Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Boys and men

59 replies

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:26

I have two boys. DS1 is 11 and has always been a kind of 'alpha male' type - wants big muscles! massively sporty, naturally loves all traditionally 'male' pursuits. His younger brother is a bit the opposite. He is v gentle, likes to keep fit but not sporty, into art and music. I love them both for who they are. They r great kids (in my v bias mum opinion!)

Anyway, DS1 has become increasingly frustrated at school because the girls are being given preferential treatment when it comes to sport. Head of PE is a great woman, a feminist and strongly believes in girls doing football etc.. I'm all for that. She has v good intent. But it now seems to be at the expense of the boys. Girls allowed on the AstroTurf at break, not the boys. Girls football taken to local matches, not the boys. Girls hockey promoted at lunchtime, no opportunity for the boys. Boys do netball and girls do basketball. DS loves basketball so this hasn't gone down well! DS and his friends even organised a little protest one lunch time and made plaquards to say 'give boys a chance too' or something like that!

I've had lots of discussions with DS about how it's great that girls do football etc.. and there should be equal opportunities for both sexes, but he feels boys aren't given a chance. He loves sport but only sees the girls getting opportunities. He has started talking about Andrew Tate with admiration. I've told him what Andrew Tate stands for, what he's done etc.. and DS seems to understand, but his friends talk about him and DS only picks up what they say and what he sees as good stuff.

Now, maybe things have to sway this way (girls having more opportunity than boys) in society for things to eventually even out and reach equality status. But I'm worried this kind of action at school level leads to men and boys later feeling disillusioned and seeking male role models who perpetuate sexism (like Andrew Tate) in order to try and find their way. DS says half the girls don't even like football and just sit on the AstroTurf at lunch chatting (he knows some girls do enjoy the football but can't see why they can't all play together), whereas he and his friends actually want to play. He's really fed up.

This is not really a question of 'how do I handle it all' as we r finding a way. But more a statement for discussion on what's happening at school level and in wider society to men and boys. I don't want my son or his friends feeling pushed aside as woman used to be, and searching for role models in the wrong places.

OP posts:
Badleg85 · 25/05/2023 11:41

I thunk its good the boys are doing netball, it's always been seen as a girls sport so I don't think the school are wrong there.

Is it possible there is some funding the school are using for girls sports? I know there was in my area at one point for girls to fo stem activities which I thought was great. Girls are still a long way off being valued as equal and I think need more opportunities like this

KnickerlessParsons · 25/05/2023 11:40

justpushingthrough · 25/05/2023 10:38

Boys moaning that girls are getting what boys/men have had for years 😂

Exactly. The boot is now on the other foot and boys don't like it any more than the girls did. I don't have much sympathy tbh.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 11:38

CalmYourThunder · 25/05/2023 11:29

His clips really do spin a certain story that appeals to boys, especially boys like DS1 who love all the muscles and money and fast cars stuff

Hmmm. I’m finding some of your comments around Andrew Tate a little odd. At age 11, he shouldn’t be watching Andrew Tate videos whether you’re there to give balance or not. Just have the conversations, he doesn’t need to watch them.

You almost seem happy that your son is a ‘cool kid’ who likes cars and muscles.

This whole thread just seems a bit ‘off’ to me.

He's not necessarily cool! (Probably a bit cooler than I was at school! But he's not one of the cool kids in the class!) But I love each of my kids for who they are. I can't stop DS1 from loving sport (actually I encourage that as I like him to keep healthy!) and wanting muscles one day and enjoying fast cars. It's up to him, its what he likes! but it is my job to guide him.

I watched the videos so I could see for myself what Andre Tate was saying. As I have said, he's not allowed to watch them on his own. Watching them with me is a v rare event, and has only happened when I've been wanting to discuss with my son and understand what might be being said at school. He's reached his own conclusion about Tate now, after our discussions. But Tate and others like him are a reality. Shutting down all discussions or being overly strict is not the path I want to take as I don't think it helps (but get others have a different approach).

