Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed about child benefit threshold?

266 replies

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 06:50

I earn not far over the threshold to claim child benefit so am not going to put in any claim.

Maybe it seems completely unreasonable to many but given the large amount I pay in tax and NI every year, I feel annoyed that we get nothing back for this, especially with costs of absolutely everything going up.

If we could claim it, we would use it to fund baby related groceries or the heating bill in winter, both of which can be quite expensive.

I don't understand why the threshold can't be more towards 100k mark like the childcare costs threshold as once you're into six figure salaries that's a different ball game (although those people also pay hefty amounts of tax so why shouldn't they see something for it too?)

I expect to be slated for daring to question any of this as someone who earns a comfortable amount but when you've put into the system over the years, it would be nice to get more back when it's for your child.

I have a very wealthy elderly relative who still received the government's pensioner cost of living payment last year regardless of her massive income. They didn't means test that but they will set limits and thresholds for benefits for children rather than make it more universal.

OP posts:
EasterIssland · 25/05/2023 10:49

TimesRwo · 25/05/2023 10:33

Isn’t it already limited to two children…? Why would larger families be in even more poverty?

Not the child benefit. Only the child tax

EasterIssland · 25/05/2023 10:48

HerMammy · 25/05/2023 10:23

90 every 4 weeks (13 payments per year) is a good amount though, we use it for savings for our DC, so she gets an extra £1000 per year in savings from it 90 every 4 weeks (13 payments per year) is a good amount though, we use it for savings for our DC, so she gets an extra £1000 per year in savings from it

this pisses me off, it's not to top up your savings

Why not ? My child doesn’t need it now. But he might need it when he’s 16. He might need some cash then for something I can’t afford. It’s not like we’re not feeding and paying what a child needs in the mean time. Who says it has to be exclusively used on food?

highlandspooce · 25/05/2023 10:47

I find threads like these a greta example of how out of touch people truly are.

A household income of > £85k and OP would like CB to use it to fund baby related groceries or the heating bill in winter, both of which can be quite expensive.

I mean surely with such a high income you just fund it yourself? There are people out there waiting for their CB to drop so they can get another £10 on their electric meter every week Biscuit

I realise the criteria for CB makes no sense but I struggle to sympathise with someone who wants to claim it because when you've put into the system over the years, it would be nice to get more back when it's for your child.

landbeforegrime · 25/05/2023 10:42

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 07:01

This is crazy as I earn just over 60k but my partner is on 25k. If we both earned 49k we'd have more household income AND could claim. It's insane, who makes these rules??

Genuinely, I believe these rules are made by the out of touch and thoroughly incompetent. It's not a political party bash. All parties are equally ridiculous. Don't hear any proper plan for the future from any of them. The current system breeds resentment and at all levels appears to incentivise the minimisation of work to reduce tax. I am part time precisely because I do not want to earn more and get pushed into the next tax threshold.

Cantstaystuckforever · 25/05/2023 10:41

(and that's £50k each not total!)

Cantstaystuckforever · 25/05/2023 10:41

https://www.civitas.org.uk/content/files/State-dependency-FINAL.pdf

Civitas is pretty right of centre, but the data is ONS

https://www.civitas.org.uk/content/files/State-dependency-FINAL.pdf

Cantstaystuckforever · 25/05/2023 10:39

To all the people calling selfish to people upset about this.

A huge % of the country get benefits.
36 million people in the UK - more than half the population - live in households receiving more in benefits than they pay in tax
27 million receive an average of £23k per year in benefits in cash and in kind (housing, childcare, PIP, vouchers etc)

Many of these households are really struggling to cope and could do with more. However many of those households will also have as much or more disposable income as a single mum of 2 on £55k in London, with far, far more time for leisure or training.

It's also annoying to hear that it's too hard to means test winter fuel payments for older people living in fully-owned houses on generous pensions, but not too hard to do a tax clawback on our child benefit. If a single mum ever does make it to the heights of £100k, she'll end up £14k a year worse off than a dual income family on £50k with kids the same age, due to tax thresholds, and child and childcare support means testing. How is that right for her or for her kids?

All these caps and cutoffs are illogical and not helpful.

Speermint · 25/05/2023 10:38

What pisses me off is that a family with one parent earning 60k and the other parent earning nothing gets zero child benefit. But a family with two parents earning a total of 96k gets full child benefit.

Conkersinautumn · 25/05/2023 10:38

It's a benefit that we as a family aren't entitled to. There are many, I'm not bitter about it because there's so little support for those who do need it. I can't begrudge child benefit as it's not a position I'd want my children to be in.

TimesRwo · 25/05/2023 10:33

NewNovember · 25/05/2023 10:24

Yeah why not put larger families in even more poverty , great vote winner actually. Take a look at yourself.

Isn’t it already limited to two children…? Why would larger families be in even more poverty?

Ilovecleaning · 25/05/2023 10:26

drpet49 · 25/05/2023 07:00

Ill get my tiny violin out OP

FFS. Why do even bother with a childish reply like this?

NewNovember · 25/05/2023 10:24

bridgetjonesmassivepants · 25/05/2023 10:21

Why not make child benefit for two kids universal with no means testing?

Pensioner in laws, who have a higher income than us with no mortgage get winter fuel allowance with no means testing and they are loaded.

As a family, we are paying a lot if tax but not getting much back. GP appointments are difficult to get, dentists are practically impossible, just spent £4000 on braces for DD. Child benefit reinstalled would make me feel slightly less resentful. You can tax higher earners more but they do need basic services in return.

Yeah why not put larger families in even more poverty , great vote winner actually. Take a look at yourself.

WomanUnknown · 25/05/2023 10:23

OutDamnedSpot · 25/05/2023 07:00

This is the bit that drives me bonkers. As a single parent, I am just over the threshold and don’t get it. Friends with significantly higher household income (and less pressure in other areas of childcare) do get it. Madness.

Yea agreed, this drives me mad. I know plenty of couples hitting close to the 80-100k mark when combining their income who get full child benefit.

HerMammy · 25/05/2023 10:23

90 every 4 weeks (13 payments per year) is a good amount though, we use it for savings for our DC, so she gets an extra £1000 per year in savings from it 90 every 4 weeks (13 payments per year) is a good amount though, we use it for savings for our DC, so she gets an extra £1000 per year in savings from it

this pisses me off, it's not to top up your savings

MooseBreath · 25/05/2023 10:21

fellrunner85 · 25/05/2023 10:13

*£60k and DH is the sole earner.

I am an immigrant, so pay high visa fees every couple years to live in the UK as well as NHS surcharges. Student loan repayment is huge. Rent is high, so can't save for a deposit on a cheaper mortgage. Expensive area because that's where DH's highly skilled job exists*

This is exactly what I'm talking about - you have a household income significantly above the national average, only one of you is working, yet you still think you should get child benefit? Erm, no.

No it shouldn't be a race to the bottom, but nor should high earners be subsidised by the state, in my view. If either of you earn over 60k, you don't need it. As exemplified by those upthread saying they're putting it into DCs savings.

It doesn't sit right with me that some well off families are claiming CB to put into savings accounts at a time when more people than ever are struggling to afford basics such as heating and eating. And yes, for avoidance of doubt, I do earn more than 60k (only just) and do not claim CB.

The benefit is for the children, not DH and I. I am only a SAHM because putting 2 under 3s in nursery would cost more than I could bring in (my wage before I had children was £22k). DH's wage also means we don't get tax free childcare.

I'm not saying we should get tax free childcare or that we are the worst off. We're not. We are very lucky. But the system fucks over the squeezed middle and as the price if everything rises and salaries don't and the benefit cap doesn't, then you take away all taxes and student loans and visa fees and pension contributions, we are far worse off than the £60k suggests.

SapphosRock · 25/05/2023 10:21

YANBU OP. I think the threshold should change to match the rising cost of living. It must be at least 7 or 8 years that they set the cut off at £60k, it should now be £75k or more.

They should also do it on total household income - very unfair that a couple earning £49k each can claim child benefit but a single person earning £60k cannot.

Take home pay on £60k is about £3,600.

This is not a lot for a single parent.

Full time nursery can be up to £90 a day, even at £70 a day that's around £1,200 a month. Two kids and you are looking at over £2k on childcare. Then there is the rising cost of food. Nappies, clothes etc.

Mortgage rates have gone up, rent is extortionate, energy prices are through the roof.

bridgetjonesmassivepants · 25/05/2023 10:21

Why not make child benefit for two kids universal with no means testing?

Pensioner in laws, who have a higher income than us with no mortgage get winter fuel allowance with no means testing and they are loaded.

As a family, we are paying a lot if tax but not getting much back. GP appointments are difficult to get, dentists are practically impossible, just spent £4000 on braces for DD. Child benefit reinstalled would make me feel slightly less resentful. You can tax higher earners more but they do need basic services in return.

ilovesooty · 25/05/2023 10:20

OutDamnedSpot · 25/05/2023 07:00

This is the bit that drives me bonkers. As a single parent, I am just over the threshold and don’t get it. Friends with significantly higher household income (and less pressure in other areas of childcare) do get it. Madness.

It's really unfair on single parents.

NewNovember · 25/05/2023 10:18

sheldonia · 25/05/2023 09:23

It's a few years since I lived in the UK, so while I was aware it had changed, I still don't really understand. It sounds complicated...tax returns and paying it back and sliding scales etc? Do you really only get it for 2 kids now?

I think universal child benefit makes much more sense, thats what we get.
I get CB for 3 of my 5 children (the oldest two are over 18 so not for them), and we get 420€ per month. Except next month, as a COL bonus, we get 720€ for June.

There is no limit on the number of children you can claim child benefit for.

24KaratCucumber · 25/05/2023 10:15

They should scrap CB and increase Universal Credit by £80 a child a month.
those that need it most should get it, people just paying more into their pension to fidge the system and get CB shouldn't.

fellrunner85 · 25/05/2023 10:13

*£60k and DH is the sole earner.

I am an immigrant, so pay high visa fees every couple years to live in the UK as well as NHS surcharges. Student loan repayment is huge. Rent is high, so can't save for a deposit on a cheaper mortgage. Expensive area because that's where DH's highly skilled job exists*

This is exactly what I'm talking about - you have a household income significantly above the national average, only one of you is working, yet you still think you should get child benefit? Erm, no.

No it shouldn't be a race to the bottom, but nor should high earners be subsidised by the state, in my view. If either of you earn over 60k, you don't need it. As exemplified by those upthread saying they're putting it into DCs savings.

It doesn't sit right with me that some well off families are claiming CB to put into savings accounts at a time when more people than ever are struggling to afford basics such as heating and eating. And yes, for avoidance of doubt, I do earn more than 60k (only just) and do not claim CB.

NewNovember · 25/05/2023 10:11

Mygazpachoistoocold · 25/05/2023 09:00

I also get it.
It seems a strange argument that £20 is nothing to those earning over the threshold and everything to those under the threshold.

what! If you are poor then £20 is more valuable to you, and a higher percentage of you income than if you are not. How is that hard to understand?

Iguanainanigloo · 25/05/2023 10:11

WheelsUp · 25/05/2023 06:58

Put enough into your pension so that you stay below the threshold.
The rules are mad because of the discrepancies it creates. A single earner on £51k won't get it but a household with 2 earners in £49k will.

This! It's so unfairly done. Every household with an income under 100k should be eligible for full child benefit. My DH earns 55k, I earn minimum wage working part time around the kids, so we have to faff around with tax returns and end up paying back most of the child benefit we receive, but a couple we know both earn 48k (so have a substantially higher annual income than us, and they get to keep all their child benefit). Anything above 50k, is a decent salary, but it really doesn't stretch far these days. Most people earning that amount, are certainly not rolling in it, and the child benefit cap needs to be re-evaluated, and be done in a fairer manner. Also know a single mother who earns 60k, works her ass off, her ex doesn't pay her a penny, and she's not eligible for any other financial help, and she receives no child benefit whatsoever. The system really screws over hard working single parents. Because yes, on paper, her salary looks great, but it's not when she's singlehandedly supporting herself and two children, plus the costs she incurs with childcare to maintain her job. If that were a two adult household earning the total equivalent (i.e 30k each) they'd get full child benefit plus other help.

Bunnycat101 · 25/05/2023 10:11

The child benefit policy change was a badly designed one. The thresholds were always a bit daft and I suspect it costs a lot to administer the taper between 50-60k.

Where it seems ridiculous is the loopholes and exceptions

Eg household 1 would be eligible
*dad earning 80k and putting in £30k to pension

  • mum earning £60k and putting £10k into pension

household 2 - single parent on £65k putting in £5k pension.

If it was about the child, they’d have designed it differently.

sweetdreamstenasee · 25/05/2023 10:09

I’m in the same boat as you, just over 60k, don’t have as much disposable income as one would imagine as I pay a higher proportion of rent and bills, husbands job business has been hugely affected by covid although it still ties us to london, can’t afford to put more into a pension. Won’t have much in the way of maternity allowance because apparently haven’t paid enough NI due to tax assessment being a year behind, will be looking into paying it early. Speaking to my accountant about it now and working our options but we’re not a rich family, comfortable but we don’t have a car or our own place, our child won’t have their own nursery, house savings will be eaten up by not earning on maternity leave and still having to cover majority of expenses, will likely have to go back to work after a 3 months max to stay a float and no family so no free child care. I’m choosing to keep a positive mindset and accept that money will be tight but the £20 would have gone into an account to supplement childcare and feel miffed we can’t get it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread