Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In-laws overstepping regarding our finances

235 replies

Mrscouldron · 24/05/2023 19:34

Hi
Im looking for advice how to sort this situation without a falling out. I’ve posted in aibu as I didn’t know where else to post it. My in laws are really overstepping the boundaries regarding our finances at the moment. For context we have 2 disabled children whom we homeschool. DH has a fairly good job and we prioritise after bills being paid giving the children the best life we can. This includes lots of day trips, holidays etc. FIL in particular is really starting to get on my nerves. He says we shouldn’t be going on holidays it’s too expensive. We shouldn’t buy the kids so much. Actually we don’t buy the kids much at all in the way of material possessions. We shouldn’t buy them so many takeaways. They have maybe 1 McDonald’s a month. He wants to know how much our outgoings are each month and what we have in savings. He demands to know what things have cost. He said my DS has too many fidget toys and I’ve spent a fortune on them. I haven’t it was a £15 pack as he had lost most of his old ones. I’ve tried ignoring him but he won’t stop and it’s got to the point I don’t want to go round there anymore. FIL isn’t actually DHs father so that complicates things further. What do I say to make him back off and let us enjoy our lives with the kids. DH is of the opinion we just ignore or lie about what we are doing as in laws live about an hour away. The trouble is the kids are sure to say something when they see them. I don’t think this is the answer. Thanks in advance for any advice.

OP posts:
TellHimDirectlyInDetail · 26/05/2023 10:17

Amazing updates

ChubbyMorticia · 26/05/2023 06:35

I’m absolutely delighted for your updates! Nicely done!

I wonder if he’s thinking that you and DH should be supplementing their income? He’s counting your spending and resenting it because he thinks it ought to be going toward providing them a more comfortable life? Some people are weirdly jealous of anyone having what they don’t, or doing what they didn’t. “We couldn’t afford to do that when we were raising kids/we can’t afford to do that now, it’s not fair!” sort of thing. None of which is your problem in the slightest, of course. But it stinks of jealousy to me.

Also, when people ask inappropriate questions, I sometimes amuse myself by channeling my inner toddler. “Why?” is pretty much the only answer they get, repeated until they stomp off.

Newestname002 · 26/05/2023 03:40

@Mrscouldron

I said it’s really none of your concern what we do or don’t spend our money on and that our finances won’t be discussed again. FIL looked at DH and said you need to control your wife! DH told him not to speak like that and to leave. Safe to say both FIL and MIL went off in a complete rage. I feel so much better for it though.

WELL! I'm glad I read the whole thread before responding! Well done to you and DH for standing firm against this nosy, misogynistic bully and his compliant wife. Looks like your lives will be a bit easier now. You'd think the old twit would have learned a lesson from how infrequently his biological children see him. I wonder if he treated them the same way? 🌹

Ihadenough22 · 26/05/2023 01:35

I was delighted to see what you said to him. Fil telling your husband he should control his wife and your husband saying what he said to him was good. I could understand him asking questions if as a family were asking him for money to pay the bills but meanwhile your having a lifestyle of meals out, holidays and 2 cars on finance.

He then gets his wife to ring her son and tell him they are unhappy about what has been said and expect you to apologize. I would not be saying sorry to them. At least you don't have to stay with them this Christmas.
Its not an easy situation your in with your 2 children. For your own sake I would try to get some respite care for your kids so that you and your husband can get a much needed brake.

You trying hard to give your kids the best life possible for them and you know what little things or days out give them some joy. Instead of him moaning he should say here a few pounds to bring the kids to X or for you to get something they like.

threatmatrix · 26/05/2023 01:11

Start asking him about his finances.

namechangingisboringme · 26/05/2023 00:30

Mrscouldron · 25/05/2023 16:28

Quick update. They came round this afternoon, it was a planned visit as they were passing through the area. DDs old water bottle had cracked so I had brought her a new one. She loves smiggle so it was one of those. Obviously FIL went mad saying there is nothing wrong with a plain Tescos one. I politely told him it’s my money and I will buy whichever water bottle I wish for her. He said we just waste money left right and centre. I said it’s really none of your concern what we do or don’t spend our money on and that our finances won’t be discussed again. FIL looked at DH and said you need to control your wife! DH told him not to speak like that and to leave. Safe to say both FIL and MIL went off in a complete rage. I feel so much better for it though.

I didn't get this far before I replied.

BLOODY WELL DONE!!! Handled beautifully.

namechangingisboringme · 26/05/2023 00:27

Mrscouldron · 24/05/2023 19:50

FIL despite my protests also wrote us down in the calendar to spend 6 days over Christmas with them. It would be hell on earth. What ever we buy the children it will be too much. He said bluntly to me last week that I must stop buying the children anything more than 1 gift at Christmas! MIL just nods along with him I think to avoid arguments.

I trot out the same line over and over when people get in my business "are you paying our bills?" Because if the answer is no then what business is it if theirs?
If I want 6 holidays and 52 day trips a year, what does it matter as long as no one else is paying my bills? If you want to give your children the earth, it should be no one else's problem.
You need to stand firm with your reply and just stick to the script
"The children and what we choose to do with them, or spend on them, is none of your concern, if we need input we'll ask for it"
Just keep doing what makes you and the kids happy, screw what anyone else's opinion is.

Pythonesque · 25/05/2023 23:22

One thing though that crossed my mind reading your story especially some of the updates - is your FIL excessively controlling in his own house? Is your MIL potentially be emotionally and/or financially abused? Might be a thought to drop in your DH's ear to think about just in case.

CelestiaNoctis · 25/05/2023 23:12

Remember the 3 F's. If you're not Fucking me, Feeding me, or Financing me, then your opinions really don't matter. Therefore, keep your opinions to yourself.

Loxah · 25/05/2023 22:35

You spent £15 on fidget toys????!!

bluebeck · 25/05/2023 22:01

Good riddance really. It’s not any loss is it?

Mrsknowitall · 25/05/2023 21:55

I would just reply with “who wants to be the richest man/woman in the graveyard” if you have it then enjoy it! Buy your kids their fidget toys and McDonald’s it has nothing to do with anyone else

AcrossthePond55 · 25/05/2023 21:51

Mrscouldron · 25/05/2023 20:28

MIL did call DH to say how upset she is. DH said that what happened earlier will not ever be tolerated and that FIL should apologise for the control your wife comment. MIL said I guess you won’t be seeing FIL again then. I think it’s safe to say the 6 days over Christmas is off 😂

"I guess you won’t be seeing FIL again then"

Oh dear, your and DH's poor little hearts must just be breaking at the thought. NOT.

Seriously, well done to both of you. Now sit back and enjoy the peace and quiet. If you want to continue a relationship with MiL, let her come to you.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 25/05/2023 21:33

What a bloody update @Mrscouldron !! Good for you and DH. You've set the groundwork which is the hard bit, now you just need to maintain your stance and they'll get the idea....

PoppyTries · 25/05/2023 21:26

Mrscouldron · 25/05/2023 16:28

Quick update. They came round this afternoon, it was a planned visit as they were passing through the area. DDs old water bottle had cracked so I had brought her a new one. She loves smiggle so it was one of those. Obviously FIL went mad saying there is nothing wrong with a plain Tescos one. I politely told him it’s my money and I will buy whichever water bottle I wish for her. He said we just waste money left right and centre. I said it’s really none of your concern what we do or don’t spend our money on and that our finances won’t be discussed again. FIL looked at DH and said you need to control your wife! DH told him not to speak like that and to leave. Safe to say both FIL and MIL went off in a complete rage. I feel so much better for it though.

Well, those six days at Christmas seem to be sorted now!

I have an uncle like your FIL. Growing up, we had little contact with him because they lived in Hong Kong and didn’t move back until we were adults. He immediately started visiting various relatives and my cousins told me that he would march up to each of the adult cousins & interrogate about their finances. I had been a terribly shy child, but found my spine at uni, so he was quite startled that, upon being pummeled with questions by a man I hadn’t seen in nearly 20 years, I replied “I cannot imagine why you would think that ANY of this is your business. I barely KNOW you.” He told me I was rude and I said he should mind his own house and not concern himself with my father’s family - he has three unsuccessful and unmotivated adult children, so saying this embarrassed him greatly. It’s been another 20+ years and we’ve only ever said “hello” and “goodbye” since.

Wexone · 25/05/2023 21:17

wohoo what a great update. had mother in law has some cheek ringing for an apology then playing guilt about not seeing him. can she not see how wrong he is ? how could he even say that ??. like what dies it really matter if the bottle has squiggls or whatever on it. he not using it he not paying for it and your child is happy. but to say control your wife is so shocking. I actually feel sorry for your mother in law.

Zarataralara · 25/05/2023 21:17

Dont know how I missed your latest posts, must have skipped a page.

Well done. He really does sound unhinged, who rants over a kids water bottle? And ‘ control your wife’???? Tell him the 1950s called and want him back.

WiddlinDiddlin · 25/05/2023 21:14

Bloody knew it, should have guessed it'd be MIL that would call to speak to your DH and expect an apology though.

FIL is never going to have the balls.

Yay, thats Christmas freed up for you! :D Result!

Zarataralara · 25/05/2023 21:10

Fil, let me stop you right there. You do realise that DH and I are adults? Fully gown up adults, the parents of two children? We have been managing our finances for x number of years and we are more than happy with how we organise everything . Should we ever need your advice we will ask for it. But right now we will leave it as DH and I know what is best for our family. Let’s not discuss this again.

IndiaRose22 · 25/05/2023 21:10

Bravo to you and DH. I didn't expect you to say you'd said it already but I'm pleased you've stood up for yourself and DH had your back!

ohfourfoxache · 25/05/2023 21:07

Lucky you, getting Christmas sorted already! 😂

Thesunwillcomeoutverysoon · 25/05/2023 21:03

You have already won Best Christmas Gift of 2023 op!!
Embrace the peace.

Starchipenterprise · 25/05/2023 20:51

Well done for standing up to them. They do not deserve you to stay with them at Christmas or details of your finances.

QueenieMe · 25/05/2023 20:48

Mrscouldron · 25/05/2023 20:28

MIL did call DH to say how upset she is. DH said that what happened earlier will not ever be tolerated and that FIL should apologise for the control your wife comment. MIL said I guess you won’t be seeing FIL again then. I think it’s safe to say the 6 days over Christmas is off 😂

A very Merry Christmas to you, OP, you're going to have a lovely peaceful one this year!

God, it makes my blood boil where I hear men saying 'control your wife'. Well done your DH for standing up to him and telling him to sling his hook.

T1Dmama · 25/05/2023 20:36

I’m very non confrontational… but if someone was badgering me like this I’d be telling them… “Thank you for your concern, however We will spend our money on our children as we feel fit.. … then EVERYTIME he brings it up repeat ‘our kids, our money!! And walk away…

as for Christmas …. cross yourself off his calendar & State VERY clearly you are spending Christmas at home alone!!! Even better book yourself a caravan holiday over Christmas x