OP posts:
FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 11:33

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 11:25

Hmm I'm going to take the perception of a group of 11 year olds who support Andrew Tate with a pinch of salt. AT has convinced a whole host of men and boys that they are being persecuted which just really isn't true.

Feel free to set up a meeting with the school to discuss this, but I imagine the reality is a lot more nuanced that your son is leading you to believe.

I am sure there is more nuance.

However, I get the school newsletter each week which highlights all the girls sporting matches etc.. and I can see a lack of photos of the boys on sporting trips, because there haven't been any. Furthermore, as my son is v sporty and has never been asked to go to any matches or events with the school, I also know that the boys are not having these opportunities.

Lack of equal (or equitable) opportunity at school is one of the reasons I have now enrolled DS in a local basketball team outside school. He loves basketball and was sad not to get to do it like the girls. He can now do it, and loves his new team. But we r lucky to be able to afford these extra curricular opportunities. Several of the boys spouting Andrew Tate at school don't have the opportunity for extra curricular activities, so you can see how these boys may become further disillusioned and why the likes of Tate become so appealing to them.

OP posts:
ApocalypseNowt · 25/05/2023 11:30

With parks and playgrounds I think it's well documented that boys take over and their games dominate. Maybe staking out the astroturf for the girls in a response/solution for this?

CalmYourThunder · 25/05/2023 11:29

His clips really do spin a certain story that appeals to boys, especially boys like DS1 who love all the muscles and money and fast cars stuff

Hmmm. I’m finding some of your comments around Andrew Tate a little odd. At age 11, he shouldn’t be watching Andrew Tate videos whether you’re there to give balance or not. Just have the conversations, he doesn’t need to watch them.

You almost seem happy that your son is a ‘cool kid’ who likes cars and muscles.

This whole thread just seems a bit ‘off’ to me.

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 11:25

Hmm I'm going to take the perception of a group of 11 year olds who support Andrew Tate with a pinch of salt. AT has convinced a whole host of men and boys that they are being persecuted which just really isn't true.

Feel free to set up a meeting with the school to discuss this, but I imagine the reality is a lot more nuanced that your son is leading you to believe.

Olios · 25/05/2023 11:25

I can understand why your son is frustrated. The teacher is being unfair however your son is going to have to learn ways to circumnavigate the unfairness perhaps organise a game in the main playground to make a point? He will also face recruitment discrimination when older. Unfortunately Andrew Tate is taking advantage of the reverse discrimination to rile up followers... very scary!

gannett · 25/05/2023 11:24

justpushingthrough · 25/05/2023 10:38

Boys moaning that girls are getting what boys/men have had for years 😂

But the OP's son hasn't had this for years. He doesn't feel the individual benefit from the centuries of benefits that different boys and men have had before him.

Teenagers aren't good at thinking structurally instead of individually. That's what the education system should teach them. The issue isn't really about the finer points of who gets to use astroturf when; it's how to teach teenagers to think in terms of historical and societal context. Once you do that, the realisation that discrimination against privileged groups isn't a thing should follow.

Though given the amount of hissy fits I see from adults complaining about bias against men, or private schools, or white Christians, our society isn't doing a great job of this generally.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 11:18

ImInACage · 25/05/2023 11:04

My DSs' primary has a similar situation regarding football at lunchtime. Traditionally the boys tended to set up football games on the astro turf and were allowed to play there. The girls steered well clear because the boys tended to get rowdy and when a girls' game did pop up, they would constantly be interrupted by the boys deliberately disrupting their game. The head ended up designating two days a week each to keep them separate after complaints from the girls' parents. Eventually, however, the boys were banned altogether, because their games almost always descended into fights, which started to bleed into the classrooms. The girls were allowed to continue because their games didn't end up with them pummeling each other. Now we are in your situation, where only the girls have access to the astro turf, because they proved that they could be trusted to behave and every time they give the boys a chance, they let themselves down. I will say though, that we're very lucky that our school offers male and female options for every sport offered and both get to compete in events.

Sounds like a good school handling things well :)

OP posts:
MagpiePi · 25/05/2023 11:18

Good for you for talking to your son about Andrew Tate and that he has come to his own conclusion.
I have two sons who are now in their 20s and really feel for parents of teens and preteens nowadays.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 11:14

CalmYourThunder · 25/05/2023 11:02

If bd more concerned that he’s hanging out with boys that admire Andrew Tate. Wtf? They’re in year 6.

The dickheads at secondary school started the Tate admiration in year 8/9, but any of the lads with a brain think he’s a twat.

Thanks calm..

We've spent quite a bit of time exploring the Andrew Tate stuff! It's quite interesting (and scary) how Andrew Tate tries to target young ones. I've watched a few YouTube clips of his with my son to try and give a balanced opinion and understand what he and his friends might find appealing. His clips really do spin a certain story that appeals to boys, especially boys like DS1 who love all the muscles and money and fast cars stuff (DS2 would never find Andrew Tate appealing in anyway, as he's just not really interested in muscles or money, fast cars etc..!)

We've had lots of discussions and are keeping channels of communication open. He's not allowed to watch Andrew Tate on YouTube without me also sitting with him to give balance. But I want to know he he breaks that rule, need him to feel able to talk about this stuff. We've talked a lot about Andre Tate and DS1 now has the message this is not a good man and understands the reasons. DS1s friends are good kids, but you can't stop children in a wider class from talking, and you can't parent other people's kids, and nor should you. How each parent parents is up to them and some of his friends are allowed to watch Andrew Tate. That's up to them, and thier parents to make that decision, and I can't judge. We all do this parenting thing differently. I can only choose how to parent my own child, and hopefully raise enough discussions with him to help him make sensible and careful choices. But yes, Andrew Tate could be a whole other thread!

OP posts:
onefinemess · 25/05/2023 11:12

OP, if it were a male teacher who was deliberately excluding girls, he would be labelled sexist, toxic and not fit to be a teacher. There is NO excuse for this behaviour from that teacher.

She is absolutely toxic and bullying and is not fit to teach children.

I would make an official complaint to the school, citing sexism and bullying. You need to be clear that the complaint is official and that you require a response from the school. Social media is your friend here, as is your local paper.

Discrimination, bullying and sexist behaviour from a teacher cannot be allowed.

If you handle this in the right way, you can ruin that teachers career.

ImInACage · 25/05/2023 11:04

My DSs' primary has a similar situation regarding football at lunchtime. Traditionally the boys tended to set up football games on the astro turf and were allowed to play there. The girls steered well clear because the boys tended to get rowdy and when a girls' game did pop up, they would constantly be interrupted by the boys deliberately disrupting their game. The head ended up designating two days a week each to keep them separate after complaints from the girls' parents. Eventually, however, the boys were banned altogether, because their games almost always descended into fights, which started to bleed into the classrooms. The girls were allowed to continue because their games didn't end up with them pummeling each other. Now we are in your situation, where only the girls have access to the astro turf, because they proved that they could be trusted to behave and every time they give the boys a chance, they let themselves down. I will say though, that we're very lucky that our school offers male and female options for every sport offered and both get to compete in events.

MagpiePi · 25/05/2023 11:04

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:56

Sometimes equality IS giving certain groups that have traditionally been marginalised more opportunities

I'm not sure I agree with this..

Do you actually mean ‘equity’ rather than equality?

There’s a cartoon of people of different heights trying to look over a wall that expresses this quite well. Equality is where everyone gets the same size box to stand on and the short people still can’t see over the wall. Equity is where everyone gets a box big enough to see over the wall, but the boxes are all different sizes.

Panteranoir · 25/05/2023 11:04

Hoppinggreen · 25/05/2023 10:43

Yep, the experience your son is having is basically what girls have had for many many years.
I fought with her school to call it Boys football and girls football rather than football and girls football.
Perhaps rather than make your son turn to the likes of Andrew Tate this experience could make him more empathetic to what women and girls have to put up with?

