to form such a category. Perhaps you could make an event for people of Jamaican heritage, or people descended from the Windrush generation, or 2nd generation Nigerian immigrants. But categorising people by their skintone alone is absurd.

Men and women, on the other hand, can be categorised into two groups because biologically, down to our very chromosomes, we fall into two obviously distinct categories.

I’d love to but my ancestors were slaves and we don’t have any records of where we’re from or any connection to those communities 😂

Sunnysunbun · 25/05/2023 18:27

Couldn’t care less.

HeartBrokenWife · 25/05/2023 18:27

Racial segregation wasn’t a success the first time around, so I’m not sure it will work this time round. I’m happy to let people of other races go to the theatre without being there myself, but I’ve never subjected anyone to my “white gaze” so my absence won’t spare anyone that weirdness I’m afraid.

Swipe left for the next trending thread