Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To withdraw my child from school sports day

667 replies

MissHoollie · 24/05/2023 20:02

So my son age 7 has been upset for a few weeks about sports day and " always coming last"
None of us in the family are sporty and my other children " were always last " but they didn't mind at all and it almost became a family joke with them enjoying the fact it was a family tradition to be rubbish at sport
So my 7 year old is begging not to take part
We've done all the " it's fine ..someone has to be last in the races "
" You are good at other things "
" It's part of life "
But he's still loosing sleep over it all.
They've been practicing all week which is winding him up even more.
So it occurred to me , and this is where I need perspective.
Would schools parade kids out in order of best reader to worst for all the parents to applause the best reader? ,no of course not ,so why do schools do this?
Yes it's good to celebrate success but why is it so demoralising for some kids ?
Am I being unreasonable taking him out of school that day?
As I say looking for other perspectives

OP posts:
cansu · 10/06/2023 12:27

Carduelis
If we follow your itinerary then we should keep our kids off when there is a spelling test or if they hate PE when it is tennis should keep them off as well. Doing this leads to children who struggle to cannot cope with difficulty and often present with anxiety later on. Parents should reassure and build the understanding that it is OK to take part and do your best. No one is good at everything. I was and am very unsporting. I didn't enjoy sports day but it wasn't a big deal and the end of the world because my parents did not encourage days off unless we were ill.

carduelis · 10/06/2023 12:09

TheaBrandt · 10/06/2023 07:31

Exactly card. It’s the public aspect there really is no equivalence. The stuff of nightmares for the non sporty / self conscious child.

And it doesn’t mean the sporty ones don’t get their sports day. Have it! But why require the children who hate it to take part too? They can watch and cheer and do low key stuff.

You wouldn’t shove a desperately shy child with a stutter who really didn’t want to do it on stage with a main speaking part would you?

I’m actually starting to think some parents must do that: force their child to participate publicly in every competition available to them regardless of their inclination or ability in order to “build resilience” and “learn to lose”. No-one has explained the difference to me yet so I can only assume that’s what all these parents must be doing.

carduelis · 10/06/2023 11:29

cansu · 10/06/2023 07:45

Sports day is very different now to when I was at school. There are all kinds of events that he might be able to enjoy and do well in such as welly throwing etc. Maybe it is time for you to build up two things: resilience and accepting that he can't always do well in everything. It is also not great parenting to let him stay off school when he is well just to avoid something he dislikes.

Thinking that a non-sporty child needs to participate in sports day to learn that they can’t be good at everything implies a mind-boggling lack of empathy.

If OP was “letting him stay off school when he is well just to avoid something he dislikes” then he’d be off school every time there was a PE lesson. Or maybe a geography lesson or any of the other things a child might “dislike”. No-one in their right mind would advocate that.

I would argue that putting a child through obvious considerable distress for the benefit of absolutely no-one is “not great parenting”, personally.

CecilyP · 10/06/2023 10:49

I think in the OPs situation, I would keep trying to get him to go, big reward and praise for participation etc. If on the day they were really upset, then maybe I would change my mind, but I would try my hardest first.

No, I think the exact opposite. If OP keeps him off this year without any fuss, rather than racking up his anxiety to an even higher level, he might be willing to give it a go next year.

carduelis · 10/06/2023 10:49

Another thing I don’t understand is this:

I had a really hard time learning to drive. I had to have a LOT of lessons, struggled to make any progress, and failed three tests before passing. But I kept going because I really wanted to pass.

I’m currently trying to teach myself to play the piano. It’s slow going and I sound terrible. But I’m persisting because I enjoy it.

I’m not, however, going to try to improve in all the many, many sports I’m rubbish at, don’t enjoy, and don’t need to be good at… because why would anyone do that?! Does anyone here who thinks kids need to “face their fears” and “push through their anxieties” and “show up and do their best” on sports day do that for all the things they’re not good at, don’t enjoy, and don’t need to be good at?

You’ll never do anything like sports day again in your life. There is no valuable life lesson in doing it. Honestly the more you think about it the less it makes sense!

CabernetSauvignon · 10/06/2023 10:46

cansu · 10/06/2023 07:45

Sports day is very different now to when I was at school. There are all kinds of events that he might be able to enjoy and do well in such as welly throwing etc. Maybe it is time for you to build up two things: resilience and accepting that he can't always do well in everything. It is also not great parenting to let him stay off school when he is well just to avoid something he dislikes.

