Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To withdraw my child from school sports day

667 replies

MissHoollie · 24/05/2023 20:02

So my son age 7 has been upset for a few weeks about sports day and " always coming last"
None of us in the family are sporty and my other children " were always last " but they didn't mind at all and it almost became a family joke with them enjoying the fact it was a family tradition to be rubbish at sport
So my 7 year old is begging not to take part
We've done all the " it's fine ..someone has to be last in the races "
" You are good at other things "
" It's part of life "
But he's still loosing sleep over it all.
They've been practicing all week which is winding him up even more.
So it occurred to me , and this is where I need perspective.
Would schools parade kids out in order of best reader to worst for all the parents to applause the best reader? ,no of course not ,so why do schools do this?
Yes it's good to celebrate success but why is it so demoralising for some kids ?
Am I being unreasonable taking him out of school that day?
As I say looking for other perspectives

OP posts:
SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 18:11

carduelis · 10/06/2023 18:09

As a teacher, and a parent, and a person who went to school, I do know what prize giving is.
I have yet to attend one where a teacher said “And finally, here is carduelis, who got 3/50 in the spelling test and came right at the bottom of the class!”

There is a massive difference between being one of the many, many kids who didn’t come first and being the kid who lost.

Also all the prizegiving events I’ve ever been to have included prizes for sport so this idea that we ONLY celebrate the sporty kids on sports day doesn’t hold up at all anyway.

Exactly. It isn't close to being the same thing.

carduelis · 10/06/2023 18:09

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 18:03

Children who walk to the front of the hall and sit in the front seats or up on the stage for the entire end of year prize giving. Then are individually given prizes with individual clapping and their names being read out
is very privileged

(nb : I’ve had kids that are academic and sporty and not academic or sporty either )

The others
Sitting in the side aisles, the cheap seats or in our case with their parents at the back are definitely put in a different league.

Theres no difference
Those kids in the cheap seats learn to accept it and celebrate their friends getting the prizes because maybe, just maybe, their mates clapped for them when they came in first in the 100m. If they bothered to turn up that is.

We had a kid ( a few actually ) whose parents always found an excuse for him to miss anything that was even remotely physically competitive. He learnt to not support his mates which was reciprocated.

Supporting others is an important life’s lesson.

As a teacher, and a parent, and a person who went to school, I do know what prize giving is.
I have yet to attend one where a teacher said “And finally, here is carduelis, who got 3/50 in the spelling test and came right at the bottom of the class!”

There is a massive difference between being one of the many, many kids who didn’t come first and being the kid who lost.

Also all the prizegiving events I’ve ever been to have included prizes for sport so this idea that we ONLY celebrate the sporty kids on sports day doesn’t hold up at all anyway.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 18:08

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 18:03

Children who walk to the front of the hall and sit in the front seats or up on the stage for the entire end of year prize giving. Then are individually given prizes with individual clapping and their names being read out
is very privileged

(nb : I’ve had kids that are academic and sporty and not academic or sporty either )

The others
Sitting in the side aisles, the cheap seats or in our case with their parents at the back are definitely put in a different league.

Theres no difference
Those kids in the cheap seats learn to accept it and celebrate their friends getting the prizes because maybe, just maybe, their mates clapped for them when they came in first in the 100m. If they bothered to turn up that is.

We had a kid ( a few actually ) whose parents always found an excuse for him to miss anything that was even remotely physically competitive. He learnt to not support his mates which was reciprocated.

Supporting others is an important life’s lesson.

If children don't want to run in the races, they could sit and watch instead. It's possible to support others without racing.

It's also possible to learn how to support others without sports day.

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 18:07

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 17:42

Which I don't think is comparable as actually watching a child struggle, sometimes several times in one sports day.

Sports day isn't an issue for me, it's the fact that it is mandatory and usually full of parents. Some who aren't always kind.

If it was behind closed doors or voluntary/fastest times only compete then I wouldn't have as much of an issue.

Parents who aren’t kind, yes we ve definitely had some of those.
Need to be asked not to attend in future.
In fact that’s exactly what our school did.

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 18:03

carduelis · 10/06/2023 17:48

Prize giving isn’t remotely analogous to sports day. Not a single parent (or child) has any problem with publicly celebrating other children’s achievements. That’s not what sorts day is, though - it’s not just bigging up the winners, it’s every child being publicly ranked from best to worst.

If prize giving included mentioning the child who wrote the worst story or came bottom of the class, I think a lot of parents would be much less keen on it.

Children who walk to the front of the hall and sit in the front seats or up on the stage for the entire end of year prize giving. Then are individually given prizes with individual clapping and their names being read out
is very privileged

(nb : I’ve had kids that are academic and sporty and not academic or sporty either )

The others
Sitting in the side aisles, the cheap seats or in our case with their parents at the back are definitely put in a different league.

Theres no difference
Those kids in the cheap seats learn to accept it and celebrate their friends getting the prizes because maybe, just maybe, their mates clapped for them when they came in first in the 100m. If they bothered to turn up that is.

We had a kid ( a few actually ) whose parents always found an excuse for him to miss anything that was even remotely physically competitive. He learnt to not support his mates which was reciprocated.

Supporting others is an important life’s lesson.

OutsideLookingOut · 10/06/2023 18:02

Again people seem to forget there are non-academic non-athletic kids. Usually those reasonably healthy are good at both their studies and sports even if not the best.

carduelis · 10/06/2023 18:01

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 17:34

My post was about ( end of year ) prize giving and assemblies.
Obviously all children attend assemblies and prize giving.
Parents attend end of year prize givings.

They always do at our kids schools and did when I was at school.
In fact parents didn’t attend sports day when I was at school ( never) and only attended up to child’s age 12/13 at my kids schools.

However. My post was about prize giving and assemblies.

If assemblies and prize giving were the academic equivalent of sports day, as you’re suggesting, we’d have kids who were so anxious they were losing sleep over attending them. But we don’t. Could that be because children can easily cope with not winning at something, but find it much harder to cope with publicly losing at something (that, as others have pointed out, they had no choice but to compete in)?

CecilyP · 10/06/2023 17:59

I think sports day is really important.

Seriously? As neither my primary or secondary did sports day, I am going to have to disagree!

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 17:52

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 17:42

Which I don't think is comparable as actually watching a child struggle, sometimes several times in one sports day.

Sports day isn't an issue for me, it's the fact that it is mandatory and usually full of parents. Some who aren't always kind.

If it was behind closed doors or voluntary/fastest times only compete then I wouldn't have as much of an issue.

Noticed you had a very similar conversation with @lifeturnsonadime yesterday.
Her points are the same as mine in essence.

carduelis · 10/06/2023 17:48

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 17:19

Just like prize giving every year really.
Or awards, colours whatever the school does on a regular basis at assemblies

Who gets the prize for best story, maths, spelling and years later it’s Chemistry, physics etc.
The same kids will be sat on their bums in a different part of the hall knowing there’s no prize for them.
All in front of parents (when it’s the end of year).

Prize giving isn’t remotely analogous to sports day. Not a single parent (or child) has any problem with publicly celebrating other children’s achievements. That’s not what sorts day is, though - it’s not just bigging up the winners, it’s every child being publicly ranked from best to worst.

If prize giving included mentioning the child who wrote the worst story or came bottom of the class, I think a lot of parents would be much less keen on it.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 17:42

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 17:34

My post was about ( end of year ) prize giving and assemblies.
Obviously all children attend assemblies and prize giving.
Parents attend end of year prize givings.

They always do at our kids schools and did when I was at school.
In fact parents didn’t attend sports day when I was at school ( never) and only attended up to child’s age 12/13 at my kids schools.

However. My post was about prize giving and assemblies.

Which I don't think is comparable as actually watching a child struggle, sometimes several times in one sports day.

Sports day isn't an issue for me, it's the fact that it is mandatory and usually full of parents. Some who aren't always kind.

If it was behind closed doors or voluntary/fastest times only compete then I wouldn't have as much of an issue.

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 17:34

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 17:23

It isn't the same to me because the parents don't actively watch them do whatever they may struggle with.

The same would be forcing all children to perform in a musical or forcing all children to do the spelling bee. Usually, only the children who are interested and have some talent at singing or spelling are picked.

My post was about ( end of year ) prize giving and assemblies.
Obviously all children attend assemblies and prize giving.
Parents attend end of year prize givings.

