Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women's Park Run Record smashed to smithereens

204 replies

changedforanswer · 24/05/2023 20:34

The way to beat records for men to self ID and run as a female. Straight into the record books and stand aside females whilst man in dress sets the record. Is nothing safe from men anymore?

Was a married man until just 4 years ago.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 14:43

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 25/05/2023 14:35

You are trying to argue that it's OK to stymie women in SOME leagues. That is not how sports works. It's supposed to be fair at all levels. How is an amateur female ever going to make it to professional level if she's being beaten by males before she gets there?

Why is the backlash unfair against a male born competitor who is free to compete in the correct sex class, but running roughshod over all the women is completely fine?

The identity does not change the physical fact of the male advantage. Sports is not sex segregated to reassure female athletes that we think they're women. We know everyone considers them women because they're expected to put up with the unfair, discriminatory double standards that people like you want to impose. You always know who the women are when it comes to deprioritising them.

People like me?! You know nothing about me, and I can assure you I am not interested in discriminatory double standards.

I don't think trans women should compete as women in professional sports. But this is a bloody park run. Something that you can do with your kid or your dog on a sunday morning. Something you can put your name down and Runny McRunnerson if you fancy. I am totally against the deterioration of women's rights in this topic. But what else is this person meant to do? I can't begrudge someone for wanting to do a Sunday park run or for putting down the gender they identify with. This entire situation could have happened entirely unintentionally.

But no, sure, I just love discriminating against women, espeically if a few double standards at thrown in 🙄

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 25/05/2023 14:35

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:34

yeah it's not really that.

It's more just that (1) she wanted to do park run - which she is allwoed to do and (2) she wanted to use the gender she identifies as - which she is allowed to do.

If she didn't do it to smash the record then all the backlash feels a little unfair. Park run isn't exactly a professional sport!

You are trying to argue that it's OK to stymie women in SOME leagues. That is not how sports works. It's supposed to be fair at all levels. How is an amateur female ever going to make it to professional level if she's being beaten by males before she gets there?

Why is the backlash unfair against a male born competitor who is free to compete in the correct sex class, but running roughshod over all the women is completely fine?

The identity does not change the physical fact of the male advantage. Sports is not sex segregated to reassure female athletes that we think they're women. We know everyone considers them women because they're expected to put up with the unfair, discriminatory double standards that people like you want to impose. You always know who the women are when it comes to deprioritising them.

BitOutOfPractice · 25/05/2023 14:15

Of course not @changedforanswer we just need to stop worrying our pretty little heads about it eh?

changedforanswer · 25/05/2023 13:58

BitOutOfPractice · 25/05/2023 10:06

this isn’t the park run case. It’s a different one mentioned in the article.

They are not an ex criminal. They are currently serving 19 years in jail for attempting (by repeated stabbing) to murder an athletics official who questioned if they should be running in a women’s race. Yet we are supposed to accept that men being in our spaces and sports is completely reasonable. The double think in this case is staggering.

Indeed the reason I mentioned this is an official questioned a trans women running in a female race and the result was horrendous. No females are at risk of course!

OP posts:
changedforanswer · 25/05/2023 13:56

DM even!

OP posts:
changedforanswer · 25/05/2023 13:56

SerafinasGoose · 25/05/2023 10:23

At this rate there will be no women's records left anymore. They'll all be held by men.

Women ARE being erased. This isn't hyperbole. It's an unassailable fact.

Apparently though because the story is covered by the DN then it doesn't matter, move on nothing to be seen. Some people are only prepared to hear the story if covered by the Guardian or BBC so will wait until no more women's records left before they catch up. 🙄

OP posts:
Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 13:34

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 25/05/2023 13:30

Who cares? Sports should be open and fair at every level.

yeah it's not really that.

It's more just that (1) she wanted to do park run - which she is allwoed to do and (2) she wanted to use the gender she identifies as - which she is allowed to do.

If she didn't do it to smash the record then all the backlash feels a little unfair. Park run isn't exactly a professional sport!

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 25/05/2023 13:30

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 12:56

Well, generally and professional sports, I think this is totally not on.

