Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed about child benefit threshold?

266 replies

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 06:50

I earn not far over the threshold to claim child benefit so am not going to put in any claim.

Maybe it seems completely unreasonable to many but given the large amount I pay in tax and NI every year, I feel annoyed that we get nothing back for this, especially with costs of absolutely everything going up.

If we could claim it, we would use it to fund baby related groceries or the heating bill in winter, both of which can be quite expensive.

I don't understand why the threshold can't be more towards 100k mark like the childcare costs threshold as once you're into six figure salaries that's a different ball game (although those people also pay hefty amounts of tax so why shouldn't they see something for it too?)

I expect to be slated for daring to question any of this as someone who earns a comfortable amount but when you've put into the system over the years, it would be nice to get more back when it's for your child.

I have a very wealthy elderly relative who still received the government's pensioner cost of living payment last year regardless of her massive income. They didn't means test that but they will set limits and thresholds for benefits for children rather than make it more universal.

OP posts:
HerMammy · 26/05/2023 08:26

@Betterbear
Seriously? talk about an over reaction 🤣
I've made many good choices, am financially comfortable but I wouldn't bleat about £20pw with savings in the bank, if you're struggling use what you have, not hoard it and expect a handout because you don't want to use your savings.

Hellocatshome · 26/05/2023 07:32

EasterIssland · 25/05/2023 22:30

Think you’re misunderstanding.
two households
45+45 would get £20/week
60+30 wouldn’t get it and they’d be paying also more on income tax

that’s what many are complaining about. It’s not the money. It’s the system that is not set well

btw as others have said 60k is really not a rich person. They live confortable but not rich

Rich is relative though. If you have no money, have to use a food bank and live in constant fear of eviction. A person living a comfortable life is very rich indeed.

ImAGoodPerson · 26/05/2023 07:29

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 07:01

This is crazy as I earn just over 60k but my partner is on 25k. If we both earned 49k we'd have more household income AND could claim. It's insane, who makes these rules??

Do you not pay anything into a pension at all? On an income of over £60k?

Betterbear · 26/05/2023 07:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

giggly · 25/05/2023 23:35

WheelsUp · 25/05/2023 06:58

Put enough into your pension so that you stay below the threshold.
The rules are mad because of the discrepancies it creates. A single earner on £51k won't get it but a household with 2 earners in £49k will.

This is what is wrong with the system, not your scenario of two household wages. I get fucked off as a single parent that I am penalised if my one wage goes over 50 and your moaning about raising it even further for two adults earning.
Your not the first to have paid childcare.

HerMammy · 25/05/2023 23:26

spend my savings it ain't happening.
If you have savings you can't whinge about low income or what benefits you can't get, savings are a luxury, use them!

headache · 25/05/2023 22:48

In Scotland our HRT tax rate starts at 42% I can’t remember (and it’s too late to look at the % of HRT tax payers in Scotland but it’s quite low) what did shock me is the % of adults not in work or not paying any tax at all.

The point I’m making is that there is only so much tax you can actually raise, HRT and tax payers in general can only pay so much tax. Like a previous poster said most adults are in receipt of some sort of benefit. The money has to come from somewhere.

A lot of people I know only work 16 hours as after that they loose their UC to me that’s a crazy system I thought it was all about making work pay?

When the changes to CB were brought in our family were one of those who lost our CB we were right on the threshold, we have 4 DC and overnight we lost over 3K. Now before I get jumped upon and told well it serves you right for earning so much etc I think every family would have felt the loss of that money. Family next door despite earning almost double got to keep there’s that was the unfairness. If we had lost it and the poorest families had had there’s doubled fair enough but that didn’t happen, if it was properly means tested. A fair system.

EasterIssland · 25/05/2023 22:30

Starlitestarbright · 25/05/2023 19:13

This is crazy as I earn just over 60k but my partner is on 25k. If we both earned 49k we'd have more household income AND could claim. It's insane, who makes these rules?

So a combined income of 85k and your moaning about 20 quid a week benefit. World's gone mad it's a couple of thousand a year. 85k a year is not struggling.

