Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To withdraw my child from school sports day

667 replies

MissHoollie · 24/05/2023 20:02

So my son age 7 has been upset for a few weeks about sports day and " always coming last"
None of us in the family are sporty and my other children " were always last " but they didn't mind at all and it almost became a family joke with them enjoying the fact it was a family tradition to be rubbish at sport
So my 7 year old is begging not to take part
We've done all the " it's fine ..someone has to be last in the races "
" You are good at other things "
" It's part of life "
But he's still loosing sleep over it all.
They've been practicing all week which is winding him up even more.
So it occurred to me , and this is where I need perspective.
Would schools parade kids out in order of best reader to worst for all the parents to applause the best reader? ,no of course not ,so why do schools do this?
Yes it's good to celebrate success but why is it so demoralising for some kids ?
Am I being unreasonable taking him out of school that day?
As I say looking for other perspectives

OP posts:
PamTheExam · 25/05/2023 10:46

I think he should go and its a valuable lesson in not being a sore loser! I do understand - my eldest was terrible for getting upset if he didn't get a win or star of the week or man of the match etc but I don't think opting out is a good idea. He's got over it now as a teenager! Or at least finds other things to huff about!

Iwasafool · 25/05/2023 10:46

Delatron · 25/05/2023 09:16

But children have to do stuff they don’t like/aren’t good at all the time. They have to read out loud in class and assembly (some love this/some hate this. They don’t get to opt out of tests and other competitions at school.

Why do non-sporty kids get to opt out of the one thing they may not do so well at?

One of my GC has dyslexia, he was never forced to go on stage and "read" when he couldn't read. With lots of intervention he started to read, he was behind and his reading was slower than others but when he felt ready to face reading in public he volunteered to do it. That was a positive, making him stand up with a book that made no sense to him would have been bullying and humiliating and yet it is OK to do that to children who just aren't good at sport for some reason (dyspraxia is an example.)

FernGully43 · 25/05/2023 10:45

I'd take him out and go do someone active and fun together.

LavenderfortheBees · 25/05/2023 10:44

I would keep him off but book something physical that he will enjoy instead. He gets to do some exercise and gets the message that physical activity is something that can suit him rather than fitting in with what society expects.

MyOtherCarIsAPorsche · 25/05/2023 10:44

"At that age, they volunteer for their events so the kids who are rubbish end up in the egg and spoon race."

Oh dear - my granddaughter ended up the egg and spoon, the sack race, stilt race, skipping and obstacle race. (She was tangled for ages in a large net she had to crawl under until I eventually helped her out - no one else did. She never crawled as a baby. She was a quick 'bum shuffler'. We later found out that, because her knees are prone to sublux, she would never choose to crawl.) She certainly didn't volunteer for any sports day races - she was told which races she was in. She must be rubbish. All 'egg and spooners' are rubbish - eh? But then all parents judge - that's true isn't it?

My daughter's school did large team sports days. Whole school was divided into four groups and points were totalled at the end. She didn't have the ignominy of having to come last as, like her daughter is suspected, she has an EDS diagnosis and is also autistic, dyslexic, dyspraxic.

She did find out at High School though that she excelled at long distance running after unexpectedly winning in the first cross country when it happened to rain on a PE day. (Cross country always took place when outdoor PE was abandoned due to heavy rain.) So she did find something she was good at.

Unfortunately, my granddaughter continues to dread this competitive version of sports day where most children achieved a medal last year - and she didn't. (Medals awarded to first 6 children across the line.) A classmate wanted to give her one of her medals, but she wouldn't accept it because she hadn't earned it.

OP - I was a primary school teacher and there were always several children (we knew which children were likely not to turn up) absent in each class on sports days. As a teacher and a parent - I wouldn't judge.

Iwasafool · 25/05/2023 10:37

Ourladycheesusedatum · 25/05/2023 10:08

But adults can opt out of some things.
I can choose to do or not do many many things for any reason or none.

If I chose a job where sports day/pick your equivalent was compulsory then I would deal with it or not ever take the job.

You hear it on here sometimes, particularly round Christmas, adults who don't want to go to the work's do and feeling pressured to go. Posters on here telling them they don't have to, why should they etc. But kids, well they have to do it, it's so important that they get the practice at being miserable because it's a skill don't you know and how will they get through life if they haven't practised hard enough.

Treaclemine · 25/05/2023 10:31

I can directly compare with an exam. Same school, same teacher. Said I was lazy, even when I always came top. I never knew what I wasn't doing that she thought I should be. I finished work quickly and spent a lot of time staring at the map on the wall. Anyway, we had an exam, called the Common Entrance, though I don't believe it was. We sat a mock version, and Mary (not her name) came top, and I came one mark less. Then we had the real one, and I came top. and Mary came one mark less. She was usually Form Leader and went on to become Head Girl, and a very nice girl she was. On Prize Day, I got a great big cup big enough to hold a champagne bottle. One day when I wasn't in the room Miss told the rest of the class that I shouldn't have got it because I was lazy. I had never had a prize before, my younger sister had one every year, except the Mrs D one which she only awarded one year to me.

It was only when I was marking SATS and hunting through to make sure I had given every child every point they deserved that I realised that Miss must have spent ages on Mary's and my papers hoping to award the prize to Mary, so I absolutely did win.

And she left a legacy. Every year when I got my OU results, I dreaded opening them because I was afraid of failing. Although I usually did rather well.

I am, as I mentioned, 77. For a school which claimed to develop each girl's potential fully, to leave me with this sort of stuff is ridiculous. So thinking that children get over failing easily is easy for people who only see it once, but where it is reinforced year after year it soaks in deeply. You can see it would be bad for reading and maths, but not sport. Being told it is a fatal flaw in character, not trying hard, being lazy, when you don't experience that...Horrible.

Mygazpachoistoocold · 25/05/2023 10:31

Treaclemine · 25/05/2023 09:54

Do you realise you are using the ones who fail to validate the ones who win "needing a full field"? Like trans using women athletes to validate themselves? Let the good athletes race other good athletes, not the ones whose leg muscles aren't fast, beating whom is no kudos. How many of you are justfying the sports day as "someone has to come last". When it's always you it's soul destroying. Just try seeing it through the struggle of some one who always, every time, year after year comes last. It's torture. Added to always being picked for teams last every week.

I got round that with other ways of picking teams when I taught PE.

Blimey, I hope you warmed up before that stretch. You can't equate a seven year old child's sports day to the hugely complex and emotive topic of trans people in sports.

Ourladycheesusedatum · 25/05/2023 10:08

electriclight · 24/05/2023 21:24

No, don't teach him that he can opt out if things he doesn't like or isn't good at. It's a terrible message and sets a precedent. At that age, they volunteer for their events so the kids who are rubbish end up in the egg and spoon race. He'll come out the other side and learn that mum doesn't give him a day off when something is tricky, that he can cope with adversity and that he was very likely better than he expected.

But adults can opt out of some things.
I can choose to do or not do many many things for any reason or none.

If I chose a job where sports day/pick your equivalent was compulsory then I would deal with it or not ever take the job.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/05/2023 10:07

Delatron · 25/05/2023 09:50

Great lesson for them - you might lose this one unimportant race. So you can stay home with Mummy and let everyone else compete.

By allowing them to miss school you are making it a big deal. I’m guessing they are phoning in sick? So add in a lie to that too. Great parenting all round…

Except that isn't what OP is saying. Her son is anxious and worrying over it despite the usual ''Just do your best'', ''Someone has to come last'' etc that can work for some children.

By insisting he take part in this meaningless, unimportant race I'd be saying it's a big deal. It certainly isn't worth a 7 year old getting so upset and worried about.

I wouldn't phone in sick. I'd have a word with the teacher first to see if he could participate in a different way such as just sit and cheer on friends and/or help hand out any awards/trophies but if that wasn't possible, I'd just tell them that he isn't going.