BUT, was this person setting out to be the best? Or could it just be that she, after her transition, still loved running and wanted to continue parkrun. In that situation it wouldn't be that weird - and it wouldn't be wrong imo - to allocate her identifying gender and run as she would. So for me, in this case, it depends a little on the intent.

Who cares? Sports should be open and fair at every level.

flyingtherag · 25/05/2023 13:20

To the poster who asked about aowalc it just means parkrun is All one word, all lower case.

I had a snoop on Siam’s Facebook. It’s open and made me feel quite sad. Sian was Simon, married to Kimberley and has 2 little children. Running for a while now transitioned.

I don’t think Sian transitioned to cheat as such but ended up transitioning then being able to run at the same speed meant they could take the women’s records.

feels horribly unfair though. I’ve done hundreds of parkruns and I think this really hurts.

there was a new trustee (David Dinsmore) who was ousted recently as he was previous editor of the Sun and had very questionable integrity. He apparently resigned but basically many parkrunners called it out and said it was never acceptable to have him on board.

you would think HQ would be a bit more awake to the community and their feelings now.

what a shitshow.

CorderBollie · 25/05/2023 13:14

Why do they publish results under female and male then?

Kanaloa · 25/05/2023 13:01

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 25/05/2023 12:46

A huge faff (no idea how you'd regulate for the effects of any hormones being taken), and everyone knows there are only two categories really, but ok. As long as there's a protected category for female bodied people, no drugs/hormones, that's fine.

I'm so, so offended at the idea that a woman is just a man at artificially reduced capacity. I can't believe it's not considered more offensive. A black person is not a white person with a ton of fake tan.

It is a huge faff but I suppose it would satisfy every side. Trans people could no longer complain and protest that their rights are being violated - they have a category, which is ‘male born people who identify as/want to be treated as women.’ I see it as literally beating them at their own pedantic game.

Yes it’s very offensive. I slightly worry for my youngest child, she is getting really into martial arts now and wants to start competing like her brother does. However when she reaches his age (teen) the categories are split so boys and girls compete separately. I wonder what things will be like when she’s that age.

Nordicrain · 25/05/2023 12:56

Well, generally and professional sports, I think this is totally not on.

BUT, was this person setting out to be the best? Or could it just be that she, after her transition, still loved running and wanted to continue parkrun. In that situation it wouldn't be that weird - and it wouldn't be wrong imo - to allocate her identifying gender and run as she would. So for me, in this case, it depends a little on the intent.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 25/05/2023 12:46

Kanaloa · 25/05/2023 11:03

Well they could still be separated by their ‘gender identity.’ So there could be sporting events for men, for women, for men who identify as women, and for women who identify as men. That way everyone is competing somewhere they feel comfortable and are tested alongside similar athletes.

A huge faff (no idea how you'd regulate for the effects of any hormones being taken), and everyone knows there are only two categories really, but ok. As long as there's a protected category for female bodied people, no drugs/hormones, that's fine.

I'm so, so offended at the idea that a woman is just a man at artificially reduced capacity. I can't believe it's not considered more offensive. A black person is not a white person with a ton of fake tan.

Kanaloa · 25/05/2023 11:03

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 25/05/2023 10:58

If you really, really don't want transwomen to have to confront the reality of sex, then we can do what Sharron Davies suggests: a Female category for all female born people who are not taking any performance enhancing drugs, and an Open category for everyone else.

Obviously transmen who want to compete will need to acknowledge they are female born this way, but nobody really gives a crap about them. Can't imagine why.

Well they could still be separated by their ‘gender identity.’ So there could be sporting events for men, for women, for men who identify as women, and for women who identify as men. That way everyone is competing somewhere they feel comfortable and are tested alongside similar athletes.

DarrellRiversCriminalBehaviourOrder · 25/05/2023 10:58

Season0fTheWitch · 24/05/2023 21:00

I'm a TRA and still think badly of this situation. Yes, women should be allowed to compete with women but clearly there is an unfair advantage in most of these cases where Trans women win records. But what is the solution? Mixed gender awards only?

If you really, really don't want transwomen to have to confront the reality of sex, then we can do what Sharron Davies suggests: a Female category for all female born people who are not taking any performance enhancing drugs, and an Open category for everyone else.

Obviously transmen who want to compete will need to acknowledge they are female born this way, but nobody really gives a crap about them. Can't imagine why.

MargotBamborough · 25/05/2023 10:51

Jenn3112 · 24/05/2023 21:27

When you are supporting something in the Daily Mail, you really need to reassess your priorities.

No, we need to assess why more respectable publications aren't covering this issue adequately.

JudgeJ · 25/05/2023 10:49

Jenn3112 · 24/05/2023 21:27

When you are supporting something in the Daily Mail, you really need to reassess your priorities.

Thanks for the advice, I'll look elsewhere for the F1 result shall I, maybe the Grauniad will have a more acceptable result!
It's amazing how critical MNers are re DM yet seem to be very au fait with the content!

PSNonsense · 25/05/2023 10:48

@Beowulfa Have you watched the long documentary about him? He is utterly devoid of any empathy and I felt like he bordered on sociopathic. Nothing screamed male entitlement like he did.

Just like the militant TRA's really and those who steal women's spaces.

MargotBamborough · 25/05/2023 10:48

Season0fTheWitch · 24/05/2023 21:00

I'm a TRA and still think badly of this situation. Yes, women should be allowed to compete with women but clearly there is an unfair advantage in most of these cases where Trans women win records. But what is the solution? Mixed gender awards only?

The solution is adding transgender categories, and trans people doing the decent thing and running in those instead of as the opposite sex.

JudgeJ · 25/05/2023 10:46

changedforanswer · 24/05/2023 20:34

The way to beat records for men to self ID and run as a female. Straight into the record books and stand aside females whilst man in dress sets the record. Is nothing safe from men anymore?

Was a married man until just 4 years ago.

I think we all know that this record wasn't set by a real woman and shouldn't be in any record book.

Beowulfa · 25/05/2023 10:43

I read a good biography of Lance Armstrong recently (not into cycling, but enjoy sports journalism). His psychology is fascinating; he is still adamant he didn't cheat, because as everyone was doing it he didn't gain an unfair advantage so it's not really cheating.

Early in his career, he was a star attraction at a charity cycling event and was riding along in a mock race with a group of kiddies on tricycles and starter bikes with stabilisers. All good fun. However, approaching the finishing line he stopped dawdling with the kids and pushed on in order to cross the line first (ie a professional adult didn't let the children win).

I think of this self-absorbed lack of empathy when I read about males in women's races, and their attitude to cheating.

ChateauMargaux · 25/05/2023 10:40

Parkrun has been going for nearly 20 years, with over 3 million participants globally, nearly 350,000 people run, each week in over 20 countries and more than 2,000 locations. The results, age gradient and position as well as finishing time has always been an important part of Parkrun.

The answer is not to do away with the male / female categories but to apply the guidance of the UK National Sporting Bodies issues in Sept 2021 which concluded that existing guidance on self identifying into the female category to be out dated and no longer valid and that self identifying into the female category is not compatible with competitive fairness.

Inclusion does not trump fairness. We need to see this rolled out across all sports at all levels. What is sport without fairness?

Contact Parkrun and let them know your thoughts.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 25/05/2023 10:26

YANBU

Women's Park Run Record smashed to smithereens
SerafinasGoose · 25/05/2023 10:23

At this rate there will be no women's records left anymore. They'll all be held by men.

Women ARE being erased. This isn't hyperbole. It's an unassailable fact.

Kanaloa · 25/05/2023 10:09

I saw a comedian talk about this a while ago, Monroe Martin. The bit is still up on Instagram. He basically said it was ‘a bit like winning the Tour de France with an e-bike. Technically it’s a bike but what’s the motor doing there.’

What I loved was that someone in the comments had commented that it ‘doesn’t come off like the joke of an ally’ and that Martin should take a lead from James Acaster for how to tell trans positive jokes. Martin responded on the comment and said ‘you found a comedian who tells jokes you like, go watch their jokes.’

Swipe left for the next trending thread