Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed about child benefit threshold?

266 replies

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 06:50

I earn not far over the threshold to claim child benefit so am not going to put in any claim.

Maybe it seems completely unreasonable to many but given the large amount I pay in tax and NI every year, I feel annoyed that we get nothing back for this, especially with costs of absolutely everything going up.

If we could claim it, we would use it to fund baby related groceries or the heating bill in winter, both of which can be quite expensive.

I don't understand why the threshold can't be more towards 100k mark like the childcare costs threshold as once you're into six figure salaries that's a different ball game (although those people also pay hefty amounts of tax so why shouldn't they see something for it too?)

I expect to be slated for daring to question any of this as someone who earns a comfortable amount but when you've put into the system over the years, it would be nice to get more back when it's for your child.

I have a very wealthy elderly relative who still received the government's pensioner cost of living payment last year regardless of her massive income. They didn't means test that but they will set limits and thresholds for benefits for children rather than make it more universal.

OP posts:
PrincessHoneysuckle · 25/05/2023 07:51

You're either a troll or delusional.CB is around 90 a month for one child.If you need help with the income you said you have then you're living beyond your means somewhere.

Swrigh1234 · 25/05/2023 07:50

This is another form of fiscal drag. More people being dragged into paying more tax by stealth. Despite that we have an ever decreasing number of net contributors propping up the system while the number of net recipients grows ever larger.

MumblesParty · 25/05/2023 07:50

Littlebluebellwoods · 25/05/2023 07:01

I agree the limits are odd - and if there has to be a threshold it should be based on household income not individual income.

this cannot be a serious post? You cannot really think every household is some happy family. There is everything in there, from new partners to separated and living together to the abusive financial controlling ones. Of course it shouldn’t be on household. This isn’t Disney land.

I’m confused. Do you actually think it’s fair that a household with 2 parents with a combined income of £98k should get child benefit but a single parent earning £60k shouldn’t ? Just on the off-chance that one of the parents is financially abusive? How would that abuse work by the way, given that each parent would be earning the same?

DiIIy · 25/05/2023 07:49

I agree with you. People on higher salaries paying more tax but are not allowed anything back. Its the like free childcare hours that people moan that higher earners shouldn't be entitled to, but why not? Higher earners pay their taxes, and plenty of it.

Spacestace · 25/05/2023 07:48

it's more the principle that threshold hasn't changed for a while despite inflation etc

I mean if the government aren't arsed about raising public sector wages in line with inflation they aren't arsed about this.

I'm also over the threshold but the amount it is a month I'm still better of on the salary I'm on. The £100k threshold though I've been actively avoiding until DC are all out of childcare!

Newmumatlast · 25/05/2023 07:46

Tellmeimcrazy · 25/05/2023 07:09

I wonder why, as a person who has no children, I can't take out anything from the put I put into. I'm sure many others in my position feel the same

But you do. By using/receiving public services, living in the environment created and maintained by councils/government. You may not be made a payment (unless you ever receive something like statutory sick pay/furlough etc) but you do still 'take' from the pot.

You also arguably receive a benefit in kind due to things like child benefit even though you don't have kids. If children are better cared and provided for, their life chances are better. Meaning more will survive into adult hood, be better workers etc generating tax payments which will not only help to support you in older age but will mean that there are people to take up public service roles which help you to continue to have the society set up that you do I.e. you can go to a supermarket and buy items because people work there and perform tasks which you benefit from.

Hadituptoere · 25/05/2023 07:45

Apologies 85k! Which is even more unfathomable in all honesty.

Hadituptoere · 25/05/2023 07:44

You have 75k coming into your home PA, I’m struggling to understand how £96 extra a month is going to help as much as you say.

I have 3 DC and CB is everything to us. I’m currently having to use a credit card to pay for food to avoid using a food bank, we’re on the breadline despite DH working 50 hour weeks and me having to stay at home because my job as support worker doesn’t pay enough to cover childcare.

We moved to a cheaper area to afford our home and living costs, we buy everything second hand (apart from underwear), we drive a second hand car, we go camping for holidays etc. Surely there’s things you can do instead of paying more into your pension to swindle £96 a month? We had to opt out and pay nothing into our pensions right now just to keep afloat, it doesn’t seem fair. But then I guess under this shitty Tory government nothing is and it shows even a family pulling in 75k PA is also relying on CB, you’ve obviously worked very hard to earn 60k and it’s such fucking bullshit that you have to struggle even earning that kind of money.

fellrunner85 · 25/05/2023 07:43

Oh come on. 60k is a massive salary. You do not need CB.
Yes, there is an argument for means-testing per household; and yes I'm aware the threshold hasn't changed in line with inflation, but none of those additional arguments negate the fact that 60k is a huge salary - double the average - and it's not the best use of taxpayers' money to be giving additional benefits to people earning that.

And fwiw yes I do earn more than 60k, and no I don't feel "rich" - but I'm well aware I'm significantly richer than most.

Starlightstarbright1 · 25/05/2023 07:43

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 07:01

This is crazy as I earn just over 60k but my partner is on 25k. If we both earned 49k we'd have more household income AND could claim. It's insane, who makes these rules??

I earned 16 thousand last year single parent of a child with Sen so for context you absolutely don’t need the money - you do get money back a health care system which meant you didn’t pay to give birt , a education system you don’t have to use , free prescriptions on the nhs for your children.
you earn £85 thousand would you really notice that money ?

Panda89 · 25/05/2023 07:43

Yeah this really bugs me too.
DH is a relatively low earner (£24k) so it irrationally bugs me that we could both earn £49k and still get it, and be in a better net position.
I can’t put my extra into my pension easily either, as my work have a habit of chucking random unknown bonuses into pay when you are least expecting it. So I never really know how much I’ll be paid in the tax year.

GlitteryGreen · 25/05/2023 07:42

I agree OP, it's ridiculous. 50-60k is not a huge salary these days and the self-assessment element definitely worries me about claiming in case I do it wrong.

My DP earns half what I do so we have a much lower income overall than so many who are able to claim.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 25/05/2023 07:42

If it was done on household income the kids who don't get it are the kids of women trapped in abusive relationships with financially controlling partners.
Reforming it so that OP doesn't suffer will make those kids suffer instead.

Yes it's an imperfect system but any reform that involves a different way of categorising people into worthy and unworthy would harm the poorest and most vulnerable too. Going back to making it a universal benefit would be totally fine but the books would have to be balanced elsewhere.

Newmumatlast · 25/05/2023 07:40

Lizzt2007 · 25/05/2023 07:30

That's extremely disingenuous, if you actually read that thread you would have seen that there was three adults looking to work to realise that £5000 per month household income, and it included the cost of childcare for two toddlers in the £5000 needed. The poster was just interested in the type of jobs that could realise that monthly figure.

Yep and bearing in mind the costs of childcare. We are looking at over £500 for 4 half days with 30hr funding (which doesn't cover the full cost at all given not just term time required and longer hours than gov covers) and 2 half days for baby. And that's with a sibling discount. If they went full time.... !

middleager · 25/05/2023 07:40

I don't know if YABU.

You say you earn just over £60k and your partner £25k so that's heading towards £90k yet you're happy for those on a combined income of £100k not to get it. Besides, you've been told how to top up your pension so you can now play the game too while topping up your own pension, earning a high salary and claiming CB too. You are in a good position IMO.

You have a high income OP, so I'm struggling to see how you need help with food and heating on that income.

ApplesandOrangesandPears · 25/05/2023 07:39

You earn £60,000 a year, you're child does not suffer or go without because you don't get £20 a week back. Compare that to someone on a lower wage and you realise that some families DO depend on that money. Child benefit is exactly that - to benefit the child, your child already has a step up from many of their peers by having comfortably well off parents.

Frankly, the only change I think needs to happen currently is that child benefit should be based on combined wages rather than individual wages because it's not fair that a household earning up to 90k can it get whereas a single parent on 60k can't.

yutu · 25/05/2023 07:37

I have a friend who has very rich parents. She bought a £700k house cash a few yrs ago and her kids go to private school. However because her husbands only works part time and shes not working, they still get child benefits.