Yes it's a good learning experience for him. Given that women and girls have had generations of social pressure to shut up and be happy with the crumbs they are given by society a tiny peek into that world won't kill him.

God forbid women have access to what men had. Ruth Bader Ginsburg gave a fascinating interview when she recalled being asked how many women it would be fair to have as Supreme Court justices. She would answer, it will be fair when it's all of them. Obviously this provoked strong reactions. The unfairness of the idea that it should be all women! The audacity! Yet as Ginsburg pointed out, no one cared and moaned for the long period it was all men it was merely accepted by society. And doesn't that say it all. It's okay for men to do it, but not women. God forbid they have equity, let alone power.

Point out to your son that he will walk the streets at night alone when he's at uni. Hes unlikely to have to worry about his drinks being spiked or being injected with a date rape drug. Hes less likely to be beaten or killed by his partner. He will likely to have easier access to a career, it will be unaffected by maternity pay. Or his pension for that matter. He probably won't be the one to go part time to facilitate parenting. Hes unlikely to should the brunt of the domestic drudgery .He won't be objectified and treated as a lesser being until his looks start to fade, where upon he will become invisible.

Then thank the PE teacher for the tiny window into inequity that she has given your son the chance to glimpse. He may even grow as a person by understanding his male privilege.

On this occasion you can stand up for sisterhood instead of trying to undo what these girls have been given access to. Men and boys learning to live without things is not the massive injustice you think it is.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 11:03

AlexaM86 · 25/05/2023 11:03

Tell him to identify as a girl at break times and go right on and use the astroturf. That'll send them into a right spiral.

🤣🤣

OP posts:
AlexaM86 · 25/05/2023 11:03

Tell him to identify as a girl at break times and go right on and use the astroturf. That'll send them into a right spiral.

CalmYourThunder · 25/05/2023 11:02

If bd more concerned that he’s hanging out with boys that admire Andrew Tate. Wtf? They’re in year 6.

The dickheads at secondary school started the Tate admiration in year 8/9, but any of the lads with a brain think he’s a twat.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:58

Dressydress · 25/05/2023 10:57

I have 2 boys and 2 girls. All sporty. Great that the girls are given so many chances! Amazing even. But its shouldn't be a boy or girl thing. They should have it for both. Feminism isn't about women being at the top or getting or taking what men have always had but about equal opportunities.

I agree

OP posts:
Dressydress · 25/05/2023 10:57

I have 2 boys and 2 girls. All sporty. Great that the girls are given so many chances! Amazing even. But its shouldn't be a boy or girl thing. They should have it for both. Feminism isn't about women being at the top or getting or taking what men have always had but about equal opportunities.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:56

Hoppinggreen · 25/05/2023 10:52

Sometimes equality IS giving certain groups that have traditionally been marginalised more opportunities but I take your point that as a child he doesn’t necessarily see that.

Sometimes equality IS giving certain groups that have traditionally been marginalised more opportunities

I'm not sure I agree with this..

OP posts:
Conkersinautumn · 25/05/2023 10:52

Don't try to persuade. Raise it bluntly, with no get out.

'Why aren't boys allowed to use the astro turf at break?'
When will the boys get to do basketball?
Why aren't the boys teams getting into local competitions?

There might be straightforward reasons, there might not.

Hoppinggreen · 25/05/2023 10:52

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:48

Except he's a child. I've taught him about how women have been treated historically. I've talked to him about how things were in my childhood (I hate to play netball not basketball for example, just like he's experiencing now!) But from his experience, boys are the ones not getting the opportunities. I agree woman have been wronged in the past, and many still are. But now denying men and boys opportunities is not the way forward. We need equality surely. Not just the attitude of 'ha ha see how it feels' - especially as my son has not contributed to historical sexism. It's not his fault that in the past girls were not treated well.

Sometimes equality IS giving certain groups that have traditionally been marginalised more opportunities but I take your point that as a child he doesn’t necessarily see that.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 10:48

*had to play... not hate to play (damn typos!)

OP posts: