Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed about child benefit threshold?

266 replies

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 06:50

I earn not far over the threshold to claim child benefit so am not going to put in any claim.

Maybe it seems completely unreasonable to many but given the large amount I pay in tax and NI every year, I feel annoyed that we get nothing back for this, especially with costs of absolutely everything going up.

If we could claim it, we would use it to fund baby related groceries or the heating bill in winter, both of which can be quite expensive.

I don't understand why the threshold can't be more towards 100k mark like the childcare costs threshold as once you're into six figure salaries that's a different ball game (although those people also pay hefty amounts of tax so why shouldn't they see something for it too?)

I expect to be slated for daring to question any of this as someone who earns a comfortable amount but when you've put into the system over the years, it would be nice to get more back when it's for your child.

I have a very wealthy elderly relative who still received the government's pensioner cost of living payment last year regardless of her massive income. They didn't means test that but they will set limits and thresholds for benefits for children rather than make it more universal.

OP posts:
TimesRwo · 25/05/2023 09:27

ArdeteiMasazxu · 25/05/2023 07:42

If it was done on household income the kids who don't get it are the kids of women trapped in abusive relationships with financially controlling partners.
Reforming it so that OP doesn't suffer will make those kids suffer instead.

Yes it's an imperfect system but any reform that involves a different way of categorising people into worthy and unworthy would harm the poorest and most vulnerable too. Going back to making it a universal benefit would be totally fine but the books would have to be balanced elsewhere.

In such a controlling situation, wouldn’t the man just arrange it to have the payments sent to his account? Or just take it from the woman if sent to her account?

Not asking you personally, I just see that argument a lot, but I don’t understand how CB allows a woman to keep some financial freedom when the man is so controlling.

orangegato · 25/05/2023 09:26

I think more things should be universal, and I’m a Tory (not the best place to say this, I am aware).

Means testing certain things (eg pensions) penalises people who have worked their arse off. A tiny pension disqualifies you from getting literally everything for free, why actually bother saving and working hard?

The CHB threshold annoys people more due to how nonsensical it is taking into account the highest earner not household income. Which moron decided that?!

sheldonia · 25/05/2023 09:26

Justtobeclear · 25/05/2023 09:07

We have a situation where I live with my DH who is my DC’s stepdad. He earns 80k and I earn 30k. I can’t claim CB because he earns over the income threshold. But he has no legal obligation to provide for them or legal rights as a parent over them. If I was to get it, he’d have to pay it back through self assessment. As our money goes into one pot it wasn’t worth the hassle. I don’t need it but it annoys me that if we were earning 49999.99 each we’d still get it and that’s the bit that needs to change I think.

Not sure on the logic of this...if you married someone who earns nearly 3 times your wage but wouldn't share finances with you or take responsibility for your children, that seems like a you thing rather than a need for a benefit from the government? I mean, you have a household income of 110k....why would you be able to claim CB?

Retrain12345 · 25/05/2023 09:24

I find it really confusing.
DH is on 48k.

Once he reaches 50k are we only entitled to a proportion, how do we pay back what we have been overpaid?

Stupid system, no the wonder people can’t be bothered and stick the extra in pensions!

sheldonia · 25/05/2023 09:23

It's a few years since I lived in the UK, so while I was aware it had changed, I still don't really understand. It sounds complicated...tax returns and paying it back and sliding scales etc? Do you really only get it for 2 kids now?

I think universal child benefit makes much more sense, thats what we get.
I get CB for 3 of my 5 children (the oldest two are over 18 so not for them), and we get 420€ per month. Except next month, as a COL bonus, we get 720€ for June.

Movingonupi · 25/05/2023 09:19

I think it’s silly and should be done by household, a single parent living in London on £60k wouldn’t get it, but a couple living in Yorkshire on, say, £45k each would be able to claim…£60k sadly doesn’t go as far as you think in todays climate, particularly if you have hound kids and it’s the only salary.

brunettemic · 25/05/2023 09:18

The threshold probably should move but all you’re doing with your suggestion is moving it so YOU benefit, you’re not solving a problem you’re just coming across as entitled and whiney. It sounds like you’re not willing to pay more pension to get it or change your lifestyle and so want help funding that.

the change I’d make is base it on household income not singular income. FWIW we still probably wouldn’t get it then so it’s doesn’t help me anyway.

chickensandbees · 25/05/2023 09:14

For me it's the system of paying back that is way too complicated. I'm PAYE and the government know how much I earn so they should just reduce how much I get or take more in tax if I go over the threshold. I checked my annual salary in March last year and was going to be about £4k over £50k so I looked into how to pay it back and it would have been a self assessment form which seemed too much hassle, so I just put £4k extra in my pension that month and sorted.

