Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should a 12 year old have impulse control? Worried about DC

40 replies

madmenpeggy · 24/05/2023 21:44

Namechanged for this.

DS seems to be unable to stop himself craving screen (gaming, in particular) and sugar. We have boundaries in place for both, but he said tonight that he will try and get both whenever the opportunity arises. He said himself, he worries he has no impulse control. He's even asked for a therapist 🤔

He has very low impulse control, this is true. Of course, in context - both sugar and gaming are designed to loop you in, so he's not alone. But it's a war of attrition if you say no and he's bent on getting more.

But is this normal? Are we expecting too much from him? Have no idea of context.

DH and I worry about the next stage - drugs, drink etc.

Not sure how to help him, what to do, if there is anything to do etc

Sorry if I sound neurotic!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
madmenpeggy · 25/05/2023 21:18

Thanks all. Food for thought.

OP posts:
PeppermintPorpoise · 25/05/2023 19:50

I'm a psychotherapist and work with kids. Just chiming in to say that children sometimes will ask for help in roundabout ways. He may be asking you for help for this alleged impulse control issue but it might be something else he really wants to talk to someone about that he doesnt feel he can share with you. Best to get them checked out and let them talk to someone when they ask directly for it. Just in case.

BertieBotts · 25/05/2023 19:42

That's the whole point though isn't it? It's normal for 12 year olds to want to play computer games and eat junk.

What's unusual is a 12yo who feels distressed by their own lack of control about something. That doesn't sound like a parent has made him paranoid - how many of us are nagging our tweens daily to get off the phone and eat vegetables? And they aren't all worried about their own lack of control.

That's why I'd say listen to him and seek some kind of professional input. If you've thought ADHD several times over the years why not ask someone actually qualified to diagnose? They aren't just going to randomly say that he has something if he doesn't.

It's normal for a 12yo to have less impulse control than an adult, it's not normal for them to be distressed by their lack of control over it.

LilyLemonade · 25/05/2023 19:30

I think therapy is a great idea, especially if he’s specifically asked for it. If he himself is worried about his lack of impulse control, i would want to get him help - at the very least to talk it through.
I think it's great for a child to understand that they can reach out for help when they are struggling with their behaviour or emotions.
From a parent’s perspective you can think of therapy as a back up or extension to your own parenting in situations where you don’t feel confident to deal with a situation.
I am not in the UK and here it’s quite normal for kids to see a therapist here and there for different issues. It doesn’t have to be reserved for extreme situations. A good therapist will give him tools and strategies that he can draw on.

BHRK · 25/05/2023 19:14

This thread has got ridiculous. I wouldn’t expect a 12yo to have impulse control. Most adults don’t have impulse control, which is why most people are overweight! And it’s why we have alcoholism and gambling.
You can be good parents and steer him, you can put boundaries in place which you have. He WILL learn

madmenpeggy · 25/05/2023 18:59

OhcantthInkofaname · 25/05/2023 17:41

Impulse control to the started at about 7. You are 5 years too late.

huh?

OP posts:
Willyoujustbequiet · 25/05/2023 18:33

Another vote for ADHD assessment. Impulsivity is a textbook sign.

Also some drinks can mimic the affect of the meds (stimulants)

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 18:28

madmenpeggy · 25/05/2023 17:42

Apology accepted. I came on here to clarify if it was normal and I have.

And we do tell him ALL THE TIME that screen and sugar is made to draw you in, that he's no different. Equally, it's our job to make sure he doesn't go mad with it

👍 👍

madmenpeggy · 25/05/2023 17:42

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 17:08

Sorry, I didn't mean to be offensive. I'm just so confused by the thread. OP, you sound a great mum trying to make sure you r doing everything right by your son. He's lucky to have you care so much. I didn't mean to come across so judgemental. But please, know this is v normal behaviour for a 12 yr old, and let him know that too. Let him know he's normal and most 12 yr olds crave a bit more computer time and a few more sweets than they r allowed.

Apology accepted. I came on here to clarify if it was normal and I have.

And we do tell him ALL THE TIME that screen and sugar is made to draw you in, that he's no different. Equally, it's our job to make sure he doesn't go mad with it

OP posts:
OhcantthInkofaname · 25/05/2023 17:41

Impulse control to the started at about 7. You are 5 years too late.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 17:08

madmenpeggy · 25/05/2023 17:05

I really take offence at the 'this is weird' crap. Well done. Massive pat on the back to you that you are so super confident about everything to do with your kids. That you are able to easily identify what's normal, what isn't. So judgmental. Jesus

Sorry, I didn't mean to be offensive. I'm just so confused by the thread. OP, you sound a great mum trying to make sure you r doing everything right by your son. He's lucky to have you care so much. I didn't mean to come across so judgemental. But please, know this is v normal behaviour for a 12 yr old, and let him know that too. Let him know he's normal and most 12 yr olds crave a bit more computer time and a few more sweets than they r allowed.

madmenpeggy · 25/05/2023 17:05

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 16:52

I'm quite confused by this thread.

A 12 year old likes gaming and has a sweet tooth.

That's V V normal.

There is nothing wrong with him! He doesn't get to play much each day on his computer and wants more .... That's is NORMAL.

He has acces to a pain au chocolate at break, so he eats it! That is NORMAL

I expect the reason he wants a therapist is because he's being made to feel that there is something wrong with him for wanting these things. There isn't. He's fine! My 11 yr old is on his PC right now, and when I ask him to stop he'll complain. That is most kids.

This is so weird!

I really take offence at the 'this is weird' crap. Well done. Massive pat on the back to you that you are so super confident about everything to do with your kids. That you are able to easily identify what's normal, what isn't. So judgmental. Jesus

OP posts:
Notquitegrownup2 · 25/05/2023 16:52

DS2 was the same. I was so worried, but used it as a talking point, in calm moments with no screens on, reminding him that it was my job to set limits for him. I wouldn't let him run about on a busy road: I wasn't going to let him have unlimited sugar or screen time. He saw the logic even if he didn't like it. I also stressed that some people have addictive personalities and that he would be more at risk of addiction to drugs and drink with such low impulse control.

He's now 21. H chose not to drink as a teen. He had his first drink at 17, and has set himself v sensible limits. He distanced himself from b friends who got into drugs. He still eats too much sugar but it's learning to regulate it a bit. He still loves his gaming too and struggled throughout school, needing lots reminding of the rules but is now at Uni, doing a course he loves, and managed to switch off the games to complete Uni work on time.

Hope that helps.

FinallyTimeToSleep · 25/05/2023 16:52

I'm quite confused by this thread.

A 12 year old likes gaming and has a sweet tooth.

That's V V normal.

There is nothing wrong with him! He doesn't get to play much each day on his computer and wants more .... That's is NORMAL.

He has acces to a pain au chocolate at break, so he eats it! That is NORMAL

I expect the reason he wants a therapist is because he's being made to feel that there is something wrong with him for wanting these things. There isn't. He's fine! My 11 yr old is on his PC right now, and when I ask him to stop he'll complain. That is most kids.

This is so weird!

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 25/05/2023 16:48

He sounds like a totally normal teenage boy to me.

madmenpeggy · 25/05/2023 16:29
  • Sorry - the line 'I think we must not' shouldn't be there
OP posts:
madmenpeggy · 25/05/2023 16:29

Thanks to all for interesting thoughts.

He doesn't sneak around or lie (as far as I know) - in fact, he hates himself for being so open! He tells us everything overshares.

Without seeming as if I'm minimising his feelings - I'm really not - I don't know how much is him feeling upset with himself over his feelings about sugar/screen, OR how much is influenced by the fact he knows we don't like it. He pushes against, but simultaneously wants, our approval. He knows we think this stuff needs to be moderately used, and so that impacts his feelings.

I think. We'll see. I don't know about ADHD. Certainly we've discussed it over the years, but we've always come full circle and thought, no.

I think we must not

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 25/05/2023 16:00

@madmenpeggy

“Sugar wise - he seems to eat a lot. Yesterday, for example, he had a pain au chocolate at break, a Rubicorn drink at the shop, gum, and a chocolate brunch bar.”

i don’t think that that is that much sugar over the course of a day tbh

brunettemic · 25/05/2023 16:00

This is a difficult one. DS is 11 and would sit and play on his Switch all day if we let him and will regularly just pick it up out of habit. It’s good that he’s aware of it but I’m not sure he’s “addicted” too it, 12 is still a young age to be able to control everything, no matter how mature they may appear.

PizzazzRoxyStorma · 25/05/2023 15:42

I agree with the ADHD assessment. You'll have to go through school to get it (at least, that's how it works around here). Get it just to rule it out! But it's worth noting that my child with ADHD really, really struggles with screen time and sugar - to the point of sneaking downstairs in the dead of night to try and get on video games, and hiding the sugar pot from the kitchen. He's a well-behaved child in other regards, but I have to lock video games and sugar away, it's that bad.

potniatheron · 25/05/2023 15:40

I had binge eating disorder aged 10, which did a lot of damage then morphed into anorexia, which did more damage.

It's not about how much you think your son objectively eats or games, it's about HIS perception of the effect it's having on his life. And he's telling you it's a problem. So don't minimise his feelings like other posters are doing. That will just send him the message that his feelings aren't important. He wants help. So help him.

BertieBotts · 25/05/2023 15:31

If he's really struggling with impulse control and going so far as to actively ask for help with it, I think you should speak to your GP about an ADHD assessment for him.

I do agree that games are addictive and some people experience sugar as addictive. So limiting access to these things may well help. I also really like this article about how to help a child that seems to only be interested in screens: https://slate.com/human-interest/2010/05/how-to-motivate-an-inert-child.html

One of the authors, Alan Kazdin, is a respected behaviourist and parenting expert.

But OTOH, plenty of 12 year olds enjoy sugar and video games but aren't distressed by their own inability to control their impulses. That points to more of an issue IMO that should be investigated.

How to motivate an inert child.

We've written often for Slate about specific behaviors that parents want to develop or discourage in their children, but there is more to family life...

https://slate.com/human-interest/2010/05/how-to-motivate-an-inert-child.html

Poopoolittlekitten · 25/05/2023 15:25

'Yesterday, for example, he had a pain au chocolate at break, a Rubicorn drink at the shop, gum, and a chocolate brunch bar.'

That's lot - our DC would be the same given the chance so we limit options with money and what we have a home. It's water or milk to drink only at home.
It's hard to control what they eat outside after a certain age, so we have very little in the way of sweets, sugar treats, biscuits at home now. We don't buy pop, 'breakfast' bars or any of that kind of stuff. Or anything claiming to be 'healthy'
while full of sugar and additives.

I feel your pain. It's so hard when they're surrounded by cheap sweets, giant bars of choc, processed food.

Mariposista · 25/05/2023 15:25

Both screens and sugar are highly addictive. Just like drugs and alcohol. And A 12 YO brain is immature and not fully developed.

Poopoolittlekitten · 25/05/2023 15:19

Both designed to be addictive... friend had issue with her DS that age and he messed up big time so they took away gaming for a month. He was like a changed kid. Ended up being several months and he found other stuff to do with his time, and as for the 'social' aspect of gaming, he replaced it with actually meeting friends out instead.

Our DS seems to have a balance, but we are very strict ( he's 13) according to him, and he only games at weekends for a couple hours each time max. So his friends tend to be more outdoorsy like him rather than the kids who's spend hours gaming - and there are many.

Swipe left for the next trending thread