Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys and men

59 replies

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:26

I have two boys. DS1 is 11 and has always been a kind of 'alpha male' type - wants big muscles! massively sporty, naturally loves all traditionally 'male' pursuits. His younger brother is a bit the opposite. He is v gentle, likes to keep fit but not sporty, into art and music. I love them both for who they are. They r great kids (in my v bias mum opinion!)

Anyway, DS1 has become increasingly frustrated at school because the girls are being given preferential treatment when it comes to sport. Head of PE is a great woman, a feminist and strongly believes in girls doing football etc.. I'm all for that. She has v good intent. But it now seems to be at the expense of the boys. Girls allowed on the AstroTurf at break, not the boys. Girls football taken to local matches, not the boys. Girls hockey promoted at lunchtime, no opportunity for the boys. Boys do netball and girls do basketball. DS loves basketball so this hasn't gone down well! DS and his friends even organised a little protest one lunch time and made plaquards to say 'give boys a chance too' or something like that!

I've had lots of discussions with DS about how it's great that girls do football etc.. and there should be equal opportunities for both sexes, but he feels boys aren't given a chance. He loves sport but only sees the girls getting opportunities. He has started talking about Andrew Tate with admiration. I've told him what Andrew Tate stands for, what he's done etc.. and DS seems to understand, but his friends talk about him and DS only picks up what they say and what he sees as good stuff.

Now, maybe things have to sway this way (girls having more opportunity than boys) in society for things to eventually even out and reach equality status. But I'm worried this kind of action at school level leads to men and boys later feeling disillusioned and seeking male role models who perpetuate sexism (like Andrew Tate) in order to try and find their way. DS says half the girls don't even like football and just sit on the AstroTurf at lunch chatting (he knows some girls do enjoy the football but can't see why they can't all play together), whereas he and his friends actually want to play. He's really fed up.

This is not really a question of 'how do I handle it all' as we r finding a way. But more a statement for discussion on what's happening at school level and in wider society to men and boys. I don't want my son or his friends feeling pushed aside as woman used to be, and searching for role models in the wrong places.

OP posts:
FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:48

Hoppinggreen · 25/05/2023 10:43

Yep, the experience your son is having is basically what girls have had for many many years.
I fought with her school to call it Boys football and girls football rather than football and girls football.
Perhaps rather than make your son turn to the likes of Andrew Tate this experience could make him more empathetic to what women and girls have to put up with?

Except he's a child. I've taught him about how women have been treated historically. I've talked to him about how things were in my childhood (I hate to play netball not basketball for example, just like he's experiencing now!) But from his experience, boys are the ones not getting the opportunities. I agree woman have been wronged in the past, and many still are. But now denying men and boys opportunities is not the way forward. We need equality surely. Not just the attitude of 'ha ha see how it feels' - especially as my son has not contributed to historical sexism. It's not his fault that in the past girls were not treated well.

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 25/05/2023 10:43

justpushingthrough · 25/05/2023 10:38

Boys moaning that girls are getting what boys/men have had for years 😂

Yep, the experience your son is having is basically what girls have had for many many years.
I fought with her school to call it Boys football and girls football rather than football and girls football.
Perhaps rather than make your son turn to the likes of Andrew Tate this experience could make him more empathetic to what women and girls have to put up with?

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:42

justpushingthrough · 25/05/2023 10:38

Boys moaning that girls are getting what boys/men have had for years 😂

Well I think this might be the PE heads opinion. But two wrongs don't make a right. It was wrong when girls did not have the opportunity that boys had. But it isn't right to now deny boys the opportunity girls have. It's should be equal opportunity for all, surely.

OP posts:
Rainyrunway · 25/05/2023 10:40

I don't see this as "boys moaning" though. Equality is what we need. Not girls just getting would boys and men had before!
OP you raise some very interesting points. Please do speak to the school.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:39

Maddy70 · 25/05/2023 10:30

It would be worth mentioning the Andrew tate admiration of several pupils to the head of year. Maybe they can so some sort of assembly and. Rasiw awareness.

I would also speak to the head of PE. You seem reasonable with well reasoned questions to raise but the boys competition shouldn't be Compromised

Thanks. I'll think about raising the Andrew Tate thing. He's in Yr6 and with only a few weeks now til the end of term I wasn't sure whether to bother to raise it with school, it maybe I should.

I spoke briefly to pe head (also son's form teacher) at parents evening. She was of the opinion 'think you can do better, then crack on..' she didn't say it in those words, but I think she felt a bit annoyed I was raising it, and I didn't want to push it as she's a good teacher and has good intent for the girls. I don't think I'm socially skilled enough to raise it again in a way that doesn't offend her. Again, with only a few weeks til the end of term i've just been thinking that hopefully next year at his secondary school he'll start getting the opportunities he doesn't have now (he also does quite a bit of sport outside school, so in his own case, he does have opportunity for what he enjoys). It's more that I feel generally this might be a wider issue than just his school.

OP posts:
justpushingthrough · 25/05/2023 10:38

Boys moaning that girls are getting what boys/men have had for years 😂

brunettemic · 25/05/2023 10:36

I don’t agree with things have to sway to girls having more opportunities than girls thing, that is just as bad as boys having more opportunity. Is high school sport not mixed? Both my DC are in primary school and DS has a girl in his Saturday football team (side note, she’s very good!).

The andrew tate thing is worrying, what a horrible excuse for a human being that scumbag is.

All your concerns are perfectly valid and I know you’re not asking for solutions but speaking to the school should help. It will also show DS how to stand up for things in the right way, kudos to him for the mini protest too.

Pixiedust1234 · 25/05/2023 10:35

Girls allowed on the AstroTurf at break, not the boys. Girls football taken to local matches, not the boys. Girls hockey promoted at lunchtime, no opportunity for the boys.

You need to take this up with the teacher first, then possibly the Head. There could possibly be valid reasons as to why the boys are seemingly excluded, ie the boys fall under another teacher who is off sick etc.

Maddy70 · 25/05/2023 10:30

It would be worth mentioning the Andrew tate admiration of several pupils to the head of year. Maybe they can so some sort of assembly and. Rasiw awareness.

I would also speak to the head of PE. You seem reasonable with well reasoned questions to raise but the boys competition shouldn't be Compromised

Swipe left for the next trending thread