Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel annoyed about child benefit threshold?

266 replies

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 06:50

I earn not far over the threshold to claim child benefit so am not going to put in any claim.

Maybe it seems completely unreasonable to many but given the large amount I pay in tax and NI every year, I feel annoyed that we get nothing back for this, especially with costs of absolutely everything going up.

If we could claim it, we would use it to fund baby related groceries or the heating bill in winter, both of which can be quite expensive.

I don't understand why the threshold can't be more towards 100k mark like the childcare costs threshold as once you're into six figure salaries that's a different ball game (although those people also pay hefty amounts of tax so why shouldn't they see something for it too?)

I expect to be slated for daring to question any of this as someone who earns a comfortable amount but when you've put into the system over the years, it would be nice to get more back when it's for your child.

I have a very wealthy elderly relative who still received the government's pensioner cost of living payment last year regardless of her massive income. They didn't means test that but they will set limits and thresholds for benefits for children rather than make it more universal.

OP posts:
Whenisitsummer · 25/05/2023 07:22

I agree. They haven’t changed the earning thresholds for 10 years which is wrong. Plus a family with two parents earning 30k each take home more than one person on 60k. Yet they keep their child benefit. It should be based on household income and the threshold increased to 70- 80k, which in 2023 is probably the equivalent of 50- 60k in 2013.

Spendonsend · 25/05/2023 07:19

Its a strange benefit. The threshold seems to penalise single parents trying to house and feed their children by thenselves.

CatsOnTheChair · 25/05/2023 07:16

YABU
You earn over 60k.
That is a massive salary (we were comfortable, pre covid, with DH on 55k, I now earn 20k and we are extremely comfortable).
There has to be a limit somewhere, and tapering between 50 and 60k is it.

Stuff more into pension or loose it.

FWIW, I agree with it being based on a single income is less than ideal.

Morph22010 · 25/05/2023 07:16

ArcticSkewer · 25/05/2023 07:10

And that's why it was originally a universal benefit. So the middle classes felt invested in the system, not pissed off about more handouts.

The conservatives always change things to remove middle class entitlement for exactly this reason

Labour did the same with tax credits, when my son was born at the end of the last labour government we could claim a small amount of tax credit even through our income is way way above the limit now. It means there’s isn’t a them and us situation. Now it’s very much a case of divide and conquer used, setting people against each other to defect from the true situation

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 07:16

Tellmeimcrazy · 25/05/2023 07:09

I wonder why, as a person who has no children, I can't take out anything from the put I put into. I'm sure many others in my position feel the same

Do you not get free healthcare?
Did you not receive free primary and secondary level schooling?
If you became disabled you would recite e benefits.
If your income dropped you would be entitled to things like free prescriptions and dental.
If you’re a pensioner you get a winter fuel allowance.

There are lots that child free people can ‘take out’ from the system.

AliceA2021 · 25/05/2023 07:15

HerMammy · 25/05/2023 07:07

Household income of £85k and you're annoyed you can't get £20pw CB, I've heard it all now.

This.

When some use food banks this household want more!

MathsNervous · 25/05/2023 07:15

We get Scottish Child Payment which helps us out. But I hear you. It's really not great, many are struggling these days.

holliebo · 25/05/2023 07:14

GodSaveTheClean · 25/05/2023 06:56

Stop moaning and bashing others and try thinking creatively about how you can maximise what you do have. Put more in your pension for a start.

OP has said she could do with the payment to help with groceries for dc and heating in the winter. That doesn't sound to me like someone who can afford to start paying more into a pensio

Iwantmyoldnameback · 25/05/2023 07:13

You mentioned a wealthy relative still getting state pension, (well done for that elderly dig) but it didn't occur to you if you paid more in to your pension you could have it both.

Kazzyhoward · 25/05/2023 07:11

YABU. We need to change our thinking about tax and this idea that we expect something back from it. It's not a savings scheme! Taxes pay for the NHS, education, security, transport infrastructure, defence, social services, benefits, etc etc, that benefit everyone. People shouldn't be greedy and expect more than that. We certainly shouldn't be expecting "cash back" - perhaps we've grown too accustomed to banks/supermarket loyalty schemes!

ArcticSkewer · 25/05/2023 07:10

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 25/05/2023 07:08

Agree with you. It's so bloody annoying.
move just stopped claiming it as finally over it.
my ex has 50/50 shared care and is retired though so I've spoken to tax line and he could claim instead so he does (and then we put it in savings).

I do fully think that this is one the most divisive things in working class though. I've always fully supported benefits (and grew up on them!), but the way lower earners behave over you complaining about losing some child benefit has made me think screw anyone in that bracket that needs me to complain to MPs etc. it's a fullyndivide and conquer scheme by government I think.

And that's why it was originally a universal benefit. So the middle classes felt invested in the system, not pissed off about more handouts.

The conservatives always change things to remove middle class entitlement for exactly this reason

Tellmeimcrazy · 25/05/2023 07:09

I wonder why, as a person who has no children, I can't take out anything from the put I put into. I'm sure many others in my position feel the same

ArdeteiMasazxu · 25/05/2023 07:09

If you earn not far over the threshold it's very easy to just increase your pension contributions to bring your taxable pay back under.

It's vital for ensuring that vulnerable children don't suffer that the process for claiming this benefit is very very simple. If there was any kind of detailed declaration of household setup needed which might make a few comfortably-off middle class families who are currently excluded get included because of their particular situation, would disproportionately impact some desperately poor families who will simply not apply if any such declarations are needed. That's why it was a universal benefit for so long - not because the wealthy needed it but because means-testing doesn't just exclude the wealthy and vulnerable children are the most important factor.