Think you’re misunderstanding.
two households
45+45 would get £20/week
60+30 wouldn’t get it and they’d be paying also more on income tax

that’s what many are complaining about. It’s not the money. It’s the system that is not set well

btw as others have said 60k is really not a rich person. They live confortable but not rich

Tellmeimcrazy · 25/05/2023 21:12

Againstmachine · 25/05/2023 18:34

Whilst you are correct you also have to remember a single person working on around minimum wage full time is entitled to nothing.

So don't pretend it benefits everyone it doesn't.

Exactly the point I was trying to make this morning.

RagingWoke · 25/05/2023 19:43

Betterbear · 25/05/2023 13:05

I absolutely agree!
I do get child benefit because my income is less than 50k, but that is all I am entitled to. It makes me very angry.
Universal credit is literally the goose that laid the golden egg of benefits. It is the gateway to literally everything.

Why should my children suffer because I made the right choices in life? Saved, bought a house, paid extra towards my mortgage etc. I am on a very low income and the extra support would be very welcomed, but unless I debt up my property and spend my savings it ain't happening.

This is wrong, the way they dish out benefits to people that have no clue about making responsible life choices. It is people like me who's taxes literally pay for it all. To get absolutely nothing back is soul destroying. Makes me wish I hadn't bothered!

If you were genuinely on a 'very low income' and in need of help then you would be eligible for UC in some form. If you have savings it's not unreasonable to be expected to use them.

Why should my children suffer because I made the right choices in life?

By your logic you haven't made good choices if you have such a low income, and how much are 'your taxes' 'literally' paying for on this very low income?

Welfare (that includes UC) isn't a big proportion of what taxes are spent on so that argument is pointless. Very few people put in more than they take out.

Starlitestarbright · 25/05/2023 19:13

This is crazy as I earn just over 60k but my partner is on 25k. If we both earned 49k we'd have more household income AND could claim. It's insane, who makes these rules?

So a combined income of 85k and your moaning about 20 quid a week benefit. World's gone mad it's a couple of thousand a year. 85k a year is not struggling.

Peanutlatte · 25/05/2023 18:49

Betterbear · 25/05/2023 13:05

I absolutely agree!
I do get child benefit because my income is less than 50k, but that is all I am entitled to. It makes me very angry.
Universal credit is literally the goose that laid the golden egg of benefits. It is the gateway to literally everything.

Why should my children suffer because I made the right choices in life? Saved, bought a house, paid extra towards my mortgage etc. I am on a very low income and the extra support would be very welcomed, but unless I debt up my property and spend my savings it ain't happening.

This is wrong, the way they dish out benefits to people that have no clue about making responsible life choices. It is people like me who's taxes literally pay for it all. To get absolutely nothing back is soul destroying. Makes me wish I hadn't bothered!

"Why should my children suffer because I made the right choices in life? Saved, bought a house, paid extra towards my mortgage etc." What??? Do you think everybody who is receiving benefits has made poor decisions? people get sick, people get abused etc etc..

Againstmachine · 25/05/2023 18:34

TheThinkingGoblin · 25/05/2023 12:48

Its become largely a waste of time to try to take the time to correct them.

The handout mentality in the UK has reached unsustainable proportions.

These folks seem to be under the impression that higher earners exist just to pay a lot of tax so that they in turn get access to benefits.

Apparently, we are not allowed to receive any benefits as higher earners because that would be "unfair". The convoluted logic is just amazing.

Thats why the UK keeps being levelled down.

Over half the population in the UK are now net recipients (receive more in benefits vs what they pay in as tax) with the top 10% of higher earners (£62k and above) paying 2/3rds of income taxes.

Totally usustainable.

Whilst you are correct you also have to remember a single person working on around minimum wage full time is entitled to nothing.

So don't pretend it benefits everyone it doesn't.

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 25/05/2023 18:13

ParentsTrapped · 25/05/2023 14:14

I haven’t read the full thread so apologies if others have made these points already.

Child benefit used to be a universal entitlement (ie not means tested) and there are good arguments for reinstating it as such: firstly, the cost of applying the means test almost eradicates the “saving” of not paying it to high earners; and secondly, from an ideological perspective it suits the tories’ narrative to create a divide between “sponging benefits claimants” (inc child benefit) and hardworking taxpayers funding those claimants. Some of the responses on this thread seem to have fully bought into that narrative.

It also creates a dynamic where these benefits can be cut down the line (in the name of austerity or similar) as most Tory voters won’t be receiving them. It’s bad for all of us.

Yes! This!

I remember it coming out and talking about it on here, and although I didn't earn close to it then, I asked for people to help write to MPs etc.A huge chunk of people said if you earn £50kplus you shouldn't get it, tough luck etc.

And now here we are, and when benefits get cut, and they will, tories aren't exactly friendly on those, when those same people complain and ask for help, and to be in uproar and protest etc, I'll replay the tiny violins that someone shared for me and ignore the lot of them. Because actually I'm ok, and yes the money goes into my DD savings account, and yes I'm fine, so crack on. And I say that as someone who's daughter still gets it (through my ex). It's the whole point of how people have sneered at those wanting to claim it. Offering budgeting advice etc.

It's massively divisive and that's what they want, and we handed it to them.

ParentsTrapped · 25/05/2023 14:14

I haven’t read the full thread so apologies if others have made these points already.

Child benefit used to be a universal entitlement (ie not means tested) and there are good arguments for reinstating it as such: firstly, the cost of applying the means test almost eradicates the “saving” of not paying it to high earners; and secondly, from an ideological perspective it suits the tories’ narrative to create a divide between “sponging benefits claimants” (inc child benefit) and hardworking taxpayers funding those claimants. Some of the responses on this thread seem to have fully bought into that narrative.

It also creates a dynamic where these benefits can be cut down the line (in the name of austerity or similar) as most Tory voters won’t be receiving them. It’s bad for all of us.

tabulahrasa · 25/05/2023 14:10

It’s a completely stupid unfair set up, it should be either universal or properly fairly means tested, it’s not like HMRC don’t know what people earn.

But you’re not complaining about that, you don’t mind the set up, just that it affects you and you Andy it to affect other people instead, so YABU.

MakesMeFeelSad · 25/05/2023 14:07

Comedycook · 25/05/2023 13:13

The fact we think 60k is a good salary and you're a rich bastard if that's what you earn just goes to prove how our lives are getting worse and worse.

60k is roughly 3.5k a month...where I live a three bed house costs £2,500 a month to rent. Let's say you are a family of four...you now have £1k left to pay council tax, gas, electric, food, travel, water, etc etc. Ok so let's say you rent a two bed house and your kids share a room instead. £2k a month...you now have £1.5k left a month. Now I have two kids and we spend £200 a week on food at the moment and that's being careful and shopping at Lidl.. council tax is £160. Gas and electric is £300. There are also numerous other essential bills...water, travel etc.

Hardly living the high life. You could easily be struggling on 60k a year.

If your take home pay was 3.5 k and you were renting at 2.5 k in an area where that was typical of rent prices eg London then you would be entitled to universal credits to help with the rent Check out entitled to

Tellmeimcrazy · 25/05/2023 14:04

Tellmeimcrazy · 25/05/2023 13:56

And contribute to much more and don't reap any benefit whatsoever

Monetarily I mean.

Tellmeimcrazy · 25/05/2023 13:56

DRS1970 · 25/05/2023 13:13

People who don't have children pay taxes that contribute to your child's schools, is that fair? You have failed the test for a means tested benefit, get over it.

And contribute to much more and don't reap any benefit whatsoever

GasPanic · 25/05/2023 13:41

TheThinkingGoblin · 25/05/2023 13:06

With an aging population, which means way less working people (c10% of whom pay 2/3rds of the tax) relative to net benefit recipients & retired people (who are very costly due to healthcare, social care, pensions etc. and do not pay in much either) we have reached that point.

In fact, what is happening now is that we are borrowing to fund those benefits, as we do not have enough people paying in tax (with higher earners basically being maxed out).

Its the end of the line basically.

Well to be honest we have borrowed for years.

I think what Truss did scared the hell out of the government financial people and they have rolled back the borrowing a bit. But no doubt it will continue in the future until the markets say no. What is more interesting is whether the borrowing is being eroded faster by inflation at 10% than the rate we are increasing it at, but that will probably be reflected in increased borrowing costs.

I don't think any government going forwards is going to be able to borrow much more money than they do at the moment. That's why Tories or Labour it is more about re-arranging the deck chairs on the Titanic than coming up with any fundamental change to the way the country operates.