They always do at our kids schools and did when I was at school.
In fact parents didn’t attend sports day when I was at school ( never) and only attended up to child’s age 12/13 at my kids schools.

However. My post was about prize giving and assemblies.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 17:23

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 17:19

Just like prize giving every year really.
Or awards, colours whatever the school does on a regular basis at assemblies

Who gets the prize for best story, maths, spelling and years later it’s Chemistry, physics etc.
The same kids will be sat on their bums in a different part of the hall knowing there’s no prize for them.
All in front of parents (when it’s the end of year).

It isn't the same to me because the parents don't actively watch them do whatever they may struggle with.

The same would be forcing all children to perform in a musical or forcing all children to do the spelling bee. Usually, only the children who are interested and have some talent at singing or spelling are picked.

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 17:19

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 17:12

Some children are absolutely bothered with many parents watching them, especially when they do the sympathy clap.

You don't think those children realise that in PE? Why does it need to happen in front of everyone at sports day too?

Just like prize giving every year really.
Or awards, colours whatever the school does on a regular basis at assemblies

Who gets the prize for best story, maths, spelling and years later it’s Chemistry, physics etc.
The same kids will be sat on their bums in a different part of the hall knowing there’s no prize for them.
All in front of parents (when it’s the end of year).

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 17:12

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 15:54

Things have changed. Certainly in my dcs school and friends schools.
The not so clever are aware and made aware of it every single day.

They may not be outed in front of parents but kids aren’t really bothered by other parents it’s their piers that they can’t deal with. So when a bad reader has to read aloud or a bad mathematician is asked to solve a problem in front of the whole class that is very outing.

We can’t, however, all live in isolation of others that are better than us. In life there is always someone better and it’s best to realise that, learn from it and learn to deal with it.

Some children are absolutely bothered with many parents watching them, especially when they do the sympathy clap.

You don't think those children realise that in PE? Why does it need to happen in front of everyone at sports day too?

cryinginhmart · 10/06/2023 17:11

I think sports day is really important. I have children who are not academic and sports is where they really shine. It’s lovely to see them totally come out of themselves! I had sports day this week and my class were all so wonderful - supporting each other, the sportiest kids encouraging everyone, cheering every member of the class, a really lovely atmosphere. I was a child who hated sports day and I know that some of my kids would have felt like that too but it did feel like a positive and affirming vibe.

In a way I would feel sad if it became opt out because I love the way it feels as a class to be there together giving it all a go.

However, I also do not love the teacher’s race and I think that children who find it very hard shouldn’t have to. I let children refuse to do their race - I’m not fighting that battle and there’s always someone who is happy to do it for them. It would be hard because I feel like a lot of kids might opt out and then the whole vibe of sports day would change - it would be more of one of those events where kids on a specific team compete. But I hate the idea of any kids feeling anxious and upset on sports day, so anything that removes that is fair game to me.

wingsandstrings · 10/06/2023 17:01

Well schools do kinda parade the best at reading and the best at maths -in my DC's primary the tables they sat at were dependent on your standing in these subjects, and in their secondary they are in sets. Every day the DC on the lowest tables and lowest sets are physically set apart as bad academically. At least sports day is only once a year. I totally understand the drive to remove him, although I would think about whether that could send him the message that if he isn't good at something he doesn't have to do it, that something is only worth doing if he's good at it, and that you will save him from any uncomfortable situation. At GCSE English they have to do a speech for oracy; it's a compulsory part of the gcse. There were some kids in my DS's class who - like most people - had some nerves around public speaking. Their parents asked for them to be exempt from giving the speech and were outraged to be told 'no', the kids couldn't believe they were made to do it . . . . they had clearly always been saved from doing stuff that upset or challenged them before and were ill prepared to have to just grit their teeth and get through.

JustBeKindItsEasy · 10/06/2023 15:54

DonnaBanana · 10/06/2023 15:43

but non-bookish kids it could be argued that there is a visible demonstration of their lack of academic ability every single school day

Maybe things have changed but it was not a negative thing to do badly academically when I was at school. The clever ones got called geeks and boffins. It was nothing like sport. Who gets ridiculed for being the fastest runner?

Things have changed. Certainly in my dcs school and friends schools.
The not so clever are aware and made aware of it every single day.

They may not be outed in front of parents but kids aren’t really bothered by other parents it’s their piers that they can’t deal with. So when a bad reader has to read aloud or a bad mathematician is asked to solve a problem in front of the whole class that is very outing.

We can’t, however, all live in isolation of others that are better than us. In life there is always someone better and it’s best to realise that, learn from it and learn to deal with it.

DonnaBanana · 10/06/2023 15:43

but non-bookish kids it could be argued that there is a visible demonstration of their lack of academic ability every single school day

Maybe things have changed but it was not a negative thing to do badly academically when I was at school. The clever ones got called geeks and boffins. It was nothing like sport. Who gets ridiculed for being the fastest runner?

SpringIntoChaos · 10/06/2023 15:39

fUNNYfACE36 · 24/05/2023 20:10

So do the poor readers get to opt out of reading or the poor mathematicians out of a maths test.teach him to grow some resilence

The poor readers and mathematicians aren't being forced to read a book or solve equations in front of the whole school and possibly hundreds of parents though are they?? Can you really not see the difference here? Also, reading and maths are essential life skills...being unable to balance a quoit on your head and run down a field without dropping it, is hardly going to affect your life chances now is it?? 🤦‍♀️

SpringIntoChaos · 10/06/2023 15:35

I'm a primary teacher (Year 2) and I get what you are saying...I was also that child in school OP and it's horrible! I would never read out the children's spelling test results in order from 10/10 to 0/10, or pin rosettes on those children who have scores full marks in our recent SATS tests!

Sports Day is even worse, as it's watched by the whole school, all staff and hundreds of parents and other family members!

We are not all the same and yes, we do need to foster resilience, endurance and stamina in our children...but there are less humiliating ways to do it!

carduelis · 10/06/2023 14:02

This reply has been deleted

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

As I’ve always said: imagine the complaints if they did that in any other subject…

Dontcallmescarface · 10/06/2023 13:36

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/06/2023 13:23

Justloggedontocommentoncornwall · 10/06/2023 07:46

I do understand what you are saying, but i think i would try and find a way to try and push him through it. Losing things is hard, but part of life (sayingthis as the one who comes last!!). It's not my thing. I am very academic though. But I am resilient as as adult because I learned to take my knocks through things like sport.

My son is the worst academically in the class and I promise you everyone knows about it. Followed around by an adult in class to be able to do lessons, constant interventions and adapted work etc. Children talk. The parents all know because I get sympathetic side tilts if the head each time they ask how he is 'getting on'. He will win the sprint though. He takes his knock academically and needs this to shine. I hope the other bright kids turn up so he has kids to race!!

I work in education and children's resilience is at an all time low and we need to strengthen it desperately.

I think in the OPs situation, I would keep trying to get him to go, big reward and praise for participation etc. If on the day they were really upset, then maybe I would change my mind, but I would try my hardest first.

A child who isn’t sporty doesn’t need sports day to learn resilience. It happens every week in PE when they come last or are always the last child picked when the other children are picking teams.

Sports day isn’t necessary to teach resilience.

carduelis · 10/06/2023 13:17

cansu · 10/06/2023 12:27

Carduelis
If we follow your itinerary then we should keep our kids off when there is a spelling test or if they hate PE when it is tennis should keep them off as well. Doing this leads to children who struggle to cannot cope with difficulty and often present with anxiety later on. Parents should reassure and build the understanding that it is OK to take part and do your best. No one is good at everything. I was and am very unsporting. I didn't enjoy sports day but it wasn't a big deal and the end of the world because my parents did not encourage days off unless we were ill.

Did you read the bit of my post where I said no parent in their right mind would advocate keeping their child off for every PE lesson?

FWIW though if there was a Spelling Day with every child spelling in front of all their peers and their parents and a child was really anxious about that then I’d be in favour of keeping them off that too.

This is the whole point. Kids have plenty of opportunities to get better at stuff they’re not good at, to learn they can’t be the best at everything, to be told their best is good enough, and to accept they have to do things they don’t like, every single normal day at school. They don’t need a special day of being rubbish in front of the whole school and their parents to learn those life lessons: it’s just pointless humiliation.