Kanaloa · 25/05/2023 10:06

FloralBloomers · 25/05/2023 10:02

Yes of course children who don’t like speaking in public have to participate in assembly and read in front of peers and teachers. Otherwise how will they gain confidence?

They have the skill capacity to do it and need to overcome shyness and gain confidence. No amount of confidence can give you the physical capacity to not keep coming last in races. It's just demonstrating over and over again that no matter how hard you try, you'll never win a race against your peers.

Also sometimes it is just maturity. I used to find public speaking so anxiety inducing that it would make me unwell. As I got older I matured and thought differently and now I speak in front of people all the time.

Plus atmosphere. Putting yourself out there by choice in theatre group or a sport club or at uni/higher education where you’re surrounded by others who are like minded and form a supportive environment is so different than being forced out of your comfort zone surrounded by others who may not be supportive. One is a great way to help kids overcome difficulties. One is a great way to make them uncomfortable and give them bad memories.

FloralBloomers · 25/05/2023 10:02

Yes of course children who don’t like speaking in public have to participate in assembly and read in front of peers and teachers. Otherwise how will they gain confidence?

They have the skill capacity to do it and need to overcome shyness and gain confidence. No amount of confidence can give you the physical capacity to not keep coming last in races. It's just demonstrating over and over again that no matter how hard you try, you'll never win a race against your peers.

Kanaloa · 25/05/2023 10:01

Delatron · 25/05/2023 09:16

But children have to do stuff they don’t like/aren’t good at all the time. They have to read out loud in class and assembly (some love this/some hate this. They don’t get to opt out of tests and other competitions at school.

Why do non-sporty kids get to opt out of the one thing they may not do so well at?

Tests are not the same. Every child, sporty or not, has to participate in PE. This is normal. Academic tests are not performed in front of an audience. That is why they are different.

I’ve never seen kids forced to read at assembly in front of parents, so possibly they don’t do it at our school. If my kids struggled badly with reading and were forced to read passages at assembly in front of an audience I would go into school and have a conversation about this as I don’t think it’s a good learning environment.

Again, why does it bother you? Of course the sporty children could still compete in sports if they want to do so. Why should those who are not confident in competing in athletics in front of an audience participate?

FloralBloomers · 25/05/2023 09:57

By allowing them to miss school you are making it a big deal. I’m guessing they are phoning in sick? So add in a lie to that too. Great parenting all round…

There was no need to phone in sick on sports day at my dcs school in the 80s. If you didn't want to join sports day the school was fine with it.
It's making sports day a big deal that's making it a big deal.

Hippyhippybake · 25/05/2023 09:57

Isn’t the point that those who learn to confront failure and deal with it are far more likely to be happy with themselves later in life. It is horrible for anyone to come last in anything but it happens to everyone sooner or later and isn’t it a parent’s job to help a child cope with the perceived humiliation.

Treaclemine · 25/05/2023 09:55

Meant to say, keep your child off.

Treaclemine · 25/05/2023 09:54

Do you realise you are using the ones who fail to validate the ones who win "needing a full field"? Like trans using women athletes to validate themselves? Let the good athletes race other good athletes, not the ones whose leg muscles aren't fast, beating whom is no kudos. How many of you are justfying the sports day as "someone has to come last". When it's always you it's soul destroying. Just try seeing it through the struggle of some one who always, every time, year after year comes last. It's torture. Added to always being picked for teams last every week.

I got round that with other ways of picking teams when I taught PE.

Delatron · 25/05/2023 09:52

Yes of course children who don’t like speaking in public have to participate in assembly and read in front of peers and teachers. Otherwise how will they gain confidence?

Delatron · 25/05/2023 09:50

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/05/2023 09:25

Because like you keep saying. It's just a race and doesn't matter.

Great lesson for them - you might lose this one unimportant race. So you can stay home with Mummy and let everyone else compete.

By allowing them to miss school you are making it a big deal. I’m guessing they are phoning in sick? So add in a lie to that too. Great parenting all round…

Blort · 25/05/2023 09:39

At some point as a child, I was not a good athlete but enjoyed taking part. I enjoyed playing with my friends and celebrating their wins. I think for some athletic kids it's important to have a full field and for them to be able to compete, win, enjoy.

And for the 10% who find the day hugely uncomfortable (as I went on to do) there's no reason to attend. My 2 kids arent great at sports but dont mind sports day - it's important that they go. If my daughter was horribly uncomfortable I would keep her off sick for the day without question.

And to answer the question about prizes for maths etc - this isnt a PE prize, its a full competitive day in front of crowds etc.

FloralBloomers · 25/05/2023 09:37

And then I chose to go in the school
play and my confidence and public speaking got better

That's overcoming shyness, which is different to knowing you have to run in a race where you know you'll be last. Again.

GreatBigBoots · 25/05/2023 09:37

OP- lots of people will disagree with you whichever choice you make. You need to do what you think is best for your child.

But I really think traditional sports days are due a rethink. Do we have a day where everyone has to take part in a maths quiz with the whole school and parents etc watching? Do we have public reading competitions with compulsory participation? Does every child HAVE to take a speaking part in the school play? No. We celebrate those who are particularly good at these things and try to sensitively encourage those who struggle. Surely the point of PE in schools should be to get every child doing some regular activity and make exercise part of their life for good. So a sports day would be more effective if those who excel at sport could have competitions (with an audience if they wish) and those who don't could have different activities, with no audience, aimed at building enjoyment of sport.

I was always rubbish at sport and have strong memories of being ridiculed by pupils and parents at sports day. This did not make me resilient. It taught me to fear trying any form of exercise where anyone would see me. My DD was also terrible at traditional school sports and when she was upset at the thought of having to fail in front of the whole school etc I gave her the option of not doing sports days. I have encouraged her to find exercise that she enjoys and surprise surprise because she enjoys practising she's actually become OK at it, and that's given her confidence to try other sports. She's never going to be a world class athlete but is now a very resilient, physically fit young adult. Shielding your child from public ridicule is not helicopter parenting.

Treaclemine · 25/05/2023 09:34

The person who won the egg and spoon cheated. She dropped it by throwing it forward and continued from the place it fell. That sort of skill will help in life. I didn't drop it, so the skill of balancing and egg successfully I know I have never needed.

Dontcallmescarface · 25/05/2023 09:30

If a child hates speaking in public are they expected to take a speaking part in the school play, or are they allowed to just be in the background where they feel more comfortable? In my head it's the same as telling a child who doesn't like sports day "well you have to do it regardless of how stupid it makes you feel".

As for those saying "well what's the difference between those not being good at maths/English, they still have to do tests whether they like it or not", well of course they do. The better at those they are, the better chance they have in adult life. I doubt there has been any child in history who got a place at uni/decent job, because they were able to run fast whilst holding an egg on a spoon.

Treaclemine · 25/05/2023 09:29

Well, this brought back memories, last again and again and again, and it didn't teach resilience. Teachers who said I didn't try hard enough, I tried so hard I pulled something in my hip "You couldn't have, you came last," it still twinges now I'm 77.That was in a race I didn't choose to enter, when given the choice, but the teacher overrode that to have enough to race. So why choose me, there were others?

When I was teaching we had lots of activities on Sports Day, due to a sensible head, and done in teams. Except the year that a parent donated a load of trophies. And some of the children booed. It completely changed the dynamics.

We didn't need races. As there is one who always comes last (I still hate that teacher, as I have recognised now how she let her dislike of me out in every aspect of life at the school) there is one who always comes first, yes I know it will be you Darren, all the children knew, all the way through junior school, and I gather infants as well, and I suspect that no one dared to challenge that. Why bother to confirm him in his entitlement?

And at secondary school, where we practiced hurdling at 30 inches and I could do it, but on sports day they changed it to 33. Trail of capsized hurdles.

Teach resilience? Teach that your place is last and always will be? Bloody pecking order when we aren't chickens. Why not teach the fastest respect for others?

Swipe left for the next trending thread