Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving newborn alone for 5 mins at a time?

359 replies

Birminghambabe · 25/05/2023 08:35

This might sound ridiculous but I’m a FTM and unsure if I am BU.

If my 4 week old is asleep in our bedroom but I need to do some washing up, have a quick shower etc I leave him for 5 mins at a time (always checking on him every 5 mins). Sometimes if I move him into his Moses downstairs he wakes up so I try and keep him asleep in his crib upstairs.

My friend who is also a mum to a newborn said she could never do that and would just move him even if it disturbs him into the same room as her.

Now as a FTM I’m now paranoid that I shouldn’t be leaving him - someone please tell me if I’m doing this wrong!

OP posts:
Hugasauras · 28/05/2023 12:13

I love the confidence with which 'your breathing regulates theirs' is always trotted out on here despite there being no actual evidence that's the case, merely a theory in a sea of theories. And if it were proven, then there would be other conditions attached because simply being in the same room wouldn't be enough for that.

Shayisgreat · 28/05/2023 12:12

Birminghambabe · 25/05/2023 08:49

This is my logic and why I don’t mind leaving him for 5 mins at a time but she was so shocked at me I thought I was doing something wrong

Although I have just ordered a baby monitor, I don’t know why I didn’t think of this myself - must have baby brain!

Oh don't worry, you're going to come across a lot of martyr mummies who are shocked when some other parents are comfortable not having their babies glued to them.

If your baby can sleep without lying in you then you can leave them with a monitor and/or check in on them. I found my baby found it easier to link sleep cycles when I was in the room with him during the day though.

powerrangers · 28/05/2023 12:09

QuiltedHippo · 25/05/2023 08:44

Your breathing helps regulate theirs to protect against SIDs thats why they recommend baby is the same room for all sleep including naps, so a monitor is no substitute. In reality you have to live! I would be checking very frequently though

So breathing on the other side of the room helps regulate theirs?

MeandT · 28/05/2023 11:59

@PinkPlantCase but it's not just about the fact that the 'current advice says popping out for 5 minutes is fine' is it?

It's about the fact that particular element of current advice isn't actually routed in any solid evidence & it makes (yet another) rod for mothers' (not parents', as others have mentioned) backs...

Like the advice on eating peanuts, the current NHS 'Eat Well' advice on replacing sugary foods with foods containing artificial sweetners, giving kids semi-skimmed milk, that salt & fat content being the only 'important' part of ultra-processed foods etc....in 10 years time the advice will have completely shifted again.

So beating up the current generation of new parents if they leave baby in a different room for an hour for a nap is bonkers. Shove a movement monitor in with them so you know immediately if they stop breathing & get on with your lives, seriously!

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/05/2023 11:58

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/05/2023 11:45

Don't you just love the whole 'I love my baby more than yours' judgement?Because you can only be a good mother (not parent, mother, men aren't judged like this) if your baby is stuck to you 24/7.

No. If someone wants to drag their baby around the house, that's fine but I shower alone because I'm human and my needs don't stop just because I've had a baby.

No. If someone wants to drag their baby around the house, that's fine but I shower alone because I'm human and my needs don't stop just because I've had a baby.

dont see how anyone could argue with that!

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 28/05/2023 11:57

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/05/2023 11:45

Don't you just love the whole 'I love my baby more than yours' judgement?Because you can only be a good mother (not parent, mother, men aren't judged like this) if your baby is stuck to you 24/7.

No. If someone wants to drag their baby around the house, that's fine but I shower alone because I'm human and my needs don't stop just because I've had a baby.

I feel much the same. I’ve been back at work for almost 10 months so maternity leave feels like a while ago, but when I was on leave and my little girl was much smaller than she is now, I used to relish my showers. They were a glorious bit of me time. As for carry around in a sling, that’s not possible for me, I have a congenital ankle problem which makes them very unstable and causes a lot of random falls. It would be a mistake to carry my baby around in a sling as it would make me more unstable and more likely to fall. My bathroom also really is too small to put a bouncer in it anywhere, I attempted it once when she was going through a particularly fussy phase and it seemed like it might be easier. It wasn’t easier!

For me, all of this comes down to personal choice. The vast majority of parents interpret guidelines individually and make reasonable, rational choices based on their own assessment of risk.

My sister is more relaxed about it than me and her children were both in their own room rooms overnight from a couple of weeks. Between us we have three thriving children who never went near a sling, a sensor mat, a video monitor, got carried around in their baskets all day or had to join their mums in the shower. It’s not how we do things and it’s fine. It’s also fine if you want to, but those that do should leave everyone else alone and stop trying to insist their way is the only way!

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/05/2023 11:45

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 28/05/2023 10:34

No thank you to any of that!

You’re the same poster who told me I don’t love my baby on a thread about infant sleep though so you’re hardly reasonable or rational.

Don't you just love the whole 'I love my baby more than yours' judgement?Because you can only be a good mother (not parent, mother, men aren't judged like this) if your baby is stuck to you 24/7.

No. If someone wants to drag their baby around the house, that's fine but I shower alone because I'm human and my needs don't stop just because I've had a baby.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 28/05/2023 10:42

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 10:32

I didn't say it did a pp said how can you stay with baby and a toddler I was explaining how I managed with more than one child.

Well done. So did I.

Zanatdy · 28/05/2023 10:36

I left them to have a shower / go to the toilet. I think that’s very different to putting them in their own room at 1 month old etc.

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 28/05/2023 10:34

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 01:11

I have multiple children I took the baby from room to room I didn't stay in one room, so moved bassinet or a bouncer or baby wear and baby sleeps in the sling.
Nobody has a bathroom that can't fit a bouncer in the open doorway. You shower when they are in the bouncer. It's really not difficult

No thank you to any of that!

You’re the same poster who told me I don’t love my baby on a thread about infant sleep though so you’re hardly reasonable or rational.

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 10:32

TooOldForThisNonsense · 28/05/2023 09:26

And? You’re having “multiple children” doesn’t make you a better mother than anyone else. There’s no reason to have a baby bouncer in a bathroom door to have a shower if you don’t want to or if mum needs that 5 mins for her mental health.

I didn't say it did a pp said how can you stay with baby and a toddler I was explaining how I managed with more than one child.

PinkPlantCase · 28/05/2023 09:36

TooOldForThisNonsense · 28/05/2023 09:26

And? You’re having “multiple children” doesn’t make you a better mother than anyone else. There’s no reason to have a baby bouncer in a bathroom door to have a shower if you don’t want to or if mum needs that 5 mins for her mental health.

I think this poster was referring to all of the PP saying it isn’t possible to keep young baby with you if you have more than 1 child at home.

I think everyone needs to calm down tbh.

Not every mother struggles with her mental health, even those who’ve had babies in the last 10 years.

Either way the guidance (if following guidance is important to someone) is quite clear that popping out for 5 minutes is fine.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 28/05/2023 09:26

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 01:11

I have multiple children I took the baby from room to room I didn't stay in one room, so moved bassinet or a bouncer or baby wear and baby sleeps in the sling.
Nobody has a bathroom that can't fit a bouncer in the open doorway. You shower when they are in the bouncer. It's really not difficult

And? You’re having “multiple children” doesn’t make you a better mother than anyone else. There’s no reason to have a baby bouncer in a bathroom door to have a shower if you don’t want to or if mum needs that 5 mins for her mental health.

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 01:11

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/05/2023 21:21

💯. I started to put my baby into her cot for naps from a couple of weeks old and she’d go up to bed in our room from a couple of weeks and be in there without us, until we went to bed from a couple of weeks too. She was always on her back, towards the bottom of the cot, with layers of light blankets and nothing else in with her. We also checked on her frequently and had the monitor on.

We were satisfied with those arrangements and still have a little girl who couldn’t be easier in terms of night time sleep and naps. We’ve kept our relationship, have our evenings and we’re fresh for our now toddler when she wakes from her naps and in the morning.

Parents need to take reasonable actions that’ll allow them to enjoy their children and their lives without living in constant fear of judgement and whatever else.

I have multiple children I took the baby from room to room I didn't stay in one room, so moved bassinet or a bouncer or baby wear and baby sleeps in the sling.
Nobody has a bathroom that can't fit a bouncer in the open doorway. You shower when they are in the bouncer. It's really not difficult

BertieBotts · 27/05/2023 22:37

I think most people get that it's impractical though.

Can you point to any actual official advice that says you need to be in contact with your baby for every minute of every day? I don't think there is any advice like that.

It only seems to come from places like:

Influencers, that have a whole brand so they end up having to be extreme about things just to set themselves apart from everyone else. It's bollocks obviously, just like the insta-perfect houses and the colour-coordinated children. Just made up crap to sell sponsorships.

Facebook groups with mods on a power trip. They also like taking things to extremes. Actually commonly it's not even the mods on these groups (though sometimes it is), sometimes it's just members getting competitive to be the best <whatever the point of the group is> ever.

People who are very black and white thinkers, possibly suffering from anxiety who are overly rigid about how they interpret the guidelines, which are much more sensible in reality. Tend to spend a lot of time on internet forums trying to convince others that their OTT interpretation is the right one, including all the logical knots they have tied to convince themselves. (In case you think I'm being mean, I can spot myself in this one a little bit. Can be a manifestation of PFB thinking I suppose.)

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 27/05/2023 21:21

aloris · 27/05/2023 19:46

Well I'm also wondering what mums are meant to do in terms of never leaving the baby alone if they are
-a single mother
-married but the other parent is traveling for work
-the other parent has Covid
-they have other children who need care in a different area of the house, e.g. toddlers who cannot be confined to the one room where the baby is napping 18 hours per day.
-what if your bathroom or shower is not big enough, or is not positioned in such a way that you can have your baby nearby while you shower or use the bathroom.

Is a lone parent supposed to not shower for a week, a month, six months, until the other parent arrives from their trip/gets over Covid/the baby reaches six months old?

I think a sanity check will show that this guilt-tripping advice:

"I will never understand obviously loving parents who spend thousands on fancy prams , clothes , aesthetic nurseries and then leave their very young baby in rooms alone alone."

is so impractical and frankly cruel to some mothers, that it simply should not be given.

💯. I started to put my baby into her cot for naps from a couple of weeks old and she’d go up to bed in our room from a couple of weeks and be in there without us, until we went to bed from a couple of weeks too. She was always on her back, towards the bottom of the cot, with layers of light blankets and nothing else in with her. We also checked on her frequently and had the monitor on.

We were satisfied with those arrangements and still have a little girl who couldn’t be easier in terms of night time sleep and naps. We’ve kept our relationship, have our evenings and we’re fresh for our now toddler when she wakes from her naps and in the morning.

Parents need to take reasonable actions that’ll allow them to enjoy their children and their lives without living in constant fear of judgement and whatever else.

aloris · 27/05/2023 19:46

Well I'm also wondering what mums are meant to do in terms of never leaving the baby alone if they are
-a single mother
-married but the other parent is traveling for work
-the other parent has Covid
-they have other children who need care in a different area of the house, e.g. toddlers who cannot be confined to the one room where the baby is napping 18 hours per day.
-what if your bathroom or shower is not big enough, or is not positioned in such a way that you can have your baby nearby while you shower or use the bathroom.

Is a lone parent supposed to not shower for a week, a month, six months, until the other parent arrives from their trip/gets over Covid/the baby reaches six months old?

I think a sanity check will show that this guilt-tripping advice:

"I will never understand obviously loving parents who spend thousands on fancy prams , clothes , aesthetic nurseries and then leave their very young baby in rooms alone alone."

is so impractical and frankly cruel to some mothers, that it simply should not be given.

BlackWhiteColour · 27/05/2023 18:36

Has anyone explained what mums can do if they are asleep with their baby and there is an issue with the other child eg their five year old suddenly screams from their room or downstairs. Do they yank their baby up and waste precious seconds before going to their other child who could be in a crisis?

T1Dmama · 27/05/2023 18:08

Of course not!
You buy a monitor and download the app to your phone if you’re overly worried…. But how does your friend think people coped 40 years ago? Baby was in cot and mum was downstairs looking after other kids, washing cleaning etc!…..
You don’t check on a newborn every 5 minutes throughout the night when they’re safely asleep in their cot…. Even if they wake while you take a 20 minute shower, crying for a few minutes isn’t going to hurt them!!…. It’s not like a newborn is going to throw themselves out of their cot or fall downstairs! Even without a monitor your baby will be fine being left to sleep unsupervised while you shower poop etc!

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 13:28

OttoGraph · 27/05/2023 13:14

You scoffing at a being alone to show there is evidence isn’t really a surprise

Your reply makes absolutely no sense

OttoGraph · 27/05/2023 13:14

You scoffing at a being alone to show there is evidence isn’t really a surprise

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 13:13

LuckySantangelo35 · 27/05/2023 12:41

@SapphireStar77

you actually hired someone?!

surely you can recognise that not everyone cab afford to do that?

No of course I don’t - I was being facetious to somebody else’s ridiculous remark

Pickingmyselfup · 27/05/2023 13:12

I used to leave mine when I needed the toilet, make a cup of tea...

In the day they would sleep in the moses basket downstairs. If I needed to go upstairs to get something/go to the toilet they stayed put unless I had to move them because of the cats. A shower or a nap they came with me but for a shower they would be in their cot in my room next to the ensuite.

If I was cooking they stayed in the lounge with the door to the kitchen open, a much safer place to be.

My second was a little different in that I did leave him for longer for naps because he wouldn't settle with a toddler charging around the place and it was affecting his sleep. Was it ideal? No. Did I do best I could? Yes.

Sometimes we have to weigh up the risks like we do in every day life. Ours was relatively low, back sleeper, non smoker, not premature or low weight and always had a dummy but I was aware that leaving him for longer naps was a bit riskier than not. Just like how I used to be aware that driving us somewhere was riskier than staying at home but needs must.

SIDS is a horrible thing to have to happen and it is important that we try and reduce the risks wherever possible but there is never guarantee.

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 13:11

OttoGraph · 27/05/2023 13:10

Yet there is data on putting babies on their back to sleep as it reduced SIDS by up to 50%

Yes - I know that. I was scoffing at your demand to provide data

OttoGraph · 27/05/2023 13:10

SapphireStar77 · 27/05/2023 12:40

Lol data!!! Come off it!

Yet there is data on putting babies on their back to sleep as it reduced SIDS by up to 50%