Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In-laws overstepping regarding our finances

235 replies

Mrscouldron · 24/05/2023 19:34

Hi
Im looking for advice how to sort this situation without a falling out. I’ve posted in aibu as I didn’t know where else to post it. My in laws are really overstepping the boundaries regarding our finances at the moment. For context we have 2 disabled children whom we homeschool. DH has a fairly good job and we prioritise after bills being paid giving the children the best life we can. This includes lots of day trips, holidays etc. FIL in particular is really starting to get on my nerves. He says we shouldn’t be going on holidays it’s too expensive. We shouldn’t buy the kids so much. Actually we don’t buy the kids much at all in the way of material possessions. We shouldn’t buy them so many takeaways. They have maybe 1 McDonald’s a month. He wants to know how much our outgoings are each month and what we have in savings. He demands to know what things have cost. He said my DS has too many fidget toys and I’ve spent a fortune on them. I haven’t it was a £15 pack as he had lost most of his old ones. I’ve tried ignoring him but he won’t stop and it’s got to the point I don’t want to go round there anymore. FIL isn’t actually DHs father so that complicates things further. What do I say to make him back off and let us enjoy our lives with the kids. DH is of the opinion we just ignore or lie about what we are doing as in laws live about an hour away. The trouble is the kids are sure to say something when they see them. I don’t think this is the answer. Thanks in advance for any advice.

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 24/05/2023 23:38

Has he always been like this? If this is a new thing it did make me wonder of your hubby has borrowed money from his mum? It’s so weird he has an opinion on your finances!

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 24/05/2023 23:37

Every time he insists on something I’d ask why he felt that was his decision to make with your finances and your children.

RandomMess · 24/05/2023 23:32

Tell them you won't be able to visit again any time soon as the fuel is far too costly Wink

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 24/05/2023 23:31

You're not asking him to help out because you're short at the end of the month, so it is completely none of his business how you run your household finances. I would be doing the same in your situation and making precious memories with my wee ones.

I would be reducing the exposure to him, and when he does start, saying something like 'thanks, DH and I are doing just fine and are happy with how we budget for our household' and change the subject. Just close it down and grey rock him.

SW2002 · 24/05/2023 23:27

Just say 'Don't worry we can afford it, we're adults with jobs and can manage our finances just fine thanks'.
That's it, it's as easy as that.

Yellowdays · 24/05/2023 23:08

You don't need to be rude to win this discussion. Just tell him you don't want to discuss your finances so let's change the subject.

Thesharkradar · 24/05/2023 23:01

this man sees you & your husband as children whom he can boss around, be prepared for him to try & tell you off like a child when you 'back chat' him, have a response ready.
I'd tell him to shut the fuck up, but then he'd get that vibe from me from the get go and wouldnt try any shit- I'd imagine?
I long for relatives like this, I'd have so much FUN

Frosto · 24/05/2023 22:58

Is your partner aware of this, I usually find this overstepping links in to the oversteppers history, maybe they are not doing well financially and they are just worried you are repeating their mistakes. I would speak to your partner and ask them to have a word with them, explain to them you are meeting fiscal obligations, you aren't carrying crazy credit card debt for jet skis you purchased on a whim.

You sound like me you value your time on this earth but aren't the human equivalent of Greece in 2008

Merangutan · 24/05/2023 22:51

‘The details don’t concern you.’ ‘You don’t need to know that information.’ ‘That’s private.’

Every time.

It really needs to be that blunt.

Moveoverdarlin · 24/05/2023 22:48

My in-laws are so tight and out of touch with what things cost I tell them nothing about what we’re doing. They refuse to go out for a coffee because it’s £3.50 for a cup and you can get a whole jar of instant in Lidl for £1.80.

We earn good money and do loads of nice things with the children but we tell them nothing about where we’ve been and what we’ve bought.

Fallowandbar · 24/05/2023 22:48

My family are similar, and I'm not bolshy enough to do half of what people suggest, although i wish I were!
What worked for me was saying "we're fine, please stop worrying about us" followed the next time by "I told you, we're fine financially, please don't worry about us". By framing it as thinking they were concerned (rather than judgemental) it took some of the sting out of the response, but they got no information, and referencing the fact that we'd been over it before seemed to massively reduce their desire to bring it up for a 3rd time.

Goldbar · 24/05/2023 22:38

2bazookas · 24/05/2023 21:35

He (FIL) wants to know how much our outgoings are each month and what we have in savings. He demands to know what things have cost.

           Turn the tables; ask  him  and MIL  how much their outgoings are each months, what they have in savings,  how much their stuff costs. Are you sure you can afford that, FIL?  Seems like a waste of money. 

When he finds your enquiries really impertinent and rude, you reply "Yes, isn't it. So don't keep asking about ours".

I agree with this... fight fire with fire. You could really have some fun with this.

"That's a nice TV, FIL, are you sure you can afford it? People don't really need TVs nowaday, there's nothing good on anyway, I think you should sell it."

"You and MIL should really stop going for coffee and lunch out. It's a waste of money... you're wasting your children's inheritances".

"We haven't bought you anything for Christmas because you have too many presents already. We actually think you should consider donating some of them".

"We're economising on pens and paper so we got the kids to draw you a virtual birthday card on the tablet this year, rather than making you one. We've emailed it to you.

"I really don't think you should have turkey for Christmas. Such a waste of money that could be used for better things. I'll send you a lentil roast recipe instead."

"Why have you put the heating on? It's only November."

"You don't need a teabag per cup. Don't chuck them away, that's a waste of money, save them and reuse them. And no one needs more than two biscuits."

Wolbarker · 24/05/2023 22:32

“It only cost a pound.” In reference to EVERYTHING

Maray1967 · 24/05/2023 22:28

Mrscouldron · 24/05/2023 21:40

This is an excellent idea!

This is exactly what you should do. Let him say his piece and then calmly ask him several questions about his finances. When he objects, make the point back.

SaveTheDeal · 24/05/2023 22:25

FIL isn’t actually DHs father

”While I’m sure MIL appreciates you taking an interest in her son and her grandchildren, we’re really not comfortable discussing finances with you. Please don’t raise the topic again”.

Sodullincomparison · 24/05/2023 22:24

My PIL do the same- constantly commenting on what we buy or spend our money on ( but happily accept an overseas summer holiday all paid for)

and now they have decided to spend their financial wisdom to my DM and say to her how tough it must be for her to cope as a pensioner on her own.

she told them in response that she had learned a long time ago not to count someone else’s money for them.

my FIL is jealous of the success DH has has and also like to comment on us being workaholics.

we have gone low contact because the negativity was making us all miserable.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 24/05/2023 22:23

Start pushing back

You should only buy dc 1 present for Xmas - that's a good idea, you buy them one present and we'll buy them as many as we want

You shouldn't spend money on holidays - how much did you spend when you went to x last year FIL?

How much are your bills - I can't remember, how much are your outgoings each month?

How much money do you have in savings - we're happy with the amount, what about yourselves. How much do you have?

I'd start to make it very uncomfortable for him to ask questions as you can turn it back on them. Hopefully he'll stop asking questions to stop you asking him

Mrscouldron · 24/05/2023 22:15

ArcticSkewer · 24/05/2023 21:58

That's very sad. Can dh speak to his mum? Let her know you won't be visiting as much because of this?

My first thought was that they are defensive about your dh having to carry the burden of being the sole earner, but it really doesn't sound like he has confided in them about this, or other financial worries.

If fil has not always been this way, is it part of a pattern of cognitive decline? Only other thing I can think of that might make it excusable/bearable

My DH is the sole earner because I am the carer for our children. Being homeschooled and having such high needs I could never hold down a job and take care of them. Don’t get me wrong he gets up at night with them and we spend evenings and weekends all together. The reality was one of us had to be a full time carer/stay at home parent as childcare wasn’t an option for them and even if it was the costs would be phenomenal. My husband isn’t resentful of this. We are a team and each have our own responsibilities within our family unit.

OP posts:
Thesharkradar · 24/05/2023 22:15

bibbityboppityboo · 24/05/2023 19:38

I think your options are;

A) ignore him totally as DH suggested
B) wildly exaggerate. Triple every price you've ever paid for anything, wind him up with it and have a bit of fun.
C) start quizzing FIL. What's his pension worth? How's it invested? Does he have savings? Is he planning for retirement? What's with all the new shoes / jumpers etc?

I'd do all three on rotation until he gets bored personally. Some people are nosey and don't take subtle hints!

this!
the problem as I see it is that you want to avoid a falling out and he is (I'm assuming) sending very clear signals that if you dont defer to him he will create a falling out.
You'll have to find your ovaries of steel & deliberately piss him off.
Please report back when you've done it and we'll all give you gold stars⚜

bellsbuss · 24/05/2023 22:14

When we were younger and had decided to buy a bigger house FIL told us we shouldn't do it and it would be too expensive. DH started looking a bit panicked but quick as a flash I said thanks for your advice, we weren't actually asking for any and we are buying the house. He told me I was rude and I upped and left , he did apologise the next day though. These things need to be nipped in the bud straight away.

WiddlinDiddlin · 24/05/2023 22:13

" FIL - you seem to be very concerned about our finances and seeing how we manage them. Is everything OK? Do you need us to take a look at your finances and paperwork to help you out, only you keep mentioning money and spending so often we're worried you can't cope any more.'

That should do the trick :D

icelollycraving · 24/05/2023 22:12

I can be a bit upfront. I’d say god, do you begrudge my disabled children their toys, are you jealous? Is that why your own kids don’t visit much, we can go the same way if you like.

Thesunwillcomeoutverysoon · 24/05/2023 22:11

Maybe he has plans to spend his retirement at your expense end is fuming you are spending it.
My sil was fuming when ils remortgaged as she saw it as her inheritance..

Luredbyapomegranate · 24/05/2023 22:05

There some great ideas on here, but basically OP you need to accept a bit of conflict now to save a lot more long term.

Whatever you do has to end this. It shouldn’t be that hard, people who do this do usually stop when they are firmly called out and put back in their place because they are so obviously out of line.

It might be worth considering what it is about conflict that makes you run in the other direction.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 24/05/2023 22:05

LordEmsworth · 24/05/2023 19:37

Laugh and say, there's no pockets in shrouds Ebenezer! Who wants a nice cup of tea before the first ghost gets here, woooooo...

This made me laugh!