My feeling is that we should hike inheritance tax hugely and make it unavoidable. That way the people who have benefited most from the massive borrowing pay for it, at a point in their lives where they don't need the money. But there are squeals of outrage every time this is suggested.

And yes, we have become a nation of people who believe in entitlement rather than a nation of people who believe we should give something in order to get something back. It's not going to end well.

Comedycook · 25/05/2023 13:13

The fact we think 60k is a good salary and you're a rich bastard if that's what you earn just goes to prove how our lives are getting worse and worse.

60k is roughly 3.5k a month...where I live a three bed house costs £2,500 a month to rent. Let's say you are a family of four...you now have £1k left to pay council tax, gas, electric, food, travel, water, etc etc. Ok so let's say you rent a two bed house and your kids share a room instead. £2k a month...you now have £1.5k left a month. Now I have two kids and we spend £200 a week on food at the moment and that's being careful and shopping at Lidl.. council tax is £160. Gas and electric is £300. There are also numerous other essential bills...water, travel etc.

Hardly living the high life. You could easily be struggling on 60k a year.

DRS1970 · 25/05/2023 13:13

People who don't have children pay taxes that contribute to your child's schools, is that fair? You have failed the test for a means tested benefit, get over it.

TheThinkingGoblin · 25/05/2023 13:06

GasPanic · 25/05/2023 13:00

My favourite is the statement "it's not a race to the bottom".

Of course it is.

The money (or more specifically the wealth) has to come from somewhere. You can't create wealth out of nothing (money is a different matter), unless you live in some sort of socialist fantasy land.

If one person is getting more, then another is getting less.

So yay, higher earners get more child benefit. Who is going to pay for that ?

"the rich". ie everyone who is richer than me.

The rich are seemingly this endless depositary of wealth, that can and should be squeezed more and more to transfer wealth to the poor.

There are limits as to how far you can go with this strategy. The question is how close we are to those limits.

With an aging population, which means way less working people (c10% of whom pay 2/3rds of the tax) relative to net benefit recipients & retired people (who are very costly due to healthcare, social care, pensions etc. and do not pay in much either) we have reached that point.

In fact, what is happening now is that we are borrowing to fund those benefits, as we do not have enough people paying in tax (with higher earners basically being maxed out).

Its the end of the line basically.

Betterbear · 25/05/2023 13:05

I absolutely agree!
I do get child benefit because my income is less than 50k, but that is all I am entitled to. It makes me very angry.
Universal credit is literally the goose that laid the golden egg of benefits. It is the gateway to literally everything.

Why should my children suffer because I made the right choices in life? Saved, bought a house, paid extra towards my mortgage etc. I am on a very low income and the extra support would be very welcomed, but unless I debt up my property and spend my savings it ain't happening.

This is wrong, the way they dish out benefits to people that have no clue about making responsible life choices. It is people like me who's taxes literally pay for it all. To get absolutely nothing back is soul destroying. Makes me wish I hadn't bothered!

GasPanic · 25/05/2023 13:00

TheThinkingGoblin · 25/05/2023 12:48

Its become largely a waste of time to try to take the time to correct them.

The handout mentality in the UK has reached unsustainable proportions.

These folks seem to be under the impression that higher earners exist just to pay a lot of tax so that they in turn get access to benefits.

Apparently, we are not allowed to receive any benefits as higher earners because that would be "unfair". The convoluted logic is just amazing.

Thats why the UK keeps being levelled down.

Over half the population in the UK are now net recipients (receive more in benefits vs what they pay in as tax) with the top 10% of higher earners (£62k and above) paying 2/3rds of income taxes.

Totally usustainable.

My favourite is the statement "it's not a race to the bottom".

Of course it is.

The money (or more specifically the wealth) has to come from somewhere. You can't create wealth out of nothing (money is a different matter), unless you live in some sort of socialist fantasy land.

If one person is getting more, then another is getting less.

So yay, higher earners get more child benefit. Who is going to pay for that ?

"the rich". ie everyone who is richer than me.

The rich are seemingly this endless depositary of wealth, that can and should be squeezed more and more to transfer wealth to the poor.

There are limits as to how far you can go with this strategy. The question is how close we are to those limits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread