Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving newborn alone for 5 mins at a time?

359 replies

Birminghambabe · 25/05/2023 08:35

This might sound ridiculous but I’m a FTM and unsure if I am BU.

If my 4 week old is asleep in our bedroom but I need to do some washing up, have a quick shower etc I leave him for 5 mins at a time (always checking on him every 5 mins). Sometimes if I move him into his Moses downstairs he wakes up so I try and keep him asleep in his crib upstairs.

My friend who is also a mum to a newborn said she could never do that and would just move him even if it disturbs him into the same room as her.

Now as a FTM I’m now paranoid that I shouldn’t be leaving him - someone please tell me if I’m doing this wrong!

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 27/05/2023 12:50

NewNovember · 27/05/2023 11:21

It's not about looking at your baby hence why monitors are no substitute pre six months it's about bsby regulating their breathing to yours to protect against SIDS. I will never understand obviously loving parents who spend thousands on fancy prams , clothes , aesthetic nurseries and then leave their very young baby in rooms alone alone. It's six months of your life to protect you baby. Parents buy the best car seat to provide maximum protection for a crash but SIDS is way down on their list of priorities. Just baffles me.

Baby regulating their breathing to the parents is just a theory, no one actually knows why baby sharing a room offers some protection against SIDS.

It's about risk assessment, a car accident is much more likely to happen than SIDS. Especially if you have baby on their back in an empty cot which is the biggest protective factor, not room sharing.

It's also about mental health. Mothers need to know that they can step away for 5 minutes without thinking that their babies might die, that's no way to live.

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2023 12:41

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 12:15

@saraclara “So do you hire someone to stare at your baby for every second that you are asleep at night?” yes I do! 🙄🙄🙄
It’s not about being anxious or maternal mental health it’s about looking after and protecting a vulnerable new born - it’s a mothers job to do this, I don’t give a stuff about guidelines btw every mother does what is right for their baby and this is my way which I think is the right way - it’s not about control but safety and a bloody huge dollop of love

@SapphireStar77

you actually hired someone?!

surely you can recognise that not everyone cab afford to do that?

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 12:40

OttoGraph · 27/05/2023 12:28

Can you show the data that not leaving your baby alone for the first 6 months has reduced SIDS since the baby on back advice in the 1990s

Lol data!!! Come off it!

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2023 12:40

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 12:18

I completely agree with you - six months to protect your baby who is meant to be the most precious thing in the world - not a huge deal really is it

@SapphireStar77
@NewNovember

6 months is long enough to destroy someone’s mental health
and where would that leave the baby then eh?

OttoGraph · 27/05/2023 12:28

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 12:18

I completely agree with you - six months to protect your baby who is meant to be the most precious thing in the world - not a huge deal really is it

Can you show the data that not leaving your baby alone for the first 6 months has reduced SIDS since the baby on back advice in the 1990s

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 12:18

NewNovember · 27/05/2023 11:21

It's not about looking at your baby hence why monitors are no substitute pre six months it's about bsby regulating their breathing to yours to protect against SIDS. I will never understand obviously loving parents who spend thousands on fancy prams , clothes , aesthetic nurseries and then leave their very young baby in rooms alone alone. It's six months of your life to protect you baby. Parents buy the best car seat to provide maximum protection for a crash but SIDS is way down on their list of priorities. Just baffles me.

I completely agree with you - six months to protect your baby who is meant to be the most precious thing in the world - not a huge deal really is it

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 12:15

saraclara · 27/05/2023 10:48

So do you hire someone to stare at your baby for every second that you are asleep at night?

Seriously, all these guidelines need to come with a maternal mental health warning. Because anxiety levels for mums these days must be through the roof.

I had my babies before the back to sleep research was done. So yes, we were all very aware of SIDS because it was more common then. But we didn't hover over our babies to this kind of degree at all.

Theoretically information should help mums and babies, but what it actually seems to do is make mums feel that they have to control everything and gives them the room to blame themselves (or feel that they should) if anything goes wrong.

I really do worry about maternal mental health for the new mums of the last decade or so.

@saraclara “So do you hire someone to stare at your baby for every second that you are asleep at night?” yes I do! 🙄🙄🙄
It’s not about being anxious or maternal mental health it’s about looking after and protecting a vulnerable new born - it’s a mothers job to do this, I don’t give a stuff about guidelines btw every mother does what is right for their baby and this is my way which I think is the right way - it’s not about control but safety and a bloody huge dollop of love

Pyri · 27/05/2023 11:44

NewNovember · 27/05/2023 11:21

It's not about looking at your baby hence why monitors are no substitute pre six months it's about bsby regulating their breathing to yours to protect against SIDS. I will never understand obviously loving parents who spend thousands on fancy prams , clothes , aesthetic nurseries and then leave their very young baby in rooms alone alone. It's six months of your life to protect you baby. Parents buy the best car seat to provide maximum protection for a crash but SIDS is way down on their list of priorities. Just baffles me.

Do you also judge parents who formula feed their babies as they don’t have the benefit of BF, which lowers SIDS rates?

SunnySaturdayMorning · 27/05/2023 11:44

NewNovember · 27/05/2023 11:21

It's not about looking at your baby hence why monitors are no substitute pre six months it's about bsby regulating their breathing to yours to protect against SIDS. I will never understand obviously loving parents who spend thousands on fancy prams , clothes , aesthetic nurseries and then leave their very young baby in rooms alone alone. It's six months of your life to protect you baby. Parents buy the best car seat to provide maximum protection for a crash but SIDS is way down on their list of priorities. Just baffles me.

Agreed. Although most people don’t buy the best car seats otherwise forward facing wouldn’t be the norm.

NewNovember · 27/05/2023 11:21

saraclara · 27/05/2023 10:48

So do you hire someone to stare at your baby for every second that you are asleep at night?

Seriously, all these guidelines need to come with a maternal mental health warning. Because anxiety levels for mums these days must be through the roof.

I had my babies before the back to sleep research was done. So yes, we were all very aware of SIDS because it was more common then. But we didn't hover over our babies to this kind of degree at all.

Theoretically information should help mums and babies, but what it actually seems to do is make mums feel that they have to control everything and gives them the room to blame themselves (or feel that they should) if anything goes wrong.

I really do worry about maternal mental health for the new mums of the last decade or so.

It's not about looking at your baby hence why monitors are no substitute pre six months it's about bsby regulating their breathing to yours to protect against SIDS. I will never understand obviously loving parents who spend thousands on fancy prams , clothes , aesthetic nurseries and then leave their very young baby in rooms alone alone. It's six months of your life to protect you baby. Parents buy the best car seat to provide maximum protection for a crash but SIDS is way down on their list of priorities. Just baffles me.

saraclara · 27/05/2023 10:48

SapphireStar77 · 25/05/2023 22:11

well I used to be able to keep an eye on my babies whilst using the loo. Babies that young shouldn’t be left on their own - it only takes a second for something to happen

So do you hire someone to stare at your baby for every second that you are asleep at night?

Seriously, all these guidelines need to come with a maternal mental health warning. Because anxiety levels for mums these days must be through the roof.

I had my babies before the back to sleep research was done. So yes, we were all very aware of SIDS because it was more common then. But we didn't hover over our babies to this kind of degree at all.

Theoretically information should help mums and babies, but what it actually seems to do is make mums feel that they have to control everything and gives them the room to blame themselves (or feel that they should) if anything goes wrong.

I really do worry about maternal mental health for the new mums of the last decade or so.

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2023 09:26

rainydaysandtuesday · 27/05/2023 02:55

I remember desperately needing a
Poo and baby was crying. I HAD to just go and leave baby in the crib crying for a few mins

Sometimes you just have to 🤷‍♀️

who could argue with this?
what else could you have done in that situation?!

Emmamoo89 · 27/05/2023 08:30

I put my son in his own room at 8 weeks for naps so he got used to his cot then he went in fully at 11 weeks.
Its fine to leave them to do things 😊

Emmamoo89 · 27/05/2023 08:29

SomeNights · 25/05/2023 08:39

Safe sleep guidelines say they shouldn't sleep in a room alone until six months. I think there's a difference between leaving for five minutes total to pop to the toilet, and leaving for half an hour or more but checking in every five minutes.

A sling might be useful for getting on with general household jobs.

Yes thats guideline but some parents put their baby in their own room before 6 months and that's fine.

Jem123456789 · 27/05/2023 08:26

Of course you can leave them asleep in their cot to do your chores or whatever. A baby doesn’t have to be attached to the mother 24/7. Stop checking every 5 mins too, you’ll drive yourself mad. Stick a baby monitor on and chill. A relaxed mum is far better for the baby too.

Tiddlypomtiddlypom · 27/05/2023 06:39

Never occurred to me not to leave mine if they were sleeping. Even in a Moses basket. I just got on and did stuff in the time I had. Mine was also a very independent sleeper.

rainydaysandtuesday · 27/05/2023 02:55

I remember desperately needing a
Poo and baby was crying. I HAD to just go and leave baby in the crib crying for a few mins

Sometimes you just have to 🤷‍♀️

MeandT · 26/05/2023 23:19

@89redballoons I feel for you. There are generations of knowledge of how to get poor sleepers to settle. Swaddling & setting my eldest to sleep on their front made a massive difference & stopped me from becoming an unsafe parent due to lack of sleep.

Obviously it's a complete no-no to confess to actually having done this. I don't want to minimise the risk of SIDS & know a couple of people whose children stopped breathing at different points, so I was properly worried about it. But using a movement mat monitor gave me my peace of mind back AND allowed me to use some methods that meant baby actually bloody slept a bit too!

MeandT · 26/05/2023 23:14

I feel for every parent with the SIDS risk, no-one wants to feel a child's death is their 'fault'. Yes, there are things you can do to reduce the risk, but for me, I just took a view that ALL I wanted to know was that my children were breathing properly.

You can't know that when you're asleep - even in the same room.

You can't know that from a video monitor.

You can't know that from a sound only monitor.

For me, the only answer was to get a monitor with a movement mat that would set an alarm off if they stopped breathing.

I went about my day during nap time, I slept soundly at night (haha, well at least when they were), I even (shock!) put them to sleep on their front when they had snotty noses because it could drain & they actually breathed better & got some sleep (and I did) when they were ill. But I knew that if there was a problem, I'd know about it in less than a minute - awake, asleep, or 3 rooms away. And that was FAR more reliable than checking on them every 5 minutes.

As they got older & occasionally shuffled into a far corner of the cot off the mat, there were some rare frantic moments when it bleeped away, but it gave me 4+ years of complete peace of mind across 2 kids.

Do what you need to get the balance right for your own peace of mind, but you can torture yourself trying to do the right thing constantly hovering, and baby could still stop breathing with you in the same room - so perhaps ease off on restricting what you can do while they nap & if you're concerned, maybe get a monitor that will actually tell you what you really want to know!

89redballoons · 26/05/2023 21:16

aloris · 26/05/2023 15:14

That's a very sad story, although, as you point out, they were with their baby the whole time. I think most mums would do pretty much anything for their baby, and to me it seems that guidance tends to take advantage of that, sometimes to the detriment of the mother's mental health. As someone pointed out upthread, when you become a mum, you don't stop being a person. You aren't just a vessel. But I feel that sometimes medical guidance for mothers expects mothers to go to any lengths, no matter how burdensome on the mother, and fails to incorporate sufficient attention to the welfare of the mother. I see that on this thread there is a split between mums who think it's ok to leave your baby for a few minutes to go to the bathroom or have a shower or something to eat, and those who think that's not ok. I guess I would ask those who think it's not ok, what is a woman supposed to do if her baby is a poor sleeper who wakes when you move him? Suppose she has just gotten him down for a nap and needs to go to the bathroom. Is she supposed to move him even if it means waking him, even if it means she'll have to start over with rocking him for another couple hours?

I feel really sad for young mums. It was hard enough when I had my kids, over a decade ago, and it feels like guidance has become even more burdensome on women since then.

Hugs to all of you. Take care of yourselves, you matter too!

My kids are 1 and 3, and I do agree with this. I can remember being so anxious around the safe sleep guidance when I was a first time mum.

My first was a terrible sleeper and it seemed like anything I thought of or that my mum suggested to help him sleep was a SIDS risk - leaving him to try and settle himself, swaddling, adding a cellular blanket if he was cold - he was a scrawny December baby and our bedroom was in an extension without much insulation, which sometimes got to 15°, but I stuck religiously to the clothing chart that came with the room thermometer and even if he felt cold to touch, I wouldn't add a layer in case he overheated and died 🤦‍♀️

Of course, my tired and hormonal brain translated "there is a slightly increased risk of SIDS at a population level" to "this will definitely kill your baby". I am fairly numerate normally - I work with numbers although not in any kind of medical field - and it still really got to me. Looking back I was totally irrational.

It seemed that all the Lullaby Trust could recommend if you have a poor sleeper is trying to get someone else to watch your baby while you got a nap in. Shit load of help that was when Covid happened.

I was interested to read, further up this thread, that even some of the evidence for safe sleep guidelines (apart form putting them on their back in an empty cot), which I would have thought was robust because the NHS and Lullaby Trust seem to rely on it, actually isn't.

Trishthedish · 26/05/2023 21:01

When I see things like this I wonder how my two made it to adulthood. Of course you can leave her whilst she’s sleeping. Monitor is a great idea. Do what feels right for you. And congratulations 🎉

wentworthinmate · 26/05/2023 20:34

A baby doesn’t die from crying as someone once told me! Would have been a v long time ago though.

linsey2581 · 26/05/2023 20:16

@Maebh9 Have you been watching Friends 😂

Ange1233556 · 26/05/2023 20:11

Your friend is insane. Of course you can leave the baby to nap!

Get a monitor with a sensor pad mat - very reassuring.

Guccigirl123 · 26/05/2023 20:05

I had triplets so they were straight into cots when they got home from scbu. Of course you can go have shower etc and leave for 5 mins. What is going to happen? What is this rubbish they can’t sleep in their own room till 6 months, what a load of rubbish