Newmumatlast · 25/05/2023 07:36

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 07:00

They already pay it. It’s not a new tax on them.
It used to be universal which I don’t disagree with but tories gonna Tory.
But what is interesting is that means testing is made out to be so expensive and not worth it for other benefits like the winter fuel allowance!

The whole thing needs massively addressing.
A household income of 50k from a single salary is actually not well off and it’s even worse when a household income of 99k but from 2 equal salaries keeps their child benefit.

This is a good point re the cost of means testing. I suspect it's to do with attracting the grey vote. People go on about the entitlement of youth but I have to say, in my experience I hear the most entitled views from older people re having paid in for years and so they should get x y and z back when actually most of them would never have paid in anywhere near enough over their lives to cover what they've had back from the state (working class background, not high incomes). I personally think winter fuel and cost of living not being means tested for pensioners is ridiculous. Not all pensioners are struggling and if it wasn't paid across the board there would be more in the pot to help those who are at risk of death each year through not having enough to heat and eat.

In terms of child benefit, it's always been mad to me that its not per household. If it can be means tested to any person over x amount in a household, why not combined in a household? I think a 100k combined cap would be fair (and a lower cap than the childcare one which is any person in the household being over 100k - again, it should be household not individual as you could have a huge combined income and still qualify).

Personally I think child benefit should be for everyone given its actually for the child but I can see why means testing was introduced. Too many people using it for savings for their kids not for essentials therefore not actually needed. However you could argue that by saving for kids, it benefits the state later. I know the savings I am making for my kids will go towards things like uni, house etc meaning less chance they will be reliant on the state. Similarly I pay extra into my pension every year which yes, reduces my tax but at the same time means I'm alot less likely to rely on state funding in old age, including care costs.

Butterflybutterflies · 25/05/2023 07:35

The higher earner may be financially controlling. The lower earner/stay at home parent was at least guaranteed an income every month. When the new rules came in I felt it was very unfair for that reason.

Morph22010 · 25/05/2023 07:35

Whenisitsummer · 25/05/2023 07:22

I agree. They haven’t changed the earning thresholds for 10 years which is wrong. Plus a family with two parents earning 30k each take home more than one person on 60k. Yet they keep their child benefit. It should be based on household income and the threshold increased to 70- 80k, which in 2023 is probably the equivalent of 50- 60k in 2013.

The issue is because taxation is independent since the 70s the government has no clue or any way in their system to calculate and check household income only individual income. They only know household income where someone has filled in an application for other benefits

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 25/05/2023 07:32

People on MN are so short sighted- they can say poor you boo-hoo but in accepting this crap, and the awful way it is calculated (individual not household income)- is the governments way of phasing it out altogether and plays nicely into the narrative your children your problem.!

Lizzt2007 · 25/05/2023 07:30

Lapland123 · 25/05/2023 07:07

None of the tax thresholds have changed in years and this is just one of these examples.
We are all being taxed senseless and getting what in return? While everything costs more and more from the post tax income.

Did you see the thread about a family wanting to come off benefits but wondering what job they could get 5k take home pay as that’s what they’d need to find their lifestyle.

meanwhile we are all paying for that

That's extremely disingenuous, if you actually read that thread you would have seen that there was three adults looking to work to realise that £5000 per month household income, and it included the cost of childcare for two toddlers in the £5000 needed. The poster was just interested in the type of jobs that could realise that monthly figure.

WonderingWanda · 25/05/2023 07:29

I think it should be on household income, it's very unfair to single parents or families where only one parent works.

AllThatFancyPaintsAsFair · 25/05/2023 07:28

LIZS · 25/05/2023 07:25

Register for CB but you can opt out of payments. That way your ni during ml and any future void periods is protected and dc is allocated an ni number.

if youre earning too much for CB by definition you're well paying enough NI

LIZS · 25/05/2023 07:25

Register for CB but you can opt out of payments. That way your ni during ml and any future void periods is protected and dc is allocated an ni number.

Swipe left for the next trending thread