The non-sporty types don't avoid what they dislike. They get to do it generally at least twice a week throughout the school year, and certainly know full well that they can't do well in everything. I really don't understand why so many sports day supporters ignore that fact. Why do these children also have to have it rubbed in their faces in front of the whole school and parents? And if that's a good thing to do, should we take it that you support putting the non-academic types through the same? After all, it'll build up resilience, right?

CecilyP · 10/06/2023 10:46

He will win the sprint though. He takes his knock academically and needs this to shine. I hope the other bright kids turn up so he has kids to race!!

Of course bright kids will turn up to race. It’s not an either/or! Plenty of academically able kids are also great at sport. There are also kids who struggle with both.

And most kids are somewhere in the middle and will enjoy a day away from lessons anyway. OPs child’s level of anxiety is different so she would be best advised to keep him off.

CabernetSauvignon · 10/06/2023 10:34

TheHoover · 09/06/2023 19:54

Watered down hunger games! Haha just a tad over-dramatic.

So for the bookish but non-athletic kids we have one day of supposed humiliation per year and for the athletic but non-bookish kids it could be argued that there is a visible demonstration of their lack of academic ability every single school day (just without parents involved). So maybe rather than cancel sports day for the parents of the kids that can’t cope with being last why not just hold it behind closed doors? Because someone has to come last and if being last is an acceptable excuse for an opt out then there are no participants and it needs to be cancelled.

It’s a little difficult to take the views of any parents of ‘academic but not sporty’ kids seriously in this matter. I don’t see why encouraging participation and rewarding effort and progress is fine for academic subjects but not for sport.

Non-bookish children don't have that visible demonstration every day. Good teachers differentiate so that children can learn at their own pace and can achieve even when they have serious learning difficulties. No good teacher reads out the marks in class so that everyone can see that little Johnny's come last yet again. However, there is no way of hiding the fact that little Johnny has come last in every race he entered for in a public sports day.

CabernetSauvignon · 10/06/2023 10:29

KarmaStar · 09/06/2023 00:02

No.help him to train.help him to learn that doing your very best is good enough.he needs to know hiding away will not teach him confidence in the ability he does have.help him understand that when he has done his best that is a huge accomplishment and to be very proud of himself.

Training won't help someone who just doesn't have an athletic body. Staying off for one pointless day isn't hiding away from anything, he will be in school the rest of the year. Doing your best and coming last makes no child proud of himself.

carduelis · 10/06/2023 10:20

Justloggedontocommentoncornwall · 10/06/2023 07:46

I do understand what you are saying, but i think i would try and find a way to try and push him through it. Losing things is hard, but part of life (sayingthis as the one who comes last!!). It's not my thing. I am very academic though. But I am resilient as as adult because I learned to take my knocks through things like sport.

My son is the worst academically in the class and I promise you everyone knows about it. Followed around by an adult in class to be able to do lessons, constant interventions and adapted work etc. Children talk. The parents all know because I get sympathetic side tilts if the head each time they ask how he is 'getting on'. He will win the sprint though. He takes his knock academically and needs this to shine. I hope the other bright kids turn up so he has kids to race!!

I work in education and children's resilience is at an all time low and we need to strengthen it desperately.

I think in the OPs situation, I would keep trying to get him to go, big reward and praise for participation etc. If on the day they were really upset, then maybe I would change my mind, but I would try my hardest first.

Limping in last in front of all my peers on sports day just gave me a deep and lifelong hatred of sport and a massive inferiority complex. Glad it worked for you though!

Justloggedontocommentoncornwall · 10/06/2023 07:46

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 20:13

They don't have to do a maths test in public with not only their peers watching them struggle but also many unfamiliar adults also watching.

It's not the same thing.

I do understand what you are saying, but i think i would try and find a way to try and push him through it. Losing things is hard, but part of life (sayingthis as the one who comes last!!). It's not my thing. I am very academic though. But I am resilient as as adult because I learned to take my knocks through things like sport.

My son is the worst academically in the class and I promise you everyone knows about it. Followed around by an adult in class to be able to do lessons, constant interventions and adapted work etc. Children talk. The parents all know because I get sympathetic side tilts if the head each time they ask how he is 'getting on'. He will win the sprint though. He takes his knock academically and needs this to shine. I hope the other bright kids turn up so he has kids to race!!

I work in education and children's resilience is at an all time low and we need to strengthen it desperately.

I think in the OPs situation, I would keep trying to get him to go, big reward and praise for participation etc. If on the day they were really upset, then maybe I would change my mind, but I would try my hardest first.

cansu · 10/06/2023 07:45

Sports day is very different now to when I was at school. There are all kinds of events that he might be able to enjoy and do well in such as welly throwing etc. Maybe it is time for you to build up two things: resilience and accepting that he can't always do well in everything. It is also not great parenting to let him stay off school when he is well just to avoid something he dislikes.

TheaBrandt · 10/06/2023 07:31

Exactly card. It’s the public aspect there really is no equivalence. The stuff of nightmares for the non sporty / self conscious child.

And it doesn’t mean the sporty ones don’t get their sports day. Have it! But why require the children who hate it to take part too? They can watch and cheer and do low key stuff.

You wouldn’t shove a desperately shy child with a stutter who really didn’t want to do it on stage with a main speaking part would you?

carduelis · 10/06/2023 01:16

And to address the idea that an academic non-sporty child has one day of humiliation a year while a non-academic child is humiliated every day:

The level of humiliation a non-academic child faces in academic lessons is equivalent to the level of humiliation a non-sporty child faces in PE lessons.

The level of humiliation a non-sporty child faces on Sports Day is the equivalent of what a non-academic child would face if a school lined all the Y6 pupils up on the school field in order of their SATS results and invited the rest of the school and all the parents to watch.

Funnily enough though no school would ever consider doing that…

carduelis · 10/06/2023 00:52

TheHoover · 09/06/2023 19:54

Watered down hunger games! Haha just a tad over-dramatic.

So for the bookish but non-athletic kids we have one day of supposed humiliation per year and for the athletic but non-bookish kids it could be argued that there is a visible demonstration of their lack of academic ability every single school day (just without parents involved). So maybe rather than cancel sports day for the parents of the kids that can’t cope with being last why not just hold it behind closed doors? Because someone has to come last and if being last is an acceptable excuse for an opt out then there are no participants and it needs to be cancelled.

It’s a little difficult to take the views of any parents of ‘academic but not sporty’ kids seriously in this matter. I don’t see why encouraging participation and rewarding effort and progress is fine for academic subjects but not for sport.

It really isn’t that hard.

I didn’t have the faintest idea who came bottom of the class in any exam I’ve ever done throughout my academic life. A child wouldn’t even know they came last unless the teacher told them or they asked the entire class their results and worked it out.

It isn’t the same at all and I’m baffled that anyone is suggesting it is.

SouthLondonMum22 · 09/06/2023 20:19

TheHoover · 09/06/2023 19:54

Watered down hunger games! Haha just a tad over-dramatic.

So for the bookish but non-athletic kids we have one day of supposed humiliation per year and for the athletic but non-bookish kids it could be argued that there is a visible demonstration of their lack of academic ability every single school day (just without parents involved). So maybe rather than cancel sports day for the parents of the kids that can’t cope with being last why not just hold it behind closed doors? Because someone has to come last and if being last is an acceptable excuse for an opt out then there are no participants and it needs to be cancelled.

It’s a little difficult to take the views of any parents of ‘academic but not sporty’ kids seriously in this matter. I don’t see why encouraging participation and rewarding effort and progress is fine for academic subjects but not for sport.

Many parents wouldn't be happy about holding it behind closed doors but I do like the idea of having 'heats' behind close doors and then those with the fastest times can race again in front of parents.

TheHoover · 09/06/2023 19:54

Watered down hunger games! Haha just a tad over-dramatic.

So for the bookish but non-athletic kids we have one day of supposed humiliation per year and for the athletic but non-bookish kids it could be argued that there is a visible demonstration of their lack of academic ability every single school day (just without parents involved). So maybe rather than cancel sports day for the parents of the kids that can’t cope with being last why not just hold it behind closed doors? Because someone has to come last and if being last is an acceptable excuse for an opt out then there are no participants and it needs to be cancelled.

It’s a little difficult to take the views of any parents of ‘academic but not sporty’ kids seriously in this matter. I don’t see why encouraging participation and rewarding effort and progress is fine for academic subjects but not for sport.

TheaBrandt · 09/06/2023 13:00

Totally agree with Christmas and Widdling. Also love a PPs description of “watered down Hunger Games” 😀

Have sports day of course but allow the non sporty kids to opt out and do something non competitive and but vaguely sport related. Surely that’s not that hard to arrange?

Comparing sports day to other shit things is silly. Everything else your failure is low key and personal. This public humiliation. Fuck that!

We live right next to the school and have a happy memory of dd1 (then year 2, bookish, one of the youngest in her year) who hated the very visible coming last and fakey sympathy thereafter and I reading our books as we studiously ignored the screaming and yelling from the school.

KarmaStar · 09/06/2023 00:02

No.help him to train.help him to learn that doing your very best is good enough.he needs to know hiding away will not teach him confidence in the ability he does have.help him understand that when he has done his best that is a huge accomplishment and to be very proud of himself.

CabernetSauvignon · 08/06/2023 23:34

Gwlondon · 08/06/2023 21:41

I still don’t agree. You don’t have to be good at sports day. Turning up and doing something is what’s important.

I never did well at sports at school. My PE gcse was my lowest grade but I put effort into it. Tried to revise for the exams. Did my best in the practicals.

But I place a lot of value on turning up to things. Parties. Events. I feel like sometimes you have to do these things for the group and help make the event by being there. That’s just me. Good luck OP.

How on earth does it "make the event" for someone who is useless at sport to be there on sports day? If people were that keen to have me do things for their group, I wonder why I was always among the last to be chosen when it came to sports? I'm quite sure my contemporaries were far more happy to have me safely out of the way so that I didn't slow everyone else down.

Ponderosamum · 08/06/2023 22:41

WiddlinDiddlin · 27/05/2023 17:12

What a stinking pile of horse-shit...

I cannot think of a single fucking thing that I have to do, that I don't like...

That I have to do, badly, in front of loads of people patronisingly cheering, groaning about how long I take to do it, sarcastically clapping, muttering rude things under their breath...

Sure, theres shit I don't like doing - tax return - hoovering - tidying my desk - organising stock...

There is a clear point to all of them, and none are done with any sort of audience, and as long as I do them to the best of my ability and on time, it doesn't matter how long it takes.

Theres plenty of time and opportunity to learn about getting on with shit you don't really enjoy, between the ages of 7 and being a bloody adult, it doesn't need to involve humiliation in front of ones peers at sports day!

I really can't think of a single example where an adult is forced by others, to do something they absolutely hate, that causes huge anxiety in them, that is in fact totally unnecessary to daily life, that they're awful at. It just doesn't happen!

Brilliantly said @WiddlinDiddlin my thoughts entirely

Ponderosamum · 08/06/2023 22:36

ChristmasFluff · 26/05/2023 10:08

I took my son out of every Primary sports day after the first two - and I'd have done the same if he'd wanted to in Secondary.

What the fuck difference does it make? Except meaning he didn't have to be worried, upset, and put off sport. And oh look at him - doing a Masters in September that he is completely funding himself due to working so hard for very long hours this year.

Not a failure at life at all. And he also has empathy - something very lacking for children on this thread from some posters.

Totally agree with this. It’s just not necessary or important enough for anyone to suffer for it. My son has not attended sports day since yr 4. He is now top of his class in yr 9 at secondary school. He works really hard and he does not miss the annual humiliation for him that comes with sports day. He is not sporty, he has flat feet he is not fast. He goes to sports lessons at school, he takes part, that’s enough. You are not forced to enter academic competitions, sports day should be optional. Personally, I could not continue to watch him suffer every time, getting anxious, throwing up and feeling a failure every year.

carduelis · 08/06/2023 22:16

Gwlondon · 08/06/2023 21:41

I still don’t agree. You don’t have to be good at sports day. Turning up and doing something is what’s important.

I never did well at sports at school. My PE gcse was my lowest grade but I put effort into it. Tried to revise for the exams. Did my best in the practicals.

But I place a lot of value on turning up to things. Parties. Events. I feel like sometimes you have to do these things for the group and help make the event by being there. That’s just me. Good luck OP.

If you’re bad at sport then you’re not letting anyone down by not showing up, though, are you? You’re not doing anything “for the group” by being incompetent, nor are you helping to “make the event by being there”. The kids who are good at sport get to have their moment whether you’re there coming in last or not.

TheaBrandt · 08/06/2023 21:58

Oh definitely miss it. Ignore all the nonsense. Its a special hell for non sporty sensitive kids - so public! Failing in front of a baying crowd. Theres no other equivalent in adult life. No thanks.

I let dd1 miss it a few times, shes a hard worker, gets great results and found a sport she enjoyed at secondary. DD2 was also not great at athletics but didnt care so she would go along and roll her eyes and come last.

Gwlondon · 08/06/2023 21:41

I still don’t agree. You don’t have to be good at sports day. Turning up and doing something is what’s important.

I never did well at sports at school. My PE gcse was my lowest grade but I put effort into it. Tried to revise for the exams. Did my best in the practicals.

But I place a lot of value on turning up to things. Parties. Events. I feel like sometimes you have to do these things for the group and help make the event by being there. That’s just me. Good luck OP.