If there has to be a threshold then linking it to higher rate tax is the sensible way to achieve this as it is a simple way to ensure that only the families who are nowhere near poverty will get excluded. No system is perfect and there will always be cases near the borderline where their specific circumstances might on a personal level seem to be a reasonable case for the rule being imperfect but we are not seeking, and could never achieve, a perfect set of rules with no flaws. The important thing is to ensure that the kids who lose out due to the inevitable imperfections in the setup are not the most vulnerable in society, but are those who will somehow be actually ok on the whole despite their families having a little bit less.

Morph22010 · 25/05/2023 07:08

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 07:00

They already pay it. It’s not a new tax on them.
It used to be universal which I don’t disagree with but tories gonna Tory.
But what is interesting is that means testing is made out to be so expensive and not worth it for other benefits like the winter fuel allowance!

The whole thing needs massively addressing.
A household income of 50k from a single salary is actually not well off and it’s even worse when a household income of 99k but from 2 equal salaries keeps their child benefit.

It’s not means tested as such though it is paid to anyone who claims and it’s the responsibility of the claimant to pay back if they are over limit. There are some spot checks where they match things up through their computer system. They could potentially do the same for winter fuel allowance but pensioners vote

ZeroFucksGivenToday · 25/05/2023 07:08

Agree with you. It's so bloody annoying.
move just stopped claiming it as finally over it.
my ex has 50/50 shared care and is retired though so I've spoken to tax line and he could claim instead so he does (and then we put it in savings).

I do fully think that this is one the most divisive things in working class though. I've always fully supported benefits (and grew up on them!), but the way lower earners behave over you complaining about losing some child benefit has made me think screw anyone in that bracket that needs me to complain to MPs etc. it's a fullyndivide and conquer scheme by government I think.

Lapland123 · 25/05/2023 07:07

None of the tax thresholds have changed in years and this is just one of these examples.
We are all being taxed senseless and getting what in return? While everything costs more and more from the post tax income.

Did you see the thread about a family wanting to come off benefits but wondering what job they could get 5k take home pay as that’s what they’d need to find their lifestyle.

meanwhile we are all paying for that

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 07:07

drpet49 · 25/05/2023 07:00

Ill get my tiny violin out OP

What an interesting contribution to the debate.

ArcticSkewer · 25/05/2023 07:07

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 07:02

@ArcticSkewer I know your point is the same for £50 or £60k but just in case it stops people on £50k claiming

To be fair I think the self assessment element does make quite a few people stop claiming at 50k!

I know.

I've just never understood how people earn £60k (a lot where I live but perhaps not much in other areas) and don't have basic maths and accounting skills. It's usually worth doing self assessment if you donate to charity and have professional subs (mind you, those you can add to tax code these days). I've pretty much never not done one. Always get at least a few hundred quid back.

HerMammy · 25/05/2023 07:07

Household income of £85k and you're annoyed you can't get £20pw CB, I've heard it all now.

Tumbleweed101 · 25/05/2023 07:07

It's a bit like the help for prescriptions. Wages have crept up due to min wage rises but the threshold hasn't moved so some people are being pushed into paying prescription charges when their real cost of living circumstances haven't changed.

ArcticSkewer · 25/05/2023 07:03

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 06:59

To clarify I earn just over 60k - I wasn't aware about the pension thing so will look into that. I planned to do full time hours also when I return but I guess if I ever reduced them I could also potentially be eligible.

I'm not sure I want to make too many radical changes to claim it though- it's more the principle that threshold hasn't changed for a while despite inflation etc

That's your choice.

I do all of the above and still claim it and therefore don't have to whine about how unfair life is on my salary. My pension looks great too.

Sissynova · 25/05/2023 07:02

@ArcticSkewer I know your point is the same for £50 or £60k but just in case it stops people on £50k claiming

To be fair I think the self assessment element does make quite a few people stop claiming at 50k!

Littlebluebellwoods · 25/05/2023 07:01

I agree the limits are odd - and if there has to be a threshold it should be based on household income not individual income.

this cannot be a serious post? You cannot really think every household is some happy family. There is everything in there, from new partners to separated and living together to the abusive financial controlling ones. Of course it shouldn’t be on household. This isn’t Disney land.

Mirenda · 25/05/2023 07:01

WheelsUp · 25/05/2023 06:58

Put enough into your pension so that you stay below the threshold.
The rules are mad because of the discrepancies it creates. A single earner on £51k won't get it but a household with 2 earners in £49k will.

This is crazy as I earn just over 60k but my partner is on 25k. If we both earned 49k we'd have more household income AND could claim. It's insane, who makes these rules??

OP posts:
Sissynova · 25/05/2023 07:00

Lostinalibrary · 25/05/2023 06:54

I don’t disagree but here is the problem. You’re happy to shift it even higher. The 100k earners you describe who lose childcare, and their personal allowance have an effective tax rate of over 100%. They clear less for earning more. If they don’t use childcare it more 70% tax. Why should an ever decreasing pool of people fund everyone else by paying those rates of tax?

They already pay it. It’s not a new tax on them.
It used to be universal which I don’t disagree with but tories gonna Tory.
But what is interesting is that means testing is made out to be so expensive and not worth it for other benefits like the winter fuel allowance!

The whole thing needs massively addressing.
A household income of 50k from a single salary is actually not well off and it’s even worse when a household income of 99k but from 2 equal salaries keeps their child benefit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread