Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Leaving newborn alone for 5 mins at a time?

359 replies

Birminghambabe · 25/05/2023 08:35

This might sound ridiculous but I’m a FTM and unsure if I am BU.

If my 4 week old is asleep in our bedroom but I need to do some washing up, have a quick shower etc I leave him for 5 mins at a time (always checking on him every 5 mins). Sometimes if I move him into his Moses downstairs he wakes up so I try and keep him asleep in his crib upstairs.

My friend who is also a mum to a newborn said she could never do that and would just move him even if it disturbs him into the same room as her.

Now as a FTM I’m now paranoid that I shouldn’t be leaving him - someone please tell me if I’m doing this wrong!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Stewball01 · 04/06/2023 15:17

Mine were with me for 3 months when I went back to work. It didn't dawn on me to keep checking on them and I didn't have a baby monitor. This was over 50 years ago.

Summerfun2023 · 31/05/2023 18:29

@sunshinesis you have to rub their back until they burp babies struggle to burp after a meal. Colief is good you add it to every bottle or breast feed it helps with digestion.

sunshinesis · 31/05/2023 17:28

My baby stopped breathing at 2 months old - was in her pram in the same room as us and started making a choking noise. I Picked her up while partner called the ambulance. 5 seconds panic before tipping her upside side and patting her on the back. Started breathing after 30-45 seconds (seemed like forever). Not sure she would still be here if she hadn't been in the same room. It happened twice more before she grew out of it - doctor was vague but said it could have been reflux, but she obviously couldn't choke it up herself.

Teateaandmoretea · 30/05/2023 13:01

aloris · 28/05/2023 18:31

Don't get me started. The pressure from doctors, daycares, and other mothers, to follow infant feeding guidelines for allergen introduction in exactly the right order prescribed by the "evidence based" guidelines and those guidelines were totally wrong about nuts. The exact opposite in fact, probably resulting in many children developing life-threatening nut allergies who otherwise would have been fine (including mine, so, Thanks, "evidence based guidelines"). But none of those people got any humility from seeing that they totally overstated the evidence behind the "evidence based" guidelines. They just started being pushy about whatever was the next big thing, and using THAT as a stick to beat mothers with.

Completely.

But there is a very weird earnestness about some mumsnetters and this eagerness to follow absolutely every guideline to the letter.

This thread is like a weird parallel universe. Personally I ate nuts when I was pregnant because it sounded like bollocks to me. And guess what it was.

While there are some really rare unlucky cases particularly those involving prematurity ‘cot death’ is often linked to neglect. That is why the rates are 5x as high in mothers under 20. So if you are an attentive non-smoking, non drug addict parent who puts their baby to bed on their back it it is very highly unlikely that they will die of cot death. This is regardless of them sleeping in their own room and breastfeeding.

In real life I have come across people who put babies to sleep on their slide or front cos apparently they wouldn’t sleep otherwise. I wouldn’t have done that personally but equally they were in their own rooms from 3 months and were put into bed upstairs at this point. Others wouldn’t do that and that’s fine.

In the end we all risk assess things differently using the same information and that’s fine. Personally I think that taking a newborn to the toilet with you is nuts, but it’s your decision to either do it or not do it.

But ‘best mother’ contests on mumsnet help no one.

Newnamenewname109870 · 29/05/2023 19:40

Nohelpfromme · 29/05/2023 01:13

Do people here realise that nurseries take babies from 6 WEEKS old for up to 10 hours a day? That's 10 hours a day away from their mothers breathing, presence, influence and touch. Yes, the SIDS guidance is important but a lot of the posters are causing themselves so much unnecessary anxiety. Babies are actually quite tough little things, and can be far more resilient than many of the posters appreciate. It's lovely that you all want to do your best but stop fretting so much and take time to enjoy your poo!

They’re never completely alone though and there are other babies nearby to regulate breathing. Most nurseries I know require at least 12 weeks anyway.

SouthLondonMum22 · 29/05/2023 11:38

Nohelpfromme · 29/05/2023 01:13

Do people here realise that nurseries take babies from 6 WEEKS old for up to 10 hours a day? That's 10 hours a day away from their mothers breathing, presence, influence and touch. Yes, the SIDS guidance is important but a lot of the posters are causing themselves so much unnecessary anxiety. Babies are actually quite tough little things, and can be far more resilient than many of the posters appreciate. It's lovely that you all want to do your best but stop fretting so much and take time to enjoy your poo!

My baby started nursery at 12 weeks. The baby room at his nursery has a sleep room with no door off of the main area with several cots.

The babies in the sleep room are checked on but no one stays with them the entire time, even when they are under 6 months.

SapphireStar77 · 29/05/2023 11:37

Summerfun2023 · 29/05/2023 01:36

I was joking but I warn you don't tell your children that you brought them to the bathroom they will say the same thing and be disgusted. They will love you but at the same time they will feel disgusted.

Enjoy your children as they get older and develop their quirky personalities.

I can assure you they don’t feel disgusted by me

Summerfun2023 · 29/05/2023 01:36

SapphireStar77 · 28/05/2023 16:46

Exactly!!! Can if we want to - so why am I getting grief for taking my baby into the bathroom with me - people saying that they feel sorry for my baby having to smell my stinky shit FGS!

I was joking but I warn you don't tell your children that you brought them to the bathroom they will say the same thing and be disgusted. They will love you but at the same time they will feel disgusted.

Enjoy your children as they get older and develop their quirky personalities.

Nohelpfromme · 29/05/2023 01:13

Do people here realise that nurseries take babies from 6 WEEKS old for up to 10 hours a day? That's 10 hours a day away from their mothers breathing, presence, influence and touch. Yes, the SIDS guidance is important but a lot of the posters are causing themselves so much unnecessary anxiety. Babies are actually quite tough little things, and can be far more resilient than many of the posters appreciate. It's lovely that you all want to do your best but stop fretting so much and take time to enjoy your poo!

user1477391263 · 29/05/2023 00:11

The big risks, honestly, are things like crashing a car with the baby inside, or falling asleep at a dangerous moment like when you are nursing a baby on a chair or sofa. Parents NEED to safeguard their own sleep. Threads like these are worrying.

Delatron · 28/05/2023 23:05

Theoldcuriosityshop · 28/05/2023 14:11

Long ago we put our babies out in the garden to sleep. I can't imagine never being away from a baby for more than 5 minutes. Goodness knows how my great grandmother would have brought up 11 children if she had sat next to a sleeping baby all day.

Exactly. I’ve read some crazy threads on Mumsnet but really? Now babies can’t be left for a few minutes? Insane…

user1477391263 · 28/05/2023 22:56

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 14:55

Slings existed so she could have used one or pushed babies pram from room to room and used something a drawer on the floor maybe for upstairs.

In the UK? Slings were not a thing in most of the UK 100 years ago (the exception might be if the poster’s great grandmother was in rural Wales or something like that, where there were some traditional equivalents).

In families with 10 kids, it was accepted that a lot of baby care was actually done by older children. Mothers these days don’t really have this option; older kids are in school all day.

In any case, I can guarantee that the great grandmother in question did NOT spend her time working out ways to shuttle her baby about so she was never away from this. This whole thread is ridiculous.

aloris · 28/05/2023 18:31

MeandT · 28/05/2023 11:59

@PinkPlantCase but it's not just about the fact that the 'current advice says popping out for 5 minutes is fine' is it?

It's about the fact that particular element of current advice isn't actually routed in any solid evidence & it makes (yet another) rod for mothers' (not parents', as others have mentioned) backs...

Like the advice on eating peanuts, the current NHS 'Eat Well' advice on replacing sugary foods with foods containing artificial sweetners, giving kids semi-skimmed milk, that salt & fat content being the only 'important' part of ultra-processed foods etc....in 10 years time the advice will have completely shifted again.

So beating up the current generation of new parents if they leave baby in a different room for an hour for a nap is bonkers. Shove a movement monitor in with them so you know immediately if they stop breathing & get on with your lives, seriously!

Don't get me started. The pressure from doctors, daycares, and other mothers, to follow infant feeding guidelines for allergen introduction in exactly the right order prescribed by the "evidence based" guidelines and those guidelines were totally wrong about nuts. The exact opposite in fact, probably resulting in many children developing life-threatening nut allergies who otherwise would have been fine (including mine, so, Thanks, "evidence based guidelines"). But none of those people got any humility from seeing that they totally overstated the evidence behind the "evidence based" guidelines. They just started being pushy about whatever was the next big thing, and using THAT as a stick to beat mothers with.

BertieBotts · 28/05/2023 16:53

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 12:15

Wouldn't that be an argument in favour of bed sharing?

I think it probably is, to be perfectly honest. If you think about all the obvious-seeming dangers of bedsharing, especially how much of a known risk it is when it's done "improperly", but then look at the actual stats when it is done with certain things in place such as the instinctive way breastfeeding mothers tend to position both themselves and their babies, it's nowhere near as risky as it "should" be, so it seems perfectly clear to me that there must be some protective factor(s) from bedsharing which cancel out the risks. We just don't know what those are because you can't possibly study it.

SapphireStar77 · 28/05/2023 16:46

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/05/2023 16:25

@SapphireStar77
@NewNovember

no you really don’t need to bring baby into bathroom if you’re having a quick shower
if you want to fine
but you don’t HAVE to

Exactly!!! Can if we want to - so why am I getting grief for taking my baby into the bathroom with me - people saying that they feel sorry for my baby having to smell my stinky shit FGS!

LuckySantangelo35 · 28/05/2023 16:25

SapphireStar77 · 28/05/2023 14:57

Exactly!!

@SapphireStar77
@NewNovember

no you really don’t need to bring baby into bathroom if you’re having a quick shower
if you want to fine
but you don’t HAVE to

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/05/2023 15:37

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 14:55

Slings existed so she could have used one or pushed babies pram from room to room and used something a drawer on the floor maybe for upstairs.

Or she left them for 5 minutes and all was fine.

My baby hated the sling, much prefers chilling in his cot for 5-10 minutes if I need the toilet or a shower.

Hugasauras · 28/05/2023 15:30

Common sense. It disappears sometimes when you are recently PP and in the throes of anxiety, believe me I know, but almost every parenting decision requires an element of common sense about it. I'm pretty risk averse when it comes to the kids, but even cautious lil me felt comfortable about going for a shit while either of my DDs was asleep downstairs in their Moses basket Grin or going to make a cup of tea or a sandwich. Poor mothers get the fear of god put into them about everything and it results in being unable to critically assess risk or use common sense. I doubt there are many dads fretting about whether they should carry a baby asleep in its Moses basket into the bathroom while they do a poo. I know it wouldn't even have occurred to my husband, and he's a perfectly attentive and cautious parent!

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 28/05/2023 14:58

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 14:55

Slings existed so she could have used one or pushed babies pram from room to room and used something a drawer on the floor maybe for upstairs.

Right, but not everyone and by that I mean most people, don’t want to use slings. I wanted my baby to be okay in rooms on her own and now she is and I don’t regret it at all. You aren’t doing your cause any favours, you just go on and on and on and seem incapable of taking on anyone else’s point of view because you believe you’re oh so right and virtuous… when in fact you’re really unhelpful and judgemental.

SapphireStar77 · 28/05/2023 14:57

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 01:11

I have multiple children I took the baby from room to room I didn't stay in one room, so moved bassinet or a bouncer or baby wear and baby sleeps in the sling.
Nobody has a bathroom that can't fit a bouncer in the open doorway. You shower when they are in the bouncer. It's really not difficult

Exactly!!

NewNovember · 28/05/2023 14:55

Theoldcuriosityshop · 28/05/2023 14:11

Long ago we put our babies out in the garden to sleep. I can't imagine never being away from a baby for more than 5 minutes. Goodness knows how my great grandmother would have brought up 11 children if she had sat next to a sleeping baby all day.

Slings existed so she could have used one or pushed babies pram from room to room and used something a drawer on the floor maybe for upstairs.

Theoldcuriosityshop · 28/05/2023 14:11

Long ago we put our babies out in the garden to sleep. I can't imagine never being away from a baby for more than 5 minutes. Goodness knows how my great grandmother would have brought up 11 children if she had sat next to a sleeping baby all day.

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 28/05/2023 12:48

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/05/2023 12:27

Mine will be 6 months in just over a week so he's very nearly at the recommended age now.

I agree that it's about personal choice and risk assessment. I'm fairly relaxed like your sister in that we moved him to his own room at 12 weeks but I do use a video monitor. No slings/baby carriers, I found them uncomfortable and awkward and my usually settled baby always got grumpy and shouty in it.

He also started nursery at 12 weeks when I went back to work and they definitely don't stay with him when he sleeps there either.

I thought about having a video monitor at one stage and didn’t get one, but I can see how they can be handy.

We kept our daughter in our room for 6 months but she had naps in her own room from a couple of weeks and we put her in our room after her bath every night from a couple of weeks too and we’d sleep in the same room when we were ready to go to bed. We just found it worked well for us and our baby, she’s an excellent sleeper and as she’s such a happy little girl who’s generally always in a good mood, I can’t see that we’ve done anything wrong!

She went into her own room at around 6 months and she was happy to go in there. It wasn’t a brand new room for her and she was used to being on her own by then. As we’ve both said, it’s just about what works for you.

I was happy to have her in with us until 6 months and you were happy to put your son in his own room from 3 months. Two parents who’ve done things differently and not having a big shouty match coming out with ‘you do realise what the advice is, don’t you?’ Very refreshing!

SouthLondonMum22 · 28/05/2023 12:27

WhatAmIDoingWrong123 · 28/05/2023 11:57

I feel much the same. I’ve been back at work for almost 10 months so maternity leave feels like a while ago, but when I was on leave and my little girl was much smaller than she is now, I used to relish my showers. They were a glorious bit of me time. As for carry around in a sling, that’s not possible for me, I have a congenital ankle problem which makes them very unstable and causes a lot of random falls. It would be a mistake to carry my baby around in a sling as it would make me more unstable and more likely to fall. My bathroom also really is too small to put a bouncer in it anywhere, I attempted it once when she was going through a particularly fussy phase and it seemed like it might be easier. It wasn’t easier!

For me, all of this comes down to personal choice. The vast majority of parents interpret guidelines individually and make reasonable, rational choices based on their own assessment of risk.

My sister is more relaxed about it than me and her children were both in their own room rooms overnight from a couple of weeks. Between us we have three thriving children who never went near a sling, a sensor mat, a video monitor, got carried around in their baskets all day or had to join their mums in the shower. It’s not how we do things and it’s fine. It’s also fine if you want to, but those that do should leave everyone else alone and stop trying to insist their way is the only way!

Mine will be 6 months in just over a week so he's very nearly at the recommended age now.

I agree that it's about personal choice and risk assessment. I'm fairly relaxed like your sister in that we moved him to his own room at 12 weeks but I do use a video monitor. No slings/baby carriers, I found them uncomfortable and awkward and my usually settled baby always got grumpy and shouty in it.

He also started nursery at 12 weeks when I went back to work and they definitely don't stay with him when he sleeps there either.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 12:15

Hugasauras · 28/05/2023 12:13

I love the confidence with which 'your breathing regulates theirs' is always trotted out on here despite there being no actual evidence that's the case, merely a theory in a sea of theories. And if it were proven, then there would be other conditions attached because simply being in the same room wouldn't be enough for that.

Wouldn't that be an argument in favour of bed sharing?