They did an assessment on me a few years ago and I had a temporary pay increase so had to pay back 1 years worth but was fine for all the others they checked, but had to provide loads of evidence for gift aid payments and pension payments. It's a lot of work for me and them and should be easier.

GOW56 · 25/05/2023 09:08

The way it has been set up is very unfair as households on just under 100k if 2 parents earn 49k each will get full child benefit but those on 60k between them wont if one parent earns 51 and the other is on a low or no income.
But it was set up to be simple and consistent with the tax system to make it easy for HMRC to administer.
Originally child benefit was a universal benefit and I think it should have stayed that way

Justtobeclear · 25/05/2023 09:07

We have a situation where I live with my DH who is my DC’s stepdad. He earns 80k and I earn 30k. I can’t claim CB because he earns over the income threshold. But he has no legal obligation to provide for them or legal rights as a parent over them. If I was to get it, he’d have to pay it back through self assessment. As our money goes into one pot it wasn’t worth the hassle. I don’t need it but it annoys me that if we were earning 49999.99 each we’d still get it and that’s the bit that needs to change I think.

littleblackcat27 · 25/05/2023 09:07

HerMammy · 25/05/2023 07:07

Household income of £85k and you're annoyed you can't get £20pw CB, I've heard it all now.

yep

My contribution to 'the debate' is - hard luck and suck it up. You don't need child benefit. You need to learn how to budget your considerable income.

As for saying 'I don't get anything for paying my taxes' maybe it's not all about you and taxes are for the greater good.

Bumpitybumper · 25/05/2023 09:07

@MaidOfSteel
*You'd think nobody else actually paid any tax, wouldn't you.

Well off people moaning is sickening*
More than half of all households received more in benefits and 'benefits of kind' than they paid in tax. Lots of people wrongly assume because they pay some tax that they are somehow 'paying their way'. This often simply isn't the case and they are being propped up by other tax payers.

It is natural that there is going to be a cut off point where people not only stop receiving benefits that top up earning but also where people are expected to pay more tax. If you have ever received a promotion that has taken you into a new tax bracket or pushed you over the limit for a benefit entitlement then you will understand how demoralising it is to end up working harder with a lot more responsibility for sometimes the same or even less money. I don't think it's wrong or sickening for people to find this hard to deal with and question the system.

I don't know why you expect people to gladly accept that they should be increasingly paying into a system that they get less and less from.

MaidOfSteel · 25/05/2023 09:01

Teateaandmoretea · 25/05/2023 08:33

People on mumsnet pitching average people against each other and making everything a race to the bottom is what sickens me.

Being in the top 10% of this country's earners doesn't make you average.

Mygazpachoistoocold · 25/05/2023 09:00

MooseBreath · 25/05/2023 08:29

I get it OP.
My DH earns 60k, so no child benefit for us. But I am a SAHM because we can't afford childcare for me to go back to work, so that 60k is all we have as a household (plus deducting NI, tax, student loan, pension, and all of my visa fees because I am an immigrant). DH has only been working for 5 years as he got his MEng and a PhD on a minimal stipend while I worked for a whopping 22k, so it's not like we have any savings or assets built up. Rent is extortionate and we live in an expensive area because that is where DH's work is.
Child benefit would help our children massively, but the system doesn't consider any of those things. We just fell through the net.

I also get it.
It seems a strange argument that £20 is nothing to those earning over the threshold and everything to those under the threshold.

ActDottie · 25/05/2023 08:59

As others have said put more in your pension.

I am currently pregnant with our first baby, and I earn too much to get child benefit but I don’t feel angry about it because tbh we don’t really need it.

Naunet · 25/05/2023 08:59

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 06:50

I earn not far over the threshold to claim child benefit so am not going to put in any claim.

Maybe it seems completely unreasonable to many but given the large amount I pay in tax and NI every year, I feel annoyed that we get nothing back for this, especially with costs of absolutely everything going up.

If we could claim it, we would use it to fund baby related groceries or the heating bill in winter, both of which can be quite expensive.

I don't understand why the threshold can't be more towards 100k mark like the childcare costs threshold as once you're into six figure salaries that's a different ball game (although those people also pay hefty amounts of tax so why shouldn't they see something for it too?)

I expect to be slated for daring to question any of this as someone who earns a comfortable amount but when you've put into the system over the years, it would be nice to get more back when it's for your child.

I have a very wealthy elderly relative who still received the government's pensioner cost of living payment last year regardless of her massive income. They didn't means test that but they will set limits and thresholds for benefits for children rather than make it more universal.

I pay a lot of tax too, have worked since 16 and am helping the planet by not having kids at all. Where’s my help? Everyone seems to have their hand out, where do you think this money comes from?

EasterIssland · 25/05/2023 08:58

LIZS · 25/05/2023 08:26

Does not work like that, limit applies if either earns more than 50k. So yes dp could claim it but op still repays via a tax return.

This. My husband claims it. I earn over 60k. I have to return the money we got for last year as I changed jobs midway which pushes me over the limit.

TripleDaisySummer · 25/05/2023 08:58

If you're not far over the threshold and really want it why not whack a bit more in your pension? You'll get the 40% relief and then the benefit.

This.

First time ever we are getting close to first threshold and DH is doing this - though DD1 nearing 18 anyway and hopefully off to Uni so it tailing off anyway though still very useful amount to spend on the kids - bus passes into college books etc.

I do agree with PP that real unfair bit is it not based on household income so single parents who are high earners are disadvantaged.

MaidOfSteel · 25/05/2023 08:57

Overthebow · 25/05/2023 07:55

£90 every 4 weeks (13 payments per year) is a good amount though, we use it for savings for our DC, so she gets an extra £1000 per year in savings from it.

Necessities, eh.

BelindaBears · 25/05/2023 08:56

It never should have been means tested. Either keep it for everyone or scrap it entirely and add a bit to universal credit.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 25/05/2023 08:53

YANBU

The threshold hadn’t gone up for around 10 years, and in that time inflation has gone wild.

The other desperately unfair thing is that it goes on one person’s income, rather than the household income. So you can have two earners just under the threshold getting full CB, but one person earning just over it doesn’t get anything. Really unfair and should change to household income - single parents have enough additional burden!

MaidOfSteel · 25/05/2023 08:52

Newmumatlast · 25/05/2023 07:46

But you do. By using/receiving public services, living in the environment created and maintained by councils/government. You may not be made a payment (unless you ever receive something like statutory sick pay/furlough etc) but you do still 'take' from the pot.

You also arguably receive a benefit in kind due to things like child benefit even though you don't have kids. If children are better cared and provided for, their life chances are better. Meaning more will survive into adult hood, be better workers etc generating tax payments which will not only help to support you in older age but will mean that there are people to take up public service roles which help you to continue to have the society set up that you do I.e. you can go to a supermarket and buy items because people work there and perform tasks which you benefit from.

This applies to people with children, too. It applies to all of us. We all benefit from a functioning state.

Porkandbeans1 · 25/05/2023 08:47

DH and myself always had a jiggle about where we could so that we didn't lose the entitlement. And we were far better off as two people just under the threshold than a single high earner. The rule does seem odd and unfair to single parent families.

But when were no longer entitled to it I couldn't be angry, we never needed the money and I can't say I noticed the £20 a week that was missing. I'd rather have the £20k ISA limit raised which has been in place since 2017.

Quveas · 25/05/2023 08:46

Somebody will always complain about the rules. If you are unemployed, the savings thresholds haven't changed in forever! It's tough that there have to be rules. But it's hard to get too bothered about people with relatively high incomes not getting child benefit. By your argument (I pay alot of tax so I should get something back) I'm owed a bloody fortune back - I pay a lot of tax, and I'm paying for the nursery / school your children go to. What's fair about that then?

gogohmm · 25/05/2023 08:41

@Mirenda

Very annoying isn't it, my ex earned £65k (so over even after pension) I was at home as dd has autism and couldn't do childcare, later I've worked pt ( i still have to support her at university). I think it should be based on family wage of £80k or similar

Swipe left for the next trending thread